Each step shows the best option of each kind first; “See more” has the rest.
1. Where you are now⌄4 steps · 29 items
1Check whether to see your GP or a dietitian first3 studies2 websites⌄
If you have, or have had, an eating disorder, or have kidney disease or diabetes treated with insulin or other medicines that can cause low blood sugar, talk to your GP or a dietitian before making big changes to how you eat.
What it found: KDIGO's 2024 international kidney guideline advises that a renal dietitian guide people with chronic kidney disease on salt, potassium, phosphorus and protein. Those at risk of worsening should avoid over 1.3 g of protein per kg a day. Both are ungraded expert advice.
What it means for you: If you have kidney disease, get a dietitian's help before big diet changes; this is expert advice, not trial-tested.
▸ See 2 more studies▾ 2 more studies, best firstMembers
Best for: The UK guideline behind 'get support first' if you have, or have had, an eating disorder.
Caution: UK guideline for health professionals.
▸ See 1 more website▾ 1 more websiteMembers
+ Add a note
2Take stock of a usual week1 product10 studies3 websites⌄
For a few typical days, count vegetable, fruit and whole-grain serves; processed meat, sugary drinks and takeaway; and your main cooking fat. Counts, not calories; a diet-quality check is a rough guide. Had an eating disorder? See your GP first.
What it found: Across 65 trials in about 10,000 adults with overweight, followed for 6 months or more, behaviour-change programs gave about 3.25 kg more weight loss than control groups. Programmes using self-monitoring, mostly tracking food, steps or weight, showed a slightly bigger effect.
What it means for you: Counting your serves is a simple form of self-monitoring, which weight-loss trials link with better results.
The figures and the limit
About 3.25 kg extra loss from behavioural programs (g −0.19, 65 trials); with self-monitoring g −0.26 (20 trials).
The limit: Weight outcomes only, not graded, and mostly calorie, step or weight tracking.
▸ See 9 more studies▾ 9 more studies, best firstMembers
Product
Calorie-counting and diet-tracking apps
Do diet-tracking apps help you lose weight?
Not yet knownMore data needed
In teens and adults with overweight, an app on its own made no clear difference to weight at 1 or 2 years versus little or no help. Coached weight programs, most including food or weight tracking, do help.
+Coached weight programmes, most with tracking: about 2.4 kg more lost over 12–18 monthsModerate evidence
+About half a serve more fruit and vegetables a day, in mostly short studiesModerate evidence
–Eating-disorder history: 73% of app users with one felt it fed their disorderEarly evidence
–20,991 Australian Android health apps: 88% could collect data, 28% lacked privacy policiesModerate evidence
–Apps under-counted energy by about 200 calories (850 kJ) a dayEarly evidence
The diabetes result measured long-term blood sugar (HbA1c), not diabetes complications
How to do it: In weight programs, people tracked food or weight for months, alongside 12 or more coaching sessions in the first year.
Counting vegetable, fruit and takeaway serves for a few days (counts, not calories) gives self-monitoring without calorie numbers.
Sticking with it: No data on how many keep logging for a year; in one trial of 212 adults, logins fell sharply after the first month.
Cost: Basic versions are free; premium tiers cost about US$20–80 a year (our estimate).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: A current or past eating disorder, or a teenager prone to dieting: check with a doctor or psychologist before tracking calories.
Risks and who should be careful (12)
calorie and food tracking triggers or worsens disordered eating, in adults, including those with an eating-disorder historyMixed resultsEarly evidenceTrials (1–12 months) in low-risk women and adults with overweight: no rise in risk. Of app users with an eating disorder, 73% felt it contributed.The detailsTwo trials (200 low-risk women, 1 month; 250 adults with overweight, 12 months): no rise in risk. 73% of app-using eating-disorder patients felt it contributed.Who makes this claim: Eating-disorder clinicians and charitiesRoth 2024 · 72 Good (independence estimated*)Jebeile et al. 2023 · 82 StrongMoody 2025 · 75 GoodLevinson, Fewell and Brosof 2017 · 46 WeakSimpson and Mazzeo 2017 · 47 Weak (independence estimated*)Draft Clinical Practice Guidelines for the Management of Overweight and Obesity in Australia · Official dataHahn et al. 2021 · 68 Good (independence estimated*)Jospe et al. 2018 · 68 Good (independence estimated*)
dieting with calorie or food tracking triggers disordered eating, in teenagers and young adultsNot yet knownEarly evidenceSupervised teen programs lowered eating-disorder scores on average, but 5% of 141 teens had new or returning symptoms. Young adult app users report more symptoms.The detailsSupervised teen programs: eating-disorder scores fell (36 studies); one 141-teen trial: 5% new or returning symptoms. Young adults: app use linked with more symptoms.Who makes this claim: Eating-disorder clinicians; paediatric obesity researchersJebeile et al. 2019 · 71 GoodJebeile et al. 2024 · 59 LimitedAnderberg, Kemps and Prichard 2025 · 56 LimitedSimpson and Mazzeo 2017 · 47 Weak (independence estimated*)
apps collect and share sensitive health data (privacy)Shown to harmModerate evidenceOf 20,991 health and fitness apps on Australian Android, 88% could collect user data, 3.9% were seen sending it and 28% had no privacy policy.The detailsOf 20,991 medical and fitness apps (Australia, Android): 88% had code able to collect user data; 3.9% were seen sending it; 28% lacked privacy policies.Who makes this claim: Privacy researchers; US Federal Trade CommissionTangari et al. 2021 · 57 Limited (part-funded by a telecom company's university hub)US Federal Trade Commission 2024 · Official dataOffice of the Australian Information Commissioner · Official data
app calorie and nutrient estimates are inaccurate, giving false reassuranceProbably harmfulEarly evidenceAcross 11 studies, apps under-counted about 200 calories (850 kJ) a day; trained adults weighing food were off by 4% and 8% (two apps).The details11 validation studies: apps under-recorded energy by 202 kcal (845 kJ) a day versus reference methods; trained adults logging weighed food: 3.7% and 8.0% error.Who makes this claim: DietitiansGriffiths, Harnack and Pereira 2018 · 48 Weak (independence estimated*)Diktas et al. 2025 · 47 Weak (two authors hold a patent on one of the apps tested)Zhang et al. 2021 · 67 Good
Physical side effectsNo physical harm expected; the concern is disordered eating, covered below.The detailsNo physical harm expected. The concern is disordered eating (see below).Metzendorf, Wieland and Richter 2024 · 81 Strong (independence estimated*)
Eating disorders and teenagersCurrent or past eating disorder: don't track for weight loss until it's treated. Teenagers: check with a doctor; 5% of 141 in one trial had new or returning symptoms.The detailsPeople with a current or past eating disorder: weight-loss tracking is not advised before the eating disorder is treated (Australian draft guideline practice point; NICE eating-disorder guidance covers treatment). Teenagers: in supervised programs eating-disorder scores fell on average, but 5% of 141 teens in one trial had new or returning symptoms; check with a doctor.Draft Clinical Practice Guidelines for the Management of Overweight and Obesity in Australia · Official dataNICE 2017 · 79 Good (independence estimated*)Levinson, Fewell and Brosof 2017 · 46 WeakJebeile et al. 2019 · 71 GoodJebeile et al. 2024 · 59 Limited
Checking too oftenProgrammes used tracking for months with coaching; compulsive or very frequent checking is a reasonable concern that hasn't been tested.The detailsWeight programs used tracking for months with coaching; compulsive or very frequent checking is a reasonable concern, not tested.US Preventive Services Task Force 2018 · 88 Strong
Food database accuracyApp food databases are partly user-entered; each of five popular free apps under-counted at least one nutrient.The detailsApp food databases are partly user-entered; five popular free apps under-estimated at least one nutrient each.Griffiths, Harnack and Pereira 2018 · 48 Weak (independence estimated*)
Calorie counts can be offCalorie totals can run about 200 calories (850 kJ) a day low, mostly from food-database differences; even trained adults weighing their food were off by about 4–8%.The detailsApps under-recorded energy by about 202 kcal (845 kJ) a day across 11 validation studies, mostly from food-database differences; trained adults logging weighed food had mean errors of 3.7% (MyFitnessPal) and 8.0% (PortionSize).Diktas et al. 2025 · 47 Weak (two authors hold a patent on one of the apps tested)Griffiths, Harnack and Pereira 2018 · 48 Weak (independence estimated*)Zhang et al. 2021 · 67 Good
Restrictive eatingYoung adults who track report more restrictive eating. Trials found no rise in eating-disorder risk on average, but four weight-program studies saw new symptoms in up to 6.5%.The detailsSnapshot studies link tracking with more dietary restraint in young adults. In a 1-month trial, 200 low-risk university women who counted calories showed no rise in eating-disorder risk, nor did 250 adults with overweight who tracked for 12 months; observational studies found no clear link overall (9 studies). Weight-program studies found eating-disorder scores fell on average in adults and in 7-17-year-olds, with new symptoms in 0-6.5% in four adult studies; in a trial of 141 teenagers on a supervised diet, 5% had new or returning symptoms.Simpson and Mazzeo 2017 · 47 Weak (independence estimated*)Jebeile et al. 2023 · 82 StrongMoody 2025 · 75 GoodHahn et al. 2021 · 68 Good (independence estimated*)Jospe et al. 2018 · 68 Good (independence estimated*)Roth 2024 · 72 Good (independence estimated*)Jebeile et al. 2019 · 71 GoodJebeile et al. 2024 · 59 Limited
CostFree versions exist; premium tiers cost about US$20–80 (A$30–120) a year (our estimate).The detailsFree versions exist; premium tiers about US$20-80 or A$30-120 a year (our estimate). Shown as information only.
PrivacyMost health apps can collect user data and some send it. US: the FTC's health-breach rule covers apps since 2024. Australia: complaints go to the privacy regulator (OAIC).The details88% of medical and health-and-fitness apps had code that could collect user data, 3.9% were seen sending it, and 28% had no privacy policy (Australia, Android, 2021). In the US: since 2024 the FTC's health-breach rule covers health apps not covered by HIPAA, and unauthorised sharing counts as a breach. In Australia: privacy law sets strict rules for how health service providers handle health information, and complaints go to the privacy regulator (OAIC).Tangari et al. 2021 · 57 Limited (part-funded by a telecom company's university hub)US Federal Trade Commission 2024 · Official dataOffice of the Australian Information Commissioner · Official data
The evidence, claim by claim (6)Members
What it does
Tracking what you eat (self-monitoring, by app or on paper), as part of a weight program, helps adults with overweight lose weightShown to helpModerate evidenceIn 67 trials of 22,065 adults, people in coached weight programs, most with tracking, lost about 2.4 kg more than control groups over 12–18 months.The detailsUS task force, 67 trials, 22,065 adults: coached behavioural programs, most with self-monitoring, cut 2.39 kg more at 12-18 months (small benefit).Who makes this claim: US Preventive Services Task Force; weight programs; app makersUS Preventive Services Task Force 2018 · 88 StrongPreuhs 2026 · 77 GoodRaber 2021 · 68 GoodChew et al. 2023 · 86 Strong
Diet apps improve diet quality (more fruit and vegetables), in adultsShown to helpModerate evidenceAcross 21 studies (11,389 people, typically 12 weeks), diet apps added about half a serve of fruit and vegetables a day.The details20 results from 21 studies (15 randomised trials, 1 non-randomised, 5 before-after; before-after and between-group results pooled together), 11,389 people, median 12 weeks: fruit and vegetables up 0.48 serves a day (0.18 to 0.78).Who makes this claim: Digital-health researchersCurtin 2025 · 82 Strong
App programs help blood-sugar control, in adults with type 2 diabetesShown to helpModerate evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesIn adults with type 2 diabetes, app programs lowered long-term blood sugar (HbA1c) by about 0.4 percentage points more; full programs, not tracking alone.The details26 meta-analysed trials (of 56 reviewed): smartphone app programs cut HbA1c 0.42 percentage points more (0.20 to 0.63); full programs, not tracking alone.Who makes this claim: Diabetes educatorsLancet Digital Health 2023 · 86 Strong (independence estimated*)
What it doesn't clearly do
A free diet-tracking app on its own, without coaching, helps adults with overweight lose weightNot yet knownMore data neededApps alone, without coaching: no clear weight difference at 12 or 24 months, nor over 6 months with a free calorie-counting app (212 adults).The detailsCochrane: -2.5 kg at 12 months (-6.8 to 1.7), +0.7 kg at 24. Free-app trial (212 adults): -0.3 kg. Ranges include no effect.Who makes this claim: App makers, fitness mediaMetzendorf, Wieland and Richter 2024 · 81 Strong (independence estimated*)Laing et al. 2014 · 67 GoodArumäe et al. 2026 · 74 Good (co-funded with an app company)
Not reviewed yet
People who log more consistently lose moreUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNo reviewed evidence yet.Who makes this claim: App makers, trial authors
Macro tracking helps muscle gain and body compositionUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNo reviewed evidence yet.Who makes this claim: Fitness media
Fact-checked 4 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
+ Add a note
3Start with your biggest gap4 studies1 website⌄
Start with your biggest gap and set a specific goal and plan for it. You can pick more than one gap: take on as much as you can keep up.
What it found: Six trials in 7,429 adults compared changing several habits at once with changing them one after another (smoking, diet, activity and alcohol). Three found a difference on one habit each, split both ways; drop-out was the same. Both approaches beat minimal care.
What it means for you: Start with your biggest gap, and take on more at once only if you can keep it up.
The figures and the limit
6 head-to-head trials; 3 found a difference on one behaviour each, split both ways; no difference in drop-out.
The limit: Small evidence base, mainly smoking and activity rather than diet.
▸ See 3 more studies▾ 3 more studies, best firstMembers
Best for: Guideline on individual behaviour change; recommends goal setting and action planning.
Caution: UK guidance for practitioners.
+ Add a note
4What helps you stick with itOptional5 studies⌄
Structured diet and activity programs (about 12 sessions over 6–18 months) using goal setting, self-monitoring and problem solving lower heart risk in adults with risk factors. With high blood pressure or cholesterol, ask your GP about one.
What it found: In 94 trials of 52,174 adults with high blood pressure or cholesterol, diet and activity counselling (typically 12 sessions over a year) was tested. In the 9 trials that counted heart attacks, strokes and similar events (12,551 people), it cut them by about 20%.
What it means for you: If you have high blood pressure or cholesterol, ask your GP about a structured program like these.
The figures and the limit
Cardiovascular events RR 0.80 (95% CI 0.73 to 0.87; 9 trials, 12,551 people); median 12 sessions, about 6 hours.
The limit: US evidence; techniques weren't tested one by one; benefit is smaller in adults without risk factors.
▸ See 4 more studies▾ 4 more studies, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
2. Two patterns with the best evidence⌄5 steps · 52 items
1Know what the evidence shows5 books3 protocols13 studies3 websites⌄
Optimal: Mediterranean-style (plenty of vegetables, fruit, whole grains, legumes, nuts and fish; olive oil as main fat), or DASH-style, sodium about 2 g a day or less, if blood pressure is your focus. Healthy: the Australian Dietary Guidelines.
What it found: The European Society of Cardiology's 2024 blood pressure guideline recommends a healthy, balanced diet such as Mediterranean or DASH, and cutting sodium to about 2 g a day (about 5 g of salt).
What it means for you: If blood pressure is your focus, Mediterranean or DASH-style eating with sodium near 2 g a day matches this guideline.
▸ See 12 more studies▾ 12 more studies, best firstMembers
From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 1 November 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 1,137 ratings, about 82% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. 2 readers say the effect has lasted. Audiobook, 3.2 h.
Note: "Guaranteed" fast weight loss and "boost metabolism" are marketing claims. Not for anyone with an eating-disorder history. Any medicine is your doctor's call.
Why it isn't the top pick: fewer of its readers said it helped than for a typical book.
▸ See 4 more books▾ 4 more books, best firstMembers
Best protocol
Mediterranean-style eating
What it is: Olive oil as the main fat; vegetables twice and fruit three times a day; legumes, fish and nuts three times a week; less red meat, butter, sweets and sugary drinks.
Does it cut heart attacks, strokes and early deaths?
Shown to helpModerate evidence
Yes, for adults at higher heart risk. Across 12 trials, Mediterranean-style programs cut deaths by about 17 in 1,000 over 5 years versus minimal advice (36 at high risk). Low-fat programs also helped; neither clearly beat the other.
+Vs minimal advice: 17 fewer non-fatal heart attacks and 7 fewer strokes per 1,000Moderate evidence
+After heart disease: fewer repeat heart events than low-fat eating in men, not womenModerate evidence
+Linked with less type 2 diabetes; one trial found no clear differenceEarly evidence
○No clear weight change, despite the extra olive oil and nutsModerate evidence
–Wine isn't needed: the less alcohol you drink, the lower your riskModerate evidence
How to do it: About 50 g extra virgin olive oil (3–4 tablespoons, our estimate) or 30 g mixed nuts daily, with diet classes every 3 months.
Look for a harvest date on extra virgin olive oil; best-before dates aren't a reliable freshness guide.
Foods sold as 'Mediterranean' may not match the pattern tested; base it on whole foods.
Trials used about 50 g of olive oil or 30 g of nuts a day; larger amounts weren't tested.
Sticking with it: No count of who keeps it up. A year after support ended, older Australians kept about 40% of their diet gains (our estimate).
Cost: Olive oil about US$160–260 a year and nuts about US$100–180 (our estimate), partly offset by eating less meat and fewer snacks.
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Pregnant, planning pregnancy, or children up to 6: keep eating fish but follow mercury limits. Nut allergy: skip the nuts. Wine isn't required.
Risks and who should be careful (9)
the 'glass of red wine with meals' part raises alcohol harm for drinkersShown to harmModerate evidenceThe trial score credits 7+ glasses of wine a week, about 11 Australian standard drinks (our estimate); light drinkers showed no clear drop in deaths.The detailsPREDIMED's score credits 7+ glasses weekly (11 Australian standard drinks; our estimate), above Australia's 10-drink limit. Bias-adjusted cohorts: low drinking not linked with fewer deaths.Who makes this claim: Mediterranean diet scores and advocates (wine as part of the pattern); NHMRC (the risk)Martínez-González et al. 2012 · 54 LimitedNHMRC 2020 · 67 Good · Funding not read · Conflicts not readZhao et al. 2023 · 70 GoodMartínez-González et al. 2026 · 60 Limited
the extra olive oil and nuts cause weight gainShown not to helpModerate evidenceIn 7,447 older adults, 50 g olive oil (3–4 tablespoons, our estimate) or 30 g nuts a day didn't add weight over 5 years.The detailsUnrestricted Mediterranean diet with about 50 g olive oil or 30 g nuts daily: no weight gain over 5 years (−0.41 and −0.02 kg).Who makes this claim: Low-fat diet advice, first principles (fat is calorie-dense)Estruch et al. 2019 · 73 Goodde Rojas et al. 2026 · 57 Limited
mercury in some fish, for pregnancy and young childrenNot yet knownMore data neededFish in pregnancy was linked with better child development and no net harm at high intakes (44 studies); high-mercury fish weren't studied separately: follow limits.The detailsFish in pregnancy linked with better child development (44 studies, no net harm at high intakes); high-mercury species not studied separately.Who makes this claim: FSANZ (limits for some species); FAO/WHO 2024 (net benefit of fish)FSANZ 2013 · 52 LimitedFAO and WHO 2024 · 73 GoodHibbeln et al. 2019 · 73 Good
AlcoholWine isn't needed. PREDIMED's score credits 7+ glasses a week, about 11 Australian standard drinks (our estimate), above Australia's limit of 10; the less you drink, the lower your risk.The detailsAlcohol: the pattern is often described with wine, and PREDIMED's 14-item score gives a point for 7 or more glasses a week (29.5% of participants met it); at about 1.6 standard drinks per 150 mL glass that is about 11 standard drinks a week (our estimate). Australia (NHMRC 2020): healthy adults should drink no more than 10 standard drinks a week and no more than 4 on any day, which keeps the lifetime risk of dying from alcohol below 1 in 100; 'the less you drink, the lower your risk'. US (Dietary Guidelines 2025–2030): drink less alcohol for better overall health, with no daily limit given; the AHA (2021) says if you don't drink, don't start. A review of 107 cohorts (4.8 million people) found low-volume drinkers (up to about 24 g a day) didn't have significantly fewer deaths than lifetime non-drinkers once biases were adjusted for (RR 0.93, P=0.07); risk rose from about 45 g a day (25 g in women). The strongest opposing study, a 2026 PREDIMED analysis part-funded by Spanish wine-sector bodies, linked counting the wine item with fewer heart events (HR 0.55 vs 0.84 without it, the latter not significant), but its analyses least prone to bias against non-drinkers weren't significant, the younger SUN cohort showed no link with heart disease (pooled, deaths were lower with wine, P=0.01), and there was no benefit at 3 or more glasses a day. No trial tested the wine part alone. Weight: no gain on an unrestricted Mediterranean diet over 5 years (olive oil −0.41 kg, 95% CI −0.83 to 0.01; nuts −0.02 kg).Martínez-González et al. 2012 · 54 LimitedNHMRC 2020 · 67 Good · Funding not read · Conflicts not readEstruch et al. 2019 · 73 GoodZhao et al. 2023 · 70 GoodMartínez-González et al. 2026 · 60 LimitedUS Departments of Agriculture and Health and Human Services · Official dataLichtenstein et al. 2021 · 66 Good
Pregnancy, children and nut allergyPregnant, planning pregnancy, or for children up to 6: keep eating fish, but follow your food regulator's limits on high-mercury species. Nut allergy: use the olive-oil version.The detailsPregnancy, planning a pregnancy, and children up to 6: keep eating fish, but follow your food regulator's limits on high-mercury species (Australia and NZ, FSANZ: shark or flake, billfish such as swordfish and marlin, orange roughy and catfish; US, FDA/EPA: avoid king mackerel, marlin, orange roughy, shark, swordfish, Gulf tilefish and bigeye tuna, and eat 2–3 servings a week of lower-mercury fish). A 2023 FAO/WHO expert consultation found strong evidence of benefit from eating fish in pregnancy, though in some populations mercury from fish was linked with less of the expected benefit; reviews of 44 publications (106,237 mother–child pairs) found no net harm at the highest seafood intakes. Nut allergy: use the olive-oil version. No medicine interactions were found in the trials we rated.FSANZ 2013 · 52 LimitedFAO and WHO 2024 · 73 GoodHibbeln et al. 2019 · 73 GoodFDA and EPA · Official data
Treating it too strictlySome people may treat it as a strict diet rather than a flexible pattern; no study we rated measured whether that causes problems.The detailsTreating it as a strict 'diet' rather than a pattern; no study we rated measured this.
Low-fat eating insteadLow-fat programs also cut deaths, by about 9 in 1,000 over 5 years versus minimal advice; no convincing difference from Mediterranean. After heart disease, Mediterranean did better in men.The detailsIt is food. Versus minimal advice, a low-fat program also cut deaths (odds ratio 0.84, 9 fewer per 1,000 over 5 years), as did Mediterranean programs (0.72, 17 fewer); the review found no convincing difference between the two. After heart disease, Mediterranean beat low-fat in men (CORDIOPREV).Karam 2023 · 97 StrongDelgado-Lista 2022 · 75 Good
CostOlive oil adds about US$160–260 (A$240–400) a year and nuts about US$100–180 (A$160–270), partly offset by less meat and fewer snacks (our estimate).The detailsExtra virgin olive oil at about 50 g a day: about A$240–400 a year; 30 g of nuts a day: about A$160–270 (our estimate at A$12–20 a litre and A$15–25 a kg), partly offset by eating less meat and fewer snacks. Information only.
Keeping it upTrials gave dietitian support and free foods. A year after support ended, older Australians had kept about 40% of their diet improvement (our estimate); blood pressure gains were lost.The detailsWith dietitian support and free foods, people kept the diet in the trials. A year after MedLey's support ended, older Australians' diet score was 7.9 of 15 (from 9.6 at 4 months and 6.7 at the start), and blood pressure gains were lost.Murphy et al. 2022 · 61 LimitedMedLey 2017 · 63 Limited
The evidence, claim by claim (9)Members
What it does
A Mediterranean pattern cuts heart attacks, strokes and deaths, in adults at higher heart risk or with heart diseaseShown to helpModerate evidenceIn 7,447 adults aged 55–80 at high heart risk, strokes fell from 24 to 14 in 1,000 over about 5 years versus low-fat advice.The detailsVs minimal advice (12 trials): deaths OR 0.72, 17 fewer per 1,000 (moderate); similar to low-fat. One trial vs low-fat: strokes 24→14 per 1,000.Who makes this claim: Heart Foundation 2019 (heart-healthy eating patterns, including Mediterranean), Oldways, Harvard Nutrition Source, PREDIMED authors (olive oil and nuts donated by producers), CORDIOPREV authors (olive-oil-sector funders); AHA 2021 dietary guidance (US)Rees 2019 · 85 StrongKaram 2023 · 97 StrongHeart Foundation 2019 · 55 LimitedEstruch 2018 · 73 GoodDelgado-Lista 2022 · 75 GoodLichtenstein et al. 2021 · 66 Good
Following a Mediterranean pattern is linked with living longer, in the general adult populationProbably helpsEarly evidenceStudies following 1.68 million people found about 10% fewer deaths for each 2-point step up a Mediterranean diet score. This shows a link, not proof.The details29 cohorts, 1.68 million people: each 2-point higher diet score is linked with 10% fewer deaths (HR 0.90); no absolute figure available.Who makes this claim: Oldways, Harvard Nutrition Source, mediaSoltani et al. 2019 · 74 Good (independence estimated*)
A Mediterranean pattern lowers the risk of type 2 diabetes, in adults at higher heart riskProbably helpsEarly evidenceAcross 24 studies (nearly 1 million adults, about 12 years): 8% less type 2 diabetes per 2-point higher score; one trial: no clear difference.The details24 cohorts: each 2 score points linked with 8% less diabetes (no absolute figure). PREDIMED (corrected): HR 0.75 (0.56–1.01), range includes no effect.Who makes this claim: PREDIMED authors (olive oil and nuts donated by producers), Diabetes AustraliaWallerer et al. 2025 · 77 GoodSalas-Salvadó et al. 2014 · 66 Good
What it doesn't clearly do
A Mediterranean pattern helps weight lossShown not to helpModerate evidenceIn 7,447 older adults with no calorie limit, weight after 5 years was within half a kilo of the low-fat group: no clear difference.The detailsPREDIMED, 7,447 people, no calorie limit: weight change after 5 years −0.41 kg (olive oil) and −0.02 kg (nuts) vs low-fat advice.Who makes this claim: Diet sites, The Mediterranean DishEstruch et al. 2019 · 73 Good
Not reviewed yet
It protects the brain (memory, dementia), in older adultsUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (below the top claims by priority).Who makes this claim: MIND diet promoters, media
It lowers some cancers (e.g. breast cancer)UntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (below the top claims by priority).Who makes this claim: PREDIMED secondary analyses
It improves depression, in adults with depressionUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (below the top claims by priority).Who makes this claim: Deakin Food & Mood Centre (SMILES)
It lowers blood pressure and LDL cholesterolUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (below the top claims by priority).Who makes this claim: First principles
It improves gut bacteria and lowers inflammationUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (below the top claims by priority).Who makes this claim: Wellness media
Fact-checked 1 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
▸ See 2 more protocols▾ 2 more protocols, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
2Swap to unsaturated fats1 protocol7 studies2 websites⌄
Swap butter, cream, coconut oil and fatty meat for liquid plant oils and spreads made from them, not refined starch or sugar. Make plant oils your main fats; olive oil is a good choice but not shown to beat canola or sunflower.
What it found: In 15 trials of 56,675 people lasting 2 years or more, cutting saturated fat lowered heart attacks, strokes and similar events by about 17%: about 1 in 55 people avoided one over about 4 years. Deaths showed no clear difference.
What it means for you: Swapping butter, cream and fatty meat for plant oils lowers your chance of heart attacks and strokes over the years.
The limit: Moderate certainty for heart events; the benefit is small for people at low heart risk.
▸ See 6 more studies▾ 6 more studies, best firstMembers
Protocol
Plant oils as your main cooking and dressing fat (instead of butter and other saturated fats)
What it is: Cook and dress food with plant oils such as canola, sunflower or olive oil, instead of butter, coconut oil or fatty meat.
Does cooking with plant oils instead of butter cut heart attacks?
Shown to helpModerate evidence
Yes, modestly. In 12 trials of 53,758 adults, cutting saturated fat for 2 years or more cut combined heart and stroke events by 17%: about 18 fewer in 1,000 over 4 years (our estimate). Gains matter most at high risk.
+Heart and stroke events: about 18 fewer in 1,000 over 4 years (our estimate)Moderate evidence
+LDL cholesterol 0.23–0.42 mmol/L lower than with butter, for most plant oilsModerate evidence
○Deaths: little or no change in trialsModerate evidence
○Seed oils didn't clearly raise inflammation or heart disease in trialsEarly evidence
○Extra virgin olive oil wasn't clearly better than canola or sunflowerEarly evidence
–Cancer: possibly slightly more diagnoses with extra polyunsaturated fatMore data needed
The cholesterol result measured LDL in the blood, not heart attacks or strokes
How to do it: Trials replaced saturated fat such as butter and fatty meat with plant oils or other foods; bigger cuts gave bigger benefits.
Look for a 'harvested on' date on extra virgin olive oil; best-before dates aren't a reliable freshness guide.
Canola or sunflower oil are usually cheapest, and lowered LDL at least as well as olive oil.
Sticking with it: No data on how many keep the swap up at a year.
Cost: About US$40–190 a year for 40 mL of oil a day (about 3 tablespoons), versus about US$130–215 for butter (our estimate).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: No group found that should avoid it in the studies we rated.
more omega-6 raises cancer riskLeans toward harm; not yet knownMore data needed47 trials: omega-6's effect on cancer unclear. More total polyunsaturated fat: possibly 8 more cancer diagnoses in 1,000 (our estimate); some doses were very high.The details47 trials: omega-6 effect unclear (very low quality). More total polyunsaturated fat: RR 1.19 (0.99–1.42), range includes no effect. Cohorts: less cancer death.Who makes this claim: Seed-oil critics (1960s trial signal)Hanson et al. 2020 · 92 StrongHooper 2020 · 97 StrongSadeghi et al. 2025 · 63 Limited
oil is calorie-dense, so using it causes weight gainShown not to helpModerate evidenceOne omega-6 trial (371 people): BMI unchanged; cutting saturated fat gave small weight falls; PREDIMED's olive oil group didn't gain weight.The detailsOne omega-6 trial (371 people): body mass index unchanged (−0.20 kg/m²); cutting saturated fat gave small weight falls; PREDIMED's olive oil arm didn't gain.Who makes this claim: First principlesHooper 2018 · 91 StrongHooper 2020 · 97 StrongEstruch et al. 2019 · 73 Good
Deaths and cancerNo harm to heart or death outcomes from cutting saturated fat. One 1960s trial in men with heart disease had more deaths on safflower oil; cancer: possibly slightly more.The detailsHeart and death outcomes: no harm from cutting saturated fat in 15 trials ('no evidence of harmful effects'). Critics point to two recovered 1960s–70s trials: in the Sydney Diet Heart Study (458 men with heart disease) deaths were 17.6% on safflower oil vs 11.8% (HR 1.62, 1.00 to 2.64), and the Minnesota Coronary Experiment showed no death benefit; pooled omega-6 trials show little or no effect on deaths (RR 1.00). Cancer: more total polyunsaturated fat may slightly raise cancer diagnosis (RR 1.19, 0.99 to 1.42; about 8 more per 1,000; low quality; doses very high in some trials); omega-6 alone unclear.Hooper 2020 · 97 StrongRamsden 2013 · 59 LimitedRamsden 2016 · 66 GoodHooper 2018 · 91 StrongHanson et al. 2020 · 92 Strong
Who should avoid itNo group or medicine interaction found.The detailsNo group or medicine interaction found.
How much to swapThe benefit grew with bigger cuts in saturated fat. Deep-frying and re-using oil weren't tested.The detailsThe benefit grew with bigger cuts in saturated fat (and in blood cholesterol). Deep-frying and re-using oil weren't tested in the studies we rated.Hooper 2020 · 97 Strong
Seed-oil processingConcerns about how seed oils are processed weren't tested in the studies we rated.The detailsSeed-oil 'processing' concerns weren't tested in the studies we rated.
What replaces butter mattersSwap saturated fat for plant oils or high-fibre foods, not refined starch or sugar (WHO); trials didn't separate refined from whole-grain carbohydrate.The detailsWhat replaces the saturated fat matters: WHO advises unsaturated plant fats or carbohydrate from high-fibre foods, not refined starch or sugar. The trials didn't separate refined from whole-grain carbohydrate.WHO 2023 · 84 StrongHooper 2020 · 97 Strong
CostAbout A$60–290 (US$40–190) a year for 40 mL of oil a day, versus about A$200–330 (US$130–215) for butter (our estimate).The detailsAbout A$60–290 a year for 2 tablespoons (40 mL) of oil a day vs about A$200–330 for butter (our estimate). Canola is cheaper than butter; extra virgin olive oil costs about the same. Information only.
The evidence, claim by claim (8)Members
What it does
Swapping saturated fat (butter, coconut oil, fatty meat) for plant oils cuts heart attacks and strokes, in adultsShown to helpModerate evidence12 trials, 53,758 adults: cutting saturated fat cut combined heart events 17%. In 17 trials, swapping in polyunsaturated fat cut non-fatal heart attacks 25%.The details12 trials, 53,758 adults: heart events cut 17%. 17 trials: polyunsaturated swap cut non-fatal heart attacks 25% (0.58–0.99); important absolute cuts only at high risk.Who makes this claim: Heart Foundation, WHO, AHA; US Dietary Guidelines 2025–2030 (saturated fat under 10% of energy; prioritise oils such as olive oil, butter and beef tallow also listed)Hooper 2020 · 97 StrongSteen 2026 · 90 Strong (independence estimated*)WHO 2023 · 84 StrongHeart Foundation 2019 · 55 LimitedUS Departments of Agriculture and Health and Human Services · Official data
Plant oils in place of butter lower LDL cholesterolShown to helpModerate evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomes54 trials: replacing butter with 9 of 10 plant oils (palm, coconut included) as 10% of calories cut LDL 0.23–0.42 mmol/L; safflower and canola most.The details54 trials: 9 of 10 plant oils, palm and coconut too, cut LDL 0.23–0.42 mmol/L per 10% energy vs butter; safflower, canola most (low–moderate certainty).Who makes this claim: Heart Foundation, WHOSchwingshackl et al. 2018 · 94 StrongMensink 2016 · 94 Strong
What it doesn't clearly do
Using plant oils (especially olive oil) is linked with living longerShown not to helpModerate evidenceTrials: deaths little or no change. Studies following people: over 7 g olive oil a day linked with 19% fewer deaths, a link, not proof.The detailsTrials: deaths little or no change (RR 0.96, 0.90–1.03; moderate certainty). Cohorts: over 7 g olive oil daily linked with 19% fewer deaths (no absolute).Who makes this claim: Olive-oil sector, Harvard Nutrition Source, mediaHooper 2020 · 97 StrongGuasch-Ferré et al. 2022 · 68 GoodSadeghi et al. 2025 · 63 LimitedKe 2024 · 74 Good (independence estimated*)
Extra virgin olive oil is better than other plant oilsNot yet knownEarly evidenceNo trial compared oils on heart events; on LDL, sunflower and canola beat olive slightly. Studies following people: olive no different from other oils combined.The detailsNo trial compared oils on heart events; on LDL, sunflower and canola beat olive slightly. Cohorts found olive no different from other oils combined.Who makes this claim: Olive-oil sector, PREDIMED authors (olive oil donated by producers)Schwingshackl et al. 2018 · 94 StrongGuasch-Ferré et al. 2022 · 68 GoodZou 2025 · 74 Good
Not reviewed yet
Polyunsaturated oils lower type 2 diabetes riskUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (below the top claims by priority). Hooper 2020 found little or no effect on diabetes diagnosis.Who makes this claim: Harvard Nutrition SourceHooper 2020 · 97 Strong
Heating oils (deep-frying, re-using oil) creates harmful oxidation productsUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (below the top claims by priority).Who makes this claim: Seed-oil critics
Seed oils are harmful because they're 'industrially processed' (hexane extraction)UntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (below the top claims by priority).Who makes this claim: Seed-oil critics
Olive oil polyphenols lower inflammationUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (below the top claims by priority).Who makes this claim: Olive-oil sector
Fact-checked 1 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
+ Add a note
3A handful of nuts most days5 studies⌄
Eat about 30 g of nuts on most days (Optimal); skip this step if you're allergic to nuts. The evidence is mostly from observational studies, plus one large trial (PREDIMED).
What it found: In cohort studies of about 1.9 million people, those who ate the most nuts and seeds had about 20% less heart disease and about a quarter fewer heart deaths; about 30 g a day showed similar links. In trials, nuts barely changed LDL cholesterol.
What it means for you: A 30 g handful most days matches the amount linked with less heart disease; skip it if you're allergic.
The figures and the limit
Coronary heart disease RR 0.81–0.82; cardiovascular deaths RR 0.74–0.77; deaths from any cause RR 0.77.
The limit: Observational, so not proof that nuts cause the difference.
▸ See 4 more studies▾ 4 more studies, best firstMembers
We haven't found a guideline page on nut serves that clears our bar yet.
We haven't found a practical guide to eating nuts most days that clears our bar yet.
+ Add a note
4Fish about twice a week (optional)Optional1 product4 studies2 websites⌄
Eat fish, preferably oily fish, about twice a week. If you're pregnant, planning a pregnancy or feeding children under 6, follow FSANZ's advice on limiting high-mercury fish.
What it found: An American Heart Association expert advisory recommends 1 to 2 seafood meals a week to lower the risk of heart failure, coronary heart disease, ischaemic stroke and sudden cardiac death, especially when seafood replaces less healthy foods.
What it means for you: Fish about twice a week matches this advice, especially if it replaces less healthy foods.
▸ See 3 more studies▾ 3 more studies, best firstMembers
Best for: Advises 2–3 serves of fish a week, oily fish preferred.
Caution: Graded B, level III on the NHMRC scale, for preventing heart disease; no trials of fish as food.
▸ See 1 more website▾ 1 more websiteMembers
Product
Fish-oil (omega-3) capsules
What it is: Capsules of fish oil; a standard 1,000 mg capsule holds about 300 mg of the omega-3s EPA and DHA.
Do fish-oil capsules protect your heart?
Shown to helpModerate evidence
A small benefit. In 86 trials of adults with or without heart disease, over 1–7 years, heart deaths fell about 8%; deaths overall and heart and stroke events overall didn't clearly change. Capsules slightly raise irregular-heartbeat risk.
+Slightly fewer heart deaths, about 8%, in 86 trialsModerate evidence
○Deaths from any cause, and heart and stroke events overall: no clear changeStrong evidence
+On dialysis, 4 g of fish oil a day roughly halved serious heart eventsEarly evidence
+Lowers triglycerides (a blood fat) by about 15%Moderate evidence
○Memory and dementia: no clear effect in 38 trials of older adultsModerate evidence
–Irregular heartbeat: 0.8 more per 1,000 a year at standard doses, 1.6 across all doses (our estimate)Moderate evidence
–In over-50s, slightly more depression: 13.9 versus 12.3 per 1,000 a yearEarly evidence
The triglyceride result measured a blood fat, not heart attacks or strokes
How to do it: A large 5-year trial used 1 g a day; the kidney dialysis trial used 4 g of fish oil a day (a high dose) for 3.5 years.
A standard 1,000 mg capsule holds about 300 mg of EPA and DHA; check the label.
Sticking with it: No data on how many keep taking it; in a 5-year trial, 9 in 10 stayed to the end.
Cost: About US$60–90 a year at 2–3 standard capsules a day (our estimate).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Atrial fibrillation or blood thinners: check with your doctor first; atrial fibrillation rose even at standard doses, and more above 1 g a day.
Risks and who should be careful (15)
fish oil raises the risk of atrial fibrillation (adults, more at higher doses)Shown to harmModerate evidenceIn 7 trials of 81,210 adults over about 5 years, atrial fibrillation was 25% higher: about 1.6 more per 1,000 a year (our estimate).The details7 trials, 81,210 adults: atrial fibrillation 25% higher (about 1.6 more per 1,000 yearly); 12% at 1 g daily or less, 49% above (our estimates).Who makes this claim: Cardiologists, trial reviews (Gencer 2021)Gencer et al. 2021 · 83 StrongAbuknesha et al. 2026 · 80 StrongChen et al. 2024 · 67 GoodO'Keefe et al. 2025 · 63 LimitedKhan et al. 2021 · 83 Strong
fish oil raises bleeding, especially with blood thinnersLeans toward harm; not yet knownMore data neededIn 11 trials of 120,643 people, bleeding wasn't clearly higher, including with antiplatelet medicines; high-dose prescription EPA: about 6 more in 1,000 bled.The details11 trials, 120,643 people: bleeding RR 1.09 (0.91–1.31), range includes no effect; antiplatelet use didn't raise it. High-dose prescription EPA: 0.6% more.Who makes this claim: Critics, surgeonsJavaid et al. 2024 · 79 GoodOkereke et al. 2021 · 89 Strong
regular fish-oil use is linked with a first stroke or atrial fibrillation in healthy peopleProbably harmfulEarly evidenceIn 415,737 UK adults, regular use was linked with 13% more atrial fibrillation; a re-analysis treating age differently found no link.The detailsUK Biobank, 415,737 adults: use linked with atrial fibrillation (HR 1.13; no absolute), not clearly stroke. Re-analysis modelling age differently: none. 7 trials: AF raised.Who makes this claim: BMJ Medicine 2024 coverageChen et al. 2024 · 67 GoodO'Keefe et al. 2025 · 63 LimitedAbdelhamid 2020 · 100 StrongGencer et al. 2021 · 83 Strong
capsules are oxidised or hold less omega-3 than the label says (Australia, New Zealand)Probably harmfulEarly evidenceA third of 26 Australian products exceeded total oxidation limits; an industry-funded test of 10 found all met their labels. Health effect untested.The details26 Australian products: a third exceeded total oxidation limits; an industry-funded test of 10 found all met labels. Health effect untested.Who makes this claim: University lab surveys, NZ 'fishy labels' coverage; GOED (industry) disputesHeller et al. 2019 · 45 Weak (independence estimated*)Nichols et al. 2016 · 41 WeakTGA · Official data
mercury or pollutants in capsulesUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: Critics
cod liver oil gives too much vitamin A (pregnancy)UntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: First principles
Irregular heartbeatAtrial fibrillation rose in trials, about 1.6 more per 1,000 a year (our estimate), and more above 1 g a day. Stomach upset and bruising matched placebo.The detailsAtrial fibrillation rose in trials (HR 1.25; about 1.6 more per 1,000 a year, our estimate), more above 1 g a day; a GRADE-graded 38-trial review found RR 1.26 (1.08 to 1.48), and a 35-trial review by authors with omega-3 industry ties found the rise only at high doses in people at high heart risk. Stomach upset and bruising were no different from placebo at 1 g a day.Gencer et al. 2021 · 83 StrongAbuknesha et al. 2026 · 80 StrongOkereke et al. 2021 · 89 StrongKhan et al. 2021 · 83 Strong
Bleeding and blood thinnersBleeding wasn't clearly higher (11 trials), but warfarin users weren't studied separately; prescription EPA added a little. Atrial fibrillation or blood thinners: your doctor's call.The detailsBleeding was 9% higher overall (11 trials), but the range includes no effect, and trials with more people on antiplatelet medicines didn't show more bleeding; people on anticoagulants such as warfarin weren't analysed separately. High-dose purified EPA, a prescription medicine, added about 0.6 percentage points to bleeding risk. If you have atrial fibrillation or take blood thinners, whether to take it is your doctor's call.Javaid et al. 2024 · 79 GoodAbuknesha et al. 2026 · 80 Strong
DoseAtrial fibrillation risk rose about 10–11% per extra gram a day. A standard 1,000 mg capsule holds about 300 mg EPA and DHA; labels suggest 2–3 daily.The detailsNo difference in heart effects by dose across 86 trials; atrial fibrillation risk rose about 10–11% per extra gram a day. A standard 1,000 mg capsule holds about 300 mg EPA+DHA (a common Australian product's label), and the label dose is 2–3 a day.Abdelhamid 2020 · 100 StrongGencer et al. 2021 · 83 Strong
Product qualityAustralia's TGA doesn't check AUST L capsules before sale; the US FDA doesn't approve supplements. A third of 26 Australian products exceeded oxidation limits.The detailsIn Australia, capsules sold as listed medicines (AUST L on the label) aren't evaluated by the TGA for quality, safety or efficacy before sale. A third of 26 Australian products exceeded total oxidation limits (2019); an industry-funded test of 10 found all met their labels (2016). In the US, fish oil is sold as a dietary supplement, which the FDA doesn't approve before sale. Whether oxidation matters for health is untested.TGA · Official dataHeller et al. 2019 · 45 Weak (independence estimated*)Nichols et al. 2016 · 41 WeakFDA · Official data
FlavouringsFlavourings stopped an oxidation test working in 2 of 10 products, so rancidity couldn't be checked in those.The detailsFlavourings interfered with an oxidation test in 2 of 10 products in one survey, so rancidity couldn't be checked in those.Nichols et al. 2016 · 41 Weak
Feeling protectedCapsules can feel like heart protection, but 86 trials found at most a small effect; the UK's NICE tells doctors not to offer them to prevent heart disease.The detailsTaking capsules can feel like heart protection, but 86 trials found little or no effect on deaths overall and only a small cut in heart deaths, and the UK's NICE (2023) tells doctors not to offer omega-3 compounds to prevent heart disease, except prescription icosapent ethyl in set cases.Abdelhamid 2020 · 100 StrongNICE NG238 · 81 Strong
Instead of eating fishCapsules could stand in for eating fish or other heart-health steps; this hasn't been tested.The detailsCapsules could stand in for eating fish or other heart-health steps.
Oily fish insteadOily fish 2–3 times a week (Australia's Heart Foundation) is linked with fewer heart deaths, though eating fish hasn't been trialled.The detailsOily fish about twice a week is the course's food step (Australia's Heart Foundation: 2–3 serves a week); eating fish is linked with fewer heart deaths, though it hasn't been trialled.Heart Foundation 2015 · 65 GoodGiosuè et al. 2022 · 74 Good
CostA common 1,000 mg capsule costs about US$60–90 a year at 2–3 a day (A$89–134; our estimate).The detailsA common 1,000 mg capsule, 400 for about A$49 at a large Australian pharmacy chain (1 Nov 2026): about A$89 a year at 2 a day and A$134 at 3 (our estimate).
The evidence, claim by claim (9)Members
What it does
Fish-oil capsules cut heart attacks, strokes and heart deaths (adults, with or without heart disease)Shown to helpModerate evidenceAcross 86 trials, heart deaths fell about 8% and about 1 in 167 people avoided a coronary event; deaths overall didn't clearly change.The detailsCochrane, 86 trials: cardiovascular deaths RR 0.92 (0.86–0.99, moderate certainty); coronary heart disease events RR 0.91 (0.85–0.97, low; about 1 in 167); deaths RR 0.97 and all heart and stroke events RR 0.96, no clear difference (high certainty). A review including prescription EPA: heart deaths RR 0.93 (absolute none given).Who makes this claim: Fish-oil makers, AARP explainer, Huberman Lab (not rated); NICE 2023 and Heart Foundation 2015 don't recommend capsules for preventionAbdelhamid 2020 · 100 StrongKhan et al. 2021 · 83 StrongNICE NG238 · 81 StrongHeart Foundation 2015 · 65 Good
High-dose fish oil cuts heart events in adults on haemodialysisProbably helpsEarly evidenceIn 1,228 adults on kidney dialysis over 3.5 years, 4 g of fish oil a day (a high dose) roughly halved serious heart events versus placebo. Your doctor's call.The detailsPISCES, 1,228 adults on haemodialysis (Canada, Australia), 4 g daily, 3.5 years: cut serious heart events, 0.31 vs 0.61 per 1,000 patient-days.Who makes this claim: PISCES investigators; a high dose (about 8 standard capsules' worth of EPA and DHA), so your doctor's callLok et al. 2026 · 87 Strong (independence estimated*)
Fish oil lowers triglycerides (adults with high triglycerides)Shown to helpModerate evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesFish oil lowered triglycerides by about 15% in trials, more at higher doses; heart events weren't clearly cut.The detailsTrials: long-chain omega-3 lowered triglycerides about 15%, more at higher doses (high certainty); heart events weren't clearly cut.Who makes this claim: Fish-oil brandsAbdelhamid 2020 · 100 Strong
What it doesn't clearly do
Fish oil protects memory and thinking and prevents dementia (older adults)Shown not to helpModerate evidenceIn 38 trials of 49,757 adults, fish oil made no clear difference to new dementia or memory problems.The details38 trials, 49,757 adults: no effect on new dementia or similar illness (RR 0.98) or new cognitive impairment (RR 0.99); moderate certainty.Who makes this claim: Fish-oil brands, Huberman Lab (not rated)Brainard et al. 2020 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)
Fish oil improves mood and treats or prevents depression (adults)Probably harmfulEarly evidenceIn 18,353 over-50s over 5 years, 1 g daily slightly raised depression (13.9 versus 12.3 per 1,000 a year). Treatment trials: small, likely biased.The details18,353 over-50s: 1 g daily raised depression risk (13.9 vs 12.3 per 1,000 yearly; HR 1.13, 1.01–1.26); mood scores unchanged. Treatment trials: small, likely biased.Who makes this claim: Fish-oil brands, Huberman Lab (not rated)Okereke et al. 2021 · 89 StrongAppleton et al. 2021 · 89 Strong (independence estimated*)
Fishy burps, reflux and stomach upsetShown not to helpModerate evidenceIn a 5-year trial, stomach upset was 35.2% on 1 g a day versus 35.1% on placebo: no clear difference.The detailsVITAL, 1 g daily vs placebo: stomach upset or pain 35.2% vs 35.1%; easy bruising 24.8% vs 25.1%; fishy burps and reflux weren't reported.Who makes this claim: Users, criticsOkereke et al. 2021 · 89 Strong
Not reviewed yet
Fish oil eases joint pain and inflammation (arthritis)UntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: Fish-oil brands
High-dose prescription EPA (icosapent ethyl) cuts heart events in people on statins with high triglycerides (REDUCE-IT)UntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. It's a prescription medicine, so it's your doctor's call.The detailsNot yet rated: a prescription medicine, so your doctor's call.Who makes this claim: Cardiology trials, the drug's maker
Fish oil relieves dry eyesUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority); claimed in the most-viewed fish-oil video on our goal pages.Who makes this claim: YouTube: 'I Took Omega 3 Fish Oil for 90 days' (2.7M views)
Fact-checked 1 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
We haven't found a practical guide to eating more fish that clears our bar yet.
+ Add a note
5What helps you stick with itOptional4 studies2 websites⌄
Set specific goals and plans, track what you eat, and get regular feedback from a dietitian or digital program. This helped over 2 to 6 months; whether changes last once support stops isn't well tested.
What it found: In 39 trials of 7,333 adults with diet-related long-term conditions, diet programs delivered by app, website or other digital means raised fruit and vegetables by about two-thirds of a serve a day, cut weight by about 2 kg and lifted Mediterranean-style eating.
What it means for you: Digital programs with goals, tracking and feedback can help you stick with it, though the gains are modest.
The figures and the limit
Fruit and vegetables +0.63 serves a day; weight −1.94 kg (39 trials).
The limit: Low to moderate certainty; long-term keeping not reported.
▸ See 3 more studies▾ 3 more studies, best firstMembers
Best for: Australia's general-practice guide to lifestyle risk factors, including referral to support.
Caution: Written for GPs.
▸ See 1 more website▾ 1 more websiteMembers
+ Add a note
3. Fibre, plants and whole grains⌄4 steps · 40 items
1Reach your vegetable and fruit serves1 product9 studies2 websites⌄
Eat 5–6 serves of vegetables and legumes and 2 of fruit a day, by age and sex. Frozen and tinned count; don't rely on potatoes or juice. More may add a little; evidence is mixed.
Best for: Summarises WHO's 2023 guideline on vegetables, fruit and fibre.
Why it's rated 95Independence 30/30: Published by the World Health Organization, an intergovernmental body.Evidence practices 25/25: WHO's own guidance, so scored on its guidelines: a named development group, systematic reviews, a published method and conflict rules.Accuracy check 20/20: At least 400 g of fruit and vegetables a day, frozen or canned fine without added sugar or salt: matches current WHO guidance.Currency 15/15: Page dated 26 January 2026.Fit for this step 5/10: Gives a gram target, not your country's serves by age and sex.Site Rating out of 100: independence 30, evidence practices 25, accuracy against the research we've rated 20, currency 15, fit for this step 10. 80+ highly reliable · 65–79 reliable · 50–64 use with care.
What it found: Across 95 long-term studies, each extra 200 g of fruit and vegetables a day was linked with about 8% less coronary heart disease, 16% fewer strokes and 10% fewer early deaths. Links held up to 800 g a day; other reviews disagree above 5 serves.
What it means for you: Reaching your 5 to 6 vegetable and 2 fruit serves is linked with less heart disease, stroke and early death.
The figures and the limit
Per extra 200 g a day: heart disease RR 0.92, stroke RR 0.84, death RR 0.90 (95 studies).
The limit: Observational only; US servings differ from Australian serves; reviews disagree above about 5 a day.
▸ See 8 more studies▾ 8 more studies, best firstMembers
Product
Greens powders
What it is: Powdered blends of dried vegetables, fruit, grasses and algae, often with added vitamins and minerals, probiotics, enzymes or herbs.
36Skip itWorth doing?
Does a greens powder help you get your vegetables and fruit?
Shown not to helpModerate evidence
It isn't a substitute: a serve has 1–2 g of fibre, a tenth or less of 7 daily serves', and far less potassium and bulk. As a top-up, it raises blood vitamins; no health gain shown.
Bottom line: A powder doesn't count toward your serves, so put the money toward vegetables and fruit; frozen and tinned count. Leading blends cost about US$290–1,200 a year; all your recommended vegetables and fruit, about US$910–1,100 (US, 2022 prices; our estimates).
46 possible effects searched · 68 sources rated · independently checked · 5 Nov 2026
EffectStrength
Fibre and food bulk of your serves○ Shown not to help
Direct: 1–2 g fibre a serve, against about 18 g in 7 serves
Vitamins and minerals of your serves○ Shown not to help
Direct: more vitamin C and folate; far less potassium, magnesium, carotenoids
Vegetables' health benefits? Not yet known
Link only (stand-in): antioxidant pills didn't cut deaths in 78 trials
Blood vitamin levels (a top-up)✓ Probably helps
Marker only: rose in small trials; health not tested
Eating fewer vegetables? Not yet known
Link only: small lab experiments; users eat as well
Salmonella food poisoning✕ Probably harmful
Direct: one US outbreak, 2025–26; 131 ill, 36 in hospital
Lead✕ Probably harmful
Marker only: some products unsuitable for children or pregnancy
✓ helps · ✕ harms · ○ no clear difference · ? not known · dots: strength of evidence
How to do it: No trial has compared a powder with eating vegetables. We compared 5 leading blends' labels with food tables for 5 vegetable and 2 fruit serves; powder trials of 2 weeks to 8 months measured blood vitamins, digestion and colds, not serves.
Count frozen, tinned and dried vegetables and fruit toward your serves; a powder doesn't count.
Check the label: blends range from plain dried greens to a full multivitamin with herbs and probiotics.
Choose a product independently tested for lead, such as one with a third-party testing seal.
Already take a multivitamin or vitamin B6? Add up the totals; powders can double up.
Taking warfarin: keep your vitamin K intake steady and talk to your doctor before starting.
Smokers: avoid products with added beta-carotene or vitamin A.
Pregnant, or giving it to children: check lead testing and vitamin A first.
Throw out recalled powders; dry plant powders keep for months and can still carry Salmonella.
Sticking with it: No data on how many people keep taking it after a year.
Cost: About US$290–1,200 a year taken daily for leading blends (US$24–99 per 30 serves, US, 2026; our estimate). A full day's recommended vegetables and fruit cost about US$2.50–3.00 a day (US, 2022 prices).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Taking warfarin, pregnant, giving it to children, with kidney disease, or very ill or immune-suppressed: check with your doctor or pharmacist first (your doctor's call). Smokers: avoid added beta-carotene. Skip it if the cost means fewer vegetables.
Risks and who should be careful (29)
taking a greens powder leads people to eat fewer vegetables or drop other healthy habitsNot yet knownMore data neededLink only · single sessions; surveysIn one team's small experiments, people told they'd had a supplement chose less healthily; surveys find users eat as many vegetables.The studies (6)
3 small experiments, one team: looser choices · 3 surveys: users eat as well
The detailsLab: 2 deception experiments (n=150) and a buffet experiment, one Taiwanese team; licensing of exercise intent, buffet choice and walking; no vegetable intake measured; no independent replication found. Surveys: users eat as many or more fruit and vegetables (Korea +9–30% spend; Swiss, US mixed or better).Who makes this claim: Dietitians and critics ('false reassurance'); psychologists studying licensing
greens powders can carry Salmonella and cause food poisoningProbably harmfulEarly evidenceDirect · US outbreak, 2025–26Rarely. In 2025–26, moringa powder in a greens brand and in capsules caused a US Salmonella outbreak: 131 ill, 36 in hospital.The studies (1)
1 US outbreak: 131 ill, 36 in hospital · several greens and moringa recalls
The detailsCDC, Jul 2026: 131 ill in 38 states, 36 of 121 hospitalised; genome sequencing and product samples matched. One outbreak, so evidence is early; frequency unknown.Who makes this claim: US CDC and FDA; recall notices
greens powders can contain lead and other heavy metals, for regular users, children and pregnancyProbably harmfulEarly evidenceMarker only · product tests, 2016–2023US tests found lead unsuitable for children or pregnancy in several greens products; Polish barley-grass powders exceeded mercury limits. Health effects weren't measured.The studies (8)
US: lead high in some · Poland: mercury over EU limits · algae: within limits
The detailsMarker only: 4 of 13 (2016), 1 of 12 (2019) over the tester's lead limits; several of 24 (2023) unsuitable for children or pregnancy; FDA reference levels: 2.2 µg a day (children), 8.8 (women of childbearing age).Who makes this claim: Independent testers (US); regulators (US, Australia)
vitamin K and herbs in greens powders change warfarin's effect, in people taking warfarinProbably harmfulEarly evidenceLink only · reviews of studies and case reportsVitamin K weakens warfarin; a leading blend adds 90 micrograms a serve. Keep intake steady and tell your doctor; not studied with powders.The studies (4)
2 reviews: vitamin K and some herbs alter warfarin · leading blend: 90 micrograms K2
The detailsVioli 2016: intake above about 150 µg a day may shift warfarin control; green tea, ginkgo and St John's wort also interact (Tan 2021). No powder studies.Who makes this claim: Pharmacists, anticoagulation clinics, NIH Office of Dietary Supplements
vitamins in greens powders add to other supplements and pass safe upper limits, for some groupsProbably harmfulEarly evidenceLink only · trials, surveys and reportsWith other supplements, totals can pass safe limits: vitamin B6 can damage nerves, vitamin A harms pregnancies, beta-carotene harms smokers.The studies (4)
Trials: beta-carotene harmed smokers · US cohort: some over limits · Australia: 250 B6 reports
The detailsNIH: 10–15% of multivitamin users above upper limits for vitamin A, iron, zinc (one cohort). Beta-carotene: lung cancer OR 1.20 (1.01–1.42) in high-risk people. TGA: 250 B6 nerve-damage reports to Oct 2025. The US task force review also lists limited evidence of hip fracture (vitamin A), kidney stones (vitamin C, calcium) and bleeding stroke (vitamin E) at high doses.Who makes this claim: NIH Office of Dietary Supplements; US Preventive Services Task Force; Therapeutic Goods Administration (Australia)
herbs in greens powders, such as ashwagandha and green tea extract, can injure the liver, in adultsProbably harmfulEarly evidenceLink only · case reports and reviewsRarely. Ashwagandha and green tea extract have caused liver injury; doses in blends are often not listed.The studies (3)
US: supplements in 1 in 5 cases · EU: catechins capped · Australia: 11 reports
The detailsRare and dose-related: EFSA, EGCG 800 mg a day or more from supplements raised transaminases (EU cap since 2022); US network: supplements 20% of drug-related liver injury; TGA: 11 ashwagandha reports, 'very rare'.Who makes this claim: Regulators (TGA, EFSA); liver specialists
oxalate and potassium in leafy-green powders, in people with kidney diseaseLeans toward harm; not yet knownAnecdotalLink only · case reportsCase reports link oxalate-rich green juices with kidney failure, mostly with existing kidney disease; powders not studied.The studies (2)
1 case report, 1 case series: oxalate kidney injury after juicing · powders: not studied
The detailsAnecdotal: Mayo series, 3 of 65 oxalate kidney injuries presumed diet-induced on top of kidney disease; one green-smoothie cleanse case. Potassium in powders not reviewed.Who makes this claim: Kidney specialists
probiotics in greens powders can cause bloodstream infections, in very ill or immune-suppressed people and preterm babiesProbably harmfulEarly evidenceLink only · hospital data, 2018–2023In intensive care, about 1 in 90 patients given a probiotic got a bloodstream infection from it; preterm babies are also at risk.The studies (2)
1 ICU study: probiotic strain in the blood · FDA: preterm-baby infections and a death
The detailsYelin 2019: Lactobacillus bacteraemia 6 of 522 (1.1%) given probiotics vs 2 of 21,652; FDA 2023: preterm-infant infections and a death.Who makes this claim: FDA; infectious-disease researchers
greens powders cause stomach upset or other side effects, in adultsProbably doesn't harmEarly evidenceDirect · 2–12 weeksIn 3 trials of 2–12 weeks, 2 of them maker-funded, side effects and liver and kidney tests didn't differ from placebo.The studies (3)
3 trials: no more side effects than placebo · blood safety tests normal
The detailsWood 2025: 105 of 120 adults, 12 weeks, no blood safety changes, no adverse events; La Monica 2024 and Gonzalez 2026: well tolerated. Longer use not studied.Who makes this claim: Users and reviewers report bloating; makers report none
multivitamins speed age-related macular degenerationUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. Mentioned in a review of reviews; not yet checked.The detailsMentioned in a review of reviews; not yet checked.
ashwagandha or kelp in blends affects the thyroidUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. Not yet looked at for blends.The detailsNot yet looked at for blends.
spirulina, chlorella or alfalfa carry algae toxins or worsen autoimmune diseaseUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. Case reports and tester notes only.The detailsCase reports and tester notes only.
greens powders contain plasticizersUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. A tester reported them in one product; figures aren't public.The detailsA tester reported them in one product; figures aren't public.
soy-derived vitamins in blends cause allergic reactionsUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. One case report; not yet checked.The detailsOne case report; not yet checked.
Side effectsNo more side effects than placebo in 3 trials of 2–12 weeks, at least 2 maker-funded; longer use hasn't been studied.The detailsWood 2025 (120 adults, 12 weeks): no change in liver, kidney or blood safety tests and no adverse events; La Monica 2024 (30 adults, 4 weeks) and Gonzalez 2026 (20 adults, 2 weeks): well tolerated. La Monica and Gonzalez were maker-funded; Wood's funding statement wasn't read.Wood et al. 2025 · 56 Limited (independence estimated*)La Monica et al. 2024 · 59 LimitedGonzalez et al. 2026 · 56 Limited
Salmonella and recallsDry plant powders can carry Salmonella: moringa powder in one greens brand and in capsules made 131 people ill in the US (2025–26). Throw out recalled products.The detailsCDC final update 22 Jul 2026: 131 ill in 38 states, 36 of 121 hospitalised, no deaths; linked by whole-genome sequencing and product testing to moringa leaf powder from a common manufacturer. How often powders carry Salmonella isn't known (US).US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, final update 22 Jul 2026 · 95 Strong (official data)
Lead and testingUS tests found lead unsuitable for children or pregnancy in several products, including a leading brand. Supplements aren't checked by regulators before sale.The detailsConsumerLab: 4 of 13 (2016), 1 of 12 (2019) over its lead limits; 'several' of 24 (2023) unsuitable for children or pregnancy; lead found in a leading blend (2022). FDA: no safe level of lead (US). Listed supplements aren't individually evaluated before sale (Australia); the FDA doesn't approve supplements before sale (US).US Food and Drug Administration 2025 · 95 Strong (official data)ConsumerLab 2023 · 46 WeakConsumerLab 2016 · 46 WeakConsumerLab 2019 · 46 WeakConsumerLab · 46 WeakTGA · 90 Strong (official data)FDA · 85 Strong (official data)
Warfarin and other medicinesWarfarin: vitamin K and herbs such as green tea, ginkgo and St John's wort can change its effect; keep intake steady. Other regular medicines: your doctor's call.The detailsA leading blend has 90 µg vitamin K2 a serve; intakes above about 150 µg a day may shift warfarin control (Violi 2016); NIH advises warfarin users to check before any supplement with vitamin K. Not studied with powders.NIH Office of Dietary Supplements · 85 Strong (official data)Tan and Lee 2021 · 60 Limited (independence estimated*)Violi et al. 2016 · 58 Limited (independence estimated*)ConsumerLab · 46 Weak
Doubling up on vitaminsWith a multivitamin or other supplements, totals of vitamin A, B6, iron or zinc can pass safe limits; add up the labels.The detailsNIH: 10–15% of multivitamin users in one US cohort had excess vitamin A, iron or zinc. Australia's regulator: 250 reports of nerve damage from vitamin B6 products, sometimes at 50 mg a day or less; labels warn above 10 mg (Australia). A leading blend has 5 mg B6 a serve.NIH Office of Dietary Supplements · 85 Strong (official data)Therapeutic Goods Administration · 85 Strong (official data)ConsumerLab · 46 Weak
Smokers and beta-caroteneBeta-carotene supplements raised lung cancer in people at high risk; smokers and former smokers should avoid products with added beta-carotene or vitamin A.The detailsUSPSTF review: beta-carotene, with or without vitamin A, lung cancer OR 1.20 (1.01–1.42) in 4 trials of people at high risk. NIH: smokers should avoid multivitamins with large amounts of beta-carotene or vitamin A.O'Connor 2022 · 89 StrongUSPSTF 2022 · 85 StrongNIH Office of Dietary Supplements · 85 Strong (official data)
Pregnancy and childrenPregnant, or for children: check the product is lead-tested and doesn't add preformed vitamin A; your doctor's or midwife's call.The detailsSeveral tested products had lead unsuitable for children or pregnancy (US). Excess preformed vitamin A (retinol), not beta-carotene, can cause birth defects (NIH).ConsumerLab 2023 · 46 WeakConsumerLab · 46 WeakNIH Office of Dietary Supplements · 85 Strong (official data)
Herbs and the liverHerbs such as ashwagandha and green tea extract have rarely injured the liver; amounts in blends are often not listed.The detailsEFSA: 800 mg or more a day of green tea catechins from supplements raised liver-injury markers; EU cap since 2022 (EU). Australia: 11 possible ashwagandha liver-injury reports, 'very rare' (Australia). US network: supplements caused 20% of drug-related liver injury (US).European Food Safety Authority 2018 · 88 Strong (official data)Therapeutic Goods Administration · 60 Limited (official data)Navarro et al. 2017 · 46 Weak (independence estimated*)
Kidney diseaseOxalate-rich green juices have caused kidney failure, mostly in people with kidney disease; with kidney disease, check with your kidney team first.The detailsCase reports and a Mayo Clinic series; powders and their potassium content not studied.Makkapati et al. 2018 · 39 Weak (independence estimated*)Getting et al. 2013 · 39 Weak (independence estimated*)
Very ill or immune-suppressedProbiotics have caused bloodstream infections in intensive-care patients and preterm babies; check first if you're very ill or immune-suppressed.The detailsICU: Lactobacillus bacteraemia 6 of 522 given a probiotic vs 2 of 21,652 not given it. FDA: preterm infants given probiotics are at risk of invasive infection; one death in 2023 (US).Yelin et al. 2019 · 69 Good (independence estimated*)US Food and Drug Administration · 65 Good (official data)
Hidden amounts'Proprietary blends' often don't list how much of each herb or probiotic you get, so doses can't be checked.The detailsHerb, enzyme and probiotic amounts are often grouped under a blend total; not reviewed further.
A powder isn't vegetablesA daily powder can feel like covering your vegetables, but it gives at most a tenth of their fibre and little of their potassium or bulk.The detailsLabels of 5 leading blends: 1–2 g fibre, 85–450 mg potassium a serve; 5 vegetable and 2 fruit serves: about 18 g and 1,500 mg (food tables, our estimate). Antioxidant pills didn't cut deaths in 78 trials.Labels of 5 leading greens blends · 45 Weak (official data)Food Standards Australia New Zealand · 100 Strong (official data)Bjelakovic et al. 2012 · 100 StrongO'Connor 2022 · 89 Strong
Eating fewer vegetablesNot shown: small lab experiments by one team found people felt licensed to choose less healthily; surveys find supplement users eat as many or more vegetables.The detailsChiou 2011 (150 adults) and Chang 2014: placebo described as a supplement loosened exercise intent, buffet choice, walking and buffet eating; no independent repeat found. Kang 2017 (508 households), van der Horst 2011 (6,189), Reedy 2005 (727): users don't eat fewer fruit and vegetables.Chiou, Yang and Wan 2011 · 62 LimitedChang and Chiou 2014 · 62 LimitedKang et al. 2017 · 57 Limitedvan der Horst and Siegrist 2011 · 56 LimitedReedy, Haines and Campbell 2005 · 54 Limited
Vegetables and fruit insteadFrozen and tinned count. In the US, a full day's recommended vegetables and fruit cost about US$2.50–3.00 in 2022, about what a premium blend costs.The detailsUSDA ERS 2024: US$2.50–3.00 a day for 2 cups of fruit and 2½ of vegetables (2022 prices). About 5 serves a day linked with about 13% fewer deaths than 2 (Wang 2021); WHO advises at least 400 g a day.US Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service · 90 Strong (official data)Wang 2021 · 70 GoodWHO 2023 guideline · 84 StrongUS Departments of Agriculture and Health and Human Services 2026 · 52 Limited
CostAbout US$290–1,200 a year for leading blends (US), or about A$750–880 for one leading Australian blend, taken daily; our estimates.The detailsUS$24–99 per 30 serves for 5 leading blends (US, 2026); A$68–80 per 33 serves for one leading Australian blend (2026). A tester puts a leading blend at about 100 times the daily cost of a good multivitamin.Labels of 5 leading greens blends · 45 Weak (official data)US Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service · 90 Strong (official data)
The evidence, claim by claim (24)MembersGetting your serves · 3 claims · ○2?1
A greens powder gives the fibre and food bulk of your vegetable and fruit serves, in adultsShown not to helpModerate evidenceDirect · product labels and food tablesA serve gives 1–2 g fibre; 7 vegetable and fruit serves, about 18 g in 675 g of food (our estimate).The studies (5)
5 blends: 1–2 g fibre a serve · 7 food serves: about 18 g
The detailsLabels of 5 leading blends: 1–2 g fibre, 5–13 g of powder a serve. Food tables (our basket): 5 vegetable + 2 fruit serves = 18.2 g fibre in 675 g. WHO advises 25 g of naturally occurring fibre; the fibre-health evidence (Reynolds 2019) excluded supplement trials.Who makes this claim: Greens-powder marketing ('your daily greens'); critics: dietitians, ConsumerLab
A greens powder gives the vitamins and minerals of your vegetable and fruit serves, in adultsShown not to helpModerate evidenceDirect · product labels and food tablesFortified blends beat 7 serves on vitamin C and folate, but give 6–30% of their potassium and less magnesium (our estimate).The studies (3)
5 blends' labels: added vitamins high, potassium and magnesium low · food tables: the yardstick
The detailsFortified blends: vitamin C 425–500 mg and folate 680 µg a serve vs about 86 mg and 252 µg in our 7-serve basket. Potassium 85–450 mg vs about 1,513 mg (6–30%); magnesium 30–40 mg in the 2 blends that list it vs 105 mg. Vitamin A 60–900 µg RAE vs about 750 µg RAE (1,498 µg retinol equivalents); but the basket has about 11,000 µg of carotenoids, the blends at most about 1,100–1,800 µg of beta-carotene. Vitamin K has no food-table value. No label lists polyphenols or nitrate. Our estimates.Who makes this claim: Greens-powder brands ('75 vitamins, minerals and whole-food ingredients'); critics: dietitians, NIH Office of Dietary Supplements
A greens powder brings the health benefits of eating vegetables and fruit, in adultsNot yet knownEarly evidenceLink only · 28 days to 12 yearsNo powder was tested against vegetables. In 78 trials, antioxidant pills didn't cut deaths; beta-carotene and vitamin E slightly raised them.The studies (7)
78 antioxidant trials: no fewer deaths · guidelines: get nutrients from food
The detailsNo powder-vs-vegetables trial. Isolated nutrients: antioxidant pills, deaths RR 1.02 (0.98–1.05), 78 trials; low-bias trials beta-carotene RR 1.05, vitamin E RR 1.03 (Bjelakovic 2012); USPSTF 2022: no benefit, beta-carotene harm. Vegetables and fruit: about 13% fewer deaths at 5 vs 2 serves (cohorts). Rated one step less certain because powders themselves weren't tested.Who makes this claim: Greens-powder marketing; critics: US Preventive Services Task Force, World Cancer Research Fund, dietitians
On top of your serves · 7 claims · ✓2○1?4
A greens powder adds vitamins on top of your serves, in adults who eat too few vegetablesProbably helpsEarly evidenceMarker only · 2–14 weeksConcentrates raised blood beta-carotene, vitamins C and E and folate in small trials; most people already get enough vitamin C. Health wasn't tested.The studies (5)
22 concentrate reports: higher blood vitamins · 1 powder trial: more nutrients on paper
The detailsMarker only. Kiefer 2004: serum beta-carotene, C, E, selenium, folate up (59 adults); Esfahani 2011: 22 reports, same. A maker's 2-week trial: +2.8 targets met on a diet recall, 20 adults. Australia: almost all meet vitamin C from food (ABS 2011–12).Who makes this claim: Greens-powder brands ('fill nutrient gaps'); critics: dietitians, NIH Office of Dietary Supplements
Greens powders improve digestion, gut health and bloating, in adultsProbably doesn't helpEarly evidenceDirect · 2 weeks to 5 monthsIn 2 small powder trials of 2–4 weeks, digestion didn't change; probiotics didn't improve healthy adults' gut symptoms.The studies (6)
2 powder trials: digestion unchanged · 3: gut diversity unchanged · probiotic review: no benefit
The detailsDirect but small: maker-funded trials (30 adults, 4 weeks; 20 adults, 2 weeks): digestive quality of life unchanged; diversity unchanged in 3 trials. Probiotics in healthy adults: no gut-symptom benefit (low certainty).Who makes this claim: Greens-powder brands' marketing; influencers; critics: Truth in Advertising, dietitians
Greens powders lower blood pressure, in adultsNot yet knownMore data neededMarker only · 2 hours to 6 monthsNitrate from beetroot or leafy greens lowered blood pressure 2–5 mmHg in short trials, not over 5 weeks; powders rarely list nitrate.The studies (7)
Short nitrate trials: 2–5 mmHg lower · 5-week trial: no difference · powder studies: mixed
The detailsMarker only. Nitrate: systolic -4.4 mmHg (-5.9 to -2.8), 16 trials of 2 h–15 days; high blood pressure -5.3 (low certainty) vs -0.8 (not significant); 5-week trial of 300 mg: no effect. Powder trials small or maker-linked.Who makes this claim: Beet- and greens-powder makers; nitrate researchers
Disease risk, from multivitamin trials · 4 claims · ✓1?3
A greens powder helps you live longer and healthier, in adultsNot yet knownEarly evidenceLink only · 3½–27 yearsMultivitamin trials over 3½–11 years found no fewer deaths; 3 cohorts following users up to 27 years found no longer lives.The studies (5)
21 trials pooled plus 1 later: no fewer deaths · 3 cohorts: no fewer
The detailsIndirect (multivitamins): deaths RR 0.98 (0.94–1.02), 21 trials; COSMOS HR 0.93 (0.81–1.08); 3 cohorts HR 1.04 (1.02–1.07). Capped one level below, as powders differ.Who makes this claim: Greens-powder brands ('foundational health'); wellness podcasts; critics: US Preventive Services Task Force, NIH Office of Dietary Supplements
Greens powders lower heart disease and stroke, in adultsNot yet knownEarly evidenceLink only · 3½–11 yearsIn multivitamin trials over 3½–11 years, older adults had no fewer heart attacks or strokes; greens powders themselves weren't tested.The studies (4)
2 large multivitamin trials: no clear difference · pooled trials: no fewer heart deaths
The detailsIndirect: PHS II no effect on major cardiovascular events over 11.2 years; COSMOS HR 0.98 (0.86–1.12); vascular deaths RR 1.01 (0.93–1.09). Moderate for multivitamins, one level lower for powders.Who makes this claim: Concentrate makers; nitrate and antioxidant advocates; critics: USPSTF
Greens powders with added vitamins keep memory and thinking sharper, in older adultsNot yet knownEarly evidenceLink only · 2–3 yearsIn 2–3 year multivitamin trials, older adults' memory scores rose slightly, below a worthwhile size; too few dementia cases to tell.The studies (2)
1 trial's 3 parts: slightly better scores · dementia: too few cases
The detailsIndirect: COSMOS meta-analysis +0.07 SD global cognition (0.03–0.11), +0.06 SD memory; below our worthwhile size (0.2 SD); authors: about 2 years less cognitive ageing. New MCI or dementia: no clear difference, low power.Who makes this claim: COSMOS researchers; multivitamin and greens brands
Not reviewed yet · 10 claims · ?10
Greens powders lower inflammation and oxidative stressUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. Marker studies only; a urine marker of DNA damage didn't change in one trial.The detailsMarker studies only; a urine marker of DNA damage didn't change in one trial.
Greens powders improve blood-vessel function or blood sugarUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. Small marker trials; in one, the effect came with a separate fibre shake.The detailsSmall marker trials; in one, the effect came with a separate fibre shake.
Greens powders 'alkalise' the body and protect boneUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. No greens-powder studies found.The detailsNo greens-powder studies found.
Why it's rated 36Rated 36: no study has tested a powder as a swap for vegetables, but measuring what's in it shows it can't be one. A serve has 1–2 g of fibre against about 18 g in a day's serves, and far less potassium.What you get 5.5/40: Little toward the step: it doesn't count as a vegetable or fruit serve, its fibre is a tenth or less of a day's serves, and higher blood vitamins haven't been shown to improve health.How sure 18/25: Fairly sure, because the shortfall is measured: 5 leading blends' labels against Australia's food tables, every blend 9 to 18 times short on fibre. Guidelines agree: get nutrients from whole foods.Tradeoffs 12.25/20: Moringa powder in a greens brand and capsules caused a US Salmonella outbreak (131 ill), serious but rare; herb liver injury and other concerns take off a little more.Versus the alternative 0/15: Worse than the obvious alternative, eating the serves (frozen and tinned count): far less fibre, potassium and food bulk.Verdict Score out of 100, for someone who uses it as tested: what you get 40, how sure 25, tradeoffs 20, versus the alternative 15. Cost is shown, not scored. 75+ worth it · 60–74 worth it for some · 45–59 optional · under 45 skip it. With too little research on the main question, or only early research, there's no score or label, because a number would suggest we know.
Fact-checked 5 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
We haven't found a practical guide to eating more vegetables and fruit that clears our bar yet.
+ Add a note
2Swap to whole grains2 books1 protocol4 studies1 website⌄
Make most of your bread, rice, pasta and cereal whole grain; for Optimal, swap as much as you can. Don't expect the swap alone to change your weight.
What it found: Across 68 cohort studies of 1.6 million people, each extra 30 g of whole grains a day was linked with about 8% less cardiovascular disease and 6% less coronary heart disease and early death. Refined grains showed no clear link with heart disease.
What it means for you: Swapping refined for whole-grain bread, rice, pasta and cereal is linked with less heart disease and fewer early deaths.
The figures and the limit
Per 30 g a day of whole grain: cardiovascular disease RR 0.92, coronary heart disease RR 0.94, death RR 0.94 (68 cohorts).
The limit: Observational; rated with a nutrition-specific grading system (NutriGrade), not GRADE.
▸ See 3 more studies▾ 3 more studies, best firstMembers
Best book
Whole-Grain Mornings
Also rated for this step
Whole-Grain Mornings
Megan Gordon, 2013
75Highly rated
★ 4.18 on Goodreads (320) · about 5 hours
4 of 7 readers who said either way said it helped
From 30 sampled Goodreads reviews: 4 helped, 3 didn't; the rest didn't say.
Claim: PractitionerMethod from clinical or teaching practice
“Found their go-to whole-grain pancake recipe”
▸ Why it's rated 75▾ Why it's rated 75
Scorecard
Reader outcomes 40%
81
Content quality 20%
62
Author credibility 20%
70
Goal relevance 10%
100
Rating and format 10%
65
What readers said helped (paraphrased)
Found their go-to whole-grain pancake recipe
Says it reinvented their morning routine; grain bowls keep them full without sugar crash
Long failed to get family eating whole grains; now several recipes they eat and enjoy
Made several recipes, bought own copy; the oatmeal is now a favourite their babies eat
Why it didn't help some
Ingredients hard to get and recipes too involved for their cooking style
Can no longer eat whole grains, so not usable for them
Lovely introduction but no recipe appealed to them
From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 1 November 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 320 ratings, about 81% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. 1 reader says the effect has lasted. Audiobook not confirmed.
Why it isn't the top pick: fewer of its readers said it helped than for a typical book.
▸ See 1 more book▾ 1 more book, best firstMembers
Protocol
Gluten-free eating without coeliac disease
What it is: Cutting out wheat, barley and rye (the grains that contain gluten), often swapping in gluten-free breads, pasta and packaged foods.
Does going gluten-free ease bloating if you don't have coeliac disease?
Leans toward helping; not yet knownMore data needed
No clear effect. In 9 trials in people with IBS, symptoms showed no clear difference, and in blinded tests gluten and a placebo caused similar symptoms. Get tested for coeliac disease before cutting gluten.
○Gut symptoms: a possible small easing in IBS trials, but no clear differenceMore data needed
○Weight and health: no change in BMI, cholesterol or blood pressure in one trialEarly evidence
–Going gluten-free before testing can hide coeliac disease (about 1 in 120 have it)Strong evidence
–Low gluten: about 0.5 more type 2 diabetes cases per 1,000 a year (our estimate)Early evidence
–Gluten-free bread and pasta cost about 2.6 times as much (US)Moderate evidence
How to do it: IBS trials compared gluten-free with gluten-containing diets; blinded tests gave gluten, wheat or a placebo to people already eating gluten-free.
Labels differ: Australian 'gluten free' means none detectable (oats excluded); US means under 20 parts per million.
Sticking with it: No data on keeping it up for a year; about 4 in 10 people who report gluten sensitivity eat gluten-free (surveys).
Cost: Gluten-free bread and pasta cost about 2.6 times as much; about US$300–700 a year extra for one adult (our estimate).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Not yet tested for coeliac disease: get tested first, while still eating gluten. Children or past eating disorder: check with a doctor or dietitian.
Risks and who should be careful (12)
going gluten-free before testing makes coeliac tests unreliable and can hide coeliac disease (people with undiagnosed coeliac disease)Shown to harmStrong evidenceAbout 1 in 70 test positive and 1 in 120 are confirmed by biopsy; 41% of them have no symptoms. Test while still eating gluten.The detailsAbout 1 in 70 test positive and 1 in 120 are biopsy-confirmed; 41% of confirmed cases have no symptoms. Guidelines: test while still eating gluten.Who makes this claim: Coeliac Australia, American College of Gastroenterology, European Society for the Study of Coeliac DiseaseKarimzadhagh et al. 2026 · 74 Good (independence estimated*)European Society for the Study of Coeliac Disease 2019 · 67 Good (independence estimated*)American College of Gastroenterology 2023 · 85 Strong (independence estimated*)European Society for the Study of Coeliac Disease 2025 · 84 StrongCoeliac Australia 2021 · 60 Limited
cutting gluten cuts whole grains, linked with more type 2 diabetes (people without coeliac disease)Probably harmfulEarly evidenceIn studies of 202,114 adults, eating less gluten was linked with 14% more type 2 diabetes (about 0.5 more per 1,000 a year, our estimate).The detailsCohorts of 202,114 adults: lower gluten is linked with 14% more type 2 diabetes (about 0.5 more per 1,000 yearly, our estimate); heart deaths unchanged.Who makes this claim: Cochrane review authors; Harvard cohort authors (Lebwohl 2017)Schmucker et al. 2022 · 77 GoodLebwohl et al. 2017 · 72 GoodReynolds 2019 · 77 Good
gluten-free products cost more (everyone who buys them)Shown to harmModerate evidenceUS: the same product cost 139% more (2019), bread and pasta about 2.6 times as much (2024). Australia: a healthy basket up to 17% more.The detailsUS: same product 139% dearer (2019 survey); bread and pasta about 2.6 times per ounce (2024). Australia 2016: healthy staple basket up to 17% dearer.Who makes this claim: Coeliac societies, consumer price surveysLee et al. 2019 · 53 LimitedLambert and Ficken 2016 · 50 Limited (independence estimated*)de Koning et al. 2025 · 58 Limited (independence estimated*)Bajaj et al. 2025 · 40 Weak (independence estimated*)
rice-based gluten-free diets raise arsenic and mercury exposureProbably harmfulEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesIn a US survey, 101 people avoiding gluten without coeliac disease had higher blood mercury and lead and urine arsenic; health effects unknown.The detailsUS survey, 101 people without coeliac disease: avoiding gluten was linked with higher blood mercury (1.40 vs 0.93 µg/L), lead and urine arsenic; effects unknown.Who makes this claim: Food-safety researchersRaehsler et al. 2018 · 61 Limited (independence estimated*)
Side effectsNo direct harm from removing gluten in trials; the harms come from lost whole grains and missed coeliac disease. Avoiders had higher blood mercury and urine arsenic.The detailsNo direct harm from removing gluten in the trials we rated; the harms come from lost whole grains and missed coeliac disease. A US survey linked avoiding gluten with higher blood mercury and lead and urine arsenic (health effect unknown).Schmucker et al. 2022 · 77 GoodRaehsler et al. 2018 · 61 Limited (independence estimated*)
Who should check with a doctor firstNot yet tested for coeliac disease: get tested while still eating gluten, or results can be falsely negative. Children or past eating disorder: check with a doctor or dietitian.The detailsAnyone not yet tested for coeliac disease should be tested while still eating gluten: going gluten-free first can give falsely negative results (Coeliac Australia; European guideline). Children and people with an eating-disorder history: check with a doctor or dietitian (reasonable concern, not tested).Coeliac Australia 2021 · 60 LimitedEuropean Society for the Study of Coeliac Disease 2019 · 67 Good (independence estimated*)European Society for the Study of Coeliac Disease 2025 · 84 Strong
Testing after going gluten-freeBefore testing, if already gluten-free: adults eat about 4 slices of wheat bread daily for 6+ weeks, children half; none under 5 or during puberty's growth spurt. Doctor's call.The detailsIf coeliac testing is needed after going gluten-free, a gluten challenge is used. Coeliac Australia: aim for about 10 g of gluten a day (about 4 slices of wheat bread) for at least 6 weeks for adults, half for children, and avoid a challenge under age 5 or during the pubertal growth spurt. UK (NICE): gluten in more than one meal every day for at least 6 weeks. Your doctor's call.Coeliac Australia 2021 · 60 LimitedNICE NG20 2015 · 82 Strong
Refined replacement foodsGluten-free replacements are often refined: Australian gluten-free pasta and bread had 52% and 32% less protein, and gluten-free treats were no healthier.The detailsGluten-free replacement foods are often refined: in Australia, gluten-free pasta and bread had 52% and 32% less protein, and gluten-free discretionary foods were no healthier.Wu et al. 2015 · 58 Limited (independence estimated*)
Feeling better isn't proofFeeling better gluten-free often isn't due to gluten: in blinded tests, expecting gluten raised symptoms as much as eating it, and wheat fructans triggered more.The detailsFeeling better gluten-free often isn't due to gluten: in blinded tests, expecting gluten raised symptoms as much as eating it, and fructans in wheat triggered more symptoms than gluten.de Graaf et al. 2024 · 63 LimitedSkodje et al. 2018 · 64 Limited (independence estimated*)Seiler et al. 2025 · 66 Good
Anxiety and restrictionPeople reporting gluten sensitivity more often report anxiety and depression; a restrictive diet can add social and food-anxiety costs (not tested).The detailsPeople who report gluten sensitivity are more likely to report anxiety (OR 2.95) and depression (OR 2.42); a restrictive diet can add social and food-anxiety costs (not tested).Shiha et al. 2025 · 71 Good (independence estimated*)
Whole grains and low-FODMAPWithout coeliac disease, keep whole grains; for IBS, a short dietitian-led low-FODMAP trial has better evidence than gluten-free.The detailsFor people without coeliac disease, keep whole grains; for IBS, a short dietitian-led low-FODMAP trial has better evidence than gluten-free.Arabpour et al. 2023 · 75 GoodAmerican College of Gastroenterology 2021 · 80 Strong (independence estimated*)Reynolds 2019 · 77 Good
CostGluten-free bread and pasta cost about 2.6 times as much (US, 2024); a healthy basket up to 17% more (Australia, 2016). About US$300–700 (A$300–600) a year extra (our estimate).The detailsGluten-free staples cost more: bread and pasta about 2.6 times the price per ounce (US stores, 2024); up to 17% more for a healthy basket (Australia, 2016). About A$300-600 or US$300-700 a year extra for one adult (our estimate). Shown as information only.Lee et al. 2019 · 53 LimitedLambert and Ficken 2016 · 50 Limited (independence estimated*)Bajaj et al. 2025 · 40 Weak (independence estimated*)
The evidence, claim by claim (7)Members
What it does
A gluten-free diet eases bloating, pain and other gut symptoms, in people without coeliac disease who feel unwell after gluten (including IBS)Leans toward helping; not yet knownMore data neededIn 9 IBS trials, no clear difference in overall symptoms. In blinded tests, about 30% relapsed on gluten, about as many as on placebo.The details9 IBS trials: overall symptoms SMD -0.31 (-0.92 to 0.31), range includes no effect. Blinded challenges: 30% relapsed on gluten, about as many on placebo.Who makes this claim: Grain-free diet books, gluten-free food brands, wellness mediaArabpour et al. 2023 · 75 GoodDionne et al. 2018 · 65 Good (independence estimated*)Seiler et al. 2025 · 66 GoodSkodje et al. 2018 · 64 Limited (independence estimated*)de Graaf et al. 2024 · 63 LimitedLionetti et al. 2017 · 59 LimitedBiesiekierski et al. 2025 · 42 Weak (independence estimated*)Shiha et al. 2025 · 71 Good (independence estimated*)British Society of Gastroenterology 2021 · 72 Good (independence estimated*)
Wheat's fermentable carbohydrates (fructans) and expectations, not gluten, drive many symptoms; for IBS, a low-FODMAP diet works better than gluten-freeProbably helpsEarly evidenceFor IBS, a low-FODMAP diet beat gluten-free on symptom severity; in a blinded test of 59 adults, wheat fructans, not gluten, raised symptoms.The detailsLow-FODMAP beat gluten-free on IBS severity (SMD 0.66); in a blinded crossover of 59 adults, fructan, not gluten, raised symptoms.Who makes this claim: Gastroenterology guidelines and researchers (ACG 2021 recommends a limited low-FODMAP trial)Arabpour et al. 2023 · 75 GoodSkodje et al. 2018 · 64 Limited (independence estimated*)de Graaf et al. 2024 · 63 LimitedBiesiekierski et al. 2025 · 42 Weak (independence estimated*)American College of Gastroenterology 2021 · 80 Strong (independence estimated*)
What it doesn't clearly do
A gluten-free diet helps weight loss and is healthier, in the general populationNot yet knownEarly evidenceOne 6-month trial in 60 people found no change in BMI, cholesterol or blood pressure; Australian gluten-free products had less protein, not better ratings.The detailsCochrane: one 60-person, 6-month trial found no BMI, LDL or blood-pressure change; Australian gluten-free products had less protein, not better ratings.Who makes this claim: Grain-free diet books, celebrity dietsSchmucker et al. 2022 · 77 GoodWu et al. 2015 · 58 Limited (independence estimated*)Lebwohl et al. 2017 · 72 GoodNHMRC 2013 · 74 Good (independence estimated*)
A gluten-free diet lowers inflammation, fatigue or 'brain fog', or improves autoimmune thyroid disease (Hashimoto's), in people without coeliac diseaseMixed resultsMore data neededMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesIn 3 trials of 110 people with Hashimoto's thyroid disease, thyroid hormones and an inflammation marker didn't change; one antibody fell, another rose.The details3 trials, 110 people with Hashimoto's: thyroid hormones and CRP unchanged; one antibody fell, another rose; very low certainty. No high-quality evidence.Who makes this claim: Autoimmune-diet protocols, wellness mediaAraújo et al. 2025 · 69 GoodPiticchio et al. 2023 · 61 Limited
A gluten-free diet prevents heart diseaseNot yet knownEarly evidenceIn 269,282 US health professionals followed for 26 years, heart deaths were no different with low or high gluten intake.The detailsCohorts of 269,282 US health professionals over 26 years: cardiovascular death no different with low versus high gluten (HR 1.00, 0.95 to 1.06).Who makes this claim: Diet booksSchmucker et al. 2022 · 77 GoodLebwohl et al. 2017 · 72 Good
Avoiding gluten prevents coeliac disease developingNot yet knownEarly evidenceTwo trials in at-risk babies: starting gluten at 12 months, or early small amounts, didn't change coeliac disease rates by age 3 or 5.The detailsTwo trials in at-risk infants: delaying gluten to 12 months, or early small amounts, didn't change coeliac disease rates by age 3 or 5.Who makes this claim: Some parenting mediaLionetti et al. 2014 · 85 StrongVriezinga et al. 2014 · 82 Strong (independence estimated*)
Gluten-free eating improves athletic performanceNot yet knownMore data neededIn 13 endurance cyclists over 7 days, gluten-free made no clear difference to time-trial performance or gut symptoms; too small to be sure.The details13 endurance cyclists, blinded crossover, 7 days gluten-free: no clear difference in time-trial performance, gut symptoms or inflammation markers. Too small to be sure.Who makes this claim: Athlete testimonialsLis et al. 2015 · 64 Limited (independence estimated*)
Fact-checked 1 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
+ Add a note
3Reach your fibre target1 product12 studies2 websites⌄
Eat at least 30 g of fibre a day (men) or 25 g (women) from foods; Optimal is 38 g and 28 g, set by expert consensus. Eat legumes regularly. Raising fibre gradually is optional.
What it found: The World Health Organization's 2023 guideline, built on graded reviews, recommends people aged 2 and over get carbohydrate mainly from whole grains, vegetables, fruit and pulses, and adults eat at least 400 g of vegetables and fruit and 25 g of naturally occurring fibre daily.
What it means for you: Getting your fibre from whole grains, vegetables, fruit and legumes follows the WHO's advice on carbohydrate quality.
▸ See 11 more studies▾ 11 more studies, best firstMembers
Best for: Australia's fibre targets, including the higher ones for lowering chronic-disease risk.
Caution: From 2006; the higher targets are expert consensus. Our rating: Limited.
▸ See 1 more website▾ 1 more websiteMembers
Product
Fibre supplements (psyllium and similar)
What it is: Powdered or capsule fibre, mostly psyllium husk; others include methylcellulose, guar, inulin and wheat dextrin.
Do fibre supplements help with constipation?
Probably helpsEarly evidence
Yes, for many. In 9 placebo-controlled trials of 802 adults with chronic constipation, 66% improved on fibre versus 41%: about 1 more person in 4 (our estimate). Psyllium and doses over 10 g a day worked best.
+Constipation: 66% versus 41% improved, about 1 more in 4 (our estimate)Early evidence
+About 10 g psyllium daily lowered LDL cholesterol by 0.33 mmol/L (13 mg/dL)Moderate evidence
+Type 2 diabetes: viscous fibre lowered long-term blood sugar by about 0.6 pointsModerate evidence
○Weight: about a third of a kilo lost, too small to matterModerate evidence
–Past bowel polyps: no fewer polyps, and possibly more bowel cancerEarly evidence
–Choking or blockage if taken with too little waterAnecdotal
Cholesterol and diabetes results measured LDL and long-term blood sugar (HbA1c), not heart attacks or diabetes complications
How to do it: About 10 g of psyllium a day for cholesterol, about 13 g of viscous fibre for diabetes, and over 10 g for constipation.
Take each teaspoon with at least 250 mL of water; constipation relief can take 4 weeks or more.
Flavoured powders may contain sugar or sweeteners; check the label.
Sticking with it: No data on how many people keep taking it after a year.
Cost: About US$30–90 a year for 7–10 g a day (our estimate); flavoured brands cost more.
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Skip it with difficulty swallowing or past bowel blockage or narrowing. Take medicines at a different time; on diabetes medicines, ask your doctor first.
Risks and who should be careful (12)
choking or blockage if taken with too little water, or with swallowing problems or bowel narrowingLeans toward harm; not yet knownAnecdotalUS rules require a choking warning and a full glass of fluid for psyllium, methylcellulose and guar; case reports only, no rate known.The detailsUS rules require a choking warning and a full glass of fluid for psyllium, methylcellulose and guar laxatives; evidence is case reports, no rate available.Who makes this claim: FDA label rules (US), product leafletsUS FDA regulation 21 CFR 201.319 · Official dataFH Australasia Network · 61 Limited
wind, bloating and abdominal discomfort, especially when starting or at high dosesShown to harmModerate evidenceIn 3 constipation trials (153 adults), wind was worse on fibre than placebo, mainly with inulin-type fibres; bloating and stomach pain didn't clearly differ.The details3 constipation trials, 153 adults: flatulence worse on fibre than placebo (SMD 0.80, 0.47 to 1.13), driven by 2 inulin-type fructan trials; bloating not different.Who makes this claim: Product leafletsvan der Schoot et al. 2022 · 82 Strong
fibre supplements reduce absorption of some medicines (and can add to glucose-lowering medicines)Probably harmfulEarly evidenceA review of 63 studies found limited evidence that fibre cuts thyroid-tablet absorption; spacing doses avoids it. Ask your doctor about other medicines.The detailsReview of 63 studies: limited evidence fibre reduces thyroid-tablet (levothyroxine) absorption; spacing doses avoids it. Australian cholesterol network advises asking your doctor.Who makes this claim: Pharmacists, Australian Atherosclerosis Society networkWiesner et al. 2021 · 60 Limited (independence estimated*)FH Australasia Network · 61 Limited
flavoured products contain sugar or sweeteners; psyllium can carry leadUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNo reviewed evidence yet.Who makes this claim: Consumer groups
psyllium allergy (mainly from handling the powder)Leans toward harm; not yet knownAnecdotalStaff handling the powder have developed asthma; severe allergic reactions after swallowing it are rare, including one death, mostly in people with allergies.The detailsCase reports and workplace studies: asthma in staff handling the powder; rare anaphylaxis on ingestion, including one death, mostly in people with allergies.Who makes this claim: Occupational-health reportsKhalili et al. 2003 · 39 Weak (independence estimated*)
Wind and chokingMore wind than without fibre; choking or blockage if taken with too little fluid (case reports; the US requires a label warning).The detailsMore wind than placebo (SMD 0.80); choking or blockage if taken with too little fluid (case reports; required US label warning).van der Schoot et al. 2022 · 82 StrongUS FDA regulation 21 CFR 201.319 · Official data
Who should check with a doctor firstSkip with difficulty swallowing or bowel narrowing or blockage. Space it from thyroid tablets and other medicines. On diabetes medicines, blood sugar may drop further: your doctor's call.The detailsDifficulty swallowing, or bowel narrowing or blockage (US label rule). Medicines such as thyroid tablets can absorb less if taken together; space doses. With diabetes medicines, extra blood-sugar lowering is a reasonable concern (not tested). Your doctor's call.US FDA regulation 21 CFR 201.319 · Official dataWiesner et al. 2021 · 60 Limited (independence estimated*)FH Australasia Network · 61 Limited
Granular psylliumIn the US, granular psyllium products need drug approval because standard warnings were found inadequate for them.The detailsUS: granular psyllium products need drug approval because standard warnings were found inadequate for them.US FDA regulation 21 CFR 201.319 · Official data
Markers, not diseaseSupplement benefits are shown on markers (cholesterol, blood sugar, stool frequency); the lower death and disease rates are for fibre-rich foods.The detailsSupplement benefits are shown on markers (LDL, HbA1c, stool frequency); the lower death and disease rates are for fibre-rich foods.Jovanovski et al. 2018 · 86 Strong (independence estimated*)Reynolds 2019 · 77 Good
Replacing whole foodsA supplement may replace fibre-rich whole foods; this hasn't been tested.The detailsA supplement may replace fibre-rich whole foods; not tested.
Fibre-rich foods insteadWhole grains, oats, barley, legumes, fruit and vegetables; eating 25–29 g of fibre a day was linked with the largest risk reductions.The detailsWhole grains, oats, barley, legumes, fruit and vegetables; eating 25-29 g of fibre a day was linked with the largest risk reductions.Reynolds 2019 · 77 GoodFood Standards Australia New Zealand · Official data
CostAbout US$30–90 (A$40–130) a year (our estimate).The detailsAbout A$40-130 (Australia) or US$30-90 (US) a year (our estimate). Shown as information only.
The evidence, claim by claim (9)Members
What it does
Psyllium and other viscous fibre supplements lower LDL cholesterol, in adults with normal or high cholesterolShown to helpModerate evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesIn 28 trials of 1,924 adults, about 10 g of psyllium a day lowered LDL cholesterol by 0.33 mmol/L (13 mg/dL); heart attacks weren't studied.The details28 trials, 1,924 adults: about 10 g psyllium daily cut LDL 0.33 mmol/L (about 13 mg/dL); no trials of heart attacks found.Who makes this claim: Psyllium brands ('helps lower cholesterol'), FDA-authorised label claim (US)Jovanovski et al. 2018 · 86 Strong (independence estimated*)Gholami and Paknahad 2025 · 89 StrongUS FDA health claim regulation 21 CFR 101.81 · Official dataFH Australasia Network · 61 LimitedFood Standards Australia New Zealand · Official data
Fibre supplements relieve constipation and improve regularity, in adults with chronic constipationProbably helpsEarly evidenceIn 9 placebo-controlled trials of 802 adults with chronic constipation, 66% improved versus 41%; psyllium and doses over 10 g a day worked.The details9 placebo-controlled trials, 802 adults with chronic constipation (of a 16-trial review): 66% versus 41% responded (RR 1.48); psyllium and doses over 10 g a day worked best.Who makes this claim: Psyllium and bulk-laxative brands, US constipation guideline (conditional recommendation)van der Schoot et al. 2022 · 82 StrongAmerican Gastroenterological Association and American College of Gastroenterology 2023 · 85 Strong (independence estimated*)British Dietetic Association 2025 · 82 Strong (independence estimated*)
Fibre supplements lower blood sugar and HbA1c, in people with type 2 diabetesShown to helpModerate evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesIn 1,394 people with type 2 diabetes, about 13 g of viscous fibre a day lowered HbA1c by 0.58 points on top of usual care.The details28 comparisons, 1,394 people with type 2 diabetes: about 13 g viscous fibre daily cut HbA1c 0.58 points and fasting glucose 0.82 mmol/L.Who makes this claim: Psyllium brands ('supports healthy blood sugar'), metabolic-health blogsJovanovski et al. 2019 · 83 Strong (independence estimated*)Gholami et al. 2024 · 79 GoodEASD Diabetes and Nutrition Study Group 2023 · 85 Strong (independence estimated*)
The type of fibre matters: viscous, gel-forming fibres carry the cholesterol and blood-sugar evidenceShown to helpModerate evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesThe cholesterol and blood-sugar evidence is for gel-forming fibres (psyllium, beta-glucan, guar); we haven't rated inulin or wheat dextrin.The detailsReviews we rated tested viscous fibres (psyllium, beta-glucan, guar); oats and barley carry a cholesterol claim (Australia, NZ). Inulin, wheat dextrin unrated.Who makes this claim: Nutrition researchers, food regulatorsJovanovski et al. 2018 · 86 Strong (independence estimated*)Jovanovski et al. 2019 · 83 Strong (independence estimated*)Food Standards Australia New Zealand · Official dataUS FDA health claim regulation 21 CFR 101.81 · Official data
Fibre supplements (especially psyllium) ease IBS symptomsShown to helpModerate evidenceIn 16 placebo-controlled trials of 1,293 adults with IBS, 52% vs 44% improved, more with psyllium. Overall symptom scores (9 trials): no clear difference.The details30 trials of fibre vs placebo in IBS; 16 (1,293 people) reported response: 52% versus 44% (RR 1.21); psyllium RR 1.53; symptom scores unchanged (9 trials). US and UK guidelines suggest soluble fibre.Who makes this claim: Gastroenterology guidelinesStaudacher et al. 2026 · 83 Strong (independence estimated*)American College of Gastroenterology 2021 · 80 Strong (independence estimated*)British Society of Gastroenterology 2021 · 72 Good (independence estimated*)
Fibre lowers blood pressure, in adults with high blood pressureShown to helpModerate evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesIn trials raising fibre in adults with high blood pressure, the top number fell 4.3 points; these weren't supplement-only trials.The detailsTrials raising fibre intake in adults with high blood pressure: systolic 4.3 mmHg lower (high certainty); not specific to supplements.Who makes this claim: Heart-health mediaReynolds et al. 2022 · 90 Strong
What it doesn't clearly do
Fibre supplements reduce appetite and cause weight loss ('fibremaxxing'), in adults with overweightShown not to helpModerate evidenceIn 62 trials of 3,877 people not dieting, viscous fibre cut weight by about a third of a kilo: no worthwhile effect.The detailsNo worthwhile effect: 62 trials, 3,877 people: viscous fibre without dieting cut weight 0.33 kg on average (0.14 to 0.51 kg).Who makes this claim: Social-media 'fibremaxxing' trend, psyllium brands ('feel less hungry')Jovanovski et al. 2020 · 83 Strong (independence estimated*)
Fibre supplements prevent bowel polyps and bowel cancerProbably harmfulEarly evidenceIn adults with past bowel polyps (5 trials, 3–4 years), fibre didn't reduce new polyps; two trials found more bowel cancer on fibre.The detailsCochrane, people with past polyps: polyps RR 1.04 (5 trials), psyllium 1.45; bowel cancer RR 2.70 (2 trials): possible harm; low quality; no absolute figure.Who makes this claim: Supplement marketingYao et al. 2017 Cochrane review · 92 Strong
Not reviewed yet
Fibre supplements give the same benefits as fibre-rich foods (less heart disease, longer life)UntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. Fibre-rich foods are linked with 15–30% less early death; supplement trials haven't measured this.The detailsHighest versus lowest food-fibre eaters: 15-30% less death, heart disease, diabetes and bowel cancer (cohorts); no supplement trials measured these outcomes.Who makes this claim: Supplement marketingReynolds 2019 · 77 GoodVeronese 2025 · 77 GoodYao et al. 2017 Cochrane review · 92 Strong
Fact-checked 1 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
+ Add a note
4What helps you stick with itOptional5 studies⌄
Diet counselling with goal setting, problem solving and self-monitoring, or a diet app, can raise fruit and vegetable intake a little. Expect small gains; little evidence covers legumes or whole grains.
What it found: In 17 trials of 53,711 adults without known heart risk factors, diet and activity counselling raised fruit and vegetable intake by about 1 serving a day at 6 to 18 months. Results varied a lot, and US servings differ from Australian serves.
What it means for you: Counselling with goals and tracking can lift your fruit and vegetables a little; expect about a serve a day.
The figures and the limit
+1.11 servings a day (0.41–1.81) at 6–18 months; 17 trials, 53,711 people.
The limit: Very mixed results; US servings; little evidence on long-term health.
▸ See 4 more studies▾ 4 more studies, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
4. Protein that serves you⌄5 steps · 37 items
1Know and reach your protein target8 studies2 websites⌄
Aim for the US protein goal most days: 1.2–1.6 g per kg of body weight a day, adjusted to your energy needs (2025–2030 guidelines; the evidence behind the range is disputed). At 65+, European guidelines advise at least 1.0 g/kg (graded B by ESPEN).
What it found: The European Society for Clinical Nutrition and Metabolism's 2019 guideline for older people, built on a systematic search with graded evidence, advises at least 1 g of protein per kg of body weight a day, routine malnutrition screening, and avoiding restrictive diets.
What it means for you: At 65 or older, aim for at least 1 g/kg of protein a day, as European clinical nutrition guidelines advise.
▸ See 7 more studies▾ 7 more studies, best firstMembers
Best for: An international check on the Australian figures; the Nordic adult figure is 0.83 g/kg.
Caution: Written for the Nordic countries. Our rating: Limited.
▸ See 1 more website▾ 1 more websiteMembers
We haven't found a practical guide to reaching your protein target that clears our bar yet.
+ Add a note
2Pair it with strength training5 studies⌄
If you strength train, about 1.6 g/kg a day under 65, or 1.2–1.6 g/kg at 65+, adds a little strength (about 2.5 kg on a best lift) but little or no muscle mass. It helped only alongside training; over 65 the benefit is uncertain.
What it found: A joint position statement from the American College of Sports Medicine, the US Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics and Dietitians of Canada advises athletes to eat 1.2 to 2.0 g of protein per kg a day; the range comes from a narrative review.
What it means for you: About 1.6 g/kg sits within sports-body advice for strength training; later reviews find little extra gain above it.
▸ See 4 more studies▾ 4 more studies, best firstMembers
We haven't found a practical guide to protein for strength training that clears our bar yet.
+ Add a note
3Limit processed and red meat1 book7 studies3 websites⌄
Eat processed meat only now and then (Healthy) or rarely (Optimal), and keep unprocessed red meat moderate. The evidence is observational and low certainty, and stronger for processed meat.
What it found: Summarising 54 reviews of observational studies, each extra 50 g of processed meat a day (about two slices of ham, our estimate) was linked with about 17% higher bowel cancer risk. Most of the reviews were of low quality.
What it means for you: Keeping processed meat to now and then is the clearest meat change to make; the evidence is observational.
The figures and the limit
Bowel cancer +17% per 50 g of processed meat a day (low certainty).
The limit: Observational and low certainty; most of the reviews it pooled were rated low quality.
▸ See 6 more studies▾ 6 more studies, best firstMembers
Book
Also rated for this step
Food Matters
Mark Bittman, 2008
77Highly rated
★ 3.97 on Goodreads (11,212) · about 8 hours
5 of 5 readers who said either way said it helped
From 30 sampled Goodreads reviews: 5 helped, 0 didn't, 5 already knew most of it; the rest didn't say.
Claim: PractitionerJournalism and reported research
“Motivated some healthy incremental changes”
▸ Why it's rated 77▾ Why it's rated 77
Scorecard
Reader outcomes 40%
94
Content quality 20%
69
Author credibility 20%
60
Goal relevance 10%
75
Rating and format 10%
57
What readers said helped (paraphrased)
Motivated some healthy incremental changes
Less dairy, more vegetables and whole grains, cooking more, more meals at a table
Already eating this way; one statistic ended their soda buying
Cut way back on meat, more vegetables, less processed food
Already ate this way intuitively; book took it further
Why it didn't help some
Already knew most of it
Few new insights; author's cookbooks already taught them to cook
Already lives by author's cooking; message logical but nothing new
Weak distillation of books already read; skipped recipes
Not much new; recipes in other books
Nothing new after Pollan and Nestle
Rated for
Swap your top three processed foods 77
From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 1 November 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 11,212 ratings, about 94% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. Audiobook not confirmed.
Why it isn't the top pick: only one of our two independent reviewers judged it a direct fit for this step.
+ Add a note
4Decide on protein powder (optional)Optional1 product4 studies1 website⌄
Use protein powder, if at all, only to top up food when food alone doesn't reach your target, and choose a third-party batch-tested product. This rests on sports-body consensus, not trials.
What it found: This overview of 33 reviews (441 studies) found protein supplements didn't increase muscle, strength or physical performance in healthy older people. Older people with long-term conditions gained at least a little, more reliably with exercise, and hip-fracture patients had fewer complications.
What it means for you: Protein supplements gave healthy older people no clear muscle gain, so protein powder is optional, not essential.
▸ See 3 more studies▾ 3 more studies, best firstMembers
Product
Protein powder
Does protein powder help build muscle and strength with training?
Shown to helpModerate evidence
A little, if you strength train. In 49 trials of 1,863 healthy adults training for 6 weeks or more, supplements added about 2.5 kg to the heaviest weight lifted once, but little or no muscle mass (about 0.3 kg).
+With strength training: about 2.5 kg more on a one-lift maximumModerate evidence
+Frail older adults doing strength exercise: about 0.9 kg more limb lean massModerate evidence
○Healthy older adults: little or no extra muscle across 36 trialsModerate evidence
○Dieting with overweight: only about half a kilo more weight lostEarly evidence
○Healthy adults: no change in kidney function from higher protein (28 trials)Moderate evidence
–9–15% of supplements tested held undeclared drugs, including some protein productsEarly evidence
How to do it: Protein supplements with strength training for 6 weeks or more; gains stopped above about 1.6 g of total protein per kg body weight daily.
No extra gain above about 1.6 g protein per kg body weight daily (130 g at 80 kg, our estimate).
Powder only helped alongside strength training: all 49 trials paired it with training.
Choose products with third-party testing for banned substances (e.g. Informed Sport); the IOC says this lowers the risk.
Sticking with it: About 3 to 6 in 10 people still use it after a year (our estimate).
Cost: About US$275 a year at one 30 g scoop a day (our estimate).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Kidney disease: ask your doctor first; the kidney trials excluded people with it.
Risks and who should be careful (9)
heavy metals (lead, cadmium, arsenic) in protein powdersNot yet knownEarly evidenceThree lab surveys found lead, cadmium and arsenic under safety limits at a normal serving; highest in 'mass gainer' powders, lowest in whey.The detailsLab surveys: metals present but under safety limits at a normal serving; highest in 'mass gainer' powders, lowest in whey.Who makes this claim: Consumer Reports Oct 2025 (not rated: consumer test), News coverageBandara et al. 2020 · 41 WeakHorváth et al. 2025 · 53 LimitedBethencourt-Barbuzano et al. 2025 · 50 Limited (independence estimated*)
high protein harms the kidneysShown not to helpModerate evidenceIn 28 trials of 1,358 healthy adults, higher protein intakes made no clear difference to kidney function over time.The details28 trials, 1,358 healthy adults: higher protein intakes didn't change kidney filtration over time (SMD 0.11).Who makes this claim: CriticsDevries et al. 2018 · 84 Strong (independence estimated*)Teixeira Silva et al. 2026 · 81 Strong (independence estimated*)
hidden steroids or banned substancesProbably harmfulEarly evidenceIn 44 lab studies, 9–15% of supplements held undeclared drugs, with protein or muscle-building products affected in 4 studies.The details9–15% of supplements tested held undeclared drugs; 4 included studies found them in protein or muscle-building products.Who makes this claim: IOC 2018, Anti-doping bodiesAl-Saad et al. 2026 · 62 LimitedGeyer 2004 · 58 Limited (independence re-estimated 12.6*; was 57)
Stomach upset and lactoseWhey concentrate may upset the stomach, especially with lactose intolerance; the studies we rated didn't measure this.The detailsStomach upset or lactose intolerance with whey concentrate: not measured in our rated sources.
Kidney diseaseKidney disease: ask your doctor first; the kidney trials excluded it. Healthy adults: no sign of kidney injury, and kidney function didn't change over time (28 trials).The detailsKidney disease: ask a doctor (the kidney trials excluded it). Healthy adults: kidney filtration didn't change over time (28 trials); in another review eGFR rose slightly (SMD 0.39, likely a short-term filtration effect) with no sign of kidney injury.Devries et al. 2018 · 84 Strong (independence estimated*)Teixeira Silva et al. 2026 · 81 Strong (independence estimated*)
Contamination and testingMetals stayed under limits at a normal serving, but 9–15% of supplements held undeclared drugs. In Australia, powders are sold as foods, not checked by the TGA.The detailsHeavy metals stayed under limits at a normal serving in three lab surveys (Weak to Limited; one used CDC's older 5 µg/dL lead benchmark); 9–15% of supplements in 44 lab studies held undeclared drugs. In Australia protein powders are regulated as foods, not TGA-assessed; third-party testing schemes (e.g. Informed Sport) lower the risk (IOC).Bandara et al. 2020 · 41 WeakHorváth et al. 2025 · 53 LimitedBethencourt-Barbuzano et al. 2025 · 50 Limited (independence estimated*)Al-Saad et al. 2026 · 62 LimitedTGA · Official dataIOC 2018 · 52 Limited
Other ingredientsSome powders add ingredients without good evidence, which may raise contamination risk; sugar and sweeteners vary by product.The detailsPowders may contain other ingredients that aren't evidence-based and may raise contamination risk (IOC); sugar and sweeteners vary by product.IOC 2018 · 52 Limited
Food insteadFood protein counts towards the same total, and sports bodies advise food first. In older adults, whole-food programs added about 12 g of protein a day.The detailsFood protein counts towards the same total; AIS and IOC advise food first. In older adults, whole-food programs added 12.2 g of protein a day.Australian Institute of Sport 2021 · 52 LimitedIOC 2018 · 52 LimitedMorton et al. 2018 · 68 GoodHeijmans 2026 · 79 Good
CostOne 30 g scoop a day costs about A$424 (US$275) a year (our estimate).The detailsMusashi 100% Whey 2 kg A$77.49 (Chemist Warehouse, OzBargain 15 Oct 2026); one 30 g scoop a day about A$424 a year (our estimate).
The evidence, claim by claim (5)Members
What it does
With strength training, protein supplements add lean mass and strength (adults)Shown to helpModerate evidenceIn 49 trials of 1,863 adults strength training, supplements added about 2.5 kg to one-lift maximum strength; lean mass rose only about 0.3 kg.The details49 trials, 1,863 adults strength-training: one-rep max 2.49 kg higher; lean mass 0.30 kg higher, little or no difference.Who makes this claim: Protein brandsMorton et al. 2018 · 68 GoodNunes 2022 · 70 Good
Food gives the same result (food-first)Leans toward helping; not yet knownAnecdotalSports bodies advise food first. In older adults, whole-food programs raised protein by about 12 g a day (11 trials); muscle wasn't compared with powders.The detailsIOC and AIS expert statements advise food first. Older adults: whole-food programs raised protein 12.2 g a day (11 trials); muscle not compared with powders.Who makes this claim: AIS, IOCAustralian Institute of Sport 2021 · 52 LimitedIOC 2018 · 52 LimitedHeijmans 2026 · 79 Good
What it doesn't clearly do
Protein supplements preserve muscle and function in older adultsMixed resultsModerate evidenceHealthy older adults: little or no extra muscle (36 trials, 1,682 people). Frail older adults doing strength exercise: about 0.9 kg more limb lean mass.The detailsHealthy older adults: little or no extra muscle (36 trials). Frail or sarcopenic older adults gained 0.88 kg limb muscle.Who makes this claim: Protein brands (healthy ageing), PROT-AGE and ESPEN positionsTen Haaf 2018 · 74 GoodHettiarachchi 2024 · 79 GoodKirwan 2022 · 78 GoodObasi 2025 · 84 Strong
Protein shakes help weight loss and keep muscle while dietingMixed resultsEarly evidenceIn 9 trials of adults with overweight, whey cut weight about half a kilo more than control, and fat about 1.1 kg.The details9 trials, overweight adults: whey cut weight 0.56 kg more than control, no worthwhile effect; lean mass 0.77 kg higher, fat mass 1.12 kg lower.Who makes this claim: Protein brands, Weight-loss advocatesWirunsawanya et al. 2018 · 68 Good (independence estimated*)
Not reviewed yet
Whey beats other proteins and foodUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet reviewed (lower priority).Who makes this claim: Whey brands
Fact-checked 29 Oct 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
+ Add a note
5What helps you stick with itOptional5 studies⌄
No high-quality evidence. What may help: get protein from everyday foods first (programs with individual counselling and a set target raised it most), and pair protein with strength training, which helped mostly in frail people.
What it found: In 16 studies of adults aged 50 and over, food-first programs raised protein by about 12 g a day (11 pooled trials, 1,207 people). Programmes lasting 3 to 6 months, with one-to-one counselling, in-person delivery and a set protein target, did best.
What it means for you: Get protein from everyday foods first; a set daily target and personal advice helped most.
The figures and the limit
+12.2 g a day (5.0–19.4) from whole-food programs (11 pooled trials, 1,207 people).
The limit: Ungraded, part dairy-funded review; older adults.
▸ See 4 more studies▾ 4 more studies, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
5. Less salt, sugar and ultra-processed food⌄6 steps · 44 items
1Lower your salt3 studies2 websites⌄
Keep sodium under 2,000 mg a day (about 5 g of salt) by cutting your two biggest salt sources. The effect on heart attacks, strokes and deaths is less certain than on blood pressure.
What it found: In trials in about 10,000 white adults, cutting sodium from about 4.7 g to 1.5 g a day (roughly 12 g to 4 g of salt, our estimate) lowered the top blood pressure number about 5.7 points with high blood pressure, 1 point without.
What it means for you: Cutting salt matters most if your blood pressure is high; effects on heart attacks and strokes are less certain.
The figures and the limit
From about 4.7 g to 1.5 g of sodium a day: systolic about 5.7 mmHg lower with high blood pressure, 1.1 mmHg without (high certainty).
The limit: Blood pressure only, not heart events or deaths; certainty is lower for black and Asian participants.
▸ See 2 more studies▾ 2 more studies, best firstMembers
We haven't found a practical guide to cutting salt that clears our bar yet.
+ Add a note
2Consider a salt substitute (optional)Optional1 product7 studies4 websites⌄
Consider a potassium-enriched salt substitute for salt you add (WHO's advice excludes pregnancy and children). Get potassium from food; supplements only under medical supervision. Kidney disease or potassium-raising medicines? Ask your GP first.
What it found: In 26 trials of about 35,000 adults, potassium-enriched salt substitutes lowered the top blood pressure number about 5 points and deaths from heart disease and stroke by about 2 per 1,000 a year (our estimate), mostly in one Chinese trial. Blood potassium rose slightly.
What it means for you: Swapping the salt you add can help; WHO's advice excludes pregnancy and children. Kidney disease or potassium-raising medicines? Ask your GP first.
The figures and the limit
Systolic −4.76 mmHg; cardiovascular deaths rate ratio 0.77 (about 180 fewer per 100,000 person-years); blood potassium +0.12 mmol/L (moderate certainty).
The limit: The death benefit rests mostly on one rural Chinese trial; trials left out people with kidney disease.
▸ See 6 more studies▾ 6 more studies, best firstMembers
Product
Potassium-enriched salt substitute
What it is: Salt with about a quarter of the sodium chloride replaced by potassium chloride; it tastes much like salt.
Does swapping to a potassium salt substitute cut strokes and blood pressure?
Shown to helpModerate evidence
Yes, in trials. Across 20 trials of 21,414 adults, the top blood pressure number fell about 5 points. In 20,995 high-risk older Chinese villagers, strokes fell from about 34 to 29 in 1,000 a year.
+Strokes: about 34 down to 29 in 1,000 a year, in high-risk older adultsModerate evidence
+Deaths: about 5 fewer in 1,000 a year, in one large trialModerate evidence
+Aged care, where the kitchen made the swap: heart events about 40% fewerEarly evidence
○Screened adults: high potassium no more common than with regular saltModerate evidence
–Outside China most salt is in packaged food, so the gain is smaller
–Kidney disease or potassium-raising medicines: risk of high blood potassiumEarly evidence
Measured blood pressure and blood potassium; strokes and deaths were counted directly in one large trial
How to do it: A 1:1 swap for salt used at home, mostly a 75:25 salt-potassium blend; trial users ate about 8.8 g of substitute a day.
Use it 1:1 in place of the salt you add, not as extra salt.
Check the potassium share on the pack; it varies by product.
Sticking with it: About 9 in 10 still used it after 5 years in the main trial, where it was free; no data outside trials.
Cost: About US$2–8 a year to replace the salt you add (our estimate).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Advanced kidney disease: not recommended (Australia); potassium checks (US). Other kidney disease, blood-pressure or potassium-raising medicines, potassium supplements: your doctor's call. Pregnancy, children: little evidence.
Risks and who should be careful (9)
high blood potassium in people with kidney disease or taking potassium-raising medicinesProbably harmfulEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomes191 adults with moderate-to-severe kidney disease took potassium chloride for 2 weeks (like 12 g of substitute daily; our estimate): 11% got high blood potassium.The details191 adults with stage 3b–4 kidney disease, 2 weeks of potassium chloride (about 12 g of substitute daily; our estimate): 11% got high potassium.Who makes this claim: Kidney Health Australia 2026, WHO 2025, Hypertension Australia 2026, Cochrane (Brand 2022), Mayo Clinic (not rated)Brand 2022 · 100 StrongMarklund et al. 2020 · 49 WeakHypertension Australia and National Hypertension Taskforce 2026 · 66 GoodWHO 2025 · 81 StrongKDIGO 2024 · 84 StrongGritter et al. 2022 · 61 Limited (independence estimated*)Kidney Health Australia 2026 · 53 Limited
high blood potassium or other side effects in the general populationShown not to helpModerate evidenceScreened adults: high potassium little or no different (4 more per 100,000); in the large trial, serious cases 3.35 versus 3.30 per 1,000 a year.The detailsScreened adults: high potassium little or no different (4 more per 100,000; 5 trials, 22,849); SSaSS serious high-potassium events 3.35 vs 3.30 per 1,000 yearly.Who makes this claim: Critics, NutritionFacts.org (not rated)Brand 2022 · 100 StrongNeal 2021 · 81 StrongLai 2026 · 100 StrongYuan et al. 2023 · 75 Good (independence estimated*)Greenwood et al. 2024 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)
Side effectsIn screened adults, high potassium was little or no different. In aged care, high potassium on blood tests was more frequent, without clinical harm.The detailsIn screened adults, high potassium was little or no different (Cochrane: 4 more per 100,000; SSaSS serious high-potassium events 3.35 vs 3.30 per 1,000 a year). In aged care, high potassium on blood tests was more frequent, without clinical harm.Brand 2022 · 100 StrongNeal 2021 · 81 StrongYuan et al. 2023 · 75 Good (independence estimated*)
Who should check firstKidney disease, past high potassium, blood-pressure medicines, potassium supplements or potassium-raising medicines: your doctor's call; not recommended in advanced kidney disease. Not studied in pregnancy; children uncertain.The detailsKidney disease, potassium supplements, potassium-sparing diuretics or other medicines that raise potassium: whether it suits you is your doctor's call. Kidney Health Australia (2026) says salt substitutes are not recommended in more advanced kidney disease and may need to be avoided after high potassium or on blood-pressure medicines; it says they can help in earlier-stage kidney disease. All 26 Cochrane trials excluded people at risk. The one direct study gave 191 adults with stage 3b–4 kidney disease 40 mmol of potassium chloride a day for 2 weeks (the potassium in about 12 g of a 75:25 substitute, roughly ten times what an Australian swapping only added salt would take; our estimate): blood potassium rose 0.4 mmol/L and 11% developed high potassium, more often if older or with higher potassium to start. A China model (mostly stage 3 kidney disease) estimated about 0.65 extra potassium-related deaths and 1.9 fewer heart deaths per 1,000 people a year (our estimate from the model). Not studied in pregnancy; evidence in children is very uncertain; the WHO advice excludes both.Brand 2022 · 100 StrongWHO 2025 · 81 StrongHypertension Australia and National Hypertension Taskforce 2026 · 66 GoodMarklund et al. 2020 · 49 WeakKDIGO 2024 · 84 StrongKidney Health Australia 2026 · 53 LimitedGritter et al. 2022 · 61 Limited (independence estimated*)
Anti-caking agents and flavouringsThese vary by brand; the sources we rated didn't look at them.The detailsAnti-caking agents and flavourings vary by brand; not assessed in our rated sources.
Packaged-food saltA swap at home doesn't touch packaged-food salt: only about 1–2 in 10 of Australians' salt is added at home, so expect a much smaller effect (our estimate).The detailsA swap at the table doesn't touch packaged-food salt. FSANZ estimates about 20% of Australians' salt is added at home (1995 food records, with assumed amounts). Direct measures suggest less: in Victoria (2014, 24-hour urine), people who added salt at the table and in cooking had 0.7 g a day more salt than others, against a mean of 7.8 g (about 9%, our estimate; a floor, since it compares people who add salt with others); in New Zealand adults chosen because they add salt, a median 13% of sodium came from added salt (lithium-tagged salt); in the US, salt added at home was about 10.5% of sodium (2017). SSaSS users ate about 8.8 g of substitute a day; swapping 0.7–1.1 g of added salt is roughly a tenth of that, so expect a much smaller effect than in the trials (our estimate). Even at home, the effect was smaller than in shared kitchens (4.2 vs 7.7 mmHg).FSANZ · Official dataYin et al. 2023 · 67 Good (independence estimated*)Zhang et al. 2026 · 86 StrongLai 2026 · 100 StrongNowson et al. 2015 · 53 LimitedWang et al. 2022 · 53 LimitedHarnack et al. 2017 · 60 Limited
Feeling salt is 'sorted'It could make salt feel 'sorted' and slow efforts to cut packaged-food salt.The detailsIt could make salt feel 'sorted' and slow efforts to cut packaged-food salt.
Cutting salt comes firstAustralian advice comes first: add less salt, choose low-salt foods and eat more fruit and vegetables; the substitute helps when that's hard.The detailsHypertension Australia's core advice comes first: add less salt, choose low-salt foods and eat more fruit and vegetables; the substitute is the option 'when these changes are challenging'.Hypertension Australia and National Hypertension Taskforce 2026 · 66 Good
CostAbout A$3–12 (US$2–8) a year to replace the salt you add (our estimate).The detailsAbout A$3–12 a year to replace the salt you add (our estimate: about 0.26–0.4 kg a year at 0.7–1.1 g a day, at A$1–3 per 100 g).
The evidence, claim by claim (10)Members
What it does
Swapping to a potassium-enriched salt substitute cuts strokes, heart events and deaths (adults, mostly older or at high risk)Shown to helpModerate evidence20,995 high-risk Chinese villagers: strokes 29.1 versus 33.7 and deaths 39.3 versus 44.6 per 1,000 a year. Without that trial, deaths weren't clearly cut.The detailsSSaSS, 20,995 high-risk Chinese villagers: cut strokes (29.1 vs 33.7 per 1,000 yearly) and deaths (39.3 vs 44.6). Without SSaSS, deaths not clearly cut.Who makes this claim: Heart Foundation and George Institute ('Switch the salt'), Blood Pressure UK, MJA InSight+, WHO 2025Neal 2021 · 81 StrongBrand 2022 · 100 StrongLai 2026 · 100 StrongWHO 2025 · 81 StrongDing et al. 2025 · 81 StrongGreenwood et al. 2024 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)
It tastes like salt, so it's an easy swap people keep usingProbably helpsEarly evidence92% still used it after 5 years in the main trial (supplied free); urine tests suggest it replaced about 72% of their salt.The detailsSSaSS: 92% still used it after 5 years (supplied free); urine tests suggest it replaced about 72% of their salt.Who makes this claim: Heart Foundation ('minimal change in behaviour'), Hypertension Australia 2026Hypertension Australia and National Hypertension Taskforce 2026 · 66 GoodYin et al. 2023 · 67 Good (independence estimated*)Lai 2026 · 100 Strong
In aged care, where the kitchen makes the swap, it lowers blood pressure and heart events (older adults)Probably helpsEarly evidence48 Chinese aged-care homes, 1,612 residents aged 55+: top number 7.1 points lower, heart events 40% fewer over 2 years; deaths not clearly changed.The details48 Chinese aged-care homes, 1,612 residents 55+: cut systolic 7.1 mmHg and heart events 40% (HR 0.60; no absolute figure available); deaths not clearly changed.Who makes this claim: DECIDE-Salt investigatorsYuan et al. 2023 · 75 Good (independence estimated*)Zhang et al. 2026 · 86 Strong
Smaller effect outside China: most salt now comes from packaged and restaurant food, so swapping only added salt does less than in the trialsProbably helpsEarly evidenceAdded salt: about 1 in 10 of sodium in the US, 1–2 in 10 in Australia (our estimate), 7 in 10 in China.The detailsAdded salt: about 1 in 10 of sodium in the US, 1–2 in 10 in Australia (our estimate), 7 in 10 in China.Who makes this claim: First principles; Lai 2026 and Brand 2022 limitsFSANZ · Official dataMarklund et al. 2020 · 49 WeakYin et al. 2023 · 67 Good (independence estimated*)Lai 2026 · 100 StrongBrand 2022 · 100 StrongNowson et al. 2015 · 53 LimitedWang et al. 2022 · 53 LimitedHarnack et al. 2017 · 60 Limited
It raises potassium intake towards the recommended amountProbably helpsEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesIn the large trial, urine potassium rose 0.80 g a day, from about 8.8 g of substitute daily; blood potassium rose slightly across 6 trials.The detailsSSaSS: urine potassium 0.80 g a day higher, from about 8.8 g of substitute daily; blood potassium +0.12 mmol/L across 6 trials.Who makes this claim: Hypertension Australia 2026, WHO 2025Yin et al. 2023 · 67 Good (independence estimated*)Brand 2022 · 100 Strong
What it doesn't clearly do
A bitter or metallic taste makes people use more, or give upNot yet knownEarly evidence92% still used it after 5 years (supplied free), and most people couldn't tell it from salt in taste tests.The detailsSSaSS: 92% still used it after 5 years (supplied free). Hypertension Australia: most people couldn't tell it from salt in taste tests.Who makes this claim: CriticsHypertension Australia and National Hypertension Taskforce 2026 · 66 GoodNeal 2021 · 81 Strong
Not reviewed yet
It lowers blood pressure in people with normal blood pressure tooUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated; the Cochrane review says evidence is limited for adults without high blood pressure.Who makes this claim: Heart Foundation ('Switch the salt' for everyone)Brand 2022 · 100 Strong
Pregnancy and children: not covered by the WHO adviceUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. WHO's advice doesn't cover pregnancy or children.The detailsNo trials in pregnancy; evidence in children (92 children) is very uncertain; WHO's advice excludes both.Who makes this claim: WHO 2025, Cochrane (Brand 2022)Brand 2022 · 100 StrongWHO 2025 · 81 Strong
Additives (anti-caking agents, flavourings)UntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: First principles
Fact-checked 1 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
+ Add a note
3Water first for drinks1 product7 studies2 websites⌄
Keep sugary drinks to now and then (Healthy) or rarely (Optimal), with water as your default; diet drinks aren't advised as a health measure. Guideline limit for free sugars (added sugars, honey, syrups, juice): under 10% of energy.
What it found: The European Food Safety Authority's 2022 opinion found trials point to added and free sugars causing obesity and high blood fats (moderate certainty). It found no safe threshold, so set no limit, advising intake as low as possible within a nutritious diet.
What it means for you: Cutting sugary drinks keeps free sugars low; Europe's food safety authority advises 'as low as possible'.
▸ See 6 more studies▾ 6 more studies, best firstMembers
Best for: WHO's free-sugars limits: the main one a strong recommendation, the stricter one conditional.
▸ See 1 more website▾ 1 more websiteMembers
Product
Diet (artificially sweetened) drinks
Does swapping sugary drinks for diet drinks help keep weight down?
Probably helpsEarly evidence
A little. In trials of adults with overweight, swapping sugary drinks for diet drinks cut about 1 kg more over about 12 weeks; the best-run trials found no clear difference. Water is the free first choice.
+Instead of sugary drinks: about 1 kg more weight lost over about 12 weeksEarly evidence
+Swapping from sugary drinks linked with 11% less heart diseaseEarly evidence
○Blood sugar: no clear difference after swapping from sugary drinksMore data needed
○Blood sugar versus water: a rise too small to matter; gut bacteria changed short-termEarly evidence
–Each extra 355 mL a day (about a can) linked with 6% more deathsEarly evidence
–Aspartame rated 'possibly' cancer-causing; normal intake stays under the safe limitEarly evidence
How to do it: Trials swapped sugary drinks for diet drinks for a median of 12 weeks; a year-long weight program compared diet drinks with water.
Sticking with it: No data on how many keep it up; in a year-long trial, 6 in 10 adults finished.
Cost: About US$240–470 a year at one can a day, about the same as sugary drinks (our estimate).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Phenylketonuria: avoid aspartame, which contains phenylalanine. Already drinking water: no need to switch; a year-long trial found a 1.4 kg difference, too small to matter.
Risks and who should be careful (14)
diet drinks are linked with more type 2 diabetes, heart disease, stroke and death in long-term studies (adults)Probably harmfulEarly evidenceIn studies of up to 848,473 people, each extra 355 mL a day was linked with 6% more deaths; higher-risk people switching may explain it.The detailsCohorts, up to 848,473 people: each daily 355 mL linked with 6% higher death risk (HR 1.06); reverse causation possible.Who makes this claim: WHO 2023, Dr Axe and 'a diet cola every day' articles (not rated)Beigrezaei 2025 · 85 StrongRios-Leyvraz 2022 · 81 StrongWHO 2023 guideline · 79 GoodLee et al. 2022 · 71 Good
aspartame causes cancerMixed resultsEarly evidenceIARC rates aspartame 'possibly' cancer-causing; the safe limit stays. A French study suggests, if causal, about 0.7 more cancers per 1,000 a year (our estimate).The detailsIARC: 'possibly' carcinogenic; JECFA: limit unchanged (over 9–14 cans daily). Cohort: linked with 15% more cancer (our estimate, if causal: 0.7 more per 1,000 yearly).Who makes this claim: IARC 2023 coverage, criticsIARC and JECFA 2023 · 59 Limited (independence estimated*)FSANZ media statement on aspartame · Official dataDebras et al. 2022 · 73 Good
sweeteners disrupt gut bacteria and blood-sugar controlNot yet knownEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesVersus water, long-term blood sugar was 0.21 points higher, too small to matter. In 120 adults over 2 weeks, saccharin and sucralose worsened glucose responses.The detailsVersus water, pooled trials: HbA1c 0.21% higher (0.02 to 0.40), below our 0.3-point threshold. 120 adults, 2 weeks: saccharin and sucralose worsened glucose responses.Who makes this claim: Huberman Lab, Dr Axe (not rated)Suez et al. 2022 · 62 Limited (independence estimated*)McGlynn 2022 · 88 StrongOdegaard et al. 2026 · 62 Limited (independence estimated*)
sweet taste increases cravings and appetite, so people eat moreUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: Critics, popular articles
erythritol raises clotting and heart-attack riskUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: Critics, 2023 news coverage
acid erodes teethUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: Dentists, popular articles
Long-term health linksStudies following people link diet drinks with more deaths, type 2 diabetes and stroke, but people at higher risk may switch to them. Aspartame: 'possibly' cancer-causing; safe limits unchanged.The detailsLong-term cohorts link each daily 355 mL with 6% higher death risk (HR 1.06), and link diet drinks with type 2 diabetes (HR 1.16, high vs low intake) and stroke (HR 1.09 per daily 250 mL); absolute figures not available. These compare more with less diet drink, not swaps from sugary drinks, and may reflect people at higher risk switching to diet drinks. Aspartame: IARC rates it 'possibly' carcinogenic on limited evidence; JECFA and FSANZ (Australia and NZ) kept the intake limit.Beigrezaei 2025 · 85 StrongIARC and JECFA 2023 · 59 Limited (independence estimated*)FSANZ media statement on aspartame · Official dataDebras et al. 2022 · 73 Good
Phenylketonuria and diabetesPhenylketonuria: aspartame contains phenylalanine (labels warn). The WHO's advice against sweeteners for weight control doesn't cover people who already have diabetes.The detailsPhenylketonuria: aspartame contains phenylalanine (labels warn; not rated). The WHO's advice against sweeteners for weight control doesn't cover people who already have diabetes.WHO 2023 guideline · 79 Good
Aspartame safe limitA 70 kg adult would need more than 9–14 cans a day, with no other aspartame, to pass the safe limit of 40 mg per kg a day.The detailsA 70 kg adult would need more than 9–14 cans of diet soft drink a day, with no other aspartame, to pass JECFA's limit of 40 mg/kg a day.IARC and JECFA 2023 · 59 Limited (independence estimated*)
Sweeteners and gut bacteriaIn a 2-week trial of 120 healthy adults, saccharin and sucralose changed gut bacteria and worsened glucose responses; size and long-term effects unknown.The detailsThe sweeteners are the additive: in a 2-week trial of 120 healthy adults, saccharin and sucralose changed gut bacteria and worsened glucose responses; effect sizes and long-term effects unknown.Suez et al. 2022 · 62 Limited (independence estimated*)
'Zero sugar' isn't zero effectVersus water, diet drinks gave slightly higher long-term blood sugar but slightly lower blood pressure in trials; with type 2 diabetes, one 24-week trial favoured diet drinks.The details'Zero sugar' doesn't mean zero effect: compared with water, diet drinks gave HbA1c 0.21% higher but systolic blood pressure 2.63 mmHg lower in pooled trials; a 24-week trial in type 2 diabetes found HbA1c 0.29% lower on diet drinks than on water.McGlynn 2022 · 88 StrongOdegaard et al. 2026 · 62 Limited (independence estimated*)
Sweet cravingsA sweet taste could keep a sweet habit going or raise appetite; this hasn't been tested.The detailsA sweet taste could keep a sweet habit going or raise appetite; not tested in our rated sources.
Water insteadWater is free and the first choice; diet drinks did no better for weight, or slightly better. Swapping sugary drinks for water was linked with less type 2 diabetes.The detailsWater is free and the course's first choice; trial reviews found diet drinks no better than water for weight, or 0.8 kg better (low certainty), and a year-long industry-funded trial found 1.4 kg more weight loss with diet drinks, judged not clinically meaningful. In cohorts, swapping sugary drinks for water was linked with less type 2 diabetes (RR 0.96). The WHO advises against sweeteners for weight control.WHO 2023 guideline · 79 GoodMcGlynn 2022 · 88 StrongLee et al. 2022 · 71 GoodHarrold et al. 2024 · 65 Good
CostAbout US$240–470 (A$365–730) a year at one can a day, about the same as sugary drinks (our estimate); tap water is free.The detailsAbout A$365–730 a year at one 375 mL can a day, about the same as sugary drinks (our estimate); tap water about A$0.
The evidence, claim by claim (6)Members
What it does
Swapping sugary drinks for diet drinks helps weight loss and keeping it off (adults with overweight)Probably helpsEarly evidenceAdults with overweight: 12 swap trials (601 people) lost about 1 kg more than on sugary drinks; another review: no clear effect in best-run trials.The detailsAdults with overweight: 17-trial network (12 testing swaps, 601 people) cut 1.06 kg vs sugary drinks, small; another review: no clear effect in low-bias trials.Who makes this claim: Drink makers, BioLayne (not rated)McGlynn 2022 · 88 StrongShahinfar 2025 · 83 Strong (independence estimated*)Pang 2025 · 70 GoodWHO 2023 guideline · 79 GoodHarrold et al. 2024 · 65 Good
Swapping sugary for diet drinks is linked with less heart disease and fewer deaths (adults)Probably helpsEarly evidenceStudies following people linked swapping with 11% less coronary heart disease (6 studies) and 4% fewer deaths (one); no absolute figures; authors had industry ties.The detailsCohorts: swapping linked with 11% less coronary heart disease (RR 0.89, 6 cohorts), 4% fewer deaths (one); no absolute figures; low certainty; industry-tied authors.Who makes this claim: Drink makersLee et al. 2022 · 71 Good
What it doesn't clearly do
Diet drinks instead of sugary ones improve blood sugar and lower type 2 diabetes risk (adults)Not yet knownMore data neededIn 17 trials, swapping made no clear difference to long-term or fasting blood sugar; studies following people found no clear link with type 2 diabetes.The detailsTrials of the swap (17): no clear difference in HbA1c or fasting glucose. Cohorts: no clear link with type 2 diabetes (low certainty).Who makes this claim: Drink makers, diabetes advocatesMcGlynn 2022 · 88 StrongLee et al. 2022 · 71 Good
Not reviewed yet
No sugar, so no tooth decay from the drinkUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: Drink makers
Phenylketonuria: aspartame must be avoidedUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. Aspartame contains phenylalanine, and labels warn people with phenylketonuria.The detailsNot yet rated; aspartame contains phenylalanine, and labels carry a warning for people with phenylketonuria.Who makes this claim: Food labels
Caffeine in diet colasUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: First principles
Fact-checked 1 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
+ Add a note
4Swap your top three processed foods1 book4 studies1 website⌄
Swap the three ultra-processed or discretionary foods you eat most for minimally processed options, starting with processed meat, sugary drinks and ready-to-eat meals, the most consistently linked with type 2 diabetes.
What it found: A 2026 European Society of Cardiology consensus statement, drawing on an ungraded review of the evidence, says ultra-processed food is linked with higher heart risk and urges cardiologists to assess patients' intake and counsel them towards less processed, food-based diets.
What it means for you: Heart specialists now advise swapping ultra-processed foods; this is expert consensus built on links, not trials.
▸ See 3 more studies▾ 3 more studies, best firstMembers
Best for: Australia's guidelines: limit discretionary foods, the guideline term closest to ultra-processed food.
Caution: From 2013; it doesn't use the ultra-processed category.
Book
Also rated for this step
Food Matters
Mark Bittman, 2008
77Highly rated
★ 3.97 on Goodreads (11,212) · about 8 hours
5 of 5 readers who said either way said it helped
From 30 sampled Goodreads reviews: 5 helped, 0 didn't, 5 already knew most of it; the rest didn't say.
Claim: PractitionerJournalism and reported research
“Motivated some healthy incremental changes”
▸ Why it's rated 77▾ Why it's rated 77
Scorecard
Reader outcomes 40%
94
Content quality 20%
69
Author credibility 20%
60
Goal relevance 10%
75
Rating and format 10%
57
What readers said helped (paraphrased)
Motivated some healthy incremental changes
Less dairy, more vegetables and whole grains, cooking more, more meals at a table
Already eating this way; one statistic ended their soda buying
Cut way back on meat, more vegetables, less processed food
Already ate this way intuitively; book took it further
Why it didn't help some
Already knew most of it
Few new insights; author's cookbooks already taught them to cook
Already lives by author's cooking; message logical but nothing new
Weak distillation of books already read; skipped recipes
Not much new; recipes in other books
Nothing new after Pollan and Nestle
Rated for
Limit processed and red meat 77
From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 1 November 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 11,212 ratings, about 94% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. Audiobook not confirmed.
Why it isn't the top pick: it covers only part of this step.
+ Add a note
5Use labels to compare4 studies2 websites⌄
Use the Health Star Rating only to compare similar packaged foods, and check the nutrition panel. Don't let front-of-pack health claims decide for you. Labels help you understand food more reliably than they change what you buy.
What it found: A review of 221 studies, mostly experiments on food choices, found front-of-pack labels like the Health Star Rating help people understand food, and choose and buy healthier options, compared with no label. Labels that rate the food beat those listing only nutrients.
What it means for you: Use the stars to compare similar packaged foods, then check the nutrition panel.
The figures and the limit
Moderate certainty that front-of-pack labels improve understanding, choices and purchases vs no label; interpretive labels beat nutrient-only ones (221 studies).
The limit: Mostly experiments, not real shopping.
▸ See 3 more studies▾ 3 more studies, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
6What helps you stick with itOptional4 studies1 website⌄
To cut salt, structured help such as education or counselling, online or face to face, works modestly. Education alone hasn't reduced sugary drinks in adults; no rated study tests cutting ultra-processed food.
What it found: In 32 trials of 7,840 adults, salt-reduction programs, online or face to face, cut sodium by about 490 mg a day in urine tests, equal to more than 1 g of salt. Results varied a lot between trials.
What it means for you: A structured course or counselling, online or in person, can trim your salt modestly.
The figures and the limit
Sodium down 486 mg a day in urine tests (32 trials, 7,840 people) and 400 mg a day in diet records (19 trials).
The limit: Not formally graded; results varied a lot between trials.
▸ See 3 more studies▾ 3 more studies, best firstMembers
Best for: Australia's primary-care framework for brief diet support: assess, advise, refer.
Caution: Written for GPs. Our rating: Limited.
+ Add a note
6. Weight that lasts (optional)⌄6 steps · 72 items
1Know what helpsOptional5 protocols4 products6 studies2 websites⌄
At high risk of type 2 diabetes? Ask your GP about a lifestyle program: eating changes, at least 150 minutes of moderate activity weekly, 5–7% weight loss kept off. Pick a diet you can keep.
What it found: The American Diabetes Association's 2026 care standards recommend referring adults with overweight or obesity at high risk of type 2 diabetes to a prevention program: lose at least 5–7% of body weight and keep it off, with 150 minutes or more of moderate activity weekly.
What it means for you: Aiming for 5–7% weight loss and 150 minutes of activity a week, through a program, follows this guideline's advice.
▸ See 5 more studies▾ 5 more studies, best firstMembers
Best for: Australian GP guidance on referring people with prediabetes to structured lifestyle programs.
Caution: Written for GPs.
▸ See 1 more website▾ 1 more websiteMembers
Best protocol
Commercial weight-loss programs (group, app-based and prepared-meal)
What it is: Paid programs with a diet plan, regular weigh-ins and group, coach or app support; some supply prepared meals.
Do commercial weight-loss programs help you lose weight?
Shown to helpModerate evidence
Yes, a little. In 772 GP-referred adults, a year's group program cut 5.1 kg versus 2.3 kg with standard care. By 5 years, in another trial of 1,267 adults, the extra loss was no longer clear.
+Two leading programmes: at least 2.6–4.9% more weight lost at 12 months than adviceModerate evidence
○At 5 years: about 1.8 kg lighter than brief advice, not a clear differenceMore data needed
○Apps versus minimal help: no clear weight difference at 12 or 24 monthsMore data needed
○Eating-disorder scores fell on average; new symptoms in 0–6.5%Early evidence
–57% of starters lost under 5% of their weight; many dropped outEarly evidence
–Insulin or sulfonylureas: more severe low blood sugar; your doctor's callEarly evidence
How to do it: Weekly group sessions or app coaching with weigh-ins, for 12 weeks to a year; the year-long version kept slightly more off.
Track your food and weight: self-monitoring is the key ingredient, paid or free.
Keep some contact going after the program ends; ongoing support slows regain.
Free behavioural support through primary care or public programs works too.
Sticking with it: About 6 in 10 returned for the 12-month weigh-in in the main trial (free membership); half of studies lost 3 in 10 or more starters.
Cost: About US$290–850 a year depending on program (our estimate); prepared-meal programs cost more.
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Current or past eating disorder: talk to your doctor first. On insulin or sulfonylureas: your doctor's call before cutting calories.
Risks and who should be careful (13)
dieting programs trigger disordered eatingNot yet knownEarly evidence49 trials of behavioural programs: eating-disorder and binge scores fell on average; 4 studies found new symptoms in 0–6.5%.The details49 trials of behavioural programs: eating-disorder and binge scores fell on average; 4 studies found new symptoms in 0–6.5% of participants.Who makes this claim: Eating-disorder organisations, critics of dietingJebeile 2023 · 82 Strong
most people stop or don't reach a meaningful weight loss, and subscriptions keep chargingProbably harmfulEarly evidence25 studies: 57% of starters lost under 5% of their weight, and dropout was often high. A US app paid US$56 million over auto-renewals.The details25 studies: 57% of starters lost under 5%; half of studies lost 30%+. In the US: an app paid US$56m plus credits over auto-renewals.Who makes this claim: Critics, consumer lawyersMcEvedy et al. 2017 · 66 Good (independence estimated*)Jebb et al. 2011 · 67 GoodGlobe and Mail 2022
app privacy (health data shared or sold)UntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet reviewed.Who makes this claim: Privacy advocates
low blood sugar when cutting calories on insulin or sulfonylureasProbably harmfulEarly evidenceLarge diabetes trial: insulin users in intensive weight loss had 45% more severe low blood sugar than those given education. Dose changes: your doctor's call.The detailsLook AHEAD: insulin users had 45% more severe lows during intensive weight loss; no absolute figure. Dose changes are your doctor's call.Who makes this claim: Diabetes cliniciansLook AHEAD Research Group 2016 · 70 Good
Side effectsNo program-related side effects were reported in the main trials.The detailsNo program-related adverse events were reported in the main trials.Jebb et al. 2011 · 67 GoodAhern et al. 2022 · 76 Good
Who should check firstInsulin or sulfonylureas: cutting calories risks low blood sugar (your doctor's call). Eating-disorder history: talk to your doctor first.The detailsInsulin or sulfonylurea users risk low blood sugar when cutting calories (your doctor's call); people with an eating-disorder history should talk to their doctor first.Look AHEAD Research Group 2016 · 70 GoodJebeile 2023 · 82 Strong
Programme length52-week programs kept slightly more off than 12-week ones, but by 5 years the difference wasn't clear; ongoing contact slows regain.The detailsLonger programs (52 weeks) kept slightly more off than 12-week ones, but the difference at 5 years wasn't significant; ongoing contact slows regain.Ahern et al. 2022 · 76 GoodHartmann-Boyce 2021 · 85 Strong
Branded bars and shakesProgramme-branded bars, shakes and meals haven't been reviewed yet.The detailsProgramme-branded bars, shakes and meals haven't been reviewed yet.
SweetenersProgramme meal products may contain sweeteners; not yet reviewed.The detailsProgramme meal products may contain sweeteners; not yet reviewed.
Success figuresProgramme success figures often come from people who stayed; one owner's 5.5 kg figure comes from paying members with no comparison group.The detailsProgramme success figures often come from people who stayed; one program owner's 5.5 kg figure comes from paying members with no comparison group.Hendrie et al. 2025 · 52 LimitedMcEvedy et al. 2017 · 66 Good (independence estimated*)
Eating disordersOn average, eating-disorder scores fell in behavioural programs; a small share reported new symptoms.The detailsOn average, eating-disorder scores fell in behavioural programs; a small share reported new symptoms.Jebeile 2023 · 82 Strong
CostAbout A$450–1,300 a year in Australia. In the US, one app company settled for US$56 million plus US$6 million in credits over automatic renewals (2022).The detailsIn Australia: about A$450–1,300 a year depending on program. In the US: one app company settled for US$56 million plus US$6 million in credits over automatic renewals (2022).CSIRO Total Wellbeing DietWW AustraliaGlobe and Mail 2022
PrivacyApp-based programs hold weight, diet and health data; we haven't checked their privacy policies.The detailsApp-based programs hold weight, diet and health data; privacy policies weren't assessed.
The evidence, claim by claim (7)Members
What it does
Joining a commercial program gives more weight loss at a year than going it alone, in adults with overweightShown to helpModerate evidence772 GP-referred adults: 5.1 versus 2.3 kg with standard care over a year (program-funded). Review: two programs, at least 2.6% and 4.9% more than advice.The details772 primary-care-referred adults: a year's group program cut 5.1 vs 2.3 kg (program-funded); 39-trial review: WW at least 2.6% and Jenny Craig at least 4.9% more loss at 12 months than control or education (small).Who makes this claim: Commercial programs, USPSTF (US), NICE (UK)Jebb et al. 2011 · 67 GoodGudzune et al. 2015 · 81 Strong (independence estimated*)USPSTF 2018 · 85 StrongGe 2020 · 85 StrongAhern et al. 2017 · 73 GoodNICE NG246 · 78 Good
Programmes help keep weight off long term (2–5 years)Leans toward helping; not yet knownMore data needed1,267 adults: 1.76 kg lighter than with brief advice at 5 years, no clear difference; 249 trials suggest the gap may last.The details1,267 adults: 1.76 kg lighter than brief advice at 5 years (−3.68 to 0.17), range includes no effect; 249 trials model the gap lasting.Who makes this claim: Programmes ('for life'), USPSTF (US)Ahern et al. 2022 · 76 GoodHartmann-Boyce 2021 · 85 StrongUSPSTF 2018 · 85 Strong
A popular Australian online higher-protein program works (its owner's claim)Leans toward helping; not yet knownAnecdotalThe owner's data on 24,035 paying members: about 5.5 kg lost at 12 months (estimated), with no comparison group and complete data for only 27.5%.The detailsThe owner's data on 24,035 paying long-term members: about 5.5 kg lost at 12 months (estimated), no comparison group, 27.5% with complete data.Who makes this claim: The program's ownerHendrie et al. 2025 · 52 Limited
What it doesn't clearly do
App-based programs work as well as in-person supportNot yet knownMore data neededFew trials compare apps with in-person help. Versus minimal help: no clear weight difference at 12 or 24 months.The detailsFew trials compare apps with in-person help. Versus minimal help: −2.5 kg at 12 months (−6.8 to 1.7), +0.7 at 24; ranges include no effect.Who makes this claim: App makersMetzendorf, Wieland and Richter 2024 · 81 Strong (independence estimated*)Toro-Ramos et al. 2020 · 61 LimitedPreuhs 2026 · 77 Good
Prepared-meal programs beat cooking for yourselfMixed resultsEarly evidenceSame counselling for 12 weeks: prepared meals 8.6% versus own food 6.0% lost (food-company funded); meal plans with grocery lists matched supplied food (163 women).The detailsSame counselling, 12 weeks: prepared entrées 8.6% vs self-selected food 6.0% (food-company funded). Meal plans with grocery lists matched supplied food (163 women).Who makes this claim: Meal-delivery programsGudzune et al. 2015 · 81 Strong (independence estimated*)Rock et al. 2016 · 59 LimitedWing et al. 1996 · 62 Limited (independence estimated*)
Not reviewed yet
Programmes cut type 2 diabetes and heart riskUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet reviewed. Weight loss lowers diabetes risk in prediabetes trials generally.Who makes this claim: Programmes, diabetes-prevention schemesUSPSTF 2018 · 85 Strong
'Psychology-based' coaching changes habits for lifeUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet reviewed.Who makes this claim: App-based programs
Fact-checked 1 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
▸ See 4 more protocols▾ 4 more protocols, best firstMembers
Best product
Meal-replacement shakes and very-low-energy diets (including diabetes-remission programs)
What it is: Shakes or soups (about 800 calories a day) replace all meals for 8–20 weeks, then normal food is brought back step by step; or 1–2 shakes replace meals daily.
Do meal-replacement shakes help you lose weight?
Shown to helpModerate evidence
Yes, with support. In 278 GP patients with obesity, 8 weeks of 810-calorie shakes as their only food, then normal food again, led to 7.2 kg more weight lost at 1 year than usual care.
+Type 2 diabetes under 6 years: remission in 46% versus 4% at 1 yearModerate evidence
+1–2 shakes daily: about 1.4 kg more lost at 1 year than other dietsModerate evidence
○Most regain, but still 3.3 kg lighter than usual care at 3 yearsModerate evidence
○Weight lost fast wasn't regained faster than weight lost slowlyModerate evidence
–Versus 1,200–1,500 calories: about 11 more gallstone hospital stays per 1,000 yearly (our estimate)Early evidence
–Insulin or sulfonylureas: low blood sugar unless doses change; your doctor's callEarly evidence
How to do it: About 800–850 calories a day from shakes as the only food for 8–20 weeks, then food brought back over 2–8 weeks, with regular support.
Even in remission, keep having regular diabetes checks; blood sugar often rises again.
Sticking with it: Shakes are used for 8–20 weeks by design; in England's national program, 55% completed the year, and most people regain once support ends.
Cost: About US$260–750 for 12 weeks of 3 shakes a day, partly offset by food not bought (our estimate).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Pregnant, breastfeeding, under 18 or eating-disorder history: avoid, or specialist care only. Diabetes or blood-pressure medicines, kidney or heart disease: your doctor's call.
Risks and who should be careful (18)
starting a very-low-energy diet on insulin or sulfonylureas (or blood-pressure tablets) causes low blood sugar or low blood pressure unless medicines changeProbably harmfulEarly evidenceAustralian guidance halves insulin or sulfonylurea doses at the start; the remission trial stopped diabetes and blood pressure tablets. Your doctor's call.The detailsAustralian obesity algorithm halves insulin or sulfonylurea doses at the start; DiRECT stopped diabetes and blood-pressure tablets. 5:2 fasting trial: low blood sugar doubled (indirect).Who makes this claim: Australian Obesity Management Algorithm, Diabetes Australia, program makersADS, ANZOS and ADEA 2024 · 49 WeakLean et al. 2018 · 73 GoodCorley et al. 2018 · 60 Limited (independence estimated*)Diabetes Australia 2021 · 64 Limited (independence estimated*)Brown et al. 2020 · 63 Limited
the weight comes back and remission is lost once the program endsShown not to helpModerate evidenceGP trial: regained 8.9 versus 1.2 kg by 3 years, yet still 3.3 kg lighter. Diabetes remission: 13% versus 5% at 5 years.The detailsDROPLET: regained 8.9 vs 1.2 kg; still 3.3 kg lighter than usual care at 3 years. DiRECT remission: 46%, 36%, 13% vs 5% (5 years).Who makes this claim: Critics; Diabetes Australia ('two thirds cannot sustain it at two years')Astbury et al. 2021 · 67 GoodLean et al. 2019 · 70 GoodLean et al. 2024 · 54 LimitedDiabetes Australia 2021 · 64 Limited (independence estimated*)Hartmann-Boyce et al. 2023 · 85 Strong
very-low-energy diets cause gallstones and gallbladder diseaseProbably harmfulEarly evidence6,640 Swedish adults: on 500 rather than 1,200–1,500 calories a day, about 11 more per 1,000 a year needed gallstone hospital care (our estimate).The detailsSwedish matched cohort, 6,640 adults: 500 kcal vs 1,200–1,500 kcal diets linked with more gallstones needing hospital care, 152 vs 44 per 10,000 person-years.Who makes this claim: VLED product leaflets, Australian Obesity Management AlgorithmJohansson et al. 2014 · 62 LimitedADS, ANZOS and ADEA 2024 · 49 WeakLean et al. 2018 · 73 GoodPurcell et al. 2014 · 71 Good (independence estimated*)VLED maker's page
very-low-energy diets trigger or worsen eating disorders or binge eatingNot yet knownEarly evidenceIn 49 weight-program trials in adults, eating-disorder scores fell on average; 0–6.5% had new symptoms. In 56 at-risk adults with diabetes on shakes: no worsening.The detailsAdults: 49 weight-management trials, eating-disorder scores fell on average; 0–6.5% had new symptoms. 56 at-risk adults with diabetes on shakes: no worsening.Who makes this claim: Eating-disorder clinicians; NICE (assess first)Jebeile et al. 2024 · 59 LimitedNICE NG246 · 78 GoodJebeile 2023 · 82 StrongTsompanaki et al. 2025 · 63 Limited
weight lost fast is regained faster than weight lost slowlyShown not to helpModerate evidenceIn 200 Melbourne adults, a 12-week shake diet and 36 weeks of gradual loss both regained 76.3% of lost weight by about 3 years.The detailsMelbourne trial, 200 adults: 12-week VLED vs 36-week gradual loss; both regained 76.3% by about 3 years.Who makes this claim: Older guidelines advising gradual lossPurcell et al. 2014 · 71 Good (independence estimated*)
fast weight loss costs muscle and bone, in older adultsProbably harmfulEarly evidenceSydney trial, 101 women aged 45–65: severe restriction lost more hip bone, and 1.2 kg more lean mass, in line with extra weight lost.The detailsSydney trial, 101 women aged 45–65: severe restriction lost 1.2 kg more lean mass (proportionate) and more hip bone (−0.017 g/cm²).Who makes this claim: Obesity researchers, bone-health cliniciansSeimon et al. 2019 · 63 Limited
shakes are ultra-processed foodsUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot reviewed yet.Who makes this claim: Ultra-processed food critics
side effects such as constipation, tiredness, dizziness, headache and feeling coldLeans toward harm; not yet knownAnecdotalMakers list tiredness, light-headedness, headache and constipation, not compared in trials. GP trial: moderate or worse side effects 11% versus 12% with usual care.The detailsMaker lists fatigue, light-headedness, headache and constipation; not compared in trials. DROPLET: moderate or worse adverse events 11% vs 12% on usual care.Who makes this claim: Programme makersAstbury et al. 2018 · 70 GoodVLED maker's page
Side effects and gallstonesModerate or worse side effects: 11% versus 12% on usual care. Gallstone hospital stays: about 3 times those on 1,200–1,500 calories, about 11 more per 1,000 yearly (our estimate).The detailsModerate or worse adverse events were about the same as usual care (11% vs 12%, DROPLET). In DiRECT, 2 serious events in one person (biliary colic, abdominal pain) were possibly related; DiRECT-Aus reported 2 related hospitalisations in 155. Gallstones needing hospital care were about 3 times as common on a 500 kcal diet: 152 vs 44 per 10,000 person-years, about 11 more per 1,000 a year (our estimate).Astbury et al. 2018 · 70 GoodLean et al. 2018 · 73 GoodHocking et al. 2024 · 51 LimitedJohansson et al. 2014 · 62 Limited
Who should check firstNot in pregnancy or breastfeeding. Children, teens, over-65s: medical supervision. Diabetes, blood-pressure or warfarin medicines, kidney or heart disease, recent heart attack or stroke, porphyria, eating disorders: your doctor's call.The detailsInsulin or sulfonylureas: the Australian Obesity Management Algorithm halves doses at the start and adjusts by frequent glucose checks; SGLT2 inhibitors: ketone checks or stopping, for ketoacidosis risk; blood-pressure tablets were stopped in DiRECT. These are your doctor's call. Pregnancy and lactation: contraindicated (FSANZ labels, the algorithm). Children, adolescents and older people: only under medical supervision (FSANZ); over 65 with caution. Recent heart attack or stroke, porphyria, kidney disease (closer supervision) and warfarin (INR checks) are listed. Eating disorders: NICE says to assess and counsel first. Diabetes Australia: intensive dietary change can be dangerous with some medicines, kidney or heart disease. The ADA (US) cites electrolyte problems, severe fatigue and heart-rhythm problems as risks, and advises screening for past or current disordered eating.ADS, ANZOS and ADEA 2024 · 49 WeakFSANZ · Official dataNICE NG246 · 78 GoodDiabetes Australia 2021 · 64 Limited (independence estimated*)Lean et al. 2018 · 73 GoodADA 2026 · 74 Good (independence estimated*)
Shakes-only time limitsShakes as the only food: up to 12 weeks (Australian food regulator, NICE), or 3–5 months for diabetes remission (RACGP), then structured food reintroduction. Not a long-term strategy.The detailsShakes as the only food: up to 12 weeks (FSANZ, NICE), or 3–5 months for diabetes remission under RACGP's Grade A advice, then structured food reintroduction. NICE: not a long-term strategy. Losing weight fast was not regained faster than slowly (76.3% regained either way). In the US, the ADA Standards of Care advise 800–1,000 kcal plans only for carefully selected people, prescribed by trained practitioners with close monitoring, generally for up to 3 months, with long-term maintenance support (grade B).FSANZ · Official dataNICE NG246 · 78 GoodRACGP 2024 · 65 GoodPurcell et al. 2014 · 71 Good (independence estimated*)ADA 2026 · 74 Good (independence estimated*)
How products are regulatedIn Australia and New Zealand, very-low-energy diet products are regulated special medical foods with set label warnings; they aren't medicines and the TGA doesn't check them.The detailsIn Australia and New Zealand: very-low-energy diet products are regulated foods for special medical purposes (FSANZ Standard 2.9.5), with set label warnings; they are not medicines and aren't checked by the TGA.FSANZ · Official data
Sweeteners and sugarFlavoured shakes usually contain sweeteners or added sugars; we haven't reviewed evidence on this.The detailsFlavoured shakes usually contain sweeteners or added sugars; we haven't reviewed evidence on this.
Remission isn't a cureRemission isn't a cure: blood sugar often rises again, so keep having regular diabetes checks (Diabetes Australia).The detailsRemission is 'not a cure': blood sugar often rises again, and regular diabetes checks should continue (Diabetes Australia).Diabetes Australia 2021 · 64 Limited (independence estimated*)
Eating disorders and regainEating-disorder scores fell in weight-program trials, though 0–6.5% developed new symptoms in the 4 that checked. Most regain once support stops: 8.9 versus 1.2 kg (usual care) by 3 years.The detailsEating-disorder scores fell on average in adult and adolescent weight-management trials (0–6.5% developed new symptoms) and did not worsen in 56 at-risk adults with diabetes on shakes. Most people regain once support stops (8.9 kg vs 1.2 kg from 6 months to 3 years).Jebeile et al. 2024 · 59 LimitedAstbury et al. 2021 · 67 GoodJebeile 2023 · 82 StrongTsompanaki et al. 2025 · 63 Limited
Food-based diets insteadA food-based low-energy diet works too, but less: in type 2 diabetes, 400–500-calorie diets lost 6.6 kg more than 1,000–1,500-calorie diets. Low-carb was no better than higher-carb.The detailsA food-based low-energy diet works too, but less: 400–500 kcal formula diets lost 6.6 kg more than 1,000–1,500 kcal diets (low certainty). Low-carb food diets were no better than higher-carb ones for weight (high certainty).Churuangsuk et al. 2022 · 82 Strong
CostAbout A$400–1,150 (US$260–750) for 12 weeks of full replacement, partly offset by food not bought (our estimate).The detailsAbout A$400–1,150 for 12 weeks of full replacement at Australian pharmacy prices, partly offset by food not bought (our estimate). Shown as information only.
PrivacyCommercial programs and apps may collect health data; we haven't reviewed this.The detailsCommercial programs and apps may collect health data; we haven't reviewed this.
The evidence, claim by claim (6)Members
What it does
Total diet replacement or a very-low-energy diet (about 800 kcal a day, mostly shakes) cuts weight more than usual diet advice, in adults with obesityShown to helpModerate evidenceGP trial, 1 year: 45% versus 15% (usual care) lost a tenth of their weight. In diabetes, 400–500 calories beat 1,000–1,500 by 6.6 kg.The detailsDROPLET, 278 adults: −7.2 kg (−9.4 to −4.9) vs usual care at 1 year. 400–500 kcal diets: 6.6 kg more than 1,000–1,500 kcal (low certainty).Who makes this claim: Michael Mosley (800-calorie diet books), meal-replacement makers, NICE, Australian Obesity Management AlgorithmAstbury et al. 2018 · 70 GoodChuruangsuk et al. 2022 · 82 StrongNICE NG246 · 78 GoodADS, ANZOS and ADEA 2024 · 49 WeakAstbury et al. 2021 · 67 GoodADA 2026 · 74 Good (independence estimated*)
A very-low-energy diet with stepped food reintroduction (DiRECT style) puts type 2 diabetes into remission, in adults with overweight and diabetes under 6 yearsShown to helpModerate evidenceIn 298 UK adults with diabetes under 6 years, not on insulin: remission 46% versus 4% at 1 year, 36% versus 3% at 2 years.The detailsDiRECT, 298 UK adults not on insulin: remission 46% vs 4% at 1 year (420 more per 1,000, our estimate); 36% vs 3% at 2.Who makes this claim: Roy Taylor, Michael Mosley, Diabetes UK, RACGP (Grade A), Diabetes AustraliaLean et al. 2018 · 73 GoodLean et al. 2019 · 70 GoodChuruangsuk et al. 2022 · 82 StrongRACGP 2024 · 65 GoodDiabetes Australia 2021 · 64 Limited (independence estimated*)Sherifali et al. 2025 · 78 GoodHocking et al. 2024 · 51 LimitedADA 2026 · 74 Good (independence estimated*)Valabhji et al. 2024 · 62 Limited
Partial meal replacement (1–2 shakes a day) helps lose weight and keep it off, in adults with overweightShown to helpModerate evidence23 trials, 7,884 adults with overweight: 1–2 daily shakes lost 1.4 kg more at a year than other diets; about 6 kg with extra support.The details23 trials, 7,884 adults: −1.44 kg (−2.48 to −0.39) more at 1 year than other diets (small); −6.13 kg with enhanced support.Who makes this claim: Meal-replacement and shake makers, pharmacy weight-loss programsAstbury et al. 2019 · 79 GoodChuruangsuk et al. 2022 · 82 StrongADS, ANZOS and ADEA 2024 · 49 Weak
Complete-nutrition shakes are nutritionally complete and healthy as everyday foodLeans toward helping; not yet knownAnecdotalMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesOnly a 4-week, company-paid study of 20 adults on shakes alone, with no comparison group, found vitamin and mineral levels held up.The detailsOnly a company-paid 4-week pilot: 20 adults on shakes alone kept micronutrient levels; no control group. The maker says it isn't your only food.Who makes this claim: Shake makersWilcox et al. 2022 · 31 WeakShake maker's page on its own 4-week pilot
Very-low-energy diets improve blood pressure, liver fat and heart risk factorsProbably helpsEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesAt 3 years the GP trial's bottom blood pressure number was 3.3 points lower; long-term blood sugar and cholesterol: no clear difference.The detailsDROPLET, 3 years: diastolic −3.3 mmHg vs usual care; no HbA1c, LDL or heart-risk difference. 94 weight-program trials (indirect): HbA1c 0.38% lower 5 years on.Who makes this claim: Programme makers, diabetes researchersAstbury et al. 2021 · 67 GoodHartmann-Boyce et al. 2023 · 85 Strong
Very-low-energy diets cut heart attacks or deathsLeans toward helping; not yet knownMore data neededNo shake-diet trial has measured them. In 5,145 adults with diabetes on a lifestyle program with shakes, heart events: no clear difference over 9.6 years.The detailsNo VLED trial has measured them. Look AHEAD, 5,145 adults with diabetes (partial shakes): heart events HR 0.95 (0.83–1.09), range includes no effect.Who makes this claim: Remission advocatesLean et al. 2024 · 54 LimitedLook AHEAD Research Group 2013 · 86 Strong
Fact-checked 1 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
▸ See 3 more products▾ 3 more products, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
2Set a realistic goalOptional11 studies1 website⌄
To lower diabetes risk, aim to lose 5–7% of your weight and keep it off; track your waist too (risk rises from 94 cm men, 80 cm women). At 65+, lose weight only if needed, with strength training and enough protein; kidney disease? Ask your GP.
What it found: An international expert group (the International Atherosclerosis Society and International Chair on Cardiometabolic Risk) recommends measuring waist routinely alongside BMI, as a 'vital sign', and treating a smaller waist as a key goal. It says moderate exercise or diet changes can achieve this.
What it means for you: Measure your waist as well as your weight; a shrinking waist is worth aiming for in itself.
▸ See 10 more studies▾ 10 more studies, best firstMembers
Best for: Australian primary-care source for measuring weight and waist, and for the Australian waist thresholds.
Caution: Written for GPs. Our rating: Limited.
+ Add a note
3Decide on intermittent fasting (optional)Optional11 books1 protocol4 studies1 website⌄
Fasting gives about the same weight loss as cutting calories daily; any edge is small (1–3 kg in some trials) and uncertain. Choose it if it's easier to keep up. On insulin or other medicines that can cause low blood sugar? See your GP first.
What it found: In 21 trials of adults with overweight or obesity, followed for 6 months or more, fasting schedules made no clear difference to weight lost compared with ordinary daily calorie-cutting advice: about a third of 1% of body weight. Few trials ran beyond a year.
What it means for you: Pick fasting only if it's easier for you to keep up. On insulin or similar medicines? See your GP first.
The figures and the limit
Difference in weight lost vs daily calorie cutting: −0.33 percentage points (−0.92 to 0.26), 21 trials.
The limit: Low certainty; few trials beyond 12 months.
▸ See 3 more studies▾ 3 more studies, best firstMembers
Best book
Our pick for this step
The Every Other Day Diet
Krista Varady, 2013
93Top rated
★ 3.86 on Goodreads (744) · about 6 hours
6 of 8 readers who said either way said it helped
From 30 sampled Goodreads reviews: 6 helped, 2 didn't, 3 already knew most of it; the rest didn't say.
Claim: Researcher or educatorAuthor's own research
“Months on plan, 159 to 122 lb; stopped snacking, learned true hunger from boredom”
▸ Why it's rated 93▾ Why it's rated 93
Scorecard
Reader outcomes 40%
94
Content quality 20%
100
Author credibility 20%
100
Goal relevance 10%
100
Rating and format 10%
52
What readers said helped (paraphrased)
Months on plan, 159 to 122 lb; stopped snacking, learned true hunger from boredom
Started the day it arrived; three weeks in, 8 lb lighter with own tweaks
On the plan past two weeks; hunger on 500-calorie days has subsided
Six weeks on plan, 18 lb lost; energy on fast days, no binging on feast days
Experienced faster four weeks into 4:3 toward alternate days; no deprivation, about 15 lb lost
Sceptic on the plan for a while; weight coming off fairly effortlessly
Why it didn't help some
Arabic; tried one week; hunger, then 4,000-calorie feast days; abandoned, back to calorie counting
Followed plan but lost little; still eating processed high-carb food; not good for them
Already knew most of it
Already eats keto, one meal a day, alternate-day fasting; basic for them
Was already doing the diet with friends' success before reading; book validating
Does 18-hour daily fasts on own; prefers that to this diet
Rated for
Keep it off 90
From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 1 November 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 744 ratings, about 94% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. 6 readers say the effect has lasted. Audiobook not confirmed.
Note: If you take insulin or a sulfonylurea (or another medicine that can cause low blood sugar), don't start the 500-600 calorie days without your doctor's advice. Not for anyone with an eating-disorder history.
▸ See 10 more books▾ 10 more books, best firstMembers
What it is: Set eating hours (16:8 is an 8-hour window), about 500–600 calories on 2 days a week (5:2), alternate-day fasting, or multi-day water fasts or low-calorie kits.
Does intermittent fasting help you lose weight?
Shown to helpModerate evidence
Yes, a little, but no more than usual diet advice. In 6 trials of adults with overweight, over 6–12 months, fasting lost about 3.4% more body weight than no change; versus diet advice (21 trials), no clear difference.
+Versus no change: about 3 kg more lost at 90 kg (our estimate)Moderate evidence
○No clear edge over diet advice; alternate-day fasting beat calorie cutting by 1.3 kgMore data needed
+Type 2 diabetes: a monthly fasting-mimicking diet lowered blood sugar and medicine useEarly evidence
–Insulin or sulfonylureas: low blood sugar about twice as common on fasting daysMore data needed
–Multi-day water fasts: severe side effects in 28% of one US clinic's staysEarly evidence
–Under-8-hour eating windows: 34% more deaths than 12-hour ones (US survey)Early evidence
The diabetes result measured long-term blood sugar (HbA1c) and medicine use, not diabetes complications
How to do it: Trials used eating windows of 4–10 hours, 5:2 with 500–600 calories on fast days, or alternate days; fasting-mimicking kits ran 5 days a month.
Fasting drinks may contain sweeteners or caffeine; check the label.
Fasting isn't permission to eat anything: what you eat inside the eating window still matters.
Sticking with it: About 6 in 10 were still in an alternate-day fasting trial at a year (38% dropped out, versus 29% on daily calorie cutting).
Cost: No extra cost for most schedules; 5-day fasting-mimicking kits list at US$225–249, about US$2,700–3,000 a year if monthly (our estimate).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Avoid: pregnancy, breastfeeding, under 18, frailty, past eating disorder or severe lows. Doctor's call: insulin, sulfonylureas; multi-day fasts: gout, SGLT2 inhibitors, diuretics, BMI under 18.5.
Risks and who should be careful (28)
an 8-hour eating window is linked with more deaths from heart diseaseProbably harmfulEarly evidenceUS survey: an under-8-hour window was linked with 34% more deaths, or over twice the heart deaths in another analysis; eating measured on 2 days.The detailsUS survey, two analyses: 8-hour window linked with 34% more deaths, or 2.35 times heart deaths (not overall); no absolute figure; window from 2 days.Who makes this claim: AHA 2024 meeting abstract (widely reported), Mao 2025Mao et al. 2025 · 65 GoodChen, ... Zhong 2025 · 67 Good (independence estimated*)
low blood sugar when fasting on insulin or sulfonylureas, in people with diabetesLeans toward harm; not yet knownMore data neededDespite medicine cuts, low blood sugar was about twice as common on fasting days (41 adults); another trial: 6 versus 2 people, no clear difference.The detailsWith dose cuts, versus daily dieting: lows in 6 vs 2 people; range includes no effect. Smaller 41-adult trial: lows doubled on fasting days.Who makes this claim: ADA, Diabetes Australia, Australian Diabetes Society 2022 (Ramadan statement), Varady 2026 (proponents; lead author wrote a fasting book)Corley et al. 2018 · 60 Limited (independence estimated*)Varady, Chow and Peterson 2026 · 38 WeakLook AHEAD Research Group 2016 · 70 GoodCarter, Clifton and Keogh 2018 · 70 GoodObermayer et al. 2023 · 70 GoodAustralian Diabetes Society 2022 · 55 Limited
fasting triggers or worsens disordered eating, especially with an eating-disorder historyNot yet knownMore data neededIn 16 time-restricted eating studies, disordered-eating scores didn't change. A survey of young Canadians links fasting with eating-disorder symptoms; cause unclear.The detailsIn time-restricted eating studies, disordered-eating questionnaire scores didn't change (review of 16 studies). A survey of young Canadians links fasting with eating-disorder symptoms; cause unclear.Who makes this claim: Eating-disorder clinicians, NICE (dieting can trigger binge eating; not fasting-specific), Varady 2026 (advises against with a history)Vizthum et al. 2023 · 58 Limited (independence estimated*)Ganson et al. 2022 · 51 Limited (independence estimated*)Varady, Chow and Peterson 2026 · 38 WeakNICE 2017 · 79 Good (independence estimated*)
loss of lean (muscle) massNot yet knownEarly evidenceAfter 12 weeks of 16:8, limb lean mass was about 0.46 kg lower than with three daily meals (our estimate): little or no difference.The detailsTREAT, 16:8 for 12 weeks: limb lean mass index 0.16 kg/m² lower than three daily meals, about 0.46 kg (our estimate): little or no difference.Who makes this claim: Critics, Varady 2026 (caution in frailty)Lowe et al. 2020 · 66 Good
headache, hunger, irritability, dizzinessLeans toward harm; not yet knownMore data neededVersus diet advice, side effects weren't clearly more common; proponents list hunger, fatigue and dizziness, mostly on fasting days.The detailsCochrane: adverse events RR 1.45 (0.64–3.28) vs diet advice; range includes no effect, very low certainty. Proponents list hunger, fatigue, dizziness.Who makes this claim: Trial reportsVarady, Chow and Peterson 2026 · 38 WeakGaregnani 2026 · 97 Strong
pregnancy, breastfeeding, children and teensUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. Proponents themselves advise against fasting in pregnancy, breastfeeding, and for children and teens.The detailsNot tested; proponents themselves advise against fasting in these groups.Who makes this claim: Varady 2026Varady, Chow and Peterson 2026 · 38 Weak
changes sex hormones or fertility in womenUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (below the top claims by priority).Who makes this claim: Media; Varady group reviewCienfuegos et al. 2022 · 27 Weak
longer fasts on diabetes medicines or diuretics raise the risk of low blood sugar, ketoacidosis and dehydrationShown to harmModerate evidenceFasting raises ketoacidosis risk on SGLT2 inhibitors; insulin and diuretics raise refeeding risk. Changing medicines is your doctor's call.The detailsDiabetes society alert: fasting raises ketoacidosis risk with SGLT2 inhibitors. Insulin and diuretics are refeeding risk factors. Medicine changes: your doctor's call.Who makes this claim: Australian Diabetes Society, US Food and Drug Administration, NICE criteria, diabetes cliniciansAustralian Diabetes Society 2022 · 80 Strong (official data)NHS Scotland Right Decisions 2023 · 78 Good (official data)Australian Diabetes Society 2022 · 55 LimitedUS Food and Drug Administration 2020 · 66 Good (official data)
refeeding syndrome after a long fastProbably harmfulEarly evidenceLittle or no food for over 10 days, or over 5 days with another risk factor, means high refeeding risk; untested in planned fasts.The detailsGuideline criteria: little or no intake for over 10 days, or over 5 days plus another risk factor, means high risk. Untested in planned fasts.Who makes this claim: NICE (CG32) criteria, NHS Scotland; case reportsNHS Scotland Right Decisions 2023 · 78 Good (official data)Aweer et al. 2025 · 39 Weak (independence estimated*)
side effects of multi-day water fasts (near-fainting, headache, low sodium)Probably harmfulEarly evidenceIn 768 supervised water-fast stays, 28% had a severe side effect (over a third, existing high blood pressure); 2 hospitalised. Another clinic: under 1%.The detailsClinic charts, 768 stays: severe side effect in 28% (over a third high blood pressure, mostly pre-existing); near-fainting 28%; 2 hospitalised. Another clinic: under 1%.Who makes this claim: Fasting clinics' own reports (Finnell 2018, Wilhelmi de Toledo 2019)Finnell et al. 2018 · 41 WeakWilhelmi de Toledo et al. 2019 · 43 Weak
much of the weight lost in a multi-day fast is lean tissue and waterProbably harmfulEarly evidenceIn a 10-day fast, 60% of the 5.9 kg lost was lean tissue and water; a review says about two-thirds of weight lost is lean.The details10-day 200–250 kcal fast: 60% of 5.9 kg lost was lean tissue and water. Review of trials: about two-thirds of weight lost is lean.Who makes this claim: Critics; Ulupınar 2026Laurens et al. 2021 · 39 WeakUlupınar et al. 2026 · 60 Limited (independence estimated*)Ezpeleta et al. 2024 · 39 Weak (independence estimated*)
water-only fasts raise LDL cholesterol while they lastProbably harmfulEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesAcross 32 before-and-after studies, LDL cholesterol rose at every fast length, and HDL fell in fasts over 3 days.The details32 before-and-after studies: LDL rose (effect size 0.49) at every fast length; HDL fell in fasts over 3 days.Who makes this claim: Çamli 2026Çamli et al. 2026 · 63 Limited
uric acid rises and can trigger goutProbably harmfulEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesIn 1,422 clinic fasters (4–21 days), uric acid rose from 338 to 495 µmol/L; one gout attack, in a man already treated for gout.The details1,422 clinic fasters, 4–21 days: blood uric acid rose from 338 to 495 µmol/L; one gout attack, in a man already treated for gout.Who makes this claim: Rheumatology clinicians; Wilhelmi de Toledo 2019 (clinic-funded)Wilhelmi de Toledo et al. 2019 · 43 Weak
inflammation and clotting markers rise during a 10-day water fastProbably harmfulEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesIn 20 adults over about 10 days, inflammation and clotting markers rose; in 1,422 clinic fasters, CRP went from 2.8 to 4.3 mg/L. Meaning unclear.The details20 adults, about 10 days: CRP and clotting pathways rose; in 1,422 clinic fasters CRP went from 2.8 to 4.3 mg/L. Clinical meaning unknown.Who makes this claim: Commissati 2025 (one author founded a fasting clinic)Commissati et al. 2025 · 47 Weak
thiamine (vitamin B1) deficiency after very long fastsLeans toward harm; not yet knownAnecdotalCase report: a 36-year-old developed a serious thiamine-deficiency brain disorder (confusion, double vision, unsteady walking) after a 40-day water-only fast.The detailsCase report: a 36-year-old developed Wernicke's encephalopathy (confusion, double vision, unsteady gait) after a 40-day water-only fast.Who makes this claim: Case reportsAweer et al. 2025 · 39 Weak (independence estimated*)
Side effectsVersus diet advice, side effects weren't clearly more common; hunger, fatigue, dizziness and gut symptoms occur mostly on fasting days. Lean mass: little or no difference on 16:8.The detailsCochrane: adverse events RR 1.45 (0.64 to 3.28) vs diet advice, range includes no effect (very low certainty). Proponents list hunger, fatigue, dizziness and gut symptoms, mostly on fasting days. TREAT: limb lean mass index −0.16 kg/m² on 16:8, about 0.46 kg (our estimate): little or no difference.Garegnani 2026 · 97 StrongVarady, Chow and Peterson 2026 · 38 WeakLowe et al. 2020 · 66 Good
Multi-day fast side effectsOne US clinic: a severe side effect in 28% of 768 water-fast stays; 2 hospitalised. A German clinic reported under 1%, but mild symptoms were common.The detailsIn 768 stays at a US water-fasting clinic, a severe (grade 3) side effect was the worst event in 28% (over a third of these were high blood pressure, mostly present on arrival) and life-threatening in 1; fatigue 48%, headache 30%, near-fainting 28%; 2 people were hospitalised (dehydration on day 3, severe low sodium on day 9), about 2.6 per 1,000 stays (our estimate). A German clinic study of 1,422 people on 200–250 kcal a day reported adverse effects in under 1%, while self-reported mild symptoms were common (sleep problems 15%, fatigue 14%, headache 5%). Both are the clinics' own reports.Finnell et al. 2018 · 41 WeakWilhelmi de Toledo et al. 2019 · 43 Weak
Who should check with a doctor firstOn insulin or sulfonylureas, low blood sugar was about twice as common on fasting days: your doctor's call. Avoid in pregnancy, breastfeeding, teens, frailty, past severe lows or eating disorder.The detailsInsulin or sulfonylureas: in a 12-week New Zealand trial in type 2 diabetes (41 adults, all with medicine reductions), low blood sugar was about twice as common on fasting days as on other days (RR 2.05, 1.17 to 3.52; mean 1.4 episodes per 12 weeks). An Adelaide trial of 5:2 against a daily calorie-cut diet (137 adults, 12 months, with a medicine-reduction plan that was tightened after early low blood sugar) found low blood sugar in 6 vs 2 of the 46 people on these medicines in the first 2 weeks, not a significant difference. In an Austrian trial of 46 adults on insulin, with dose cuts on fasting days and a glucose monitor, there was no severe low blood sugar and time below range was 1.6% vs 1.3%. The Australian Diabetes Society's Ramadan statement advises glucose checks, switching away from sulfonylureas where possible, and insulin dose adjustments when fasting; medicines are your doctor's call. Proponents advise against fasting in pregnancy, breastfeeding, adolescence, frailty, a history of severe hypoglycaemia or a history of eating disorders.Corley et al. 2018 · 60 Limited (independence estimated*)Varady, Chow and Peterson 2026 · 38 WeakLook AHEAD Research Group 2016 · 70 GoodCarter, Clifton and Keogh 2018 · 70 GoodObermayer et al. 2023 · 70 GoodAustralian Diabetes Society 2022 · 55 Limited
Multi-day fasts and medicinesMulti-day fasts: ketoacidosis risk on SGLT2 inhibitors; insulin, sulfonylureas, diuretics and blood pressure medicines need planning. Low BMI, recent weight loss, alcohol misuse or gout add risk. Your doctor's call.The detailsFasting raises ketoacidosis risk with SGLT2 inhibitor diabetes medicines; insulin, sulfonylureas, diuretics and blood-pressure medicines also need planning. In Australia and New Zealand: the diabetes society's alert names fasting or very restricted eating as a ketoacidosis risk. In the US: the FDA label says to stop these medicines at least 3 days (one of them, 4 days) before scheduled surgery and restart once eating is back to normal. Little or no intake for more than 5 days, with low body weight (BMI under 18.5), recent weight loss, alcohol misuse or these medicines, puts people at high risk of refeeding syndrome. Uric acid rises, which matters with gout. Supervised fasting and any medicine changes are your doctor's call.Australian Diabetes Society 2022 · 80 Strong (official data)NHS Scotland Right Decisions 2023 · 78 Good (official data)Wilhelmi de Toledo et al. 2019 · 43 WeakAustralian Diabetes Society 2022 · 55 LimitedCorley et al. 2018 · 60 Limited (independence estimated*)US Food and Drug Administration 2020 · 66 Good (official data)
Very short eating windowsShorter isn't better: in US survey data, eating windows under 8 hours or of 15 hours or more were linked with more deaths; lowest risk was at about 11–12 hours.The detailsShorter is not better: in a US survey cohort, eating windows under 8 hours (HR 1.34) and 15 hours or more (HR 1.25) were both linked with more deaths than 12 hours; lowest risk at about 11–12 hours. Another analysis of the same survey linked under 8 hours with heart deaths (HR 2.35) but not with deaths overall. Observational, measured on two days.Mao et al. 2025 · 65 Good
Longer fasts, more riskIn clinic records, severe side effects reached 20% by day 5 and 28% by day 10. Refeeding risk starts at 5–10 days; a 40-day fast caused thiamine deficiency.The detailsRisk rises with length: in clinic charts, the chance of a severe side effect was 20% by day 5 and 28% by day 10. Guideline refeeding criteria start at 5 days of little or no intake (with another risk factor) or 10 days alone. A 40-day water fast led to thiamine deficiency (case report).Finnell et al. 2018 · 41 WeakNHS Scotland Right Decisions 2023 · 78 Good (official data)Aweer et al. 2025 · 39 Weak (independence estimated*)
Who funds kit trials8 of 9 rated kit trials had financial links to the maker. An 11-trial review with no declared conflicts backs the blood sugar and pressure results but pools maker-linked trials.The detailsFasting-mimicking kits are commercial products. Of the 9 kit trials we rated, 8 declare a financial link to the kit's maker: it sponsored the trial or supplied or paid for the diet, and in 7 the diet's inventor holds equity in it; we couldn't read the ninth trial's declarations. An 11-trial review with no funding or declared conflicts supports the blood sugar and blood pressure results, but it pools maker-linked trials (at least 3 of the 11) and found signs of publication bias for weight.van den Burg et al. 2024 · 63 LimitedBrandhorst et al. 2024 · 56 LimitedEspinoza et al. 2026 · 50 Limitedde Groot et al. 2020 · 61 LimitedSadeghian et al. 2021 · 61 Limited (independence estimated*)Mohammadzadeh et al. 2025 · 80 StrongMishra et al. 2023 · 59 LimitedWei et al. 2017 · 60 LimitedSulaj et al. 2022 · 58 LimitedMicarelli et al. 2025 · 63 Limited
Misleading scales and testsA fast's quick scale drop is mostly water and lean tissue; only 38% kept a real fall at 12 weeks. LDL rises during fasts, skewing blood tests.The detailsThe fast drop on the scale is mostly water, glycogen and lean tissue (60% in a 10-day fast). In a randomised 5-day fast, only 38% kept a BMI fall beyond normal variation at 12 weeks. LDL cholesterol rises during water fasts, so blood tests taken during or just after a fast can mislead.Laurens et al. 2021 · 39 WeakÇamli et al. 2026 · 63 LimitedKaufhold et al. 2026 · 66 Good
Disordered eatingTrials found no change in disordered-eating scores, but people described fear of hunger; a survey of 2,762 young Canadians links fasting with eating-disorder symptoms.The detailsTrials found no change in disordered-eating scores (review of 16 studies), but people described fear of hunger and eating without hunger; a survey of 2,762 young Canadians links fasting with eating-disorder symptoms (cause unclear).Vizthum et al. 2023 · 58 Limited (independence estimated*)Ganson et al. 2022 · 51 Limited (independence estimated*)
Diet advice insteadUsual diet advice did as well for weight in 21 trials; only alternate-day fasting beat daily calorie cutting, by about 1.3 kg in short trials.The detailsUsual diet advice did as well for weight in 21 trials (−0.33 percentage points difference, low certainty); in 99 trials only alternate-day fasting beat daily calorie cutting, by 1.29 kg in short trials.Garegnani 2026 · 97 StrongSemnani-Azad 2025 · 93 Strong
CostNo extra cost, and it may cut food spending; paid apps are optional.The detailsNo extra cost; it may cut food spending. Paid apps are optional. Information only.
Cost of kitsIn the US, a 5-day kit lists at about US$225–249, about US$2,700–3,000 a year if monthly (our estimate). No Australian price found. Water fasting is free.The detailsIn the US: a 5-day kit lists at about US$225–249; monthly use is about US$2,700–3,000 a year (our estimate). No Australian price found. Water fasting costs nothing; supervised clinic stays cost extra, and we have no price source for them. Information only.Healthline · 39 Weak (independence estimated*)
PrivacyFasting apps collect eating times, weight and sometimes health data; check the app's privacy policy.The detailsFasting apps collect eating times, weight and sometimes health data; check the app's privacy policy.
The evidence, claim by claim (16)Members
What it does
Fasting improves blood sugar and can reverse type 2 diabetesProbably helpsEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesIn 10 trials (599 people with prediabetes or type 2 diabetes, about 4 months), fasting blood sugar fell slightly; HbA1c: possible 0.3-point fall.The details10 time-restricted eating trials, prediabetes or type 2 diabetes: fasting glucose cut 0.30 mmol/L; HbA1c −0.30 points (−0.63 to 0.02), range includes no effect.Who makes this claim: Jason Fung, Michael Mosley, Satchin Panda (royalty from his book The Circadian Code), Varady 2026 (lead author wrote a fasting book)Viple et al. 2026 · 74 Good (independence estimated*)Semnani-Azad 2025 · 93 StrongVarady, Chow and Peterson 2026 · 38 Weak
Monthly 5-day fasting-mimicking diets improve blood sugar and blood pressure and cut diabetes medicinesProbably helpsEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomes11 trials: HbA1c down about 0.8 points (our estimate), top blood-pressure number 4 lower. Year-long diabetes trial, 100 adults: less medicine, 3.6 kg more lost.The detailsReview, 11 trials (4 in type 2 diabetes): HbA1c −8.6 mmol/mol, systolic BP −4.1 mmHg. 12-month diabetes trial: HbA1c −3.2; 3.6 kg more lost (small).Who makes this claim: Valter Longo (declares equity in the diet's maker in his trial papers), van den Burg 2024 (the maker supplied the diet and part of the funding; one author holds equity, declared)Mohammadzadeh et al. 2025 · 80 Strongvan den Burg et al. 2024 · 63 LimitedWei et al. 2017 · 60 LimitedSulaj et al. 2022 · 58 LimitedMicarelli et al. 2025 · 63 Limited
Fasting or a fasting-mimicking diet around chemotherapy reduces side effects or improves response, for people with cancerProbably helpsEarly evidenceIn 3 studies, fasting around chemotherapy improved tumour response more often, without fewer side effects or survival data. Cancer treatment is your doctor's call.The detailsReview, 3 studies: tumour response more often (OR 4.55); side effects not reduced. Breast cancer trial: OR 3.17. No absolute figures or survival data.Who makes this claim: Valter Longo (declares equity in the diet's maker in his trial papers); media. Cancer treatment decisions are your doctor's callde Groot et al. 2020 · 61 LimitedAgrawal et al. 2026 · 78 Good
What it doesn't clearly do
Fasting schedules cause more weight loss than ordinary dieting, in adults with overweightNot yet knownMore data neededVersus diet advice (21 trials): no clear weight difference. Across 99 trials, only alternate-day fasting beat daily calorie cutting, by about 1.3 kg short term.The detailsCochrane, 21 trials: −0.33% body weight (−0.92 to 0.26) vs diet advice. 99-trial network: only alternate-day fasting beat calorie cutting (1.29 kg, short trials).Who makes this claim: Jason Fung, Cynthia Thurlow, Michael Mosley, Krista Varady (fasting-book author fees), Eric BergGaregnani 2026 · 97 StrongSemnani-Azad 2025 · 93 StrongTrepanowski et al. 2017 · 65 GoodLiu 2022 · 70 Good (independence estimated*)
Fasting slows ageing and extends life (autophagy, 'cell clean-up')Not yet knownEarly evidenceNo human lifespan trial; the evidence is from animals and cells. A US survey links eating within 8 hours with 34% more deaths.The detailsNo human lifespan trial; animal and cell evidence only. A US cohort links eating within 8 hours with 34% more deaths; no absolute figure.Who makes this claim: Cynthia Thurlow, Eric Berg, fasting apps, de Cabo & Mattson 2019de Cabo and Mattson 2019 · 37 Weak (independence estimated*)Mao et al. 2025 · 65 Good
It is easier to keep up than counting caloriesNot yet knownMore data neededIn one trial of 100 adults, 38% quit alternate-day fasting by a year versus 29% on calorie cutting: no clear difference. Many missed fast-day targets.The detailsOne trial, 100 adults: 38% quit alternate-day fasting by 12 months vs 29% on calorie cutting, range includes no effect; fasters often missed fast-day targets.Who makes this claim: Krista Varady (fasting-book author fees), Satchin Panda (Circadian Code royalty), Jason FungTrepanowski et al. 2017 · 65 Good
Monthly 5-day fasting-mimicking diets cause more weight loss than ordinary dieting, in adults with overweightNot yet knownEarly evidenceNo advantage shown: daily calorie cutting lost 1.2 kg more in 2 months (60 women), not clearly; versus Mediterranean eating (84 adults, 4 months): similar.The detailsNo advantage: daily calorie cutting lost 1.2 kg more (60 women, 2 months), not significant (p = 0.06), a lean towards daily dieting; another trial, versus Mediterranean eating, found similar loss (3.5 vs 4.2 kg).Who makes this claim: Valter Longo (declares equity in the diet's maker in his trial papers), the maker of a commercial kit, 'longevity' protocolsSadeghian et al. 2021 · 61 Limited (independence estimated*)Mohammadzadeh et al. 2025 · 80 StrongMishra et al. 2023 · 59 Limited
Multi-day water or very-low-calorie fasts (3 days or more) cause lasting fat lossNot yet knownMore data needed5-day fast versus waiting list (38 adults): some fat loss lasted 12 weeks; only 38% kept a fall beyond normal variation. Never tested against dieting.The details5-day fast vs waitlist (38 adults): fat loss partly kept at 12 weeks (no kg figure; 38% beyond normal variation). No trial versus dieting.Who makes this claim: Jason Fung, '3-day fast' videos, fasting clinicsKaufhold et al. 2026 · 66 GoodGrundler et al. 2026 · 59 LimitedEzpeleta et al. 2024 · 39 Weak (independence estimated*)Ulupınar et al. 2026 · 60 Limited (independence estimated*)
Multi-day fasts and fasting-mimicking diets switch on autophagy ('cell clean-up') and lower biological age in humansNot yet knownMore data neededMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesAutophagy is rarely measured in people; a 30-person, maker-sponsored pilot found inconsistent changes. A blood 'biological age' score fell 2.5 years, a marker only.The detailsHuman autophagy rarely measured directly; a 30-person pilot (maker-sponsored) found inconsistent changes. A blood 'biological age' score fell 2.5 years (surrogate).Who makes this claim: Valter Longo (declares equity in the diet's maker in his trial papers), Jason Fung, wellness mediaSingh and Sargeant 2026 · 39 Weak (independence estimated*)Espinoza et al. 2026 · 50 LimitedBrandhorst et al. 2024 · 56 Limited
Supervised water-only or very-low-calorie fasting lowers blood pressureNot yet knownMore data neededMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesA review of water-fasting trials found blood pressure fell consistently; in randomised 5-day fasts (64 and 38 healthy adults), small or no change, not lasting.The detailsReview of water-fasting trials: blood pressure fell consistently. Randomised 5-day fasts (64 and 38 healthy adults): small or no change, not lasting.Who makes this claim: Water-fasting clinicsEzpeleta et al. 2024 · 39 Weak (independence estimated*)Grundler et al. 2026 · 59 LimitedKaufhold et al. 2026 · 66 Good
Not reviewed yet
It burns fat while keeping muscleUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated for 16:8, 5:2 or alternate days; see the lean-mass harm. For multi-day fasts, see the lean-loss claim below.Who makes this claim: Jason Fung, Eric Berg
It lowers blood pressure and cholesterolUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot rated for 16:8, 5:2 or alternate days; for fasting-mimicking diets and water fasts, see the claims below.Who makes this claim: Satchin Panda, Krista Varady
It sharpens focus and energyUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (below the top claims by priority).Who makes this claim: Cynthia Thurlow, Eric Berg
It lowers inflammationUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (below the top claims by priority).Who makes this claim: Wellness media
It rests the gut and improves gut bacteriaUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (below the top claims by priority).Who makes this claim: Fasting apps
Fasting treats rheumatoid arthritis and other inflammatory diseasesUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (below the top claims by priority).Who makes this claim: Clinic fasting proponents
Fact-checked 1 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
Best for: Dietitian-written article; covers who must take care, such as people on insulin.
Caution: Reference page, not rated by us; a blog article, not a guideline.
+ Add a note
4Ask about medicines if they fitOptional1 product5 studies1 website⌄
If your weight is affecting your health, ask your GP whether a GLP-1 based medicine fits you. If you take one, strength train, eat enough protein, and plan with your GP for the long term: weight comes back after stopping.
What it found: In 262 trials of 99,791 adults with overweight or obesity, GLP-1 based medicines such as semaglutide and tirzepatide gave about 10–15% more body-weight loss than lifestyle alone at one year. Gut side effects and stopping due to side effects were more common.
What it means for you: Ask your GP whether one fits you, and plan for the long term: weight returns after stopping.
The figures and the limit
About 10–15% more weight loss than lifestyle alone at 1 year.
The limit: Weight returns after stopping; heart benefit shown only in people with existing heart disease, in a maker-funded trial.
▸ See 4 more studies▾ 4 more studies, best firstMembers
Product
GLP-1 based weight-loss medicines (semaglutide, tirzepatide)
What it is: Prescription-only medicines, semaglutide and tirzepatide, usually given as injection pens.
Do semaglutide and tirzepatide help you lose weight?
Shown to helpModerate evidence
Yes. In adults with obesity, semaglutide cut about 11% more body weight than placebo over 6–17 months, and tirzepatide about 16% over 12–18 months. Weight returns after stopping. Whether it suits you is your doctor's call.
+Semaglutide: about 11% more body weight lost than placeboStrong evidence
+Tirzepatide: about 16% more body weight lost than placeboModerate evidence
+Semaglutide with heart disease: heart events 6.5% versus 8.0% over 3.3 yearsModerate evidence
–Weight returns after stopping, about 0.8 kg a monthModerate evidence
–Gut side effects: about 37 more in 1,000 stopped over 68 weeks (our estimate)Moderate evidence
–Gallbladder disease up 37%, over twice in weight-loss trials; gallstones 2 more per 1,000Moderate evidence
How to do it: Trials gave the medicines with diet and activity advice for 6 months to 3.5 years; the dose is your doctor's call.
Use only a licensed pharmacy with a prescription; imported and compounded products have been fake or wrong.
A US advisory stresses diet quality, enough protein and strength training while on these medicines.
Sticking with it: About 3–5 in 10 are still taking it a year after starting, and about 1.5 in 10 at two years (US data).
Cost: Self-pay prices of about US$299–449 a month, or US$3,600–5,400 a year (our estimate); insurance cover varies.
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Not in pregnancy or planning it, breastfeeding, or personal or family medullary thyroid cancer or MEN2. Check first: eating disorders, insulin, sulfonylureas. Doctor's call.
Risks and who should be careful (21)
weight comes back after stoppingShown not to helpModerate evidenceAfter stopping (10 study arms, 1,776 people), weight returned at about 0.8 kg a month, back to the start in about 1.5 years.The detailsAfter stopping semaglutide or tirzepatide (10 study arms, 1,776 people): regain about 0.8 kg monthly, back to start in ~1.5 years (moderate certainty).Who makes this claim: Critics, family doctors, the makers' own extension studiesWest 2026 · 90 StrongWilding et al. 2022 · 63 LimitedMozaffarian 2025 · 63 LimitedForner and Hocking 2025 · 42 Weak
nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea and constipation, which make some people stopShown to harmModerate evidenceIn 1,961 adults over 68 weeks, 4.5% versus 0.8% on placebo stopped because of gut side effects: about 37 more per 1,000 (our estimate).The details1,961 adults: 4.5% vs 0.8% stopped for gut effects over 68 weeks (~28 more per 1,000 yearly, our estimate). Cochrane: side-effect withdrawals nearly doubled.Who makes this claim: Users, product information, criticsWilding 2021 · 82 StrongBracchiglione et al. 2025 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)Nong 2026 · 93 StrongChiang et al. 2025 · 91 Strong (independence estimated*)
muscle and other lean mass is lost along with fat, especially a concern for older adultsShown to harmModerate evidenceAbout a quarter to two-fifths of weight lost was lean mass (35 trials), similar to diet alone; strength wasn't measured.The detailsLean mass: a quarter to two-fifths of weight lost (median 28%, 35 trials), like diet alone; resistance training lowered it in lifestyle trials. Strength unmeasured.Who makes this claim: Critics, geriatricians, 2025 US nutrition advisoryBatsis et al. 2026 · 78 Good (independence estimated*)Eisa 2026 · 83 Strong (independence estimated*)Nong 2026 · 93 StrongMozaffarian 2025 · 63 Limited
gallstones and gallbladder diseaseShown to harmModerate evidenceIn 76 trials (103,371 people), gallbladder disease rose 37%, and more than doubled in weight-loss trials; about 2 more gallstone cases per 1,000.The details76 trials, 103,371 people: gallbladder or bile duct disease up 37%, more than doubled in weight-loss trials; gallstones ~2 more per 1,000 (55 trials).Who makes this claim: Product information, gastroenterologistsHe et al. 2022 · 97 StrongChiang et al. 2025 · 91 Strong (independence estimated*)Galli et al. 2025 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)
pancreatitisShown not to helpModerate evidenceIn 55 placebo-controlled trials of 106,395 people, probably little or no effect on pancreatitis; rare harms could still be missed.The details55 placebo-controlled trials, 106,395 people: probably little or no effect on pancreatitis; 21 heart-outcome trials found no difference. Rare harms could still be missed.Who makes this claim: Product information, media reports, US observational studies (not rated)Chiang et al. 2025 · 91 Strong (independence estimated*)Galli et al. 2025 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)Badve et al. 2025 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)
thyroid cancer (medullary thyroid cancer seen in rodents)Shown not to helpModerate evidenceIn 48 trials, probably little or no effect on thyroid cancer; studies following people conflict, with one French study linking use with more.The details48 trials: probably little or no effect (moderate). Observational studies conflict: a French study linked use with more thyroid cancer; a larger Scandinavian one didn't.Who makes this claim: Product information (contraindication), FDA warning (US; not rated)Ko et al. 2026 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)Bezin et al. 2023 · 58 Limited (independence estimated*)Pasternak et al. 2024 · 68 GoodForner and Hocking 2025 · 42 Weak
counterfeit, compounded or online products may be fake, contaminated or the wrong strengthProbably harmfulEarly evidenceIn Australia, 10 tested imported 'GLP-1' products contained none, and compounding is banned; in the US, counterfeit pens and over 1,700 harm reports.The detailsIn Australia: tested imported 'GLP-1' products had none; compounding banned since October 2024. In the US: counterfeits found; 1,700+ compounded-product harm reports.Who makes this claim: TGA (Australia), FDA (US), WHO 2025, Australian Health Minister (compounding ban)TGA · 75 Official dataTGA · 75 Official dataWHO 2025 · 82 Strong (independence estimated*)Medical Republic 2024FDA · 82 Official data
unsafe in pregnancy and not studied in people with eating disordersProbably harmfulEarly evidenceExcluded from trials: pregnancy and eating disorders. An Australian GP review advises against use when breastfeeding and stopping two months before trying to conceive.The detailsExcluded from trials and WHO's guideline; an Australian GP journal review: stop two months before trying to conceive, and check for disordered eating first.Who makes this claim: WHO 2025, product information, AJGP 2025WHO 2025 · 82 Strong (independence estimated*)Forner and Hocking 2025 · 42 Weak
low blood sugar when combined with insulin or sulfonylureas, in people with diabetesProbably harmfulEarly evidenceIn a lifestyle weight-loss trial (not these medicines), insulin users had 45% more severe lows than with education only. Doses: your doctor's call.The detailsLook AHEAD (lifestyle weight loss, indirect): insulin users had 45% more severe lows; no absolute figure. Dose changes are your doctor's call.Who makes this claim: Diabetes cliniciansLook AHEAD Research Group 2016 · 70 Good
suicidal thoughts or depressionUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet reviewed. Regulators have reviewed the signal; large cohort studies were found but not rated.Who makes this claim: Regulator reviews, media
sudden vision loss (optic nerve, NAION) and food in the stomach during anaesthesiaProbably harmfulEarly evidenceEurope's regulator lists optic nerve damage (sudden vision loss) as a very rare semaglutide side effect, up to 1 in 10,000. Anaesthesia risk: not reviewed.The detailsEMA 2025: optic nerve damage (NAION) is a very rare side effect of semaglutide, up to 1 in 10,000 users. Anaesthesia risk not yet reviewed.Who makes this claim: Regulator reviews, ophthalmologists, anaesthetistsEMA PRAC 2025 · 82 Official data
Side effectsGut effects are most common and cause most stops (4.5% versus 0.8% over 68 weeks). Gallbladder disease up 37%. Pancreatitis and thyroid cancer: probably little or no effect.The detailsGut effects are the most common and cause most stops (STEP 1: 4.5% vs 0.8% stopped over 68 weeks). Gallbladder disease up 37% (2 more gallstone cases per 1,000 in trials). Pancreatitis and thyroid cancer: probably little or no effect in trials (moderate certainty). Lean mass is about a quarter to two-fifths of the weight lost.Wilding 2021 · 82 StrongHe et al. 2022 · 97 StrongChiang et al. 2025 · 91 Strong (independence estimated*)Ko et al. 2026 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)Batsis et al. 2026 · 78 Good (independence estimated*)
Who should check with a doctor firstNot advised in pregnancy (stop two months before conceiving), breastfeeding, or with personal or family medullary thyroid cancer or MEN2. Check eating disorders; review insulin or sulfonylureas. Doctor's call.The detailsProduct information and guidelines advise against use in pregnancy (stop at least two months before trying to conceive) and breastfeeding, and with a personal or family history of medullary thyroid cancer or MEN2; check for eating disorders before starting; insulin or sulfonylurea doses may need review. All your doctor's call.WHO 2025 · 82 Strong (independence estimated*)Forner and Hocking 2025 · 42 WeakLook AHEAD Research Group 2016 · 70 Good
Benefits last while takenBenefits last only while it's taken: weight returns at about 0.8 kg a month after stopping. Long-term plans are your doctor's call.The detailsWe give no dosing. Benefits last only while it's taken: weight returns at about 0.8 kg a month after stopping. Plans for the long term are your doctor's call.West 2026 · 90 StrongWilding et al. 2022 · 63 Limited
Fake and compounded productsAustralia banned compounded versions in 2024, and tested imports held no medicine; the US has found counterfeit pens. Use only a licensed pharmacy with a prescription.The detailsIn Australia: compounded versions have been banned since 1 October 2024; TGA tests found imported 'GLP-1' products with none in them, and a mailed compounded vial with the wrong contents. In the US: the FDA has found counterfeit pens in the supply chain and allows compounding only when an approved medicine can't meet a patient's needs; it has over 1,700 harm reports for compounded versions. Everywhere: use only a licensed pharmacy with a prescription.TGA · 75 Official dataTGA · 75 Official dataMedical Republic 2024FDA · 82 Official data
Added ingredientsNot applicable to approved medicines; unregistered products may contain undeclared ingredients.The detailsNot applicable to the approved medicines; unregistered products may contain undeclared ingredients (TGA, Australia).TGA · 75 Official data
Diet and strength still matterWeight loss can hide a poor diet, low protein or little strength training. Heart benefits were shown in people with heart disease, not everyone.The detailsWeight loss on the medicine can hide a poor diet or low protein and little strength training; the 2025 US advisory stresses diet quality and resistance training. Heart benefits were shown in people with heart disease, not everyone.Mozaffarian 2025 · 63 LimitedLincoff et al. 2023 · 82 Strong
Eating disordersNot studied in people with eating disorders; guidance says check for disordered eating first.The detailsNot studied in people with eating disorders; guidance says check for disordered eating first.Forner and Hocking 2025 · 42 Weak
Lifestyle programmes insteadStructured lifestyle programs cut about 2–3 kg more than usual care at a year; these medicines give about 10–15% more weight loss. WHO suggests lifestyle support alongside.The detailsStructured lifestyle programs cut about 2–3 kg more than usual care at a year; these medicines give about 10–15% more weight loss than lifestyle change alone. WHO suggests offering intensive lifestyle support alongside.Nong 2026 · 93 StrongWHO 2025 · 82 Strong (independence estimated*)USPSTF 2018 · 85 Strong
CostAbout A$3,100–8,300 a year privately in Australia, or US$3,600–5,400 self-pay in the US (our estimates); most people need long-term use.The detailsIn Australia: about A$3,100–8,300 a year privately (our estimate, 2024 prices); a PBS subsidy was recommended in November 2025 only for semaglutide with established heart disease and BMI 35+, not yet listed. In the US: about US$3,600–5,400 a year self-pay (our estimate). Long-term use is usually needed to keep the effect.Forner and Hocking 2025 · 42 WeakDiabetes Australia 2026PBS · 90 Official dataFiercePharma 2025
PrivacyOnline telehealth prescribing services collect health data; we haven't assessed this.The detailsOnline telehealth prescribing services collect health data; not yet assessed.
The evidence, claim by claim (10)Members
What it does
Semaglutide cuts body weight, in adults with obesity or overweight with a weight-related conditionShown to helpStrong evidenceIn 15 trials of 8,651 adults with obesity, semaglutide cut about 11% more weight than placebo over 6–17 months; about 6% with type 2 diabetes.The detailsCochrane, 15 trials, 8,651 adults: 10.7% more weight lost than placebo over 6–17 months (high certainty). With type 2 diabetes, less: 6.2% (one trial).Who makes this claim: Makers' trial programs, obesity societies, WHO 2025 (conditional), telehealth servicesBracchiglione et al. 2025 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)Nong 2026 · 93 StrongWilding 2021 · 82 StrongDavies et al. 2021 · 79 GoodWHO 2025 · 82 Strong (independence estimated*)American College of Physicians 2026 · 82 Strong (independence estimated*)Obesity Canada 2025 · 73 Good
Tirzepatide cuts body weight, in adults with obesity or overweight with a weight-related conditionShown to helpModerate evidenceIn 8 trials, tirzepatide cut about 16% more body weight than placebo over 12–18 months; 10–12% more with type 2 diabetes. Trials were maker-run.The detailsCochrane, 8 trials: 16.0% more lost than placebo, 12–18 months (moderate; Australian draft guideline: high for some doses). Type 2 diabetes: 10–12%. Maker-run.Who makes this claim: Makers' trial programs, obesity societies, WHO 2025 (conditional), telehealth servicesFranco et al. 2025 · 91 Strong (independence estimated*)Nong 2026 · 93 StrongGarvey et al. 2023 · 71 GoodWHO 2025 · 82 Strong (independence estimated*)American College of Physicians 2026 · 82 Strong (independence estimated*)Australian Government/Deakin University 2024 · 79 Good (draft; independence estimated*)
Semaglutide cuts heart attacks, strokes and heart deaths, in adults with heart disease and overweight or obesityShown to helpModerate evidenceIn 17,604 adults with heart disease and overweight but no diabetes, heart events fell from 8.0% to 6.5% over 3.3 years with semaglutide.The details17,604 adults with heart disease, BMI 27+, no diabetes: semaglutide cut heart events 20% (6.5% vs 8.0%, 3.3 years). Tirzepatide matched an older GLP-1 medicine.Who makes this claim: Makers, cardiology societies, PBAC 2025 recommendation (Australia; heart disease and obesity only)Lincoff et al. 2023 · 82 StrongGalli et al. 2025 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)Badve et al. 2025 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)Bracchiglione et al. 2025 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)Nicholls et al. 2025 · 82 StrongPBS · 90 Official dataDiabetes Australia 2026
They cut deaths from any cause, in high-risk adultsShown to helpModerate evidenceAcross 21 trials of 99,599 high-risk adults, mostly with type 2 diabetes, deaths fell 12%: about 3 fewer per 1,000 a year (our estimate).The details21 trials, 99,599 high-risk adults, mostly type 2 diabetes, 2.4 years: deaths cut 12%, about 3 fewer per 1,000 yearly (our estimate). Tirzepatide alone: uncertain.Who makes this claim: Makers, cardiology societiesGalli et al. 2025 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)Badve et al. 2025 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)Bracchiglione et al. 2025 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)Franco et al. 2025 · 91 Strong (independence estimated*)
Semaglutide or tirzepatide delays type 2 diabetes, in adults with obesity and prediabetesShown to helpModerate evidenceIn 1,032 adults with prediabetes over 3.4 years, type 2 diabetes developed in 1.3% on tirzepatide versus 13.3% on placebo.The detailsTirzepatide, 1,032 adults, 3.4 years: diabetes 1.3% vs 13.3% (~35 fewer per 1,000 yearly, our estimate). Semaglutide, 1 year: normal glucose 81% vs 14%.Who makes this claim: Makers, ADA 2026Jastreboff et al. 2025 · 79 GoodMcGowan et al. 2024 · 71 GoodADA 2026 · 74 Good (independence estimated*)
What it doesn't clearly do
They improve quality of lifeShown not to helpModerate evidenceDespite the weight loss, trials found little or no meaningful difference in quality of life.The detailsCochrane and Nong 2026: little to no meaningful difference in quality of life (moderate certainty) despite weight loss.Who makes this claim: MakersBracchiglione et al. 2025 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)Nong 2026 · 93 Strong
Not reviewed yet
They help sleep apnoea, knee osteoarthritis pain, kidney disease, fatty liver and heart failure symptomsUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet reviewed. Kidney outcomes in type 2 diabetes appear in one rated heart-and-kidney review.Who makes this claim: Makers' trial programsBadve et al. 2025 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)
They curb cravings, 'food noise', alcohol and addictionUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet reviewed.Who makes this claim: Users, media
They slow dementiaUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet reviewed.Who makes this claim: Media
Faster facial ageing from rapid weight lossUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet reviewed.Who makes this claim: Media, cosmetic clinics
Fact-checked 1 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
+ Add a note
5Keep it offOptional1 book1 product5 studies⌄
After losing weight, keep regular contact with a program or health professional and weigh yourself often. Expect some regain; the benefit of having lost weight can last 5 years or more.
What it found: In 8 trials of 1,408 adults who had already lost weight, ongoing behavioural support meant about 1.6 kg less weight regained than going without. The US Preventive Services Task Force recommends offering such programs to adults with obesity.
What it means for you: After losing weight, staying in touch with a program or health professional helps you keep more of it off.
The figures and the limit
About 1.6 kg less regain (8 studies).
The limit: Results varied widely between trials; the effect is an average.
▸ See 4 more studies▾ 4 more studies, best firstMembers
Book
Also rated for this step
The Every Other Day Diet
Krista Varady, 2013
90Top rated
★ 3.86 on Goodreads (744) · about 6 hours
6 of 8 readers who said either way said it helped
From 30 sampled Goodreads reviews: 6 helped, 2 didn't, 3 already knew most of it; the rest didn't say.
Claim: Researcher or educatorAuthor's own research
“Months on plan, 159 to 122 lb; stopped snacking, learned true hunger from boredom”
▸ Why it's rated 90▾ Why it's rated 90
Scorecard
Reader outcomes 40%
94
Content quality 20%
100
Author credibility 20%
100
Goal relevance 10%
75
Rating and format 10%
52
What readers said helped (paraphrased)
Months on plan, 159 to 122 lb; stopped snacking, learned true hunger from boredom
Started the day it arrived; three weeks in, 8 lb lighter with own tweaks
On the plan past two weeks; hunger on 500-calorie days has subsided
Six weeks on plan, 18 lb lost; energy on fast days, no binging on feast days
Experienced faster four weeks into 4:3 toward alternate days; no deprivation, about 15 lb lost
Sceptic on the plan for a while; weight coming off fairly effortlessly
Why it didn't help some
Arabic; tried one week; hunger, then 4,000-calorie feast days; abandoned, back to calorie counting
Followed plan but lost little; still eating processed high-carb food; not good for them
Already knew most of it
Already eats keto, one meal a day, alternate-day fasting; basic for them
Was already doing the diet with friends' success before reading; book validating
Does 18-hour daily fasts on own; prefers that to this diet
Rated for
Decide on intermittent fasting (optional) 93
From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 1 November 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 744 ratings, about 94% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. 6 readers say the effect has lasted. Audiobook not confirmed.
Note: If you take insulin or a sulfonylurea (or another medicine that can cause low blood sugar), don't start the 500-600 calorie days without your doctor's advice. Not for anyone with an eating-disorder history.
Why it isn't the top pick: it covers only part of this step.
Product
Meal-replacement shakes and very-low-energy diets (including diabetes-remission programs)
What it is: Shakes or soups (about 800 calories a day) replace all meals for 8–20 weeks, then normal food is brought back step by step; or 1–2 shakes replace meals daily.
Do meal-replacement shakes help you lose weight?
Shown to helpModerate evidence
Yes, with support. In 278 GP patients with obesity, 8 weeks of 810-calorie shakes as their only food, then normal food again, led to 7.2 kg more weight lost at 1 year than usual care.
+Type 2 diabetes under 6 years: remission in 46% versus 4% at 1 yearModerate evidence
+1–2 shakes daily: about 1.4 kg more lost at 1 year than other dietsModerate evidence
○Most regain, but still 3.3 kg lighter than usual care at 3 yearsModerate evidence
○Weight lost fast wasn't regained faster than weight lost slowlyModerate evidence
–Versus 1,200–1,500 calories: about 11 more gallstone hospital stays per 1,000 yearly (our estimate)Early evidence
–Insulin or sulfonylureas: low blood sugar unless doses change; your doctor's callEarly evidence
How to do it: About 800–850 calories a day from shakes as the only food for 8–20 weeks, then food brought back over 2–8 weeks, with regular support.
Even in remission, keep having regular diabetes checks; blood sugar often rises again.
Sticking with it: Shakes are used for 8–20 weeks by design; in England's national program, 55% completed the year, and most people regain once support ends.
Cost: About US$260–750 for 12 weeks of 3 shakes a day, partly offset by food not bought (our estimate).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Pregnant, breastfeeding, under 18 or eating-disorder history: avoid, or specialist care only. Diabetes or blood-pressure medicines, kidney or heart disease: your doctor's call.
Risks and who should be careful (18)
starting a very-low-energy diet on insulin or sulfonylureas (or blood-pressure tablets) causes low blood sugar or low blood pressure unless medicines changeProbably harmfulEarly evidenceAustralian guidance halves insulin or sulfonylurea doses at the start; the remission trial stopped diabetes and blood pressure tablets. Your doctor's call.The detailsAustralian obesity algorithm halves insulin or sulfonylurea doses at the start; DiRECT stopped diabetes and blood-pressure tablets. 5:2 fasting trial: low blood sugar doubled (indirect).Who makes this claim: Australian Obesity Management Algorithm, Diabetes Australia, program makersADS, ANZOS and ADEA 2024 · 49 WeakLean et al. 2018 · 73 GoodCorley et al. 2018 · 60 Limited (independence estimated*)Diabetes Australia 2021 · 64 Limited (independence estimated*)Brown et al. 2020 · 63 Limited
the weight comes back and remission is lost once the program endsShown not to helpModerate evidenceGP trial: regained 8.9 versus 1.2 kg by 3 years, yet still 3.3 kg lighter. Diabetes remission: 13% versus 5% at 5 years.The detailsDROPLET: regained 8.9 vs 1.2 kg; still 3.3 kg lighter than usual care at 3 years. DiRECT remission: 46%, 36%, 13% vs 5% (5 years).Who makes this claim: Critics; Diabetes Australia ('two thirds cannot sustain it at two years')Astbury et al. 2021 · 67 GoodLean et al. 2019 · 70 GoodLean et al. 2024 · 54 LimitedDiabetes Australia 2021 · 64 Limited (independence estimated*)Hartmann-Boyce et al. 2023 · 85 Strong
very-low-energy diets cause gallstones and gallbladder diseaseProbably harmfulEarly evidence6,640 Swedish adults: on 500 rather than 1,200–1,500 calories a day, about 11 more per 1,000 a year needed gallstone hospital care (our estimate).The detailsSwedish matched cohort, 6,640 adults: 500 kcal vs 1,200–1,500 kcal diets linked with more gallstones needing hospital care, 152 vs 44 per 10,000 person-years.Who makes this claim: VLED product leaflets, Australian Obesity Management AlgorithmJohansson et al. 2014 · 62 LimitedADS, ANZOS and ADEA 2024 · 49 WeakLean et al. 2018 · 73 GoodPurcell et al. 2014 · 71 Good (independence estimated*)VLED maker's page
very-low-energy diets trigger or worsen eating disorders or binge eatingNot yet knownEarly evidenceIn 49 weight-program trials in adults, eating-disorder scores fell on average; 0–6.5% had new symptoms. In 56 at-risk adults with diabetes on shakes: no worsening.The detailsAdults: 49 weight-management trials, eating-disorder scores fell on average; 0–6.5% had new symptoms. 56 at-risk adults with diabetes on shakes: no worsening.Who makes this claim: Eating-disorder clinicians; NICE (assess first)Jebeile et al. 2024 · 59 LimitedNICE NG246 · 78 GoodJebeile 2023 · 82 StrongTsompanaki et al. 2025 · 63 Limited
weight lost fast is regained faster than weight lost slowlyShown not to helpModerate evidenceIn 200 Melbourne adults, a 12-week shake diet and 36 weeks of gradual loss both regained 76.3% of lost weight by about 3 years.The detailsMelbourne trial, 200 adults: 12-week VLED vs 36-week gradual loss; both regained 76.3% by about 3 years.Who makes this claim: Older guidelines advising gradual lossPurcell et al. 2014 · 71 Good (independence estimated*)
fast weight loss costs muscle and bone, in older adultsProbably harmfulEarly evidenceSydney trial, 101 women aged 45–65: severe restriction lost more hip bone, and 1.2 kg more lean mass, in line with extra weight lost.The detailsSydney trial, 101 women aged 45–65: severe restriction lost 1.2 kg more lean mass (proportionate) and more hip bone (−0.017 g/cm²).Who makes this claim: Obesity researchers, bone-health cliniciansSeimon et al. 2019 · 63 Limited
shakes are ultra-processed foodsUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot reviewed yet.Who makes this claim: Ultra-processed food critics
side effects such as constipation, tiredness, dizziness, headache and feeling coldLeans toward harm; not yet knownAnecdotalMakers list tiredness, light-headedness, headache and constipation, not compared in trials. GP trial: moderate or worse side effects 11% versus 12% with usual care.The detailsMaker lists fatigue, light-headedness, headache and constipation; not compared in trials. DROPLET: moderate or worse adverse events 11% vs 12% on usual care.Who makes this claim: Programme makersAstbury et al. 2018 · 70 GoodVLED maker's page
Side effects and gallstonesModerate or worse side effects: 11% versus 12% on usual care. Gallstone hospital stays: about 3 times those on 1,200–1,500 calories, about 11 more per 1,000 yearly (our estimate).The detailsModerate or worse adverse events were about the same as usual care (11% vs 12%, DROPLET). In DiRECT, 2 serious events in one person (biliary colic, abdominal pain) were possibly related; DiRECT-Aus reported 2 related hospitalisations in 155. Gallstones needing hospital care were about 3 times as common on a 500 kcal diet: 152 vs 44 per 10,000 person-years, about 11 more per 1,000 a year (our estimate).Astbury et al. 2018 · 70 GoodLean et al. 2018 · 73 GoodHocking et al. 2024 · 51 LimitedJohansson et al. 2014 · 62 Limited
Who should check firstNot in pregnancy or breastfeeding. Children, teens, over-65s: medical supervision. Diabetes, blood-pressure or warfarin medicines, kidney or heart disease, recent heart attack or stroke, porphyria, eating disorders: your doctor's call.The detailsInsulin or sulfonylureas: the Australian Obesity Management Algorithm halves doses at the start and adjusts by frequent glucose checks; SGLT2 inhibitors: ketone checks or stopping, for ketoacidosis risk; blood-pressure tablets were stopped in DiRECT. These are your doctor's call. Pregnancy and lactation: contraindicated (FSANZ labels, the algorithm). Children, adolescents and older people: only under medical supervision (FSANZ); over 65 with caution. Recent heart attack or stroke, porphyria, kidney disease (closer supervision) and warfarin (INR checks) are listed. Eating disorders: NICE says to assess and counsel first. Diabetes Australia: intensive dietary change can be dangerous with some medicines, kidney or heart disease. The ADA (US) cites electrolyte problems, severe fatigue and heart-rhythm problems as risks, and advises screening for past or current disordered eating.ADS, ANZOS and ADEA 2024 · 49 WeakFSANZ · Official dataNICE NG246 · 78 GoodDiabetes Australia 2021 · 64 Limited (independence estimated*)Lean et al. 2018 · 73 GoodADA 2026 · 74 Good (independence estimated*)
Shakes-only time limitsShakes as the only food: up to 12 weeks (Australian food regulator, NICE), or 3–5 months for diabetes remission (RACGP), then structured food reintroduction. Not a long-term strategy.The detailsShakes as the only food: up to 12 weeks (FSANZ, NICE), or 3–5 months for diabetes remission under RACGP's Grade A advice, then structured food reintroduction. NICE: not a long-term strategy. Losing weight fast was not regained faster than slowly (76.3% regained either way). In the US, the ADA Standards of Care advise 800–1,000 kcal plans only for carefully selected people, prescribed by trained practitioners with close monitoring, generally for up to 3 months, with long-term maintenance support (grade B).FSANZ · Official dataNICE NG246 · 78 GoodRACGP 2024 · 65 GoodPurcell et al. 2014 · 71 Good (independence estimated*)ADA 2026 · 74 Good (independence estimated*)
How products are regulatedIn Australia and New Zealand, very-low-energy diet products are regulated special medical foods with set label warnings; they aren't medicines and the TGA doesn't check them.The detailsIn Australia and New Zealand: very-low-energy diet products are regulated foods for special medical purposes (FSANZ Standard 2.9.5), with set label warnings; they are not medicines and aren't checked by the TGA.FSANZ · Official data
Sweeteners and sugarFlavoured shakes usually contain sweeteners or added sugars; we haven't reviewed evidence on this.The detailsFlavoured shakes usually contain sweeteners or added sugars; we haven't reviewed evidence on this.
Remission isn't a cureRemission isn't a cure: blood sugar often rises again, so keep having regular diabetes checks (Diabetes Australia).The detailsRemission is 'not a cure': blood sugar often rises again, and regular diabetes checks should continue (Diabetes Australia).Diabetes Australia 2021 · 64 Limited (independence estimated*)
Eating disorders and regainEating-disorder scores fell in weight-program trials, though 0–6.5% developed new symptoms in the 4 that checked. Most regain once support stops: 8.9 versus 1.2 kg (usual care) by 3 years.The detailsEating-disorder scores fell on average in adult and adolescent weight-management trials (0–6.5% developed new symptoms) and did not worsen in 56 at-risk adults with diabetes on shakes. Most people regain once support stops (8.9 kg vs 1.2 kg from 6 months to 3 years).Jebeile et al. 2024 · 59 LimitedAstbury et al. 2021 · 67 GoodJebeile 2023 · 82 StrongTsompanaki et al. 2025 · 63 Limited
Food-based diets insteadA food-based low-energy diet works too, but less: in type 2 diabetes, 400–500-calorie diets lost 6.6 kg more than 1,000–1,500-calorie diets. Low-carb was no better than higher-carb.The detailsA food-based low-energy diet works too, but less: 400–500 kcal formula diets lost 6.6 kg more than 1,000–1,500 kcal diets (low certainty). Low-carb food diets were no better than higher-carb ones for weight (high certainty).Churuangsuk et al. 2022 · 82 Strong
CostAbout A$400–1,150 (US$260–750) for 12 weeks of full replacement, partly offset by food not bought (our estimate).The detailsAbout A$400–1,150 for 12 weeks of full replacement at Australian pharmacy prices, partly offset by food not bought (our estimate). Shown as information only.
PrivacyCommercial programs and apps may collect health data; we haven't reviewed this.The detailsCommercial programs and apps may collect health data; we haven't reviewed this.
The evidence, claim by claim (6)Members
What it does
Total diet replacement or a very-low-energy diet (about 800 kcal a day, mostly shakes) cuts weight more than usual diet advice, in adults with obesityShown to helpModerate evidenceGP trial, 1 year: 45% versus 15% (usual care) lost a tenth of their weight. In diabetes, 400–500 calories beat 1,000–1,500 by 6.6 kg.The detailsDROPLET, 278 adults: −7.2 kg (−9.4 to −4.9) vs usual care at 1 year. 400–500 kcal diets: 6.6 kg more than 1,000–1,500 kcal (low certainty).Who makes this claim: Michael Mosley (800-calorie diet books), meal-replacement makers, NICE, Australian Obesity Management AlgorithmAstbury et al. 2018 · 70 GoodChuruangsuk et al. 2022 · 82 StrongNICE NG246 · 78 GoodADS, ANZOS and ADEA 2024 · 49 WeakAstbury et al. 2021 · 67 GoodADA 2026 · 74 Good (independence estimated*)
A very-low-energy diet with stepped food reintroduction (DiRECT style) puts type 2 diabetes into remission, in adults with overweight and diabetes under 6 yearsShown to helpModerate evidenceIn 298 UK adults with diabetes under 6 years, not on insulin: remission 46% versus 4% at 1 year, 36% versus 3% at 2 years.The detailsDiRECT, 298 UK adults not on insulin: remission 46% vs 4% at 1 year (420 more per 1,000, our estimate); 36% vs 3% at 2.Who makes this claim: Roy Taylor, Michael Mosley, Diabetes UK, RACGP (Grade A), Diabetes AustraliaLean et al. 2018 · 73 GoodLean et al. 2019 · 70 GoodChuruangsuk et al. 2022 · 82 StrongRACGP 2024 · 65 GoodDiabetes Australia 2021 · 64 Limited (independence estimated*)Sherifali et al. 2025 · 78 GoodHocking et al. 2024 · 51 LimitedADA 2026 · 74 Good (independence estimated*)Valabhji et al. 2024 · 62 Limited
Partial meal replacement (1–2 shakes a day) helps lose weight and keep it off, in adults with overweightShown to helpModerate evidence23 trials, 7,884 adults with overweight: 1–2 daily shakes lost 1.4 kg more at a year than other diets; about 6 kg with extra support.The details23 trials, 7,884 adults: −1.44 kg (−2.48 to −0.39) more at 1 year than other diets (small); −6.13 kg with enhanced support.Who makes this claim: Meal-replacement and shake makers, pharmacy weight-loss programsAstbury et al. 2019 · 79 GoodChuruangsuk et al. 2022 · 82 StrongADS, ANZOS and ADEA 2024 · 49 Weak
Complete-nutrition shakes are nutritionally complete and healthy as everyday foodLeans toward helping; not yet knownAnecdotalMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesOnly a 4-week, company-paid study of 20 adults on shakes alone, with no comparison group, found vitamin and mineral levels held up.The detailsOnly a company-paid 4-week pilot: 20 adults on shakes alone kept micronutrient levels; no control group. The maker says it isn't your only food.Who makes this claim: Shake makersWilcox et al. 2022 · 31 WeakShake maker's page on its own 4-week pilot
Very-low-energy diets improve blood pressure, liver fat and heart risk factorsProbably helpsEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesAt 3 years the GP trial's bottom blood pressure number was 3.3 points lower; long-term blood sugar and cholesterol: no clear difference.The detailsDROPLET, 3 years: diastolic −3.3 mmHg vs usual care; no HbA1c, LDL or heart-risk difference. 94 weight-program trials (indirect): HbA1c 0.38% lower 5 years on.Who makes this claim: Programme makers, diabetes researchersAstbury et al. 2021 · 67 GoodHartmann-Boyce et al. 2023 · 85 Strong
Very-low-energy diets cut heart attacks or deathsLeans toward helping; not yet knownMore data neededNo shake-diet trial has measured them. In 5,145 adults with diabetes on a lifestyle program with shakes, heart events: no clear difference over 9.6 years.The detailsNo VLED trial has measured them. Look AHEAD, 5,145 adults with diabetes (partial shakes): heart events HR 0.95 (0.83–1.09), range includes no effect.Who makes this claim: Remission advocatesLean et al. 2024 · 54 LimitedLook AHEAD Research Group 2013 · 86 Strong
Fact-checked 1 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
+ Add a note
6What helps you stick with itOptional1 protocol9 studies2 websites⌄
Join a structured behavioural weight program rather than going it alone, ideally one lasting about a year, tailored to you, with flexible attendance. Eating slowly may cut how much you eat at a meal; it's not shown to aid weight loss.
What it found: In 67 trials of 22,065 adults, behavioural weight programs gave about 2.4 kg more weight loss than control groups at 12 to 18 months. In people with prediabetes, they cut new cases of type 2 diabetes by about a third.
What it means for you: A structured program beats going it alone, even if the extra weight lost is modest.
The figures and the limit
−2.39 kg (−2.86 to −1.93) at 12–18 months; in people with prediabetes, diabetes RR 0.67 (0.51–0.89).
The limit: Average effects are modest and varied a lot; features couldn't be separated.
▸ See 8 more studies▾ 8 more studies, best firstMembers
Best for: Australia's general-practice guide to lifestyle risk factors, including referral to support.
Caution: Written for GPs.
▸ See 1 more website▾ 1 more websiteMembers
Protocol
Intuitive and mindful eating (non-diet approaches)
What it is: No calorie counting or forbidden foods: eat when hungry, stop when full, and pay attention while eating; weight loss isn't the goal.
Does eating by hunger and fullness improve health and wellbeing?
Mixed resultsEarly evidence
Unclear. In small trials in adults, body satisfaction improved more than on weight-loss programs in one review (8 trials), but another (10 studies) found no clear psychological difference. Weight barely changed.
○Weight: no worthwhile change, about 0.35 kg versus no programmeEarly evidence
○Body image: better in one review, no clear difference in anotherEarly evidence
+Mindfulness programmes cut binge eating versus no treatment, not versus therapyEarly evidence
○Diet quality: no clear difference in 8 of 12 trial reportsMore data needed
○Blood pressure and cholesterol: no clear difference from weight-loss programmesMore data needed
–Forgoes weight loss: weight programmes cut about 2.4 kg versus no programme
Measured blood pressure and cholesterol, not heart attacks or strokes
How to do it: Programmes ran 6 weeks to 6 months, with little follow-up beyond 2 years.
Eating slowly cut how much people ate at a meal in 22 lab studies, though not weight.
Sticking with it: No data at a year; in one trial of 78 women, 92% stayed to 6 months versus 59% on a diet.
Cost: Free to learn from books and public resources; courses and counselling cost extra (no price survey found).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Current or past eating disorder, or a weight-related condition such as type 2 diabetes: talk to your doctor first.
Risks and who should be careful (7)
forgoing weight loss that would help, in people with obesity-related diseaseUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. Behavioural weight programs cut about 2.4 kg versus usual care at 12–18 months.The detailsNot tested directly. Behavioural weight programs cut 2.4 kg at 12-18 months versus control; weight-neutral approaches don't aim for this.Who makes this claim: Obesity guidelinesLeBlanc 2018 · 94 StrongDraft Clinical Practice Guidelines for the Management of Overweight and Obesity in Australia, full draft guideline · Official data
relying on a self-help approach instead of professional care, in people with an eating disorderUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. For binge eating disorder, UK, US and Australian guidelines put cognitive behavioural therapy first.The detailsNot studied directly. UK, US and Australia-NZ guidelines put CBT-based therapy first for binge eating disorder; UK guidance starts with guided self-help.Who makes this claim: Eating-disorder guidelinesNICE 2017 · 79 Good (independence estimated*)Liu et al. 2025 · 75 GoodAmerican Psychiatric Association 2023 · 74 Good (read via a journal summary; independence estimated*)Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists 2014 · 74 Good (independence estimated*)
Programme lengthTrial programs ran 6 weeks to 6 months, with little follow-up beyond 2 years.The detailsTrial programs ran 6 weeks to 6 months; little follow-up beyond 2 years.Bacon et al. 2005 · 55 Limited (independence estimated*)Babbott et al. 2023 · 53 Limited (independence estimated*)Khasteganan et al. 2019 · 74 Good
Heart healthWeight-neutral programs didn't improve heart risk factors more than weight-loss programs.The detailsWeight-neutral programs didn't improve heart risk factors more than weight-loss programs.Khasteganan et al. 2019 · 74 GoodClarke et al. 2024 · 72 Good (independence estimated*)
Dieting and eating disordersStructured weight programs lowered eating-disorder scores on average (49 trials); 0–6.5% developed new symptoms in 4 studies.The detailsFear that dieting causes eating disorders: structured weight programs cut eating-disorder scores on average (49 trials); 0-6.5% developed new symptoms in 4 studies.Jebeile 2023 · 82 Strong
CostWe found no price survey of courses or counselling.The detailsNo price survey of courses or counselling found.
The evidence, claim by claim (6)Members
What it does
Intuitive or mindful eating cuts binge eating and emotional eating, in adults with or without binge eating disorderProbably helpsEarly evidenceIn 54 studies, mindfulness programs cut binge eating versus no treatment, but not versus other therapies; another review found no clear effect.The detailsNo high-quality evidence. 54 studies: mindfulness programs cut binge eating versus no treatment (g 0.65), not versus other therapies; another review: not significant.Who makes this claim: Mindful-eating programs; DBT- and ACT-based coursesLiu et al. 2025 · 75 GoodKao et al. 2025 · 73 GoodMercado 2021 · 66 Good (independence estimated*)NICE 2017 · 79 Good (independence estimated*)
What it doesn't clearly do
Intuitive or mindful eating cuts weight compared with no program or a diet, in adultsNot yet knownEarly evidenceIn 10 trials, about 0.35 kg less than no program, too small to matter; versus diets over 1–2 years, no clear difference.The details10 trials: 0.35 kg less than no program, no worthwhile effect. Versus diets: 0.28 kg (-2.00 to 1.44), range includes no effect. No high-quality evidence.Who makes this claim: Intuitive-eating books and counsellors; mindful-eating coursesFuentes Artiles et al. 2019 · 72 Good (independence estimated*)Khasteganan et al. 2019 · 74 GoodClarke et al. 2024 · 72 Good (independence estimated*)Kao 2023 · 70 Good (independence estimated*)Mercado 2021 · 66 Good (independence estimated*)LeBlanc 2018 · 94 StrongDraft Clinical Practice Guidelines for the Management of Overweight and Obesity in Australia, full draft guideline · Official data
Non-diet approaches improve wellbeing, body image and self-esteem, in adultsMixed resultsEarly evidenceOne review of 8 small trials found better body satisfaction than weight-loss programs; another of 10 studies found no clear psychological difference.The detailsSmall trials: body satisfaction improved versus weight-loss programs in one review (8 trials); psychological outcomes didn't differ in another (10 studies). No high-quality evidence.Who makes this claim: Non-diet dietitians; Health at Every Size advocatesKhasteganan et al. 2019 · 74 GoodClarke et al. 2024 · 72 Good (independence estimated*)Babbott et al. 2023 · 53 Limited (independence estimated*)Bacon et al. 2005 · 55 Limited (independence estimated*)
Non-diet approaches improve blood pressure and cholesterol without weight lossNot yet knownMore data neededMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesTwo reviews found no clear difference from weight-loss programs in blood pressure, cholesterol or triglycerides; trials were small with many dropouts.The detailsNo high-quality evidence. Two reviews: blood pressure, cholesterol and triglycerides not clearly different from weight-loss programs; small trials, high dropout.Who makes this claim: Health at Every Size advocatesKhasteganan et al. 2019 · 74 GoodClarke et al. 2024 · 72 Good (independence estimated*)Bacon et al. 2005 · 55 Limited (independence estimated*)
Intuitive eating protects against disordered eating, compared with dietingMixed resultsEarly evidenceIn 97 mostly snapshot studies, intuitive eaters had less disordered eating; in a 5-year study of young adults, the link vanished in women.The detailsLinked with less disordered eating in 97 mostly cross-sectional studies; in a 5-year cohort the link vanished in women. No high-quality evidence.Who makes this claim: Intuitive-eating counsellors; eating-disorder preventionLinardon et al. 2021 · 60 Limited (independence estimated*)Christoph et al. 2021 · 66 Good (independence estimated*)Jebeile 2023 · 82 Strong
Intuitive eating improves diet quality, in adultsNot yet knownMore data neededIn randomised trials, 8 of 12 reports found no clear difference in diet quality; other studies found positive or neutral effects.The detailsRandomised trials: 8 of 12 reports found no clear diet-quality difference (very low certainty); mixed-design studies reported positive or neutral effects.Who makes this claim: Non-diet dietitiansGrider et al. 2021 · 63 Limited (independence estimated*)Hensley-Hackett et al. 2022 · 66 Good (independence estimated*)
Fact-checked 4 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
+ Add a note
7. Cooking it every week⌄6 steps · 48 items
1Use the sample week5 books4 studies1 website⌄
Cook most of your meals at home from a weekly plan, and eat with others when you can (studies of this were in people 65 and over). This is practical advice, not a health claim.
What it found: A review of 15 studies, only 4 of them randomised, found cooking skills and cooking more often were linked with better self-reported diets (especially more fruit and vegetables) and more cooking confidence. It found no reliable link with weight or nutritional status.
What it means for you: Cooking at home from a plan is a practical way to eat better, not a proven health treatment.
The figures and the limit
15 studies, 4 of them randomised.
The limit: Low or very low certainty, self-reported diets, and no reliable link with nutritional status.
▸ See 3 more studies▾ 3 more studies, best firstMembers
Best book
Mediterranean Diet Cookbook for Beginners
Also rated for this step
The Mediterranean Diet Cookbook for Beginners
Elena Paravantes, 2020
83Top rated
★ 4.25 on Goodreads (311) · about 10 hours
6 of 8 readers who said either way said it helped
From 30 sampled Goodreads reviews: 6 helped, 2 didn't, 1 already knew most of it; the rest didn't say.
Claim: Practising professionalMethod from clinical or teaching practice
“The cookbook they keep coming back to”
▸ Why it's rated 83▾ Why it's rated 83
Scorecard
Reader outcomes 40%
90
Content quality 20%
82
Author credibility 20%
90
Goal relevance 10%
75
Rating and format 10%
51
What readers said helped (paraphrased)
The cookbook they keep coming back to
On cardiologist-advised diet for years; everything made worked; makes following it easy
Go-to book when starting the diet; still makes many recipes
Following the diet for health with this and one other cookbook; cooked several dishes
Calls it very impactful; already cooked six recipes, all good
Cooked about fifteen recipes in a month; children asked for seconds
Why it didn't help some
They need fewer carbs and more protein; doing better on keto; won't suit family
Many recipes use tomatoes and gluten, which don't suit them
Already knew most of it
Used author's website for years for family meals; book met expectations
Rated for
Know what the evidence shows 83Plan and shop once a week 83
From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 1 November 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 311 ratings, about 90% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. 3 readers say the effect has lasted. Audiobook not confirmed.
Best for: Consumer guidance on cooking healthier meals at home.
Caution: Reference page, not rated by us.
+ Add a note
2Plan and shop once a week4 books1 product7 studies1 website⌄
Plan your meals for the week and shop from a list; there are no trials, so this is a practical tip. Tip: keep fruit and vegetables in view and discretionary food out of sight.
What it found: In a one-off survey of 40,554 French adults, people who planned meals were slightly more likely to eat in line with guidelines and about 20% less likely to have obesity. This can't show that planning caused the difference.
What it means for you: Planning your week's meals is a sensible tip; no trial has tested whether it improves your diet.
The figures and the limit
Guideline adherence OR 1.13 (95% CI 1.07 to 1.20); obesity OR 0.79 (women) and 0.81 (men).
The limit: Observational only; no trial of meal planning was found.
▸ See 6 more studies▾ 6 more studies, best firstMembers
Best book
Also rated for this step
The Healthy Meal Prep Cookbook
Toby Amidor, 2017
84Top rated
★ 3.78 on Goodreads (644) · about 9 hours
4 of 5 readers who said either way said it helped
From 30 sampled Goodreads reviews: 4 helped, 1 didn't, 3 already knew most of it; the rest didn't say.
Claim: Practising professionalMethod from clinical or teaching practice
“First book for their learn-to-cook resolution; varied their lunches; still a staple”
▸ Why it's rated 84▾ Why it's rated 84
Scorecard
Reader outcomes 40%
95
Content quality 20%
82
Author credibility 20%
90
Goal relevance 10%
75
Rating and format 10%
43
What readers said helped (paraphrased)
First book for their learn-to-cook resolution; varied their lunches; still a staple
Uses it more than their 15 other cookbooks, consistently
Uses it frequently for weekly meal planning
Newcomer did a full week of meal prep with it; few recipes tried yet
Why it didn't help some
Too restrictive for their tastes; not for them
Already knew most of it
Information very basic to them; recipes uninspiring
Experienced meal-prepper; too basic
Not much new; storage times useful
Rated for
Batch-cook and freeze 84
From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 1 November 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 644 ratings, about 95% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. 3 readers say the effect has lasted. Audiobook not confirmed.
Best for: Consumer guidance on planning meals for the week.
Caution: Reference page, not rated by us; advice, not a graded recommendation.
Product
Meal kits (recipe boxes and ready-meal delivery)
What it is: Weekly delivered boxes of recipes with measured ingredients to cook, or ready-made meals.
Do meal kits help you eat healthier dinners?
Not yet knownMore data needed
Unknown. No trial has compared kits with usual eating. Kit recipes give 2–3 serves of vegetables, but most are high in salt; in one 2-week US pilot, self-rated diets improved no more than with ready meals.
○Healthier dinners: no trial has compared kits with usual eatingMore data needed
+Diet-programme meals, not recipe kits: at least 4.9% more weight lost over a yearEarly evidence
+Parents said kits eased their mental load and got the family cookingAnecdotal
+About 25% lower climate footprint per meal in one US model (our estimate)Early evidence
–Most UK kit meals were high in salt (64%) and saturated fat (62%)Early evidence
–Cost more than the same supermarket ingredients: over A$30 a week in AustraliaEarly evidence
How to do it: No trial tested recipe kits for health. The weight trials used diet-program ready meals with counselling, for 12 weeks to 12 months.
Choose lower-salt recipes and check the sodium per serve; 'healthy' tags don't guarantee low salt.
Planning meals and cooking from a supermarket shop costs less; cooking courses can build confidence.
Sticking with it: No data on how many keep subscribing after a year.
Cost: We found no US study comparing kit and supermarket prices; in Australia and New Zealand, the supermarket was cheaper.
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Tight budgets. On a salt-restricted diet for kidney or heart disease, check the sodium per serve: your doctor's call.
Risks and who should be careful (6)
kit recipes exceed guideline limits for salt, saturated fat and energy, for regular usersProbably harmfulEarly evidenceOne Australian service's recipes: median 839 mg sodium and 678 calories (2,840 kJ) a serve; 64% of UK kit meals were high in salt.The detailsNo high-quality evidence. Recipe analyses (Australia, UK): median 839 mg sodium and 678 kcal a serve; 64% of UK meals high in salt.Who makes this claim: Public-health nutritionistsGibson and Partridge 2019 · 53 LimitedMoores et al. 2021 · 54 Limited (independence estimated*)Nixon and Ensaff 2024 · 54 Limited (independence estimated*)McKay 2023 · 53 LimitedWHO 2012 · 81 Strong
kits cost more than the same ingredients from a supermarketProbably harmfulEarly evidenceAn Australian study (2023): weekly boxes cost over A$30 more than the same supermarket ingredients; a New Zealand test also found the supermarket cheaper.The detailsAustralian study (2023): weekly boxes cost over A$30 more than the same supermarket ingredients; supermarket also cheaper in a New Zealand test.Who makes this claim: Consumer organisations; public-health researchersMcKay 2023 · 53 LimitedConsumer NZ 2023 · 56 Limited (consumer group)
Salt-restricted dietsOn a salt-restricted diet for kidney or heart disease, check the sodium per serve: your doctor's call.The detailsOn a salt-restricted diet (kidney or heart disease): check sodium per serve; your doctor's call.Nixon and Ensaff 2024 · 54 Limited (independence estimated*)
Food safety in deliveryWe found no studies on the food safety of chilled home delivery.The detailsFood safety of chilled home delivery: none found.
'Healthy' tags and saltMeals tagged as healthy did better, but almost half (46.5%) of tagged UK kit meals were still high in salt.The details'Healthy' tags helped, but 46.5% of tagged UK meals were still high in salt.Nixon and Ensaff 2024 · 54 Limited (independence estimated*)
CostWeekly boxes cost over A$30 more than the same supermarket ingredients (Australia, 2023); in New Zealand the supermarket was also cheaper.The detailsWeekly boxes cost over A$30 more than the same supermarket ingredients (Australia, 2023).McKay 2023 · 53 LimitedConsumer NZ 2023 · 56 Limited (consumer group)
The evidence, claim by claim (6)Members
What it does
Calorie-controlled prepared meals from a weight program, with counselling, help weight loss, in adults with overweightProbably helpsEarly evidenceAdults with overweight given one program's meals lost at least 4.9% more than with education or counselling (12 months); 12-week food-company trial: 8.6% versus 6.0%.The detailsReview (3 trials, one program): at least 4.9% more lost at 12 months than education or counselling, small. Food-company-funded 12-week trial: 8.6% vs 6.0%.Who makes this claim: Diet-company meal programsGudzune et al. 2015 · 81 Strong (independence estimated*)Rock et al. 2016 · 59 Limited
Meal kits build cooking skills, confidence and home-cooking frequencyLeans toward helping; not yet knownAnecdotalIn interviews with 16 Australian parents, kits eased mental load and drew the family into cooking; no trial has tested kits on cooking skills.The detailsInterviews with 16 parents: less mental load, more family help with cooking. No trial of kits on cooking skills; cooking classes improved confidence (low certainty).Who makes this claim: Recipe-box companiesAndrade 2026 · 66 GoodHasan 2019 · 67 GoodBoyar et al. 2025 · 60 LimitedFraser et al. 2022 · 39 Weak (independence estimated*)
Meal kits cut household food waste and the climate footprint of dinnersProbably helpsEarly evidenceOne US model of 5 recipes: about 6 versus 8 kg of greenhouse gases per meal, partly from less food waste. Not a health outcome.The detailsOne modelling study of 5 US recipes: 6.1 vs 8.1 kg CO2e per meal, partly from less food waste. Not a health outcome.Who makes this claim: Recipe-box companies; sustainability researchersHeard et al. 2019 · 48 Weak (independence estimated*)
What it doesn't clearly do
Meal kits improve diet quality (more vegetables, less takeaway), in adults and families who use themNot yet knownMore data neededIn the only trial (70 US food-pantry clients, 2 weeks), people's own ratings of their diets improved about equally with meal kits or no-prep meals.The detailsNo high-quality evidence. Only trial (70 food-pantry clients in Dallas randomised, 66 finished; 2 weeks): perceived diet quality improved equally with kits or no-prep meals.Who makes this claim: Recipe-box companies; family usersHollis-Hansen 2023 · 57 LimitedGibson and Partridge 2019 · 53 LimitedDobiecka et al. 2025 · 53 Limited (independence estimated*)Fraser et al. 2022 · 39 Weak (independence estimated*)Boyar et al. 2025 · 60 Limited
Free meal kits or medically tailored meals improve diet and health, in people with low income or chronic diseaseMixed resultsEarly evidenceA US heart association review of 14 trials: free food programs often improved diet and food security, but health results were inconsistent.The detailsHeart association review of 14 US trials: food programs often improved diet quality and food security; clinical outcomes were inconsistent.Who makes this claim: US 'Food is Medicine' programsSeligman et al. 2025 · 64 Limited (independence estimated*)Hollis-Hansen 2023 · 57 Limited
Not reviewed yet
Recipe-box meal kits (cook it yourself) help weight loss, in adults with overweightUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsRecipe kits untested. Indirect: prepared meals with counselling, at least 4.9% more loss (12 months); meal plans did as well as supplied food (163 women).Who makes this claim: Recipe-box lower-calorie ranges; ready-meal marketingGudzune et al. 2015 · 81 Strong (independence estimated*)Wing et al. 1996 · 62 Limited (independence estimated*)Moores et al. 2021 · 54 Limited (independence estimated*)Dobiecka et al. 2025 · 53 Limited (independence estimated*)
Fact-checked 4 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
+ Add a note
3Batch-cook and freeze5 books3 studies⌄
Cook extra and freeze portions if it saves you time. No study of batch cooking was found.
What it found: A one-off survey of 40,554 French adults. The 57% who planned meals at least occasionally had more varied diets, closer to national guidelines, and were less often obese; women planners were also less often overweight. A link only; it can't show planning causes this.
What it means for you: Planning meals is linked with better diets; batch cooking is one way to plan, though it wasn't studied directly.
▸ See 2 more studies▾ 2 more studies, best firstMembers
Best book
Our pick for this step
Skinnytaste Meal Prep
Gina Homolka, 2020
87Top rated
★ 3.92 on Goodreads (2,394) · about 8 hours
3 of 3 readers who said either way said it helped
From 30 sampled Goodreads reviews: 3 helped, 0 didn't, 1 already knew most of it; the rest didn't say.
Claim: Practising professionalMethod from clinical or teaching practice
“Finally worked out a meal-prep schedule; several dishes kept in regular rotation”
▸ Why it's rated 87▾ Why it's rated 87
Scorecard
Reader outcomes 40%
94
Content quality 20%
82
Author credibility 20%
90
Goal relevance 10%
100
Rating and format 10%
54
What readers said helped (paraphrased)
Finally worked out a meal-prep schedule; several dishes kept in regular rotation
New to cooking after moving out; cooked several recipes, one twice, made treats at home instead of buying
Starting to prep meals ahead with this book; family using it heavily
Why it didn't help some
Already knew most of it
Long-time series cook; this one too simple for them
From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 1 November 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 2,394 ratings, about 94% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. 1 reader says the effect has lasted. Audiobook not confirmed.
▸ See 4 more books▾ 4 more books, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
4Eat well on a budget1 book5 studies⌄
In Australian costings, a guideline diet usually costs the same as or less than a typical one, mainly because of discretionary spending. The cheapest options can narrow or reverse the gap for some; on welfare incomes it's often unaffordable.
What it found: Pricing model diets for a household in north-west Tasmania each year from 2021 to 2023, a diet following the guidelines cost 16% to 22% less than the typical diet, mainly because 60% of typical spending went on discretionary foods.
What it means for you: Cutting discretionary foods frees money for healthy staples, though on welfare incomes even a guideline diet is often unaffordable.
The figures and the limit
Recommended diet 16–22% cheaper than the typical diet (north-west Tasmania, 2021–23).
The limit: One costing method and group; modelled baskets; 2023 prices.
▸ See 4 more studies▾ 4 more studies, best firstMembers
Book
Also rated for this step
Cook Once, Eat All Week
Cassy Joy Garcia, 2019
80Top rated
★ 4.24 on Goodreads (1,452) · about 18 hours
16 of 20 readers who said either way said it helped
From 30 sampled Goodreads reviews: 16 helped, 4 didn't, 1 already knew most of it; the rest didn't say.
Claim: PractitionerMethod from clinical or teaching practice
“Years on, still meal-preps with it and now adds more vegetables; too meat-heavy for them”
▸ Why it's rated 80▾ Why it's rated 80
Scorecard
Reader outcomes 40%
92
Content quality 20%
82
Author credibility 20%
70
Goal relevance 10%
75
Rating and format 10%
53
What readers said helped (paraphrased)
Years on, still meal-preps with it and now adds more vegetables; too meat-heavy for them
Sunday prep gives healthy weeknight meals; made about 20 so far
Busy parent uses it heavily, preps three proteins to plan two weeks of meals
Kept the family fed through lockdown; children now cook recipes from it
Cooked all 26 weeks; changed how they feed the family
A month of use; quick weeknight dinners, hard to justify eating out now
Four weeks of plans; no deciding what to cook, tries new dishes; notes high salt
Four months of weekly prep; saves time and money, eating unprocessed food
Family eats out much less, grocery bills down, eating healthier
Worked through several weekly plans; streamlined gluten-free meal planning
Batch-cooks basics already; book gave seasoning ideas to vary them and break the rut
One week done; batch prep with partner felt efficient; plans to keep using
Second week using it; hectic weeknights easier
After a failed first try, week one worked; two weeks of meals; kept in rotation
Cooking weekly plans from scratch and planning more weeks, though prep feels heavy
Used method twice in two weeks; saved time and nightly dinner stress
Why it didn't help some
Too much meat, too few vegetables for their family; two meals bland
Five weeks tried; bland, repetitive, food thrown away; stopped using it
Two recipes tasted bad; prep day exhausting; batch cooking not for them
Recipes too bland or too salty; needed other recipes to fix them
Already knew most of it
Already cooks this way naturally; recipes not tried
Rated for
Batch-cook and freeze 83Use the sample week 80
From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 1 November 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 1,452 ratings, about 92% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. 10 readers say the effect has lasted. Audiobook not confirmed.
Note: You only need to avoid gluten if you have coeliac disease; otherwise whole grains are good for you.
Why it isn't the top pick: it covers only part of this step.
+ Add a note
5Serve smaller portions4 studies1 website⌄
Serve smaller default portions and buy smaller packs of discretionary food; smaller bowls and spoons may help, smaller plates alone don't seem to. People eat less at the time; lasting weight loss is unclear.
What it found: In 58 studies of 6,603 people, mostly short lab studies, people ate more when given bigger portions, packs or tableware. The authors estimate smaller sizes across the whole UK diet could cut about 144 to 228 calories a day (600 to 950 kJ, our estimate).
What it means for you: Serve smaller default portions and buy smaller packs of treats; whether this brings lasting weight loss is unclear.
Best for: The most recent guideline-body review of portion size and weight.
Caution: Found evidence too inconsistent to conclude on weight.
No guideline sets a portion-size target; the evidence was too inconsistent to set one.
+ Add a note
6What helps you stick with itOptional1 product5 studies⌄
Choose a cooking-skills format you'll stick with: hands-on classes can build confidence, online courses give mixed results, and we found no usable evidence on meal kits. In one small year-long trial, adding remote cooking coaching to diet advice led to about 4% more weight loss; otherwise, none has been shown to change health measures.
What it found: Across 15 studies, cooking classes built confidence and may lift vegetable intake a little, but showed no clear difference in body weight (BMI change close to zero). Most studies had serious design flaws and relied on what people reported eating.
What it means for you: Pick a cooking format you enjoy and will stick with; don't expect it alone to change your health measures.
The figures and the limit
15 studies (low or very low certainty); BMI −0.07 kg/m² (95% CI −1.53 to 1.40).
The limit: High risk of bias and self-reported diet.
▸ See 4 more studies▾ 4 more studies, best firstMembers
Product
Air fryers
Does air frying cut the fat and calories in fried food?
Probably helpsEarly evidence
Probably a little, but only lab tests exist, with no studies in people. Air-fried chips held 5.1% oil versus 7.7% deep-fried: about 4 g less fat per 150 g serve (our estimate).
+Lab tests: about 4 g less fat per 150 g of chips (our estimate)Early evidence
+Eating less fried food is linked with fewer heart eventsEarly evidence
○Harmful cooking compounds: lab tests range from lower to higher than deep fryingEarly evidence
–Reheated hash browns made more acrylamide in an air fryer than in oilEarly evidence
–About 2 million of one brand's air fryers recalled in the US (2023, fire)Early evidence
–Fumes: one test found 2–5 times pan cooking's particles; another, less than frying
How to do it: Lab tests cooked chips, wedges, hash browns and meat; no trials in people.
Cook potatoes to light golden, not brown, and soak them first; higher heat and longer cooking raise acrylamide.
Frozen chips and other pre-fried foods keep the oil, salt and additives already in them.
Sticking with it: No data on how many people keep using one after a year.
Cost: Recalled US models sold for about US$70–130; an air fryer uses about half an oven's electricity per hour.
Check with your doctor first or skip it: If you rarely eat fried food, expect little health gain.
Risks and who should be careful (8)
air frying makes as much or more acrylamide than oven baking or deep frying, for people eating air-fried potatoesMixed resultsEarly evidenceLab results disagree: one found 90% less acrylamide than deep frying; reheated hash browns made more. Acrylamide intake isn't linked with most cancers.The detailsLab tests disagree: 90% lower than deep frying in one; higher than oil for reheated hash browns. Acrylamide intake isn't linked with most cancers.Who makes this claim: Food regulators; media reportsNavruz-Varlı and Mortaş 2023 · 51 LimitedFilippini et al. 2022 · 74 GoodFood Standards Australia New Zealand · Official dataUS Food and Drug Administration · Official dataYoon et al. 2024 · 50 Limited (independence estimated*)Sansano et al. 2015 · 48 Weak (independence estimated*)Shi et al. 2026 · 48 Weak (independence estimated*)
fires and burns from faulty units, for households using air fryersProbably harmfulEarly evidenceIn a 2023 US recall of about 2 million units, there were 205 fire or overheating reports: about 1 per 10,000 units (our estimate).The detailsUS recall of about 2 million units (2023): 205 fire or overheating reports, about 0.1 per 1,000 units (our estimate). No high-quality evidence.Who makes this claim: Product-safety regulatorsUS Consumer Product Safety Commission 2023 · Official data
Fire, burns and fumesAbout 2 million units of one brand were recalled in the US in 2023 (205 reports, 10 minor burns). Fume tests disagree; built-up residue raised emissions.The detailsUS recall of about 2 million units for overheating wiring: 205 reports, 10 minor burns (2023). Air frying chicken released 2-5 times the particles of pan cooking in one lab test; a chamber study found less than conventional frying, but residue after 70 or more uses raised particles while idle.US Consumer Product Safety Commission 2023 · Official dataWang and Chan 2023 · 50 Limited (independence estimated*)Tang et al. 2026 · 48 Weak (independence estimated*)
Non-stick coatingsWe found no studies on chemicals from non-stick coatings in air fryers.The detailsNon-stick coating chemicals: none found.
Cooking habitsOne survey linked owning an air fryer with better cooking skills, but not a better diet.The detailsOwning one is linked with better cooking skills, not a better diet (one survey).Atasoy et al. 2026 · 57 Limited
Oven or boiling insteadOven baking gives similar results; boiling or microwaving whole potatoes makes no acrylamide.The detailsOven baking gives similar results; boiling or microwaving whole potatoes makes no acrylamide.US Food and Drug Administration · Official dataNavruz-Varlı and Mortaş 2023 · 51 Limited
CostAbout US$70–130 for recalled US models; in Australia, A$209 for one tested model, using about half an oven's electricity per hour (2023).The detailsAbout A$209 for one tested model; about half an oven's electricity per hour (Australia, 2023). Recalled models sold for US$70-130 (US, 2018-2022).CHOICE · 63 Limited (consumer group)US Consumer Product Safety Commission 2023 · Official data
PrivacyIn a 2024 UK test, all three app-connected air fryers asked for precise location and permission to record phone audio; one app linked to advertising trackers.The detailsIn a UK consumer test (2024), all three app-connected air fryers asked for precise location and permission to record phone audio; one app connected to social-media and advertising trackers. One maker said the audio permission doesn't apply to its fryer.Which? · 58 Limited (consumer group)
The evidence, claim by claim (4)Members
What it does
Air frying cuts fat and calories in fried foods compared with deep frying, for people who fry at homeProbably helpsEarly evidenceLab tests only, no studies in people: air-fried chips held 5.1% oil versus 7.7% deep-fried; a review says up to 80% less.The detailsLab tests only: chips held 5.1% vs 7.7% oil; a review says up to 80% less. No high-quality evidence in people.Who makes this claim: Appliance makers and retailers; recipe creatorsYavuz et al. 2026 · 50 Limited (independence estimated*)Teruel et al. 2015 · 50 Limited (independence estimated*)Téllez-Morales and Arce-Ortiz 2024 · 37 Weak (independence estimated*)Can et al. 2026 · 53 Limited
Eating less deep-fried food is linked with lower heart disease, diabetes and deathProbably helpsEarly evidenceIn studies following people, those eating the most fried food had about 24% more heart events, not more deaths. Fried potatoes are linked with diabetes.The detailsHighest fried-food intake linked to more heart events (RR 1.24; no absolute figure), not death; null in Spain. Fried potatoes linked with diabetes (high certainty).Who makes this claim: Dietary guidelines; cohort studiesQin et al. 2021 · 69 Good (independence estimated*)Sun et al. 2019 · 72 GoodQin et al. 2022 · 58 Limited (independence estimated*)Mousavi et al. 2025 · 85 StrongNHMRC 2013 · 74 GoodWHO 2023 · 85 Strong (independence estimated*)Guallar-Castillón et al. 2012 · 70 Good
Air fryers make home cooking easier and replace takeaway, for households that own oneProbably helpsEarly evidenceOne survey of 384 adults in Istanbul, one per household: owners had better cooking skills, but not a healthier Mediterranean-style diet.The detailsOne survey of 384 households: owning one is linked with better cooking and food skills, not with a healthier Mediterranean-style diet; very low certainty.Who makes this claim: Owners; recipe creatorsAtasoy et al. 2026 · 57 Limited
What it doesn't clearly do
Air frying lowers harmful cooking compounds (acrylamide, heterocyclic amines, PAHs, oxidised fat) compared with deep fryingMixed resultsEarly evidenceLab tests only: 16–43% less oxidised fat than deep frying; acrylamide about 90% lower in one test, similar or higher in others.The detailsNo high-quality evidence. Lab tests: oxidised fat 16-43% lower; acrylamide about 90% lower in one test, similar or higher in others.Who makes this claim: Appliance marketing; food scientistsCan et al. 2026 · 53 LimitedChen et al. 2024 · 53 LimitedNavruz-Varlı and Mortaş 2023 · 51 LimitedTéllez-Morales and Arce-Ortiz 2024 · 37 Weak (independence estimated*)Yavuz et al. 2026 · 50 Limited (independence estimated*)Yoon et al. 2024 · 50 Limited (independence estimated*)Sansano et al. 2015 · 48 Weak (independence estimated*)Shi et al. 2026 · 48 Weak (independence estimated*)
Fact-checked 4 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
+ Add a note
8. Claims we checked⌄16 steps · 117 items
1Low-carb and keto2 protocols6 studies⌄
At first, weight falls about 1 kg more (a small difference) and, in type 2 diabetes, blood sugar falls more, but by 1–2 years they're about the same as on balanced diets. Keto diets raise LDL cholesterol: a little in type 2 diabetes, more in lean people. If you take diabetes medicines, talk to your GP before cutting carbohydrate. Our verdict: supported with changes; certainty moderate (high for a small LDL rise in type 2 diabetes; low for larger rises in lean people).
What the research found: By 1–2 years, across 61 trials, low-carb and balanced diets gave about the same weight loss: under 1 kg more without diabetes, no clear difference with type 2 diabetes. In a 12-month trial, people lost 6.0 kg on low-carb and 5.3 kg on low-fat.
The figures and the limit
By 1–2 years, low-carb diets lead to about the same weight loss as balanced diets: 0.93 kg more lost on low-carb by people without diabetes (−1.81 to −0.04), no worthwhile effect, and 0.33 kg more (not significant) by people with type 2 diabetes (61 trials). In the 12-month DIETFITS trial, people lost 6.0 kg on low-carb and 5.3 kg on low-fat.
The limit: Moderate certainty; no trials of heart events or deaths.
What it found: The American Diabetes Association's 2026 standards suggest considering cutting carbohydrate for some adults with diabetes to improve blood sugar, for example by limiting processed foods. Cited reviews found very low-carb eating lowered blood sugar in the first 6 months, with less difference beyond a year.
What it means for you: If you have diabetes, cutting carbs can help blood sugar early on; your GP may need to adjust your medicines.
▸ See 5 more studies▾ 5 more studies, best firstMembers
Best protocol
Ketogenic (keto) diet
What it is: Cutting carbohydrate so low that the body makes ketones from fat; meals centre on meat, fish, eggs, dairy, oils, nuts and low-starch vegetables.
Does keto help you lose more weight than other diets?
Shown not to helpModerate evidence
Not by much. In 14 trials of 1,805 adults without diabetes, people on low-carb diets lost 0.93 kg more than on balanced diets at 1–2 years: no worthwhile difference. With type 2 diabetes, 0.33 kg.
○Weight: under 1 kg more than balanced diets at 1–2 yearsModerate evidence
+Type 2 diabetes: long-term blood sugar fell at 3 months, gone by 12Early evidence
+Triglycerides (a blood fat) slightly lowerEarly evidence
○Hunger: people ate about 690 calories a day more than on low-fat (small trial)Early evidence
–LDL cholesterol: small rise with diabetes; about 1 mmol/L higher if leanModerate evidence
–Diabetes medicines: ketoacidosis risk with SGLT2 inhibitors; low blood sugar with insulin or sulfonylureasEarly evidence
The diabetes and cholesterol results measured blood tests (HbA1c, LDL, triglycerides), not heart attacks or diabetes complications
How to do it: Most trials were short (median 13 weeks); the main weight comparison followed adults for 1–2 years.
Stricter isn't better: very low-carb didn't beat milder low-carb for weight unless kept up, and raised LDL more.
Sticking with it: No good data: trials were short (median 13 weeks), and benefits faded by 12 months.
Cost: Usually no extra cost; keto-branded products and supplements add cost.
Check with your doctor first or skip it: SGLT2 inhibitors, insulin or sulfonylureas, type 1 diabetes, kidney disease, pregnancy, breastfeeding, children, or eating-disorder risk: talk to your doctor first.
Risks and who should be careful (16)
keto raises LDL ('bad') cholesterolMixed resultsModerate evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesWith type 2 diabetes, LDL rose 0.16 mmol/L at 12 months, too small to matter; in lean people (BMI under 25), about 1 mmol/L.The detailsType 2 diabetes, 12 months: LDL up 0.16 mmol/L, no worthwhile rise (high certainty). Lean people (BMI under 25): about 1 mmol/L higher (low certainty).Who makes this claim: Heart Foundation (Australia), cardiologists, healthdirect (Australia)Patikorn 2023 · 78 GoodFeng et al. 2025 · 86 StrongSoto-Mota et al. 2024 · 83 Strong (independence estimated*)Naude 2022 · 89 Stronghealthdirect Australia · 72 Official data
ketoacidosis with SGLT2-inhibitor diabetes medicines, and low blood sugar with insulin or sulfonylureasProbably harmfulEarly evidenceSGLT2 inhibitors: ketoacidosis (regulator warnings, case reports). Insulin users: 45% more severe lows on a weight-loss program than with education. Your doctor's call.The detailsKeto with SGLT2-inhibitor medicines can cause ketoacidosis (regulator warnings, case reports). Insulin users had 45% more severe lows in intensive weight loss; no absolute figure.Who makes this claim: TGA and Diabetes Australia (Australia), ADA 2026 (US), healthdirect (Australia), case reportsDiabetes Australia 2018 · 67 GoodADA 2026 · 82 Strong (independence estimated*)TGA · 65 Official dataSinha et al. 2020 · 39 Weak (independence estimated*)Look AHEAD Research Group 2016 · 70 Good
long-term low-carb eating, especially animal-based, shortens lifeMixed resultsEarly evidenceStudies following people link low-carb eating with 18% more deaths if animal-based and 18% fewer if plant-based; a 2026 review found no overall link.The detailsCohorts: low-carb eating is linked with 18% more deaths if animal-based, 18% fewer if plant-based (no absolute figures). 2026 review: no overall link.Who makes this claim: Nutrition epidemiologists, criticsSeidelmann et al. 2018 · 68 GoodDuc and Nguyen 2026 · 72 Good
'keto flu', constipation, bad breath and dehydrationLeans toward harm; not yet knownAnecdotalAustralia's healthdirect lists keto flu, constipation, bad breath and dehydration as common; the trials we rated didn't measure them.The detailshealthdirect lists keto flu, constipation, bad breath and dehydration as common; not measured in the trials we rated.Who makes this claim: healthdirect (Australia)healthdirect Australia · 72 Official data
kidney stones and goutUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet reviewed.Who makes this claim: Clinicians
too little fibre, fruit, whole grains and legumesUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet reviewed.Who makes this claim: Dietitians
keto products (exogenous ketones, MCT oil, keto snacks)UntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. Get your doctor's advice before taking ketone supplements.The detailsNot yet reviewed. healthdirect advises a doctor's advice before ketone supplements.Who makes this claim: healthdirect (Australia)healthdirect Australia · 72 Official data
Side effectsCommon early on: 'keto flu' (tiredness, dizziness), constipation, headache and bad breath. LDL cholesterol rises a little with diabetes and about 1 mmol/L in lean people.The detailsCommon early: 'keto flu' (tiredness, dizziness), constipation, headache, bad breath (healthdirect). LDL cholesterol rises: a little in type 2 diabetes (high certainty), about 1 mmol/L in lean people (low certainty).healthdirect Australia · 72 Official dataPatikorn 2023 · 78 Good
Who should check with a doctor firstSGLT2 inhibitors: ketoacidosis risk; insulin or sulfonylureas: low blood sugar. Type 1 diabetes, kidney disease, pregnancy, breastfeeding and children (except supervised epilepsy diets): check first. Your doctor's call.The detailsSGLT2-inhibitor diabetes medicines: risk of ketoacidosis; insulin or sulfonylureas: risk of low blood sugar, so medicines need review; type 1 diabetes, kidney disease, pregnancy or breastfeeding, and children (except supervised epilepsy diets) should avoid it or check first. Your doctor's call.Diabetes Australia 2018 · 67 GoodADA 2026 · 82 Strong (independence estimated*)healthdirect Australia · 72 Official dataSinha et al. 2020 · 39 Weak (independence estimated*)Look AHEAD Research Group 2016 · 70 GoodTGA · 65 Official data
Keto productsKetone supplements and keto-branded products haven't been reviewed yet.The detailsKetone supplements and keto-branded products haven't been reviewed yet.
Sweeteners in keto snacksKeto snacks often use sweeteners and sugar alcohols; we haven't reviewed them.The detailsKeto snacks often use sweeteners and sugar alcohols; not yet reviewed.
Misleading early resultsEarly fast weight loss is partly water; triglycerides and HDL can improve while LDL rises.The detailsEarly fast weight loss is partly water; triglycerides and HDL can improve while LDL rises.Patikorn 2023 · 78 Good
On-and-off dietingStrict food rules can lead to on-and-off dieting; healthdirect advises against keto for anyone at risk of an eating disorder.The detailsStrict food rules can lead to on-and-off dieting; healthdirect advises against keto for anyone at risk of an eating disorder.healthdirect Australia · 72 Official data
Balanced or plant-based insteadBalanced lower-calorie diets give the same weight loss by 1–2 years; plant-based low-carb is linked with better survival than animal-based.The detailsBalanced lower-calorie diets give the same weight loss by 1–2 years; plant-based low-carb versions are linked with better survival than animal-based ones.Naude 2022 · 89 StrongSeidelmann et al. 2018 · 68 Good
CostNo extra cost needed; branded keto products add cost.The detailsNo extra cost needed; branded keto products add cost.
Keto lowers blood sugar and reverses type 2 diabetesProbably helpsEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesType 2 diabetes: HbA1c down 0.61 points at 3 months, gone by 12; at 6 months, 57% vs 31% below diabetes range, medicines allowed.The detailsType 2 diabetes: HbA1c cut 0.61 points at 3 months (moderate certainty), gone by 12 (low certainty). Low-carb trials, 6 months: HbA1c under 6.5% in 57% vs 31%, counting people on medicines; not significant without them.Who makes this claim: A US telehealth diabetes program, 'reversal' videos, keto doctors on YouTubeRafiullah et al. 2022 · 76 Good (independence estimated*)Parry-Strong et al. 2022 · 79 GoodGoldenberg 2021 · 82 StrongDiabetes Australia 2018 · 67 GoodADA 2026 · 82 Strong (independence estimated*)
Keto lowers triglycerides and raises HDLProbably helpsEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesIn 174 trials of carbohydrate-restricted diets, triglycerides fell about 0.17 mmol/L (15 mg/dL); we haven't rated HDL.The details174 trials of carbohydrate-restricted diets: triglycerides 15 mg/dL (0.17 mmol/L) lower; umbrella review: high-quality evidence for lower triglycerides. HDL not rated.Who makes this claim: Keto advocatesParry-Strong et al. 2022 · 79 GoodFeng et al. 2025 · 86 StrongPatikorn 2023 · 78 Good
What it doesn't clearly do
Keto makes you lose more weight than other diets, in adults with overweight or obesityShown not to helpModerate evidenceAdults without diabetes (14 trials, 1,805 people): low-carb lost 0.93 kg more than balanced diets at 1–2 years; strict keto, short trials: about 1.5 kg.The detailsCochrane, 14 trials, 1,805 adults without diabetes: low-carb lost 0.93 kg more than balanced diets at 1–2 years. Strict keto, short trials: 1.49 kg (low).Who makes this claim: Dr Eric Berg, Ken Berry, Gary Taubes, Diet DoctorNaude 2022 · 89 StrongŻurawski and Bartosiewicz 2026 · 79 GoodGe 2020 · 85 StrongGardner 2018 · 74 GoodFeng et al. 2025 · 86 Stronghealthdirect Australia · 72 Official data
Keto cuts hunger, making a diet easier to stick toNot yet knownEarly evidenceIn a 20-person ward trial, people ate about 690 calories a day more on keto than on low-fat; other studies found slightly less hunger.The details20-person ward trial: people ate 689 kcal a day more on keto than low-fat. Uncontrolled studies: slightly less hunger in ketosis.Who makes this claim: Keto advocates, Dr BozGibson et al. 2015 · 51 Limited (independence estimated*)Hall et al. 2021 · 62 Limited (independence estimated*)
Keto burns fat while keeping muscleMixed resultsEarly evidenceVery low-calorie keto cut fat without worsening muscle in adults with overweight; in healthy people, keto low-carb reduced muscle.The detailsUmbrella review of trials: very low-calorie keto cut fat without worsening muscle in overweight adults; keto low-carb reduced muscle in healthy people.Who makes this claim: Metabolic Mind, keto advocatesPatikorn 2023 · 78 Good
Not reviewed yet
Keto reverses fatty liverUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet reviewed.Who makes this claim: Keto video channels
Keto clears brain fog and boosts energyUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet reviewed.Who makes this claim: Keto advocates
Keto treats drug-resistant epilepsy (a supervised medical diet)UntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. It's a medical treatment run by a neurologist and specialist dietitian.The detailsA medical treatment for a small group, run by a neurologist and specialist dietitian; not rated here (claim check only).Who makes this claim: Neurologists, healthdirect (Australia)healthdirect Australia · 72 Official data
Keto treats PCOS, migraine, cancer or mental illnessUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet reviewed.Who makes this claim: Advocates, small trials
Fact-checked 1 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
▸ See 1 more protocol▾ 1 more protocol, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
2Seed oils6 studies⌄
Use seed oils such as sunflower, safflower, canola and soybean instead of butter and other saturated fats. They lower total cholesterol, and trials don't show they raise inflammation; for heart events and deaths, neither strong harm nor a large extra benefit is shown. Our verdict: weak or mixed; certainty low.
What the research found: In trials, eating more omega-6 fat, found in seed oils, lowered total cholesterol by about 0.3 mmol/L and didn't clearly raise inflammation markers. Heart events and deaths showed no clear difference either way: neither harm nor a large extra benefit.
The figures and the limit
More omega-6 lowers cholesterol, shows no clear effect on heart events or deaths, and doesn't clearly raise inflammation markers. Total cholesterol −0.33 mmol/L (high certainty); deaths RR 1.00, heart events RR 0.97 (low certainty; ranges include no effect).
The limit: Low certainty for heart outcomes; the inflammation review is ungraded, and hinted that very large increases in omega-6 might raise CRP, an inflammation marker.
What it found: The World Health Organization's 2023 guideline advises keeping saturated fat to no more than 10% of energy and trans fat to 1%, replacing them with polyunsaturated fats, monounsaturated fats from plants, or carbohydrates from fibre-rich foods such as whole grains, vegetables, fruit and pulses.
What it means for you: Cooking with seed oils instead of butter fits the WHO's advice to replace saturated fat with unsaturated fats.
▸ See 5 more studies▾ 5 more studies, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
3Vegetarian and vegan6 studies⌄
The Australian guidelines say well-planned vegetarian and vegan diets are healthy and adequate. In cohort studies they're linked with less heart disease but more hip fractures. Vegans may need a B12 supplement and should plan for iron, zinc and calcium. Our verdict: weak or mixed; certainty low.
What the research found: In long-term studies, vegetarians had about 21% less coronary heart disease, but vegetarians and vegans had more hip fractures (25% and 75% more). One UK study found 10 fewer heart disease cases and 3 more strokes per 1,000 vegetarians over 10 years than meat eaters.
The figures and the limit
In cohort studies, vegetarian diets are linked with less coronary heart disease, and vegetarian and vegan diets with more hip fractures; one large UK cohort also found more strokes. Coronary heart disease RR 0.79 (13 cohorts); hip fracture HR 1.25 for vegetarians and 1.75 for vegans. EPIC-Oxford: 10 fewer heart disease cases and 3 more strokes per 1,000 vegetarians than meat eaters over 10 years.
The limit: Associations only; hip fracture evidence is low certainty for vegetarians and very low for vegans; the stroke signal wasn't confirmed when cohorts were pooled.
What it found: Australia's Dietary Guidelines (NHMRC, 2013) say vegetarian diets with milk, eggs, nuts, seeds and legumes provide all essential nutrients; plant iron and zinc are absorbed less well, and vegans may need B12 supplements. They advise limiting added sugars, linking sugary drinks with weight gain.
What it means for you: Australia's guidelines support well-planned vegetarian eating; vegans may need B12 supplements, and should plan for iron and zinc.
▸ See 5 more studies▾ 5 more studies, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
4Fermented foods1 product6 studies⌄
In healthy adults, they may help bowel habits a little. There's no proof of wider health benefits: yoghurt and fermented milk are linked with slightly fewer deaths in cohort studies, which isn't enough for a health claim. Fermented doesn't mean probiotic. Our verdict: weak or mixed; certainty low.
What the research found: In healthy adults, fermented foods may help bowel habits a little: about 0.6 more bowel movements a week, somewhat fewer gut symptoms, and food passing through about 14 hours faster. There's no proof of wider health benefits.
The figures and the limit
In healthy adults, fermented foods may help bowel habits a little; certainty is low. About 0.6 more bowel movements a week (0.04 to 1.16); fewer gut symptoms (standardised mean difference −0.60); food took about 14 hours less to pass through the gut.
The limit: Mostly low certainty; trials disagreed a lot; one author has industry ties.
What it found: An expert panel from the International Scientific Association for Probiotics and Prebiotics defines fermented foods as foods made through desired microbial growth and enzyme changes, and separates them from probiotics. It discussed health benefits, risks and safety without a systematic review.
What it means for you: Don't assume a fermented food is a probiotic; experts treat them as different things.
▸ See 5 more studies▾ 5 more studies, best firstMembers
Product
Probiotic supplements
Do probiotic supplements help gut health, bloating and bowel habits?
Mixed resultsEarly evidence
It depends on the strain and who takes it. In 82 trials of 10,332 adults with irritable bowel syndrome, some strains eased some symptoms; in healthy adults, gut symptoms didn't improve.
+With antibiotics: diarrhoea 27% down to 23%; C. difficile 3.2% to 1.6%Early evidence
+Children on antibiotics: diarrhoea 19% down to 8%, about 1 in 9 helpedModerate evidence
+Colds: about 24% fewer people caught one, in 16 trialsEarly evidence
+Chronic constipation: 57% improved, versus 44% withoutEarly evidence
○Side effects no more common than placebo (10.9% versus 12.2%)Moderate evidence
How to do it: Trials used specific strains, often started with the antibiotic; in children, 5 billion live bacteria (CFU) a day or more worked better.
Pick a strain tested for your purpose, at the dose tested; effects differ between strains.
For IBS, UK guidance suggests trying one for up to 12 weeks to see if it helps.
Fermented foods with live cultures may modestly help bowel habits; fibre-rich foods feed gut bacteria.
Sticking with it: No data on how many keep taking them after a year.
Cost: About US$150–400 a year for a daily capsule (our estimate).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Critically ill, immune-suppressed, with a central line, or a preterm baby: serious infections have been reported; your doctor's call.
Risks and who should be careful (12)
probiotics cause bloodstream infections, in very ill or immune-suppressed people, people with central lines, and preterm babiesProbably harmfulEarly evidenceUS children's intensive care: 6 of 522 given probiotics got Lactobacillus blood infections, others about 1 in 11,000 (our estimate); FDA warned on preterm babies.The detailsUS children's ICU: probiotic use was linked with Lactobacillus bloodstream infection, 6 of 522 (1.1%) versus 0.009%; FDA warned about preterm babies.Who makes this claim: FDA, NIH (NCCIH), infectious-disease specialistsYelin et al. 2019 · 69 Good (independence estimated*)US Food and Drug Administration · Official dataUS National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health · Official dataMerenstein et al. 2023 · 56 Limited
products don't contain what the label says (strain, count, viability)Probably harmfulEarly evidenceLab tests: most of 15 Polish products and 3 of 26 Slovenian ones held fewer live bacteria than labelled; some held undeclared microbes.The detailsLab tests: most of 15 products (Poland) and 3 of 26 (Slovenia) held fewer live bacteria than labelled; some contained undeclared microbes.Who makes this claim: NIH (NCCIH), microbiology researchersZawistowska-Rojek et al. 2026 · 50 Limited (independence estimated*)Mohar Lorbeg et al. 2021 · 50 Limited (independence estimated*)US National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health · Official dataTGA · Official data
probiotics after antibiotics delay the gut's own recovery (versus the claim that they restore it)Probably harmfulEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesA small human and mouse study: a multi-strain probiotic delayed and blunted gut-bacteria recovery after antibiotics; symptoms weren't tested.The detailsSmall human and mouse study: a multi-strain probiotic delayed and blunted gut-bacteria recovery after antibiotics; symptoms weren't tested.Who makes this claim: Microbiome researchersSuez et al. 2018 · 62 Limited (independence estimated*)
gas, bloating and other side effectsShown not to helpModerate evidence37 trials: side effects, mostly mild gut symptoms, in 10.9% on probiotics versus 12.2% on control: no clear difference.The detailsCochrane, 37 trials: side effects 10.9% versus 12.2% on control (RR 0.86, 0.72 to 1.01), moderate certainty; mostly mild gut symptoms.Who makes this claim: Product leafletsEsmaeilinezhad et al. 2025 · 92 StrongZhao et al. 2022 · 83 Strong (independence estimated*)Goodoory et al. 2023 · 81 Strong (independence estimated*)
Side effectsMostly mild gut symptoms, no more common than placebo (10.9% versus 12.2%). Rare bloodstream infections, mainly in critically ill or immune-suppressed people.The detailsMostly mild gut symptoms, no more common than on placebo (10.9% versus 12.2%). Rare bloodstream infections, mainly in critically ill or immune-suppressed people.Esmaeilinezhad et al. 2025 · 92 StrongYelin et al. 2019 · 69 Good (independence estimated*)
Who should check firstCritically ill or immune-suppressed people, people with central lines, and preterm babies: serious infections reported. The safety findings apply to people with normal immunity. Your doctor's call.The detailsCritically ill or immune-suppressed people, people with central lines, and preterm babies: serious infections reported (US children's ICU 1.1%; FDA warning 2023). The Cochrane review's safety conclusion applies to people who aren't immune-compromised. Your doctor's call.Yelin et al. 2019 · 69 Good (independence estimated*)US Food and Drug Administration · Official dataEsmaeilinezhad et al. 2025 · 92 StrongUS National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health · Official data
Strain and doseEffects depend on the strain. In children, 5 billion live bacteria (CFU) a day or more worked better. US guidelines differ on C. difficile; no benefit where risk was low.The detailsEffects are strain-specific; in children, 5 billion CFU a day or more worked better, and a European paediatric guideline names two strains at that dose. US guidelines differ on C. difficile. Benefit was absent where baseline risk was low.Guo et al. 2019 · 89 Strong (independence estimated*)American Gastroenterological Association 2020 · 85 Strong (independence estimated*)Goodman et al. 2021 · 89 StrongESPGHAN Special Interest Group 2023 · 78 GoodAmerican College of Gastroenterology 2021 · 80 Strong (independence estimated*)
Label accuracy and checksSome products held fewer live bacteria than labelled. Australia: probiotics (AUST L) aren't individually checked before sale. US: supplements don't need FDA approval.The detailsSome products held fewer live bacteria than labelled in 2 European lab studies. In Australia, probiotics are listed medicines (AUST L), not individually evaluated before sale; in the US, supplements don't need FDA approval before sale.Zawistowska-Rojek et al. 2026 · 50 Limited (independence estimated*)Mohar Lorbeg et al. 2021 · 50 Limited (independence estimated*)TGA · Official dataUS National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health · Official data
Sugar and dairyGummies and drinks may contain sugar, and some products contain dairy.The detailsGummies and drinks may contain sugar, and some products contain dairy.
'Gut health' claims'Gut health' isn't measured in most marketing; in 37 studies, healthy adults had no change in gut symptoms or gut permeability (leakiness).The details'Gut health' isn't a measured outcome in most marketing; healthy adults showed no change in gut symptoms or permeability in 37 studies.Rauch et al. 2022 · 69 Good
A capsule instead of fibreA daily capsule may stand in for fibre-rich eating; not tested.The detailsA daily capsule may stand in for fibre-rich eating; not tested.
CostAbout US$150–400 (A$250–550) a year for a daily capsule (our estimate).The detailsAbout A$250-550 (Australia) or US$150-400 (US) a year (our estimate). Shown as information only.
The evidence, claim by claim (8)Members
What it does
Probiotics taken with antibiotics prevent antibiotic-associated and C. difficile diarrhoea, in children and adultsProbably helpsEarly evidence38 trials, 13,179 people on antibiotics: C. difficile diarrhoea fell from 3.2% to 1.6% (1 in 65 helped); largest trial (older inpatients): no clear difference.The detailsCochrane: cut C. difficile 3.2% to 1.6% (38 trials, NNT 65) and diarrhoea 27% to 23% (40 trials); low certainty. Largest older-inpatient trial: no effect.Who makes this claim: Probiotic brands ('after antibiotics'), pharmacists. US guidelines differ: AGA 2020 suggests named strains (conditional); ACG 2021 recommends against. Label follows the newest GRADE review (Cochrane 2025).Esmaeilinezhad et al. 2025 · 92 StrongGoodman et al. 2021 · 89 StrongGuo et al. 2019 · 89 Strong (independence estimated*)Allen et al. 2013 · 85 StrongAmerican Gastroenterological Association 2020 · 85 Strong (independence estimated*)American College of Gastroenterology 2021 · 80 Strong (independence estimated*)World Gastroenterology Organisation 2023 · 53 Limited
In children taking antibiotics, probiotics prevent diarrhoeaShown to helpModerate evidence33 trials, 6,352 children on antibiotics: diarrhoea fell from 19% to 8%, about 1 in 9 helped; higher doses worked better.The details33 trials, 6,352 children: cut diarrhoea 19% to 8% (NNT 9), moderate certainty. European paediatric guideline: two named strains at high dose (strong).Who makes this claim: Paediatric probiotic brands, Cochrane review authors, European paediatric gastroenterology society (ESPGHAN 2023; most authors declare probiotic-industry ties)Guo et al. 2019 · 89 Strong (independence estimated*)ESPGHAN Special Interest Group 2023 · 78 Good
Probiotics prevent colds and other respiratory infections ('immunity'), in children, adults and older adultsProbably helpsEarly evidence16 trials, 4,798 children and adults: about 24% fewer caught a cold or similar infection; multi-strain products in adults: about 10% fewer.The detailsCochrane, 16 trials, 4,798 people: 24% fewer had a cold (RR 0.76; low certainty; absolute figure not given). Adults, multi-strain: RR 0.90.Who makes this claim: Probiotic brands ('supports immunity')Zhao et al. 2022 · 83 Strong (independence estimated*)Zhu et al. 2025 · 89 StrongUS National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health · Official data
Probiotics ease depression and anxiety ('psychobiotics')Probably helpsEarly evidence18 small trials in adults diagnosed with depression: scores fell more than on placebo, a large effect on paper, but results varied widely between trials.The details18 small trials in diagnosed depression: scores fell (SMD -0.96), but results varied widely between trials.Who makes this claim: Gut-brain books, 'mood' probiotic brandsAsad et al. 2025 · 81 Strong
Probiotics relieve chronic constipation, in adultsProbably helpsEarly evidence34 trials in adults with chronic constipation: 57% versus 44% improved; one species (B. lactis) made bowel movements more frequent, mixtures didn't.The details34 trials: 57% versus 44% responded (RR 1.28); one species (B. lactis) raised stool frequency, mixtures didn't; high risk of bias.Who makes this claim: Probiotic brandsvan der Schoot et al. 2022 · 78 Good (independence estimated*)
What it doesn't clearly do
Probiotic supplements improve gut health, bloating and bowel habits, in healthy adults and adults with IBSMixed resultsEarly evidenceAdults with IBS (82 trials): some strains eased some symptoms; guidelines disagree. Healthy adults (37 small studies): no improvement in gut symptoms.The details82 IBS trials (10,332 adults): some strains eased some symptoms, low to very low certainty. Healthy adults, 37 small pre/probiotic studies: no gut-symptom benefit.Who makes this claim: Gut-health books, probiotic brands, influencers. Guidelines differ: US (ACG 2021) suggests against for IBS; AGA 2020: only in trials; UK (BSG 2021): a trial of up to 12 weeks is reasonable.Goodoory et al. 2023 · 81 Strong (independence estimated*)Rauch et al. 2022 · 69 GoodAmerican Gastroenterological Association 2020 · 85 Strong (independence estimated*)American College of Gastroenterology 2021 · 80 Strong (independence estimated*)British Society of Gastroenterology 2021 · 72 Good (independence estimated*)US National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health · Official data
Not reviewed yet
Probiotics help weight loss and metabolic healthUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNo reviewed evidence yet.Who makes this claim: Weight-loss probiotic brands
Condition-specific uses (preterm infants, pouchitis, infant colic, bacterial vaginosis, H. pylori add-on)UntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. These specialist uses are your doctor's call.The detailsClinician-led uses outside this card; AGA 2020 covers several. Your doctor's call.Who makes this claim: Specialist guidelinesAmerican Gastroenterological Association 2020 · 85 Strong (independence estimated*)
Fact-checked 1 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
+ Add a note
5Eggs and dairy fat2 products5 studies⌄
For healthy people, eggs aren't clearly linked with heart deaths and the Heart Foundation sets no limit; if you have type 2 diabetes, or heart disease and need LDL-lowering treatment, it advises no more than 7 eggs a week. Full-fat and reduced-fat dairy show no clear difference in heart risk; choose reduced-fat if your LDL is high or you have heart disease, and limit butter. Our verdict: weak or mixed; certainty low.
What the research found: Eggs showed no clear link with heart deaths. In some analyses, each extra egg a day was linked with about 4% more cardiovascular disease, and the highest intakes with about 20% more cancer deaths. Full-fat and reduced-fat dairy showed no clear difference in heart risk.
The figures and the limit
Eggs: no clear link with cardiovascular deaths, but in some analyses each extra egg a day was linked with slightly higher cardiovascular disease risk, and the highest intakes with more cancer deaths. Cardiovascular deaths RR 1.04 (0.87–1.23), highest vs lowest intake; cardiovascular disease RR 1.04 (1.00–1.08) per extra egg a day; cancer deaths RR 1.20 at the highest intakes. Full-fat vs reduced-fat dairy: no clear difference in heart risk (low certainty).
The limit: Observational; inconsistent between regions and outcomes.
What it found: The Heart Foundation's 2019 position statements set no egg limit for healthy people, but advise no more than 7 a week with type 2 diabetes, or heart disease needing LDL-lowering treatment. Reduced-fat dairy is advised for high cholesterol or heart disease; butter isn't heart-healthy.
What it means for you: Healthy people needn't count eggs; with type 2 diabetes or heart disease, eat 7 or fewer a week. Limit butter.
▸ See 4 more studies▾ 4 more studies, best firstMembers
Best product
Plant milks (soy, oat, almond, rice, coconut)
Are plant milks as nutritious as dairy milk?
Shown not to helpModerate evidence
Mostly not. Of 129 Australian plant milks, 81% added calcium, 27% vitamin B12 and only 3% iodine; most had less protein than cow's milk, but soy's was similar.
○Most have less protein and few add iodine; soy's protein matches cow'sModerate evidence
+Soy instead of cow's milk: top blood pressure number about 8 points lowerEarly evidence
–Young children: 3 cups a day linked with 0.8 cm shorter at age 5Early evidence
–Rice drinks contain arsenic: not advised for children up to 4.5 yearsEarly evidence
–UK modelling, unfortified versions: teen girls below minimum iodine rose from 20% to 48%Early evidence
Measured cholesterol and blood pressure, not heart attacks or strokes
How to do it: Trials replaced about 500 mL of cow's milk a day with soy or other plant drinks.
Check the label: aim for about 100 mg calcium per 100 mL, plus added B12 and iodine.
Sticking with it: No data on how many keep using them at a year.
Cost: About US$210 a year at a glass (250 mL) a day (our estimate).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Infants: breast milk or formula only. Children under 5: not as the main milk unless fortified soy. Cow's-milk allergy in children: your doctor's call.
switching to unfortified plant milks cuts iodine and B12 intake, in older children and adultsProbably harmfulEarly evidenceUK modelling: unfortified plant milk instead of dairy raised girls aged 11–18 below the minimum iodine intake from 20% to 48%.The detailsUK modelling: unfortified plant milk raised girls aged 11-18 below the lower iodine intake from 20% to 48%; only 3% of Australian products had iodine.Who makes this claim: Dietitians; iodine researchersNicol et al. 2024 · 49 Weak (author paid by a plant-milk maker and a dairy body for talks)Harmer, Craddock and Charlton 2025 · 53 Limited
rice drinks contain inorganic arsenic, in young childrenProbably harmfulEarly evidenceUS tests of rice milk: arsenic up to 17.9 µg per litre, above the 10 µg drinking-water limit; Ireland advises none up to 4.5 years.The detailsUS tests: total arsenic up to 17.9 µg per litre, above the 10 µg drinking-water limit; Ireland advises no rice milk up to 4.5 years.Who makes this claim: Food-safety regulators (Ireland, UK)Shannon and Rodriguez 2014 · 50 Limited (independence estimated*)Food Safety Authority of Ireland, 27 May 2009 · Official data
added sugar in sweetened plant milks worsens heart and metabolic markersNot yet knownMore data neededMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesSoy milk trials: sweetened and unsweetened versions had similar effects on heart markers (subgroup comparison only); no data for other plant milks.The detailsSoymilk trials: sweetened and unsweetened versions had similar effects on markers, in a subgroup comparison only; no data for other plant milks.Who makes this claim: Dietitians; ultra-processed food criticsErlich et al. 2024 · 75 Good (soy-industry co-funded)
Side effectsNone from drinking plant milks themselves; the risks are nutrient shortfalls.The detailsNone from drinking plant milks themselves in the studies we rated; the risks are shortfalls (see below).Wallerer et al. 2026 · 78 Good
Amounts and children's heightTrials used about 500 mL a day. In young children, each extra daily cup of non-cow milk was linked with 0.4 cm less height.The detailsTrials used about 500 mL a day. In young children, each extra daily cup of non-cow milk was linked with 0.4 cm less height.Erlich et al. 2024 · 75 Good (soy-industry co-funded)Morency et al. 2017 · 58 Limited (independence estimated*)
Sweeteners and additivesSweetened soy milk performed like unsweetened on heart markers; gums and oils in other drinks are a reasonable concern, not tested.The detailsSweetened soymilk performed like unsweetened on heart markers; gums and oils in other drinks are a reasonable concern, not tested.Erlich et al. 2024 · 75 Good (soy-industry co-funded)
'Milk' doesn't mean same nutritionMost plant milks have far less protein: almond about 1 g, oat about 4 g and dairy about 8 g per serve.The detailsBeing called 'milk' doesn't mean similar nutrition: most plant milks have far less protein (almond about 1 g, oat about 4 g, dairy about 8 g per serve).Dietitians Australia · Official dataHarmer, Craddock and Charlton 2025 · 53 Limited
Cow's or lactose-free milkCow's or lactose-free milk; if plant-based, fortified soy or pea milk with calcium, B12 and iodine.The detailsCow's or lactose-free milk; if plant-based, fortified soy or pea milk with calcium, B12 and iodine.Dietitians Australia · Official data
CostMedian A$3.50 a litre (Australia, 2025); about A$320 (US$210) a year at 250 mL a day (our estimate).The detailsMedian A$3.50 a litre (Australia, 2025 audit); about A$320 a year at 250 mL a day (our estimate). Shown as information only.Harmer, Craddock and Charlton 2025 · 53 Limited
The evidence, claim by claim (7)Members
What it does
Swapping cow's milk for soy milk lowers LDL cholesterol, in adultsShown to helpModerate evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomes17 trials, 504 adults swapping 500 mL a day: LDL cholesterol 0.19 mmol/L lower with soy (industry co-funded); an independent review found 0.47.The details17 trials, 504 adults, 500 mL a day: LDL -0.19 mmol/L (high certainty; soy-industry co-funded). Independent review: -0.47, low certainty. Label downgraded one step.Who makes this claim: Soy brands; heart-health advocatesErlich et al. 2024 · 75 Good (soy-industry co-funded)Wallerer et al. 2026 · 78 Good
Swapping cow's milk for soy milk lowers blood pressure, in adultsProbably helpsEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesTwo reviews of small trials: 500 mL of soy drink a day lowered the top blood pressure number by about 8 points, with wide uncertainty.The detailsTwo reviews of small trials: systolic about 8 mmHg lower with 500 mL soy drink a day; low to moderate certainty, wide intervals.Who makes this claim: Soy brandsWallerer et al. 2026 · 78 GoodErlich et al. 2024 · 75 Good (soy-industry co-funded)
Oat milk lowers cholesterol (oat beta-glucan), in adultsProbably helpsEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomes4-week pilot, 33 young women: oat drink cut LDL cholesterol 0.4 mmol/L versus cow's milk; a larger review found only a very uncertain small fall.The details4-week pilot, 33 women: oat drink cut LDL 0.4 mmol/L vs cow's milk. Network review: total cholesterol −0.12, very uncertain.Who makes this claim: Oat-drink brandsWallerer et al. 2026 · 78 GoodRosendahl-Riise et al. 2026 · 57 Limited (independence estimated*)Ho et al. 2016 · 80 Strong (independence estimated*)
What it doesn't clearly do
Plant milks match dairy milk for protein, calcium, vitamin B12 and iodine, for people who swapShown not to helpModerate evidenceOf 129 Australian products, 81% added calcium, 27% B12 and 3% iodine; overall less protein, iodine and B vitamins than cow's milk, except soy's protein.The details129 Australian products: 81% calcium-fortified, 27% B12, 3% iodine; overall less protein, iodine, B2 and B12 than cow's milk; soy's protein similar.Who makes this claim: Plant-milk brands; plant-based diet advocatesHarmer, Craddock and Charlton 2025 · 53 LimitedDietitians Australia · Official dataUS Food and Drug Administration · Official dataDietary Guidelines for Americans 2025-2030 · Official data
Plant milks are healthier overall than dairy (weight, heart disease), in adultsNot yet knownMore data neededMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomes14 trials, 543 adults: weight, blood fats and blood sugar not clearly different from cow's milk, except soy; no studies of heart attacks or deaths.The details14 trials, 543 adults: weight, lipids and glucose not clearly different from cow's milk except soy (low certainty); no studies of heart attacks or death.Who makes this claim: Plant-based advocatesWallerer et al. 2026 · 78 GoodHeart Foundation 2019 · 52 Limited
Not reviewed yet
Plant milks avoid lactose-intolerance and cow's-milk-allergy symptomsUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNo reviewed evidence yet. Lactose-free dairy milk is another option for lactose intolerance; milk allergy in children is your doctor's call.Who makes this claim: Brands
Oat milk spikes blood sugar or contains harmful seed oilsUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNo reviewed evidence yet.Who makes this claim: Social media critics
Fact-checked 4 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
▸ See 1 more product▾ 1 more product, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
6Vitamin, mineral and fish-oil supplements1 protocol7 products5 studies⌄
For healthy, non-pregnant adults without a known deficiency, there's no clear evidence that vitamin and mineral supplements prevent heart disease or early death (multivitamin trials lean towards slightly fewer deaths; more data needed). Multivitamins slightly cut cancer in trials (low strength of evidence), and guidelines advise against beta-carotene and vitamin E for prevention. Fish-oil capsules make little or no difference to deaths overall, but slightly cut heart deaths and coronary heart disease events. If a doctor has prescribed a supplement for you, talk to your GP before stopping it. Our verdict: supported with changes; certainty moderate (low for multivitamins).
What the research found: Across 78 trials, vitamin and mineral supplements showed no clear effect on deaths; multivitamins leaned lower and cut cancer about 7% (2 to 12 fewer in 1,000). High-dose beta-carotene raised smokers' lung cancer risk about 20%. Fish oil slightly cut heart deaths, not deaths overall.
The figures and the limit
Across 78 trials, vitamin and mineral supplements showed no clear effect on deaths, though multivitamins leaned towards slightly fewer; multivitamins slightly cut cancer, and high-dose beta-carotene raised lung cancer risk in smokers. Multivitamins: deaths OR 0.94 (0.87–1.01), range includes no effect; cancer OR 0.93 (0.87–0.99), about 2 to 12 fewer cancers per 1,000 in adequately powered trials; beta-carotene: lung cancer OR 1.20 (1.01–1.42). Fish-oil capsules (86 trials): deaths RR 0.97, no clear difference (high certainty); cardiovascular deaths RR 0.92 (0.86–0.99, moderate certainty) and coronary heart disease events RR 0.91 (0.85–0.97, low; about 1 in 167) slightly lower.
The limit: Low strength of evidence for multivitamins; mostly US trials; one landmark trial in men only with industry support.
What it found: The US Preventive Services Task Force recommends against beta-carotene and vitamin E supplements to prevent heart disease or cancer: beta-carotene's harms outweigh its benefits, and vitamin E has no net benefit. For multivitamins and other supplements, it found the evidence insufficient to decide.
What it means for you: Don't take beta-carotene or vitamin E to prevent heart disease or cancer: no net benefit, and beta-carotene may harm.
▸ See 4 more studies▾ 4 more studies, best firstMembers
Protocol
Taking several supplements at once
What it is: Taking 4 or more supplement products at the same time, such as a multivitamin plus single vitamins, minerals, herbs, or social-media 'stacks' for sleep, focus or ageing.
–Not enough researchWorth doing?
Does taking several supplements at once improve your health?
Not yet knownEarly evidence
No study has tested taking 4 or more products together. Supplement use isn't linked with longer life, and multivitamin trials didn't cut deaths; one long trial found slightly fewer cancers.
Bottom line: No study shows more products bring more benefit, and each adds dose, interactions and cost. Keep to supplements with a clear reason, add up doses across labels, and show your list to your doctor or pharmacist.
21 possible effects searched · 28 sources rated · independently checked · 9 Nov 2026
EffectStrength
Health and lifespan? Not yet known
Link only (stand-in): use not linked with longer life; multivitamin trials didn't cut deaths
Nutrient shortfalls✓ Probably helps
Marker only: fewer intake shortfalls in US surveys; health not tested
Doses over upper limits✕ Probably harmful
Link only: B6 nerve-damage reports; B6 hides in many products
Liver injury✕ Probably harmful
Link only: supplements behind about 1 in 5 US drug liver injuries by 2013
Emergency visits✕ Probably harmful
Link only: about 23,000 US emergency visits a year
✓ helps · ✕ harms · ○ no clear difference · ? not known · dots: strength of evidence
How to do it: No study has followed people taking 4 or more products as a group, though about 1 in 6 US adults do. The evidence comes from supplement users in general and from trials of multivitamins.
Write down every product and its daily dose, including powders, drinks and gummies.
Add up each vitamin and mineral across all labels, especially vitamin B6, vitamin A, iron and zinc.
Keep your total vitamin B6 low: regulators can't rule out nerve damage below 50 mg a day, half the US upper limit of 100 mg.
Keep only products with a clear reason, such as a shortfall your doctor has found.
Show your list to your doctor or pharmacist, and before any surgery.
Tell whoever orders a blood test if you take biotin.
Avoid products sold for sex, weight loss or muscle building; hidden drugs are most common there.
Store supplements out of children's reach.
Sticking with it: No data on how many people keep taking several supplements after a year.
Cost: Four common products (a multivitamin, fish oil, magnesium and vitamin D) cost about US$180 a year at budget US store-brand prices (Nov 2026; our estimate); name brands cost more.
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Taking prescription medicines (especially blood thinners), pregnant or planning, kidney or liver disease, or surgery coming up: check your full list with your doctor or pharmacist first (your doctor's call).
Risks and who should be careful (24)
several products add up to doses above upper limits, with harms such as nerve damage from vitamin B6Probably harmfulEarly evidenceLink only · case reports and label and intake surveys, 2007–2026B6 from several products has caused nerve damage, often in people unaware a product had B6; exceeding other limits is less common.The studies (5)
1 regulator: nerve-damage reports · 3 label and intake surveys: some over limits
The detailsTGA (to 31 Oct 2025): 250 neuropathy reports with B6 products; risk 'particularly when taken in combination'; consumers often unaware products contain B6; can't be excluded below 50 mg/day. US label census 2026: 5.1% of adult B6 products direct 100 mg/day or more, 56.2% of those not sold as B6. NHANES: more users above ULs for 8–9 of 13 nutrients, mostly under 5%; zinc highest at 3.5%.Who makes this claim: Australia's TGA; US label researchers; NIH ODS
high-dose calcium from supplements is linked with more cancer deaths, in adultsProbably harmfulEarly evidenceLink only · about 6 yearsIn one US cohort, 1,000 mg or more of supplement calcium was linked with more cancer deaths; the absolute difference could be chance.The studies (1)
1 cohort: more cancer deaths at high supplement calcium
The detailsChen 2019 (NHANES 1999–2010): 1,000 mg/day or more of calcium from supplements vs none, cancer death rate ratio 1.53 (1.04 to 2.25); rate difference 1.5 per 1,000 person-years (−0.1 to 3.1).Who makes this claim: Cohort researchers
supplements block each other's absorption (calcium and iron, zinc and copper)UntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
high vitamin A from several products harms an unborn babyUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
potassium or magnesium from several products builds up in kidney diseaseUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
supplements taken with medicines cause harmful interactions, in people taking prescription medicinesProbably harmfulEarly evidenceLink only · surveys and case reportsAbout 1 in 7 older US adults risked a major interaction among their medicines and supplements; published cases include warfarin problems.The studies (4)
3 surveys: many at risk · 1 review of 46 cases: interactions
The detailsQato 2016: 15.1% of US adults aged 62–85 at risk of a potential major drug interaction in 2010–11, up from 8.4% in 2005–06; most interacting combinations involved medicines and supplements whose use had risen. Qato 2026 (news release): more than 1 in 5 at risk in 2021–23; whether supplements are counted isn't stated. Agbabiaka 2018 (UK): 32.6% of older concurrent users at risk. Shahverdian 2025: 46 case reports incl. warfarin interactions with vitamins E and K and omega-3.Who makes this claim: FDA; pharmacists; GP researchers
biotin in multivitamins and hair, skin and nail products makes blood tests wrong, including heart-attack testsProbably harmfulEarly evidenceDirect · regulator reports 2017–2022; lab surveyBiotin can make heart-attack and thyroid blood tests wrong; the US regulator reported one death from a missed heart attack.The studies (3)
The detailsFDA (page current June 2022): continued reports of falsely low troponin results; 2019 communication: one death. Shahverdian 2025: thyroid test interference among older-adult cases. Sanders 2021: interfering biotin levels in 0.8% of UK samples (most sensitive test); 0.8% in Australia and 7.4% in the US at a higher threshold.Who makes this claim: US FDA; laboratory specialists
supplements raise bleeding risk during surgeryUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
a long pill list leads people to miss their prescribed medicinesUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
herbal and multi-ingredient supplements cause liver injuryProbably harmfulEarly evidenceLink only · liver-injury network, 2004–2013Supplements caused about 1 in 5 drug-related liver injuries in a US network by 2013, and these cases were often severe.The studies (2)
1 liver-injury network · 1 national survey of use
The detailsNavarro 2014 (US DILIN, 839 patients, 2004–2013): supplements caused 130 cases (15.5%), rising from 7% to 20%; non-bodybuilding supplement cases led to death or transplant more often than medicine cases (13% vs 3%). Likhitsup 2024: an estimated 15.6 million US adults used 1 of 6 liver-linked botanicals in a month.Who makes this claim: US liver-injury network; regulators
supplements cause emergency visits and hospital staysProbably harmfulEarly evidenceLink only · national surveillance, 2004–2013Supplements caused about 23,000 US emergency visits a year (2004–2013); a fifth involved children, and older adults often choked on pills.The studies (1)
1 national surveillance study: emergency visits
The detailsGeller 2015: an estimated 23,005 ED visits (18,611 to 27,398) and 2,154 hospitalisations a year in the US; 21.2% unsupervised children; 37.6% of visits in 65+ from choking or swallowing problems with pills.Who makes this claim: US CDC and FDA researchers
some supplements contain hidden prescription drugsProbably harmfulEarly evidenceDirect · FDA testing, 2007–2016FDA testing found hidden drugs in 776 supplements over 10 years, mostly sold for sex, weight loss or muscle building.The studies (1)
1 analysis of FDA warnings: hidden drugs
The detailsTucker 2018: 776 adulterated products in FDA warnings 2007–2016, mostly sexual enhancement (45.5%), weight loss (40.9%) and muscle building (11.9%); 20.2% had more than one unapproved ingredient.Who makes this claim: US FDA; Australia's TGA safety alerts
taking many supplements leads people to skip proven care or a healthy dietUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
Vitamin B6 across productsVitamin B6 turns up in magnesium, energy and other products, not just B vitamins; too much can damage nerves. Stop and see a doctor if you get tingling, burning or numbness.The detailsTGA: 250 neuropathy reports to 31 Oct 2025; B6 widespread in listed medicines and food supplements; consumers often unaware; harm 'cannot be excluded for doses less than 50 mg/day'.Therapeutic Goods Administration · 85 Strong (official data)Staiger 2026 · 61 LimitedNHMRC and New Zealand Ministry of Health · 73 Good (official data)
Doubling up on vitamins and mineralsThe same vitamin or mineral can be in several of your products; add up each one's total from every label.The detailsMore supplement users above ULs for 8–9 of 13 nutrients, mostly under 5%; zinc highest at 3.5% with multivitamins; case reports of the same supplement from multiple sources.Blumberg et al. 2017 · 57 LimitedWallace et al. 2014 · 61 LimitedShahverdian and Jafari 2025 · 39 Weak
Prescription medicinesIf you take prescription medicines, show your full supplement list to your doctor or pharmacist before adding anything (your doctor's call).The detailsAbout 15.1% of US adults aged 62–85 were at risk of a potential major drug interaction in 2010–11, up from 8.4%; most interacting combinations involved medicines and supplements whose use had risen; warfarin interactions among case reports.Qato et al. 2016 · 58 LimitedQato et al. 2026 · 57 LimitedAgbabiaka et al. 2018 · 43 WeakShahverdian and Jafari 2025 · 39 Weak
Blood tests and biotinBiotin, in many multivitamins and hair, skin and nail products, can make heart and thyroid blood tests wrong; tell whoever orders your tests.The detailsFDA: biotin can cause falsely low troponin and wrong hormone results; one death reported.US Food and Drug Administration 2017, updated 5 November 2019 · 65 Good (official data)
Liver injuryRarely, herbal and multi-ingredient supplements injure the liver. Stop and see a doctor if your skin or eyes turn yellow or your urine turns dark.The detailsSupplements caused 15.5% of 839 US network liver-injury cases (2004–2013), rising from 7% to 20%; non-bodybuilding supplement cases led to death or transplant in 13% vs 3% for medicines.Navarro et al. 2014 · 66 Good
Hidden drugsProducts sold for sex, weight loss or muscle building are the most likely to contain hidden prescription drugs.The details776 products with undeclared drugs in FDA warnings 2007–2016; mostly sexual enhancement, weight loss and muscle building.Tucker et al. 2018 · 54 Limited
Children at homeStore supplements out of children's reach; a fifth of supplement emergency visits involved children who got into them.The details21.2% of supplement-related ED visits involved unsupervised children (US, 2004–2013).Geller et al. 2015 · 55 Limited · Conflicts not read · Methods not read
Large pills in older ageIn older adults, choking on large vitamin and mineral pills was the most common reason for a supplement emergency visit.The detailsAmong adults 65+, choking or swallowing problems caused 37.6% of supplement ED visits; micronutrients in 83.1% of these.Geller et al. 2015 · 55 Limited · Conflicts not read · Methods not read
Pregnancy, surgery and kidney diseaseIf you're pregnant or planning, having surgery, or have kidney disease, check your list with your doctor first.The detailsNot reviewed for this card.
CostFour common products cost about US$180 a year in the US and A$150–175 in Australia at budget prices (our estimate); name brands and specialty stacks cost more.The detailsUS, budget store brands, Nov 2026, each as directed: multivitamin US$10.37 for 200 days; fish oil US$22.47 for 60 days; magnesium US$7.63 for 250 days; vitamin D US$6.24 for 200 days, about US$178 a year. Australia, pharmacy budget lines: multivitamin A$12.99 for 100–200 days; fish oil A$24.99 for 133 days; magnesium A$24.00 for 250 days; vitamin D A$15.99 for 250 days, about A$150–175 a year. Older US users spent an average US$186 a year (Baird 2025, news report).Baird et al. 2025 · 58 Limited
PrivacyNo privacy issues.The detailsNo data collected by taking supplements.
The evidence, claim by claim (8)Members
What it does
Taking supplements fills nutrient shortfalls, in adultsProbably helpsEarly evidenceMarker only · national intake surveysIn US surveys, supplement users had fewer nutrient shortfalls; lower death rates were linked with nutrients from food, not supplements.The studies (2)
2 US survey analyses: fewer shortfalls; benefit linked only from food
The detailsBlumberg 2017 (NHANES 2009–12, 10,698): supplement users had fewer inadequate intakes for 6–10 of 17 nutrients. Chen 2019: lower death rates were linked with adequate nutrients from food only. Authors of Blumberg 2017 have industry ties (paper).Who makes this claim: Supplement makers and industry-funded analysts; dietitians for specific shortfalls
What it doesn't clearly do
Taking several supplements at once improves health and helps you live longer, in adultsNot yet knownEarly evidenceLink only · cohorts of 6–27 years; trials of 3½–11 yearsNo study has tested 4 or more products together; supplement use isn't linked with longer life, and combined-pill trials didn't cut deaths.The studies (9)
No stacking study · 3 cohorts, 1 trial review, 2 large trials: no longer life
The detailsNo study of 4 or more products. Stand-ins: supplement use not linked with lower death rates (NHANES, 30,899, 6.1 years; Swiss cohort, 4,261, 9 years; 390,124 multivitamin users, up to 27 years). Trials of combined pills: PHS II (14,641 male US doctors, 11 years) cut total cancer about 8% (17.0 vs 18.3 per 1,000 a year), with no clear difference in deaths; COSMOS (21,442 older US adults, 3.6 years) found no clear difference in cancer, heart disease or deaths. 21 multivitamin trials: deaths RR 0.98 (0.94 to 1.02). Antioxidant combinations didn't cut deaths in 78 trials. Wang 2026 (19 meta-analyses): no mortality benefit. USPSTF 2022: insufficient evidence for multivitamins.Who makes this claim: Social-media 'stack' promoters; longevity protocols; supplement marketing
Multivitamins and other combined pills cut cancer, in adultsMixed resultsEarly evidenceDirect · trials of 3½–11 years (stand-in)An 11-year trial in male doctors found about 1 fewer cancer per 1,000 men a year; a shorter trial in older adults didn't.The studies (3)
The detailsStand-in for stacking. PHS II (14,641 male US doctors, 11.2 years): total cancer HR 0.92 (0.86 to 0.998), 17.0 vs 18.3 per 1,000 person-years; cancer deaths HR 0.88 (0.77 to 1.01). COSMOS (21,442, 3.6 years): invasive cancer HR 0.97 (0.86 to 1.09). USPSTF review: about 7% fewer cancers with multivitamins, low strength of evidence.Who makes this claim: Multivitamin makers; trial authors; longevity protocols
Multivitamins keep memory and thinking sharper, in older adultsProbably doesn't helpEarly evidenceDirect · 2–3 years (stand-in)Older adults on a daily multivitamin for 2–3 years scored slightly higher on memory tests, but by less than a worthwhile amount.The studies (2)
1 trial programme, pooled: small gain below worthwhile size
The detailsStand-in for stacking. Vyas 2024 (3 COSMOS studies, 5,203 adults 60+): global cognition +0.07 SD (0.03 to 0.11), below our worthwhile size of SMD 0.2. Wang 2026: trial meta-analyses found gains in global cognition, episodic memory and immediate recall.Who makes this claim: Multivitamin makers; trial authors
Not reviewed yet
Combining supplements makes each work better ('synergy')UntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
Energy, focus or sleep 'stacks' work better than single productsUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
Taking many supplements slows ageingUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
Taking several supplements boosts immunityUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
Why there's no score yetNo score yet: no study has tested taking several supplements together, and the only benefit found is fewer nutrient shortfalls on paper.What you get 2/40: Almost nothing shown: supplement users had fewer intake shortfalls in surveys, a stand-in with no proven health gain; longer life wasn't linked with supplement use.How sure 10/25: Early: the one benefit rests on intake surveys, not health outcomes.Tradeoffs 10/20: Supplements cause about 1 in 5 drug-related liver injuries in a US network, serious but rare; vitamin B6 nerve damage, emergency visits, hidden drugs and wrong blood tests take off 4 more.Versus the alternative 5/15: About the same as taking only the supplements you need: neither has a proven long-term health benefit.Verdict Score out of 100, for someone who uses it as tested: what you get 40, how sure 25, tradeoffs 20, versus the alternative 15. Cost is shown, not scored. 75+ worth it · 60–74 worth it for some · 45–59 optional · under 45 skip it. With too little research on the main question, or only early research, there's no score or label, because a number would suggest we know.
Fact-checked 9 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
Best product
Fish-oil (omega-3) capsules
What it is: Capsules of fish oil; a standard 1,000 mg capsule holds about 300 mg of the omega-3s EPA and DHA.
Do fish-oil capsules protect your heart?
Shown to helpModerate evidence
A small benefit. In 86 trials of adults with or without heart disease, over 1–7 years, heart deaths fell about 8%; deaths overall and heart and stroke events overall didn't clearly change. Capsules slightly raise irregular-heartbeat risk.
+Slightly fewer heart deaths, about 8%, in 86 trialsModerate evidence
○Deaths from any cause, and heart and stroke events overall: no clear changeStrong evidence
+On dialysis, 4 g of fish oil a day roughly halved serious heart eventsEarly evidence
+Lowers triglycerides (a blood fat) by about 15%Moderate evidence
○Memory and dementia: no clear effect in 38 trials of older adultsModerate evidence
–Irregular heartbeat: 0.8 more per 1,000 a year at standard doses, 1.6 across all doses (our estimate)Moderate evidence
–In over-50s, slightly more depression: 13.9 versus 12.3 per 1,000 a yearEarly evidence
The triglyceride result measured a blood fat, not heart attacks or strokes
How to do it: A large 5-year trial used 1 g a day; the kidney dialysis trial used 4 g of fish oil a day (a high dose) for 3.5 years.
A standard 1,000 mg capsule holds about 300 mg of EPA and DHA; check the label.
Sticking with it: No data on how many keep taking it; in a 5-year trial, 9 in 10 stayed to the end.
Cost: About US$60–90 a year at 2–3 standard capsules a day (our estimate).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Atrial fibrillation or blood thinners: check with your doctor first; atrial fibrillation rose even at standard doses, and more above 1 g a day.
Risks and who should be careful (15)
fish oil raises the risk of atrial fibrillation (adults, more at higher doses)Shown to harmModerate evidenceIn 7 trials of 81,210 adults over about 5 years, atrial fibrillation was 25% higher: about 1.6 more per 1,000 a year (our estimate).The details7 trials, 81,210 adults: atrial fibrillation 25% higher (about 1.6 more per 1,000 yearly); 12% at 1 g daily or less, 49% above (our estimates).Who makes this claim: Cardiologists, trial reviews (Gencer 2021)Gencer et al. 2021 · 83 StrongAbuknesha et al. 2026 · 80 StrongChen et al. 2024 · 67 GoodO'Keefe et al. 2025 · 63 LimitedKhan et al. 2021 · 83 Strong
fish oil raises bleeding, especially with blood thinnersLeans toward harm; not yet knownMore data neededIn 11 trials of 120,643 people, bleeding wasn't clearly higher, including with antiplatelet medicines; high-dose prescription EPA: about 6 more in 1,000 bled.The details11 trials, 120,643 people: bleeding RR 1.09 (0.91–1.31), range includes no effect; antiplatelet use didn't raise it. High-dose prescription EPA: 0.6% more.Who makes this claim: Critics, surgeonsJavaid et al. 2024 · 79 GoodOkereke et al. 2021 · 89 Strong
regular fish-oil use is linked with a first stroke or atrial fibrillation in healthy peopleProbably harmfulEarly evidenceIn 415,737 UK adults, regular use was linked with 13% more atrial fibrillation; a re-analysis treating age differently found no link.The detailsUK Biobank, 415,737 adults: use linked with atrial fibrillation (HR 1.13; no absolute), not clearly stroke. Re-analysis modelling age differently: none. 7 trials: AF raised.Who makes this claim: BMJ Medicine 2024 coverageChen et al. 2024 · 67 GoodO'Keefe et al. 2025 · 63 LimitedAbdelhamid 2020 · 100 StrongGencer et al. 2021 · 83 Strong
capsules are oxidised or hold less omega-3 than the label says (Australia, New Zealand)Probably harmfulEarly evidenceA third of 26 Australian products exceeded total oxidation limits; an industry-funded test of 10 found all met their labels. Health effect untested.The details26 Australian products: a third exceeded total oxidation limits; an industry-funded test of 10 found all met labels. Health effect untested.Who makes this claim: University lab surveys, NZ 'fishy labels' coverage; GOED (industry) disputesHeller et al. 2019 · 45 Weak (independence estimated*)Nichols et al. 2016 · 41 WeakTGA · Official data
mercury or pollutants in capsulesUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: Critics
cod liver oil gives too much vitamin A (pregnancy)UntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: First principles
Irregular heartbeatAtrial fibrillation rose in trials, about 1.6 more per 1,000 a year (our estimate), and more above 1 g a day. Stomach upset and bruising matched placebo.The detailsAtrial fibrillation rose in trials (HR 1.25; about 1.6 more per 1,000 a year, our estimate), more above 1 g a day; a GRADE-graded 38-trial review found RR 1.26 (1.08 to 1.48), and a 35-trial review by authors with omega-3 industry ties found the rise only at high doses in people at high heart risk. Stomach upset and bruising were no different from placebo at 1 g a day.Gencer et al. 2021 · 83 StrongAbuknesha et al. 2026 · 80 StrongOkereke et al. 2021 · 89 StrongKhan et al. 2021 · 83 Strong
Bleeding and blood thinnersBleeding wasn't clearly higher (11 trials), but warfarin users weren't studied separately; prescription EPA added a little. Atrial fibrillation or blood thinners: your doctor's call.The detailsBleeding was 9% higher overall (11 trials), but the range includes no effect, and trials with more people on antiplatelet medicines didn't show more bleeding; people on anticoagulants such as warfarin weren't analysed separately. High-dose purified EPA, a prescription medicine, added about 0.6 percentage points to bleeding risk. If you have atrial fibrillation or take blood thinners, whether to take it is your doctor's call.Javaid et al. 2024 · 79 GoodAbuknesha et al. 2026 · 80 Strong
DoseAtrial fibrillation risk rose about 10–11% per extra gram a day. A standard 1,000 mg capsule holds about 300 mg EPA and DHA; labels suggest 2–3 daily.The detailsNo difference in heart effects by dose across 86 trials; atrial fibrillation risk rose about 10–11% per extra gram a day. A standard 1,000 mg capsule holds about 300 mg EPA+DHA (a common Australian product's label), and the label dose is 2–3 a day.Abdelhamid 2020 · 100 StrongGencer et al. 2021 · 83 Strong
Product qualityAustralia's TGA doesn't check AUST L capsules before sale; the US FDA doesn't approve supplements. A third of 26 Australian products exceeded oxidation limits.The detailsIn Australia, capsules sold as listed medicines (AUST L on the label) aren't evaluated by the TGA for quality, safety or efficacy before sale. A third of 26 Australian products exceeded total oxidation limits (2019); an industry-funded test of 10 found all met their labels (2016). In the US, fish oil is sold as a dietary supplement, which the FDA doesn't approve before sale. Whether oxidation matters for health is untested.TGA · Official dataHeller et al. 2019 · 45 Weak (independence estimated*)Nichols et al. 2016 · 41 WeakFDA · Official data
FlavouringsFlavourings stopped an oxidation test working in 2 of 10 products, so rancidity couldn't be checked in those.The detailsFlavourings interfered with an oxidation test in 2 of 10 products in one survey, so rancidity couldn't be checked in those.Nichols et al. 2016 · 41 Weak
Feeling protectedCapsules can feel like heart protection, but 86 trials found at most a small effect; the UK's NICE tells doctors not to offer them to prevent heart disease.The detailsTaking capsules can feel like heart protection, but 86 trials found little or no effect on deaths overall and only a small cut in heart deaths, and the UK's NICE (2023) tells doctors not to offer omega-3 compounds to prevent heart disease, except prescription icosapent ethyl in set cases.Abdelhamid 2020 · 100 StrongNICE NG238 · 81 Strong
Instead of eating fishCapsules could stand in for eating fish or other heart-health steps; this hasn't been tested.The detailsCapsules could stand in for eating fish or other heart-health steps.
Oily fish insteadOily fish 2–3 times a week (Australia's Heart Foundation) is linked with fewer heart deaths, though eating fish hasn't been trialled.The detailsOily fish about twice a week is the course's food step (Australia's Heart Foundation: 2–3 serves a week); eating fish is linked with fewer heart deaths, though it hasn't been trialled.Heart Foundation 2015 · 65 GoodGiosuè et al. 2022 · 74 Good
CostA common 1,000 mg capsule costs about US$60–90 a year at 2–3 a day (A$89–134; our estimate).The detailsA common 1,000 mg capsule, 400 for about A$49 at a large Australian pharmacy chain (1 Nov 2026): about A$89 a year at 2 a day and A$134 at 3 (our estimate).
The evidence, claim by claim (9)Members
What it does
Fish-oil capsules cut heart attacks, strokes and heart deaths (adults, with or without heart disease)Shown to helpModerate evidenceAcross 86 trials, heart deaths fell about 8% and about 1 in 167 people avoided a coronary event; deaths overall didn't clearly change.The detailsCochrane, 86 trials: cardiovascular deaths RR 0.92 (0.86–0.99, moderate certainty); coronary heart disease events RR 0.91 (0.85–0.97, low; about 1 in 167); deaths RR 0.97 and all heart and stroke events RR 0.96, no clear difference (high certainty). A review including prescription EPA: heart deaths RR 0.93 (absolute none given).Who makes this claim: Fish-oil makers, AARP explainer, Huberman Lab (not rated); NICE 2023 and Heart Foundation 2015 don't recommend capsules for preventionAbdelhamid 2020 · 100 StrongKhan et al. 2021 · 83 StrongNICE NG238 · 81 StrongHeart Foundation 2015 · 65 Good
High-dose fish oil cuts heart events in adults on haemodialysisProbably helpsEarly evidenceIn 1,228 adults on kidney dialysis over 3.5 years, 4 g of fish oil a day (a high dose) roughly halved serious heart events versus placebo. Your doctor's call.The detailsPISCES, 1,228 adults on haemodialysis (Canada, Australia), 4 g daily, 3.5 years: cut serious heart events, 0.31 vs 0.61 per 1,000 patient-days.Who makes this claim: PISCES investigators; a high dose (about 8 standard capsules' worth of EPA and DHA), so your doctor's callLok et al. 2026 · 87 Strong (independence estimated*)
Fish oil lowers triglycerides (adults with high triglycerides)Shown to helpModerate evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesFish oil lowered triglycerides by about 15% in trials, more at higher doses; heart events weren't clearly cut.The detailsTrials: long-chain omega-3 lowered triglycerides about 15%, more at higher doses (high certainty); heart events weren't clearly cut.Who makes this claim: Fish-oil brandsAbdelhamid 2020 · 100 Strong
What it doesn't clearly do
Fish oil protects memory and thinking and prevents dementia (older adults)Shown not to helpModerate evidenceIn 38 trials of 49,757 adults, fish oil made no clear difference to new dementia or memory problems.The details38 trials, 49,757 adults: no effect on new dementia or similar illness (RR 0.98) or new cognitive impairment (RR 0.99); moderate certainty.Who makes this claim: Fish-oil brands, Huberman Lab (not rated)Brainard et al. 2020 · 94 Strong (independence estimated*)
Fish oil improves mood and treats or prevents depression (adults)Probably harmfulEarly evidenceIn 18,353 over-50s over 5 years, 1 g daily slightly raised depression (13.9 versus 12.3 per 1,000 a year). Treatment trials: small, likely biased.The details18,353 over-50s: 1 g daily raised depression risk (13.9 vs 12.3 per 1,000 yearly; HR 1.13, 1.01–1.26); mood scores unchanged. Treatment trials: small, likely biased.Who makes this claim: Fish-oil brands, Huberman Lab (not rated)Okereke et al. 2021 · 89 StrongAppleton et al. 2021 · 89 Strong (independence estimated*)
Fishy burps, reflux and stomach upsetShown not to helpModerate evidenceIn a 5-year trial, stomach upset was 35.2% on 1 g a day versus 35.1% on placebo: no clear difference.The detailsVITAL, 1 g daily vs placebo: stomach upset or pain 35.2% vs 35.1%; easy bruising 24.8% vs 25.1%; fishy burps and reflux weren't reported.Who makes this claim: Users, criticsOkereke et al. 2021 · 89 Strong
Not reviewed yet
Fish oil eases joint pain and inflammation (arthritis)UntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: Fish-oil brands
High-dose prescription EPA (icosapent ethyl) cuts heart events in people on statins with high triglycerides (REDUCE-IT)UntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. It's a prescription medicine, so it's your doctor's call.The detailsNot yet rated: a prescription medicine, so your doctor's call.Who makes this claim: Cardiology trials, the drug's maker
Fish oil relieves dry eyesUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority); claimed in the most-viewed fish-oil video on our goal pages.Who makes this claim: YouTube: 'I Took Omega 3 Fish Oil for 90 days' (2.7M views)
Fact-checked 1 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
▸ See 6 more products▾ 6 more products, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
7Diet drinks and sweeteners1 product5 studies⌄
Water first. Swapping a sugary drink for a diet one led to about 1 kg less weight in trials, though not in the best-run ones. The WHO advises against using sweeteners for weight control, and long-term studies link diet drinks with slightly higher disease risk, so we don't recommend diet drinks as a health measure. Our verdict: weak or mixed; certainty low.
What the research found: Swapping sugary drinks for diet ones meant about 1 kg less weight in trials, but not in the best-run ones; a sweetener trial kept 1.6 kg more off at a year. Observational studies link each daily 355 mL diet drink with 6% higher death risk.
The figures and the limit
In trials, diet drinks instead of sugary ones meant about 1 kg less weight, a small effect, but not in the best-run trials. −1.06 kg (17 trials, moderate certainty); −1.08 kg (78 trials, low certainty; no significant effect in the trials at low risk of bias); SWEET: 1.6 kg more kept off at 1 year. In cohort studies, each 355 mL of diet drink a day was linked with 6% higher risk of death.
The limit: Short trials, much of the evidence from authors with sweetener-industry ties.
What it found: The World Health Organization's 2023 guideline advises against non-sugar sweeteners to control weight or reduce disease risk: they gave no long-term body-fat benefit, and long-term use may be linked with type 2 diabetes, heart disease and death. It's conditional and doesn't cover people with diabetes.
What it means for you: Don't rely on sweeteners or diet drinks to manage your weight; reduce sweetness overall and drink water.
▸ See 4 more studies▾ 4 more studies, best firstMembers
Product
Diet (artificially sweetened) drinks
Does swapping sugary drinks for diet drinks help keep weight down?
Probably helpsEarly evidence
A little. In trials of adults with overweight, swapping sugary drinks for diet drinks cut about 1 kg more over about 12 weeks; the best-run trials found no clear difference. Water is the free first choice.
+Instead of sugary drinks: about 1 kg more weight lost over about 12 weeksEarly evidence
+Swapping from sugary drinks linked with 11% less heart diseaseEarly evidence
○Blood sugar: no clear difference after swapping from sugary drinksMore data needed
○Blood sugar versus water: a rise too small to matter; gut bacteria changed short-termEarly evidence
–Each extra 355 mL a day (about a can) linked with 6% more deathsEarly evidence
–Aspartame rated 'possibly' cancer-causing; normal intake stays under the safe limitEarly evidence
How to do it: Trials swapped sugary drinks for diet drinks for a median of 12 weeks; a year-long weight program compared diet drinks with water.
Sticking with it: No data on how many keep it up; in a year-long trial, 6 in 10 adults finished.
Cost: About US$240–470 a year at one can a day, about the same as sugary drinks (our estimate).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Phenylketonuria: avoid aspartame, which contains phenylalanine. Already drinking water: no need to switch; a year-long trial found a 1.4 kg difference, too small to matter.
Risks and who should be careful (14)
diet drinks are linked with more type 2 diabetes, heart disease, stroke and death in long-term studies (adults)Probably harmfulEarly evidenceIn studies of up to 848,473 people, each extra 355 mL a day was linked with 6% more deaths; higher-risk people switching may explain it.The detailsCohorts, up to 848,473 people: each daily 355 mL linked with 6% higher death risk (HR 1.06); reverse causation possible.Who makes this claim: WHO 2023, Dr Axe and 'a diet cola every day' articles (not rated)Beigrezaei 2025 · 85 StrongRios-Leyvraz 2022 · 81 StrongWHO 2023 guideline · 79 GoodLee et al. 2022 · 71 Good
aspartame causes cancerMixed resultsEarly evidenceIARC rates aspartame 'possibly' cancer-causing; the safe limit stays. A French study suggests, if causal, about 0.7 more cancers per 1,000 a year (our estimate).The detailsIARC: 'possibly' carcinogenic; JECFA: limit unchanged (over 9–14 cans daily). Cohort: linked with 15% more cancer (our estimate, if causal: 0.7 more per 1,000 yearly).Who makes this claim: IARC 2023 coverage, criticsIARC and JECFA 2023 · 59 Limited (independence estimated*)FSANZ media statement on aspartame · Official dataDebras et al. 2022 · 73 Good
sweeteners disrupt gut bacteria and blood-sugar controlNot yet knownEarly evidenceMeasured by a blood test or marker, not health outcomesVersus water, long-term blood sugar was 0.21 points higher, too small to matter. In 120 adults over 2 weeks, saccharin and sucralose worsened glucose responses.The detailsVersus water, pooled trials: HbA1c 0.21% higher (0.02 to 0.40), below our 0.3-point threshold. 120 adults, 2 weeks: saccharin and sucralose worsened glucose responses.Who makes this claim: Huberman Lab, Dr Axe (not rated)Suez et al. 2022 · 62 Limited (independence estimated*)McGlynn 2022 · 88 StrongOdegaard et al. 2026 · 62 Limited (independence estimated*)
sweet taste increases cravings and appetite, so people eat moreUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: Critics, popular articles
erythritol raises clotting and heart-attack riskUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: Critics, 2023 news coverage
acid erodes teethUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: Dentists, popular articles
Long-term health linksStudies following people link diet drinks with more deaths, type 2 diabetes and stroke, but people at higher risk may switch to them. Aspartame: 'possibly' cancer-causing; safe limits unchanged.The detailsLong-term cohorts link each daily 355 mL with 6% higher death risk (HR 1.06), and link diet drinks with type 2 diabetes (HR 1.16, high vs low intake) and stroke (HR 1.09 per daily 250 mL); absolute figures not available. These compare more with less diet drink, not swaps from sugary drinks, and may reflect people at higher risk switching to diet drinks. Aspartame: IARC rates it 'possibly' carcinogenic on limited evidence; JECFA and FSANZ (Australia and NZ) kept the intake limit.Beigrezaei 2025 · 85 StrongIARC and JECFA 2023 · 59 Limited (independence estimated*)FSANZ media statement on aspartame · Official dataDebras et al. 2022 · 73 Good
Phenylketonuria and diabetesPhenylketonuria: aspartame contains phenylalanine (labels warn). The WHO's advice against sweeteners for weight control doesn't cover people who already have diabetes.The detailsPhenylketonuria: aspartame contains phenylalanine (labels warn; not rated). The WHO's advice against sweeteners for weight control doesn't cover people who already have diabetes.WHO 2023 guideline · 79 Good
Aspartame safe limitA 70 kg adult would need more than 9–14 cans a day, with no other aspartame, to pass the safe limit of 40 mg per kg a day.The detailsA 70 kg adult would need more than 9–14 cans of diet soft drink a day, with no other aspartame, to pass JECFA's limit of 40 mg/kg a day.IARC and JECFA 2023 · 59 Limited (independence estimated*)
Sweeteners and gut bacteriaIn a 2-week trial of 120 healthy adults, saccharin and sucralose changed gut bacteria and worsened glucose responses; size and long-term effects unknown.The detailsThe sweeteners are the additive: in a 2-week trial of 120 healthy adults, saccharin and sucralose changed gut bacteria and worsened glucose responses; effect sizes and long-term effects unknown.Suez et al. 2022 · 62 Limited (independence estimated*)
'Zero sugar' isn't zero effectVersus water, diet drinks gave slightly higher long-term blood sugar but slightly lower blood pressure in trials; with type 2 diabetes, one 24-week trial favoured diet drinks.The details'Zero sugar' doesn't mean zero effect: compared with water, diet drinks gave HbA1c 0.21% higher but systolic blood pressure 2.63 mmHg lower in pooled trials; a 24-week trial in type 2 diabetes found HbA1c 0.29% lower on diet drinks than on water.McGlynn 2022 · 88 StrongOdegaard et al. 2026 · 62 Limited (independence estimated*)
Sweet cravingsA sweet taste could keep a sweet habit going or raise appetite; this hasn't been tested.The detailsA sweet taste could keep a sweet habit going or raise appetite; not tested in our rated sources.
Water insteadWater is free and the first choice; diet drinks did no better for weight, or slightly better. Swapping sugary drinks for water was linked with less type 2 diabetes.The detailsWater is free and the course's first choice; trial reviews found diet drinks no better than water for weight, or 0.8 kg better (low certainty), and a year-long industry-funded trial found 1.4 kg more weight loss with diet drinks, judged not clinically meaningful. In cohorts, swapping sugary drinks for water was linked with less type 2 diabetes (RR 0.96). The WHO advises against sweeteners for weight control.WHO 2023 guideline · 79 GoodMcGlynn 2022 · 88 StrongLee et al. 2022 · 71 GoodHarrold et al. 2024 · 65 Good
CostAbout US$240–470 (A$365–730) a year at one can a day, about the same as sugary drinks (our estimate); tap water is free.The detailsAbout A$365–730 a year at one 375 mL can a day, about the same as sugary drinks (our estimate); tap water about A$0.
The evidence, claim by claim (6)Members
What it does
Swapping sugary drinks for diet drinks helps weight loss and keeping it off (adults with overweight)Probably helpsEarly evidenceAdults with overweight: 12 swap trials (601 people) lost about 1 kg more than on sugary drinks; another review: no clear effect in best-run trials.The detailsAdults with overweight: 17-trial network (12 testing swaps, 601 people) cut 1.06 kg vs sugary drinks, small; another review: no clear effect in low-bias trials.Who makes this claim: Drink makers, BioLayne (not rated)McGlynn 2022 · 88 StrongShahinfar 2025 · 83 Strong (independence estimated*)Pang 2025 · 70 GoodWHO 2023 guideline · 79 GoodHarrold et al. 2024 · 65 Good
Swapping sugary for diet drinks is linked with less heart disease and fewer deaths (adults)Probably helpsEarly evidenceStudies following people linked swapping with 11% less coronary heart disease (6 studies) and 4% fewer deaths (one); no absolute figures; authors had industry ties.The detailsCohorts: swapping linked with 11% less coronary heart disease (RR 0.89, 6 cohorts), 4% fewer deaths (one); no absolute figures; low certainty; industry-tied authors.Who makes this claim: Drink makersLee et al. 2022 · 71 Good
What it doesn't clearly do
Diet drinks instead of sugary ones improve blood sugar and lower type 2 diabetes risk (adults)Not yet knownMore data neededIn 17 trials, swapping made no clear difference to long-term or fasting blood sugar; studies following people found no clear link with type 2 diabetes.The detailsTrials of the swap (17): no clear difference in HbA1c or fasting glucose. Cohorts: no clear link with type 2 diabetes (low certainty).Who makes this claim: Drink makers, diabetes advocatesMcGlynn 2022 · 88 StrongLee et al. 2022 · 71 Good
Not reviewed yet
No sugar, so no tooth decay from the drinkUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: Drink makers
Phenylketonuria: aspartame must be avoidedUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet. Aspartame contains phenylalanine, and labels warn people with phenylketonuria.The detailsNot yet rated; aspartame contains phenylalanine, and labels carry a warning for people with phenylketonuria.Who makes this claim: Food labels
Caffeine in diet colasUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The detailsNot yet rated (low priority).Who makes this claim: First principles
Fact-checked 1 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
+ Add a note
8Coffee and tea5 studies⌄
For healthy adults, coffee and tea at usual amounts appear safe: up to 400 mg of caffeine a day raises no safety concerns, and up to 200 mg a day in pregnancy. Studies linking them with fewer deaths are observational, so don't start drinking them for your health. Our verdict: weak or mixed; certainty very low.
What the research found: In observational studies, 3 to 4 cups of coffee a day were linked with about 17% lower death rates and 15% less cardiovascular disease than none, and each daily cup of tea with about 4% fewer heart deaths. Genetic studies found no effect on deaths.
The figures and the limit
Drinking coffee and tea is linked with lower death and cardiovascular disease rates, but the evidence is low to very low certainty. Coffee, 3–4 cups a day vs none: death RR 0.83, cardiovascular death RR 0.81, cardiovascular disease RR 0.85. Tea: about 4% lower risk of cardiovascular death with each daily cup.
The limit: Observational, low to very low certainty; genetic studies show no effect on deaths and a small rise in LDL cholesterol; the tea review was industry-funded.
What it found: The European Food Safety Authority's expert panel concluded that up to 400 mg of caffeine a day raises no safety concerns for healthy adults, single doses up to 200 mg are safe, and up to 200 mg a day is safe in pregnancy and breastfeeding.
What it means for you: Keep caffeine to 400 mg a day or less, or 200 mg or less if you're pregnant.
▸ See 4 more studies▾ 4 more studies, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
9Breakfast4 studies⌄
Eat breakfast if you want it. In trials, eating it didn't help weight loss and skipping it didn't cause weight gain, though skipping raised LDL cholesterol a little in trials of 4 weeks or less (not clearly in longer ones). If you take insulin or other diabetes medicines that can cause low blood sugar, talk to your GP before skipping meals. Our verdict: supported; certainty low.
What the research found: In trials lasting a few weeks, eating or skipping breakfast changed weight by under 1 kg, too little to matter. Skipping raised LDL ('bad') cholesterol by about 0.26 mmol/L (our estimate) in trials of 4 weeks or less, not clearly in longer ones.
The figures and the limit
In trials lasting a few weeks, skipping breakfast didn't cause weight gain; differences were under 1 kg, no worthwhile effect. Breakfast eaters +0.44 kg (0.07 to 0.82) vs skippers; skipping −0.66 kg (−1.09 to −0.24); but skipping raised LDL cholesterol by about 0.26 mmol/L (0.13 to 0.38; our estimate from mg/dL), driven by trials of 4 weeks or less; in longer trials, about 0.12 mmol/L, no clear difference.
What it found: The 2023 Nordic Nutrition Recommendations, from the Nordic Council of Ministers, set no recommendation on meal patterns, including breakfast: the reviews behind it were of low to critically low quality, and there were too few data to judge effects on weight.
What it means for you: Nordic guidelines found too little evidence to recommend breakfast for weight, so go with your appetite.
▸ See 3 more studies▾ 3 more studies, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
10Low-FODMAP diet9 studies1 website⌄
A treatment for diagnosed irritable bowel syndrome (IBS), not a healthy-eating pattern. In IBS it eases symptoms, including bloating, for many people; simpler IBS diet advice also helps, and some guidelines try it first. It's short-term: cut high-FODMAP foods for a trial of about 4–6 weeks, then add them back one at a time. See your GP first to rule out coeliac disease (get tested before you cut out wheat), ideally follow it with a dietitian, and talk to your GP first if you've had an eating disorder. Without IBS there's no good evidence it helps. Our verdict: supported with changes (for IBS only); certainty moderate for IBS, low for long-term use and very low without IBS.
What the research found: In 24 IBS trials, low-FODMAP about halved the chance symptoms didn't improve versus a usual diet, and eased bloating; simpler IBS diet advice also helped. It made no difference in 25 healthy adults, and in IBS trials often lowered bifidobacteria, a type of gut bacteria.
The figures and the limit
In 24 trials in adults with IBS, low-FODMAP about halved the chance that symptoms didn't improve versus a usual diet (RR 0.51, 0.37 to 0.70) and eased bloating (RR 0.55, 0.37 to 0.80); simpler IBS advice also helped (RR 0.62; 8 trials). No absolute figures available. In 25 healthy adults it made no difference to gut symptoms, and in 9 of 11 IBS trials it lowered bifidobacteria.
The limit: Diets can't be blinded; trials were short and mostly in specialist clinics; some trial authors work in a university department that earns income from a low-FODMAP app (trial disclosures).
What it found: The American College of Gastroenterology's 2021 guideline, using formal evidence grading, recommends a limited trial of a low-FODMAP diet to improve overall IBS symptoms. It also suggests blood tests to rule out coeliac disease in people with IBS and diarrhoea.
What it means for you: Treat low-FODMAP as a limited trial, not a permanent diet, after your GP has tested you for coeliac disease.
▸ See 8 more studies▾ 8 more studies, best firstMembers
Best for: Our goal page for IBS: rated videos on managing symptoms, including the low-FODMAP diet with a dietitian.
+ Add a note
11Quitting sugar10 studies⌄
Keep free sugars (added sugars, honey, syrups and juice) under 10% of your energy, mostly by cutting sugary drinks, which are linked with type 2 diabetes; more sugar is also linked with more tooth decay. But cutting sugar made no worthwhile difference to weight on its own (0.80 kg), there's little evidence sugar is addictive in humans, and whole fruit is linked with fewer deaths, so keep it. In the US: the 2025–2030 guidelines recommend no amount of added sugar, and no more than 10 g in a meal. If you've had an eating disorder, talk to your GP before setting strict food rules. Our verdict: supported with changes (cut free sugars, keep fruit); certainty moderate (low for the addiction claim).
What the research found: Cutting sugar made little difference to weight in trials (0.8 kg more lost); swapping it for other carbohydrates made none. In long-term studies, each daily sugary drink was linked with 25% higher type 2 diabetes risk, and more fruit and vegetables with 13% fewer deaths.
The figures and the limit
In trials of adults eating freely, cutting sugars led to 0.80 kg more weight loss (0.39 to 1.21), no worthwhile effect; swapping sugar for other carbohydrates with the same energy changed weight by 0.04 kg. In cohort studies, each extra daily sugary drink is linked with 25% higher type 2 diabetes risk, and more fruit and vegetables with fewer deaths (RR 0.87, 0.85 to 0.88; 1.9 million people). No absolute figures available.
The limit: Weight trials were few and short; the diabetes and death links are observational; no trial tested quitting sugar entirely; the US guideline doesn't grade the evidence behind its advice.
What it found: The World Health Organization's 2015 guideline strongly recommends adults and children keep free sugars under 10% of daily energy, and suggests under 5%. Free sugars include added sugars, honey, syrups and fruit juice. It drew on body-weight and tooth-decay evidence.
What it means for you: This is where the under-10% limit comes from, and why honey, syrups and juice count towards it.
▸ See 9 more studies▾ 9 more studies, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
12High-protein diets for weight loss12 studies⌄
Reach your protein target (see Know and reach your protein target); if you strength train, about 1.6 g/kg. Going higher while dieting made no worthwhile difference to weight: 0.79 kg over about 12 weeks, and no clear difference in trials of a year or more. Gut side effects such as constipation were more common. Healthy kidneys showed no consistent harm over months; if you have kidney disease, talk to your GP or a dietitian first. Where you can, choose plant protein, which is linked with fewer deaths. Our verdict: not supported as a weight-loss tool; certainty low.
What the research found: In trials averaging 12 weeks, high-protein weight-loss diets gave 0.79 kg more loss, too little to matter; year-long or longer trials showed no clear difference. Kidney blood tests didn't change in adults without kidney disease. The most plant protein was linked with 8% fewer deaths.
The figures and the limit
In 24 trials averaging 12 weeks (1,063 adults), high-protein weight-loss diets led to 0.79 kg more weight loss (0.08 to 1.50), no worthwhile effect, and 0.87 kg more fat lost; lean mass kept differed by 0.43 kg, little or no difference. In 15 trials of a year or more: 0.39 kg (−0.65 to 1.43; 971 people). In 19 trials of adults without kidney disease, blood creatinine didn't change. The highest plant-protein intakes are linked with 8% fewer deaths (RR 0.92; 32 cohorts; no absolute figure available).
The limit: Most weight trials were short. One graded review found 1.21 kg more lost at 3 months, but we follow the trials of a year or more; it was funded by a pasta maker and one author was its employee (paper disclosure). The evidence behind the US protein target is disputed; three of six authors of the main critique declare beef or dairy industry fees or grants (paper disclosure).
What it found: Australia's and New Zealand's government reference values, set by an NHMRC expert working party, put daily protein needs at 0.84 g per kg of body weight for men and 0.75 g for women aged 19–70, rising to 1.07 g and 0.94 g over 70.
What it means for you: Adults under 70 need under 1 g/kg; 1.6 g/kg is a strength-training target, not a weight-loss tool.
▸ See 11 more studies▾ 11 more studies, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
13Anti-inflammatory diets10 studies⌄
There's no single anti-inflammatory diet. Eating patterns scored as less inflammatory, mostly Mediterranean-style eating, are linked with less heart disease and bowel cancer, and in trials the Mediterranean diet lowered some inflammation markers a little. Lists of 'inflammatory' foods to avoid aren't supported: seed oils, for example, didn't clearly raise inflammation markers in trials (see Seed oils). Turmeric in cooking is fine. Turmeric or curcumin supplements may ease osteoarthritis pain short term (very low certainty) but are linked with rare, serious liver injury: avoid them if you have, or have had, liver disease. Our verdict: weak or mixed; certainty low (very low for turmeric).
What the research found: Long-term studies linked the most pro-inflammatory diets with 23% more cardiovascular disease and 16% more bowel cancer. In trials, the Mediterranean diet slightly lowered one inflammation marker. Australia's TGA received 18 reports of liver injury, including one death, linked with turmeric or curcumin products.
The figures and the limit
In 30 cohort studies (669,205 people), the most pro-inflammatory diets are linked with 23% more cardiovascular disease (HR 1.23, 1.14 to 1.33) and, in another review, 16% more bowel cancer (RR 1.16, 1.04 to 1.29); no absolute figures available. In 22 trials, the Mediterranean diet cut IL-6 by 1.07 pg/mL (0.20 to 1.94) but not clearly CRP; DASH, vegetarian and vegan diets showed no clear effect. In Australia: the TGA received 18 reports of liver injury, including one death, linked with turmeric or curcumin products.
The limit: Mostly observational; inflammation markers aren't health outcomes; turmeric trials were small and short; two authors of the inflammatory-index umbrella review list a company affiliation, and the index is a registered trademark (paper record).
What it found: The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners' 2018 osteoarthritis guideline neither recommends nor advises against turmeric (curcuma) for knee or hip arthritis. Three small, industry-sponsored trials showed short-term benefit over 6–8 weeks, but evidence quality was low and results inconsistent.
What it means for you: Australian GP guidance doesn't back turmeric for arthritis; the evidence is too weak to rely on.
▸ See 9 more studies▾ 9 more studies, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
14Vitamin C and zinc for colds11 studies⌄
Taking vitamin C every day doesn't prevent colds for most people and shortens them only slightly; starting it once a cold begins didn't help. People in intense physical training may get fewer colds on it. Zinc lozenges or syrup started early may shorten a cold (low certainty), with side effects such as nausea or a bad taste in about 1 extra person in 7. Don't use zinc nasal sprays or gels: they've been linked with loss of smell. High-dose vitamin C raises oxalate in urine, and in men 1,000 mg a day or more from supplements is linked with more kidney stones. Our verdict: weak or mixed; certainty moderate for vitamin C, low for zinc.
What the research found: Daily vitamin C didn't prevent colds, except in athletes and soldiers (about halved), and shortened a week-long cold about half a day (our estimate). Zinc shortened colds about 2 days, but zinc nasal sprays are linked with lost smell. In men, 1,000 mg or more daily was linked with 19% more kidney stones.
The figures and the limit
Regular vitamin C (200 mg a day or more) didn't cut colds in the general community (RR 0.97, 0.94 to 1.00; 10,708 people) but about halved them in 598 marathon runners, skiers and soldiers; it cut cold length by 8% in adults, about half a day for a 7-day cold (our estimate). Zinc taken during a cold cut its length by 2.37 days (0.53 to 4.21; 8 trials, low certainty). In men, 1,000 mg a day or more of vitamin C is linked with 19% more kidney stones (HR 1.19, 1.01 to 1.40; 3 cohorts). In the US: the FDA warned in 2009 against three zinc nasal products after more than 130 reports of lost smell.
The limit: Many vitamin C trials are old; zinc trials varied in dose and form, and the two main zinc reviews, similarly strong, disagree on prevention; the kidney-stone link is observational; we found no current Australian guidance.
What it found: The US National Institutes of Health's fact sheet says regular vitamin C doesn't cut colds in most people but shortens them slightly (8% in adults, 14% in children); starting after symptoms begin doesn't appear to help. The adult upper limit is 2,000 mg a day.
What it means for you: US government advice agrees: daily vitamin C shortens colds slightly; starting once a cold begins doesn't help.
▸ See 10 more studies▾ 10 more studies, best firstMembers
+ Add a note
15Organic food1 protocol⌄
Leans toward helping; not yet known. Organic eating is linked with slightly less heart disease and obesity, but buyers differ in income and lifestyle. Don't let its price mean less fruit and vegetables.
Protocol
Organic food
–Early research onlyWorth doing?
Does eating organic food help you live longer and healthier?
Leans toward helping; not yet knownMore data needed
Studies of adults, some over 16 years, link organic eating with slightly less heart disease and obesity, and lean toward 7% less cancer, but organic buyers differ in income and lifestyle. Eating more fruit and vegetables matters far more.
Bottom line: Fruit and vegetables, the best-evidenced eating patterns and activity matter far more for healthy years than organic food; if its price means less produce, that's likely a net loss. Pesticide harms are clearest from home spraying and farm work.
117 possible effects searched · 320 sources rated · independently checked · 5 Nov 2026
Effect · through foodStrength
Cancer✓ Leans toward helping; not yet known
Link only: 3 studies of adults over 4½–15 years; farm work linked with lymphoma
At farm or spraying levels:✕ Probably harmful
Heart disease and weight✓ Probably helps
Link only, up to 16 years: slightly less; metabolic syndrome results mixed
Cancer treatment✕ Probably harmful
Direct: pancreatic cancer, organic-diet regimen 4 months' survival versus 14 on chemotherapy
Parkinson's, dementia and ALS? Not yet known
Never studied through food; 124 studies link work exposure with Parkinson's
At farm or spraying levels:✕ Probably harmful
Children's brain development± Mixed results
Link only: pregnancy studies split; farm-community and home spraying linked with lower IQ
At farm or spraying levels:✕ Probably harmful
Raw milk infections✕ Shown to harm
US outbreaks 2009–2014: raw dairy caused 96% of dairy outbreak illnesses
Toxoplasma in pregnancy✕ Probably harmful
Marker only: organic and free-range pigs infected far more often
Pesticide traces (a stepping stone)✓ Shown to help
Marker only: adults' urine traces 89–91% lower within 1–2 weeks
✓ helps · ✕ harms · ○ no clear difference · ? not known · dots: strength of evidence
Knowing would need studies following organic and conventional eaters for deaths and healthy years, with strong control for income, diet and activity.
How to do it: In the pesticide trials, adults ate mostly or fully organic food for 1–2 weeks, and children aged 3–12 for 5–40 days; that measured pesticides in urine, not illness. The health evidence comes from studies of adults' usual eating, some over 16 years.
Packaged foods: the organic label doesn't change sugar, salt, fat or how processed a food is.
Australia: organic certification isn't required for food sold locally, so look for a certifier's mark.
Produce: if you buy some organic, choose high-residue foods eaten with the skin, like berries, leafy greens, apples and grapes.
Wash, peel or cook produce to cut residues; keep eating 2 serves of fruit and 5 of vegetables daily.
Pregnancy: cook pork and lamb thoroughly; Toxoplasma is more common in organic and free-range pigs.
Drink only pasteurised milk, organic or not. In Australia, raw cow's milk can't legally be sold for drinking.
Baby cereals: organic doesn't lower arsenic; use oat, barley or mixed-grain cereals, not only rice.
Wash produce and cook meat the same way whether it's organic or not.
Sticking with it: No data on how many keep buying organic food.
Cost: Organic versions cost about 7–82% more, depending on the food (US, 2010 data).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Skip it if the price means less fruit and vegetables. Pregnant or breastfeeding on organic milk: check iodine with your doctor or midwife. Having cancer treatment: don't replace it with an organic-diet regimen; that's your doctor's call. If food rules are part of eating-disorder recovery, your treatment team can advise.
Risks and who should be careful (27)
organic milk has less iodineShown to harmModerate evidenceMarker only · food samplesBy supplying less iodine. Half a litre of organic milk gives about 53% of daily iodine versus 88% for conventional (European data).The studies (2)
2 reviews: less iodine in organic milk
The details500 mL organic milk: about 53% of daily iodine vs 88% conventional (mostly European data); selenium also lower. 34-country review: gap mainly in summer.Who makes this claim: Średnicka-Tober 2016
organic produce, chicken and eggs carry more food-poisoning bacteriaNot yet knownMore data neededMarker only · farm and shop samplesE. coli on produce and shop chicken bacteria were similar; Campylobacter was commoner on organic chicken farms; caged hens had more Salmonella.The studies (6)
Produce, shop chicken: similar · organic farms: more Campylobacter · EU caged hens: more Salmonella
The detailsReview of food studies: E. coli contamination, no clear difference (low certainty); bacteria on retail chicken and pork common whatever the farming method. Golden 2020 (72 US studies): farm-environment Campylobacter 52.8% alternative vs 15.8% conventional; retail samples similar for both pathogens. EFSA 2019: less Salmonella in non-cage (barn, free-range, organic) laying hens; outdoor access inconclusive. No study compares human illness by farming method. Thorough cooking and kitchen hygiene remove the hazard whatever the farming method. Australia: a Canberra outbreak was traced to poor egg cleaning on one local free-range farm (Australia).Who makes this claim: Food-safety critics; Food-safety critics of organic farming
the price, or residue fears, lead people to eat less fruit and vegetablesLeans toward harm; not yet knownAnecdotalLink only · one surveyLow-income US shoppers told about residues more often said they'd buy no fruit or vegetables; buying wasn't measured.The studies (2)
1 survey: residue messages put some shoppers off produce · Cancer Council: eat produce either way
The detailsUS low-income shoppers: after residue warnings, more said they'd buy no produce (survey, part-funded by a produce-industry group, as reported).Who makes this claim: Produce-industry groups; Cancer Council NSW (cost is a barrier)
milk from cows given growth hormone (rbST) raises cancer riskLeans toward no harm; not yet knownAnecdotalMarker only · product testsUS (FDA) and WHO–FAO (JECFA) experts judged milk from rbST-treated cows safe; no study has measured cancer.The studies (7)
2 expert bodies: safe · 2 milk tests: organic lower IGF-1 · no cancer studies
The detailsNo study links rbST or organic milk with cancer. Organic milk had less IGF-1 in two tests (67% and 13% less). JECFA (1998, reaffirmed 2013): no dietary hazard; ingested IGF-1 at 'extremely low concentrations' compared with the body's own. FDA: bST is broken down in digestion. Country facts: approved in the US since 1993 (US); never approved in Australia, decided 1992 (Australia); banned in the EU from 2000 (EU); refused in Canada in 1999 for animal-health reasons. Conflict facts: Welsh 2019 was funded by the Organic Center and one author holds equity in a sampled milk company; Vicini 2008's lead author is listed at Monsanto, then the rbST maker.Who makes this claim: Organic and consumer advocates (US)
outdoor-raised (organic or free-range) pork carries more Toxoplasma, a risk in pregnancyProbably harmfulEarly evidenceMarker only · animal surveysOrganic and free-range pigs carry Toxoplasma far more often; US pasture-raised pork rarely had live parasites. In pregnancy, cook pork and lamb thoroughly.The studies (16)
Pig surveys, reviews: more in organic or outdoor pigs · US shop pork: rarely live parasites
The detailsBelluco 2016: organic pigs 53.4% (31.6–74.6%) vs conventional 0.6%; farming system the only significant factor for pigs. Danish and Dutch pigs: about 16 times the odds outdoors or organic. US pasture-raised retail pork and lamb: live parasite under 0.2%. Undercooked or cured meat caused 30–63% of infections in pregnancy in six European cities, whatever the farming method. Cooking to recommended temperatures prevents infection; freezing reduces but doesn't reliably remove it. Poultry: rare on large organic laying farms, common in backyard flocks. Trichinella not reviewed in depth.Who makes this claim: Food-safety researchers; veterinary public-health agencies
raw (unpasteurised) milk causes serious infections, especially in children and pregnancyShown to harmModerate evidenceDirect · US outbreaks, 2007–2020In US outbreaks, raw milk and cheese caused 96% of dairy illnesses, though only about 3% of people drink raw milk.The studies (7)
2 outbreak studies: far more illness from raw dairy · organic link to raw milk: unstudied
The detailsModerate under the principle 11 exception for overwhelming evidence: 840 (611–1,158) times the illnesses and 45 times the hospitalisations of pasteurised dairy (Costard 2017); consistent with a North American outbreak review; lab-confirmed named pathogens; no plausible confounder; regulators agree. Absolute: about 760 outbreak illnesses and 22 hospitalisations a year from US dairy, 96% from unpasteurised milk (drunk by 3.2%) and cheese (1.6%). Country facts: raw cow's milk can't legally be sold for drinking in Australia, though some states have allowed raw goat milk (Australia); sale is legal in at least 27 US states (US). Pasteurised soft cheeses caused most Listeria outbreaks (10 of 12), which matters in pregnancy. Opposing: a possibly confounded allergy link (Macdonald 2011). CDC review: 4 of 18 US organic-food outbreaks (1992–2014) were unpasteurised dairy; no denominator. US national surveys: raw-milk drinkers younger, rural, in legal-sale states; organic buying not examined. Williams 2001: nearly 50% perceived lower microbial and natural-toxin risk with organic produce; behaviour not measured. Agency advice to wash produce and cook meat applies to organic and conventional food alike.Who makes this claim: Food-safety agencies and paediatricians; raw-milk promoters dispute it; Food-safety agencies (CDC authors); Food-safety researchers
organic, free-range and backyard eggs carry more dioxins, PCBs and PFASProbably harmfulEarly evidenceMarker only · egg testingEuropean testing often found more dioxins in free-range and organic eggs than cage eggs, and 2–10 times more in backyard eggs; PFAS mixed.The studies (20)
EU, Dutch data: more dioxins outdoors · backyard: 2–10 times shop eggs · PFAS mixed
The detailsBy contaminant: dioxins and dioxin-like PCBs harm, early; PFAS mixed, early. Dutch organic farms (2003): 10 of 34 non-compliant with EU limits; levels rose with time outdoors; a monitoring protocol followed. Danish organic-egg PFAS came from fishmeal in feed and fell once removed; children eating 5–6 a week were at 10.4 vs a tolerable 4.4 ng/kg a week before the fix. Italy, US: no PFAS difference. Country facts: Australia's total diet study found PFAS (PFOS only) in under 2% of foods, no public health concern (Australia); a USDA survey found no PFAS in organic or conventional eggs (US). Opposing: Rawn 2012 (region mattered more); Chiumiento 2023. Hens peck soil; contaminated gardens and areas near industrial sources give the highest levels. Kitchen-scrap diets raised PFAS in Antwerp eggs; past backyard waste burning was the likely dioxin source in Dutch garden eggs. This is a home-produced food route, not commercial organic food.Who makes this claim: Food-safety researchers and regulators; Food-safety researchers
organic buying is linked with obsessive 'healthy eating' (orthorexia)Probably harmfulEarly evidenceLink only · one survey eachSurveys link organic buying with higher orthorexia scores but can't show which comes first; people with an eating-disorder history weren't studied.The studies (5)
3 surveys: higher scores in organic buyers · 2 reviews: questionnaire unreliable · no eating-disorder studies
The detailsAll cross-sectional; one Turkish study found each predicted the other, another that orthorexic tendencies predicted organic buying. Orthorexia isn't a formal diagnosis; reviews discourage the ORTO-15 questionnaire most studies use, which flags about 3 in 10 people generally. The largest study (1,022 adults) found a very small link (r = −0.08). The evidence doesn't show anyone needs to avoid organic food. One study excluded people with eating disorders; none sampled people with a history. General-population surveys use a questionnaire that reviews discourage.Who makes this claim: Eating-disorder researchers
rice-based baby and toddler foods, organic included, carry more arsenicProbably harmfulEarly evidenceMarker only · product testsRice-based baby and toddler foods carry the most arsenic, organic or not; nearly 3 in 4 tested in Australia were above the EU infant limit.The studies (5)
US and Australian tests: rice foods highest in arsenic, organic included
The detailsRice content, not organic status, drives arsenic. Organic toddler formula sweetened with brown rice syrup: total arsenic up to 6 times the US drinking-water limit (Jackson 2012). 31 US infant rice cereals averaged about 101 µg/kg inorganic arsenic, mixed-grain lowest. Australia: nearly 75% of rice-based infant products above the EU infant limit (0.1 mg/kg) (Gu 2020). US FDA: 100 ppb action level for infant rice cereal; oat, barley or multigrain cereals as alternatives.Who makes this claim: Food-safety researchers; consumer and advocacy testers
organic cereals (buckwheat, millet, maize) can carry toxic weed seeds (tropane alkaloids)Probably harmfulEarly evidenceMarker only · food tests and poisoningsWithout weedkillers, Datura seeds can end up in organic buckwheat, millet and maize; contaminated organic buckwheat flour poisoned 51 people in Martinique, and organic baby porridges were recalled.The studies (13)
Poisonings, recalls and EU alerts: organic products included · recent Danish checks within limits
The detailsOrganic farming doesn't use synthetic weedkillers, so Datura seeds can contaminate buckwheat, millet, sorghum and maize. Martinique 2019: one batch of organic buckwheat flour poisoned 51 people (all recovered). Hong Kong 2014: four organic baby porridges recalled (atropine 3.7–31.9 ppb). Serbian barley: atropine above 1 µg/kg in 60% of organic vs 14% of conventional samples, intakes still safe. EU limits (Regulation (EU) 2023/915, as summarised by AGES): 5 µg/kg for milled millet and maize, 10 for buckwheat, stricter for baby food (EU). Denmark 2024–25: 6 of 28 samples had traces, all within limits. No denominator: most European poisonings don't say whether the food was organic.Who makes this claim: Food-safety agencies; the organic sector's own guidance
higher levels of pyrethroid insecticides (from food and home sprays) are linked with more deathsProbably harmfulEarly evidenceLink only · about 14 yearsIn 2,116 US adults followed 14 years, those with the most pyrethroid traces in urine had about 56% higher death rates; one study, and farm users showed no clear rise.The studies (4)
1 urine cohort: more deaths · farm users: no clear rise · home sprays raise levels
The detailsBao 2020 (NHANES, 2,116 adults, one urine sample): highest vs lowest third, all-cause HR 1.56 (1.08–2.26), cardiovascular 3.00 (1.02–8.80); 8.5%, 10.2% and 11.9% died across rising thirds (unadjusted). Not replicated. Shrestha 2022 (50,665 applicators): no clear rise in overall deaths. Indoor insecticide use about doubles the odds of very high levels (NHANES 2007–2014). Organic food cut children's urine pyrethroid traces about 70% in 40 days (Makris 2019); no study links that drop with survival. Organic-allowed natural pyrethrins are a separate class.Who makes this claim: Environmental-health researchers
pesticide spraying at home or near farms in pregnancy and childhood is linked with lower child IQ, autism and leukaemiaProbably harmfulEarly evidenceLink only · pregnancy to age 7Farm-community and home-spraying exposure in pregnancy is linked with about 2–7 IQ points lower; spraying within 2 km with slightly more autism; home insecticides with more childhood leukaemia.The studies (9)
Farm communities, home spraying: lower IQ · near-field: more autism · home insecticides: more leukaemia
The detailsFarm-level and home exposure, not food. CHAMACOS farmworker community (329 children): 7 IQ points lower, top vs bottom fifth of maternal organophosphate traces; living near organophosphate spraying, 2.2 points lower per SD (283). New York home spraying (265): IQ 1.4% lower per SD of cord-blood chlorpyrifos. California (2,961 autism cases): glyphosate or chlorpyrifos sprayed within 2 km, 13–16% higher odds. Childhood leukaemia: home pesticide use in pregnancy, about 43% higher odds (12 pooled studies); home pesticides, about 57% (15 studies); indoor insecticides 47%. Case-control designs; recall bias likely.Who makes this claim: Paediatric and environmental-health researchers; American Academy of Pediatrics
heavy pesticide exposure at work or from frequent home spraying is linked with Parkinson's, ALS, some cancers, arthritis and lupusProbably harmfulEarly evidenceLink only · farm-level exposurePesticide exposure at work, near sprayed fields or from frequent home use is linked with Parkinson's, ALS, lymphoma and prostate cancer, arthritis, lupus and lower sperm counts; food wasn't studied.The studies (12)
Work, home, near-field: more Parkinson's, ALS, lymphoma, arthritis, lupus, poorer sperm · food: not studied
The detailsFarm-level and home exposure, not food. Parkinson's: work exposure OR 1.46, home use 1.21 (124 studies). ALS: work exposure OR 1.6, 2.7 at high exposure (8 studies). Cancer: INSERM strong presumption for lymphoma, myeloma and prostate cancer at work; prostate OR 1.33 at high work exposure. Insecticides and rheumatoid arthritis OR 1.20 (mostly applicators); frequent personal insecticide use, about twice the risk of arthritis or lupus. Sperm concentration lower with heavy work exposure to organophosphates or carbamates (SMD −0.43), not outside work. Thyroid changes in most of 19 worker studies. No absolute figures.Who makes this claim: Occupational-health researchers; INSERM expert panel
higher body levels of pesticides, mostly long-banned ones, are linked with diabetes and metabolic syndromeProbably harmfulEarly evidenceLink only · mostly one-visit studiesPeople with more pesticide in their bodies, mostly long-banned organochlorines found in organic and conventional food alike, had about 19–58% higher odds of diabetes.The studies (4)
Reviews: more diabetes and metabolic syndrome · DDE in organic and conventional milk alike
The detailsChen 2025 (19 studies): type 2 diabetes OR 1.19, pyrethroids 1.17. Evangelou 2016 (22 studies): top vs bottom third, diabetes OR 1.58, mainly organochlorines. Lamat 2022 (12 studies): metabolic syndrome +30% (+19% fully adjusted), mostly organochlorines. Organochlorines are banned in Australia, the US and the EU but persist in fatty foods; DDE was in 91–100% of organic and conventional milk alike. Case-control and cross-sectional designs can't show which came first. No absolute figures.Who makes this claim: Environmental-health researchers
seeing organic food as 'safe' leads people to skip washing or cooking itLeans toward harm; not yet knownAnecdotalLink only · one surveyNearly half of 700-plus Boston shoppers thought organic produce carried less germ risk; whether they then skip washing or cooking wasn't measured.The studies (3)
1 survey: many see organic as lower germ risk · behaviour not measured
The detailsWilliams and Hammitt 2001: over 90% perceived lower residue risk and nearly 50% lower microbial risk with organic produce; food handling not measured. CDC review: 4 of 18 US organic-food outbreaks (1992–2014) were unpasteurised dairy; handle organic food as carefully. Agency advice to wash produce and cook meat applies to organic and conventional food alike.Who makes this claim: Food-safety agencies
Food poisoning riskOrganic and free-range pork carries Toxoplasma more often, and raw milk causes serious infections; cook meat thoroughly and drink pasteurised milk.The detailsE. coli on produce was no different from conventional (review of food studies). Chicken: Campylobacter was commoner on organic and free-range farms, but shop chicken was similar; in the EU, laying hens kept out of cages had less Salmonella. Pork: organic and free-range pigs carry Toxoplasma far more often (about half of organic pig samples versus under 1% of conventional, pooled surveys). Raw milk, organic or not, causes serious infections. Cooking meat thoroughly and washing produce remove the meat and produce risks whatever the farming method; for milk, pasteurisation does.Smith-Spangler et al. 2012 · 60 Limited (funding not yet checked)Golden and Mishra 2020 · 61 Limited (funding not yet checked)European Food Safety Authority BIOHAZ Panel 2019 · 88 Strong (official data)Belluco et al. 2016 · 70 GoodUS Centers for Disease Control and Prevention 2024 · 80 Strong (official data)Costard et al. 2017 · 67 Good
Pregnancy, fertility and eating disordersNo study shows anyone needs to avoid organic food. Research hasn't looked at people with an eating-disorder history; if food rules are part of your recovery, your treatment team can advise. Pregnant: cook pork and lamb thoroughly, drink only pasteurised milk, and check iodine if you drink organic milk.The detailsNo study shows anyone needs to avoid organic food. Research hasn't looked at people with an eating-disorder history; if food rules are part of your recovery, your treatment team can advise. Pregnancy: cook pork and lamb thoroughly (Toxoplasma is more common in organic and free-range pigs), and drink only pasteurised milk. In pregnancy and breastfeeding, organic milk has less iodine: about 53% vs 88% of daily iodine per 500 mL (mostly European data; the gap varies by country and season), so check your iodine intake. People having fertility treatment: a US clinic cohort linked high-residue produce with fewer live births (observational).Średnicka-Tober et al. 2016 · 56 LimitedChiu et al. 2018 · 60 Limited (funding not yet checked)Tattersall et al. 2024 · 59 LimitedPregnancy, Birth and Baby · 80 Strong (official data)Ng et al. 2024 · 66 Good
Residues, labels and certificationOrganic isn't residue-free: 19.6% of EU organic samples had measurable residues, mostly copper. Australia has no mandatory organic certification, so look for a certifier's mark.The detailsOrganic isn't residue-free: 19.6% of EU organic samples had quantifiable residues, most often copper, which organic farming allows. In Australia: there is no mandatory certification for organic food sold domestically; misleading claims fall under consumer law, so look for a certifier's mark. In the US: food sold as organic must come from a certified farm or business (sellers with US$5,000 or less a year of organic sales are exempt but must follow the rules), and meat or milk from animals given antibiotics can't be sold as organic. Hormones: in the US they aren't approved for pigs or poultry, so no chicken or pork is raised with added hormones, but they are approved for beef cattle and sheep; in Australia hormone growth promotants are registered for cattle; in the EU they are banned. Antibiotics for growth: in the US, growth-promoting use of medically important antibiotics ended in 2017; in the EU, all growth-promoting antibiotics were banned from 2006. Resistant bacteria on retail meat: in the US, multidrug-resistant bacteria were found on organically produced meat less than half as often as on conventional (prevalence ratio 0.43; no absolute figure given); in Australia, a 2022–23 national survey of 4,151 beef, chicken and pork products found resistance low overall, with about two-thirds of bacteria resistant to none of the antibiotics tested (organic not compared). Chlorpyrifos: in Australia most uses were cancelled in 2024; in the US it has been allowed on 11 crops only since July 2025. Milk hormone (rbST): approved in the US since 1993; never approved in Australia; banned in the EU from 2000. The US FDA and the WHO–FAO expert committee (JECFA) found milk from treated cows safe. Pesticides not allowed in the EU: paraquat, atrazine and mancozeb are still registered in Australia and the US (paraquat with tight new limits in Australia from June 2026, and for certified applicators only in the US). Organic rules ban synthetic pesticides, but US organic farming could use rotenone, a natural insecticide linked with Parkinson's in farm workers, until 2019.European Food Safety Authority 2026 · 98 Strong (official data)Australian Government Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry · 78 Good (official data)US Food and Drug Administration · 78 Good (official data)Queensland Government · 73 Good (official data)European Union Regulation · 73 Good (official data)Food Safety News 2017 · 63 Limited (official data)Australian Pesticides and Veterinary Medicines Authority 2024 · 95 Strong (official data)US Environmental Protection Agency · 90 Strong (official data)US Department of Agriculture National Organic Program · 85 Strong (official data)Innes et al. 2021 · 62 LimitedFood Standards Australia New Zealand 2026 · 91 Strong (official data)US Food and Drug Administration · 80 Strong (official data)Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives · 83 Strong (official data)Library of Parliament · 55 Limited (official data)Council Decision 1999/879/EC · 85 Strong (official data)European Commission · 90 Strong (official data)Australian Pesticides and Veterinary Medicines Authority 2026 · 90 Strong (official data)European Commission Implementing Regulation · 90 Strong (official data)Australian Pesticides and Veterinary Medicines Authority · 90 Strong (official data)US Department of Agriculture National Organic Program 2018 · 83 Strong (official data)
Packaged organic foodsOrganic packaged foods can still be high in sugar, salt and fat; the label doesn't change how processed a food is.The detailsOrganic packaged foods can still be high in sugar, salt and fat; the organic label doesn't change how processed a food is.
Links aren't proofHealth links come from studies of people who already buy organic, who tend to be richer, eat more plants and be more active. Residues found aren't the same as harm.The detailsHealth links come from observational studies: people who buy organic tend to have higher incomes, eat more plants and are leaner and more active, which can explain lower disease rates even after adjustment. Detecting a residue isn't the same as harm: over 99% of US samples (2023) and 96.7% of EU samples (2024) were within legal limits.Theodoridis et al. 2025 · 77 GoodKomati et al. 2025 · 56 LimitedUS Department of Agriculture 2024 · 93 Strong (official data)European Food Safety Authority 2026 · 98 Strong (official data)
Residue warnings and produceIn a US survey of low-income shoppers, warnings naming high-residue foods made more say they'd buy no fruit or vegetables.The detailsResidue warnings may put people off produce altogether: in a US survey of low-income shoppers, messages naming high-residue foods made more say they'd buy no fruit or vegetables (part-funded by a produce-industry group, as reported). Organic labels may also make processed foods seem healthier (not rated).Huang et al. 2016 · 33 Weak
CostOrganic costs about 7–82% more depending on the food (US, 2010). In Australia, organic milk costs about 40–70% more than own-brand (our estimate).The detailsOrganic versions cost about 7–82% more depending on the food (US, 2010 data). In Australia: organic milk was A$2.50–3.05 a litre vs about A$1.78 for supermarket own-brand (Nov 2026), about 40–70% more (our estimate). We found no basket price source for a yearly cost of switching produce. Information only.US Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service 2016 · 76 Good (official data)Our shelf-price check, 4 Nov 2026 · 53 Limited (official data)
Raw milkRaw milk, organic or not, causes serious infections, especially in children and pregnancy. Drink only pasteurised milk; in Australia raw cow's milk can't legally be sold for drinking.The detailsRaw (unpasteurised) milk, organic or not, causes serious infections. In US outbreak data for 2009–2014, raw milk and cheese caused 96% of dairy outbreak illnesses, though only about 3% of people drink raw milk: about 840 times the illness rate of pasteurised dairy. Children, pregnant women, older people and people with weakened immunity are most at risk. In Australia, raw cow's milk can't legally be sold for drinking; in the US, sale is legal in at least 27 states. In pregnancy, pasteurised soft cheeses can also carry Listeria.Costard et al. 2017 · 67 GoodSebastianski et al. 2022 · 67 GoodAmerican Academy of Pediatrics · 67 Good (funding not yet checked)Dairy Food Safety Victoria · 70 Good (official data)
Baby food, rice and heavy metalsOrganic baby food isn't lower in heavy metals. Rice-based foods carry the most arsenic; use oat, barley or mixed-grain cereals too.The detailsOrganic baby food is no lower in lead, cadmium or arsenic: in US tests of 564 baby foods and 31 rice cereals, organic status made no difference. Rice-based products carry the most arsenic, organic included; an organic toddler formula made with brown rice syrup had up to 6 times the US drinking-water limit. In Australia, nearly 3 in 4 rice-based infant foods tested were above the EU infant limit. Using oat, barley or mixed-grain cereals as well as rice lowers arsenic (US FDA).Gardener et al. 2019 · 49 WeakJuskelis et al. 2013 · 53 Limited (funding not yet checked)Jackson et al. 2012 · 53 LimitedGu et al. 2020 · 50 Limited (funding not yet checked)US Food and Drug Administration 2020 · 85 Strong (official data)US Food and Drug Administration 2025 · 95 Strong (official data)
Eggs: dioxins and PFASFree-range, organic and especially backyard eggs can carry more dioxins and PFAS, depending on the soil the hens peck.The detailsIn European testing, free-range and organic eggs often had more dioxins and PCBs than cage eggs, because hens peck soil outdoors; in 2003, 10 of 34 Dutch organic farms broke EU limits, and a monitoring scheme followed. PFAS: higher in some organic eggs (Denmark, from fishmeal in feed, since fixed; Poland), no different in Italy, and none found in 20 US eggs. Backyard eggs had about 2–10 times the dioxins of shop eggs in Dutch and Belgian surveys, mostly from garden soil. In Australia, the national diet study found PFAS in under 2% of foods, with no public health concern.European Food Safety Authority 2012 · 80 Strong (official data)Kijlstra, Traag and Hoogenboom 2007 · 53 Limited (funding not yet checked)Granby et al. 2024 · 50 Limited (funding not yet checked)Hoogenboom et al. 2016 · 53 Limited (funding not yet checked)Van Overmeire et al. 2006 · 53 Limited (funding not yet checked)Food Standards Australia New Zealand 2021 · 95 Strong (official data)
Weed-seed toxins in cerealsOrganic buckwheat, millet and maize can occasionally carry toxic weed seeds; poisonings and recalls have happened.The detailsOrganic farming doesn't use synthetic weedkillers, so seeds of toxic weeds such as Datura can end up in buckwheat, millet, maize and sorghum. Contaminated organic buckwheat flour poisoned 51 people in Martinique in 2019 (all recovered), and organic millet baby porridges were recalled in Hong Kong in 2014. EU limits for these toxins (tropane alkaloids: atropine plus scopolamine) are 5 µg/kg for milled millet and maize, 10 for buckwheat, and stricter for baby food. Recent Danish checks found all samples within limits.Florentin et al. 2026 · 43 Weak (funding not yet checked)Hong Kong Centre for Food Safety, 13 December 2014 · 53 Limited (official data)Austrian Agency for Health and Food Safety · Not rated (official agency page)Commission Regulation · 85 Strong (official data)Danish Veterinary and Food Administration · 70 Good (official data)European Food Safety Authority 2022 · 95 Strong (official data)
Cancer treatmentDon't swap cancer treatment for an organic-diet regimen such as Gerson therapy; it was linked with much shorter survival. Treatment decisions are your doctor's call.The detailsDon't use an organic-diet regimen such as Gerson therapy instead of cancer treatment. People with pancreatic cancer who chose an organic-diet enzyme regimen over chemotherapy lived a median 4.3 months versus 14. Cancer Council Australia calls Gerson therapy not a valid or effective treatment, never to be used in place of surgery, radiotherapy or chemotherapy. The coffee enemas it uses have caused bowel inflammation, and 3 deaths possibly linked to them have been reported. Treatment decisions are your doctor's call.Chabot et al. 2010 · 51 Limited (funding not yet checked)Cancer Council Australia · 75 Good (official data)US National Cancer Institute PDQ · 78 Good (official data)Cancer Research UK · 75 Good (official data)
The evidence, claim by claim (41)MembersCancer · 4 claims · ✓1✕1○1±1
Organic food is linked with less of specific cancers (lymphoma, breast, bowel, stomach)Mixed resultsEarly evidenceLink only · 4½–15 yearsLymphoma was lower in UK women but higher in Danish organic eaters; breast cancer differed by study; bowel cancer showed no clear difference.The studies (5)
UK: less lymphoma, more breast · Denmark: more lymphoma, less stomach · bowel: no clear difference
The detailsLymphoma: 21% lower (UK), double with high use (Denmark). Breast: 9% higher (UK); postmenopausal 10% lower per 100 g organic produce (France). No absolute figures. Pooled 3 cohorts: bowel cancer HR 1.01 (0.93–1.10), very low certainty. Denmark: stomach HR 0.50 at low and medium use, 0.54 (0.27–1.07) at high use, p-trend 0.09; one of many sites compared, so exploratory, with no lean. UK stomach 0.92 (0.67–1.26). Prostate about 1.0; soft-tissue sarcoma 1.37 (0.82–2.27), not significant. No absolute figures.Who makes this claim: NutriNet-Santé researchers; Million Women Study; Danish Diet, Cancer and Health study; Organic advocates; Danish Diet, Cancer and Health researchers
Avoiding pesticide residues in food lowers cancer riskNot yet knownEarly evidenceLink only · about 18 yearsAmong 180,316 adults over about 18 years, high-residue produce wasn't linked with cancer, but no trial has tested it. Childhood cancer through food is unstudied.The studies (28)
Largest cohort: no link · farm work: lymphoma, prostate · children: home insecticides · glyphosate: disputed
The detailsSandoval-Insausti 2021: all cancer HR 0.99 (0.97–1.01) per daily serve of high-residue produce; NHL 0.89 (0.72–1.09), prostate 1.31 (0.88–1.93). Baudry 2023 graded the cancer evidence low. Opposing: NutriNet-Santé breast cancer HR 0.57 with a low-synthetic-pesticide diet; glioma HR 2.99 in 1 of 3 US cohorts. Farm-level exposure, not food: INSERM 2021 strong presumption for NHL, myeloma and prostate cancer; prostate OR 1.33 at high work exposure. No absolute figures. Food route: no study of dietary glyphosate and lymphoma; IARC: general-population exposure generally low. Farm-level: Gagnier 2026, highest exposure without the two cohort pools OR 1.33–1.47, all studies 1.18 (0.97–1.44); Andreotti 2018, 54,251 applicators, no link. IARC Group 2A (hazard). US EPA 'not likely to be carcinogenic' (2022 court vacatur of the human-health part; finding kept); APVMA no carcinogenic risk; ECHA not classified; EFSA dietary risk assessment unfinished. Ugalde-Resano 2025: p,p'-DDT and breast cancer OR 1.41 (1.06–1.88) in prospective studies with over 10 years' follow-up; retrospective DDE 1.15. Kim 2026: organochlorines and DDE linked with NHL. DDT is banned in Australia, the US and the EU but persists in fatty foods; DDE was in 91–100% of both organic and conventional milk (Welsh 2019). No absolute figures. Home use in pregnancy and acute lymphoblastic leukaemia OR 1.43 (1.32–1.54), 12 pooled case-control studies; household exposure and leukaemia 1.57; indoor insecticides 1.47. Brain tumours: domestic insecticides 1.44, fathers' work exposure 1.48 (case-control). No absolute figures; childhood leukaemia is rare, so any absolute difference is small (no figure available). Recall bias likely.Who makes this claim: Organic and environmental advocates; critics: Cancer Council Australia (citing FSANZ); Environmental and organic advocates; IARC (hazard classification); Environmental advocates; American Academy of Pediatrics (on home and work pesticide use)
An organic-diet regimen (such as Gerson therapy) can treat cancer instead of standard treatmentProbably harmfulEarly evidenceDirect · to deathPeople with pancreatic cancer who chose an organic-diet regimen over chemotherapy lived about 4 months, versus 14. Treatment decisions are your doctor's call.The studies (8)
2 studies: shorter survival · case reports: coffee-enema injuries · 3 cancer bodies: not a treatment
The detailsChabot 2010 (NCI-sponsored; patients chose): median survival 4.3 vs 14.0 months; adjusted death HR 6.96; alive at 1 year 16% vs 56%. Johnson 2018, 840 matched patients with curable cancer: alternative medicine alone, death HR 2.50 (1.88–3.27); diet regimens not separated. No trial of Gerson therapy exists. Opposing: Hildenbrand 1995, uncontrolled clinic series. Molassiotis 2007: 6 case studies; 'almost no scientific support for this regimen'. NCI PDQ (2015): a 1990 Austrian study of a similar diet with standard treatment reported patients seemed to live longer and said it needed further study; not opened, not stated as randomised. Son 2020: 9 case reports, 7 of colitis, 2 more serious events; no effectiveness study found. NCI: 'Reports of three deaths that may be related to coffee enemas have been published.' Cancer Research UK: dehydration, mineral imbalances, heart and lung problems.Who makes this claim: Gerson therapy practitioners and clinics; Hildenbrand 1995; Gerson therapy practitioners; US National Cancer Institute; Cancer Research UK; Cancer Council Australia
Heart, weight and metabolism · 2 claims · ✓1○1
Organic eaters have less obesity, diabetes, high blood pressure and heart diseaseProbably helpsEarly evidenceLink only · one visit to 16 yearsAdult studies link organic eating with less obesity and diabetes, and slightly less heart disease over 16 years; metabolic syndrome results are mixed.The studies (9)
Overlapping reviews: less adult obesity · Danish cohort: slightly less heart disease · metabolic syndrome: mixed
The detailsReviews: organic eating linked with less obesity (21 and 50 studies) and diabetes (21-study review; the 50-study review judged single diseases other than obesity 'insufficient'). Danish cohort: 6% less heart disease per 6-point score step; no absolute figure. Baudry 2018 (8,174 French adults): prevalence ratio 0.69 (0.61–0.78), top vs bottom third; cross-sectional. Aljahdali 2022 (6,633 US adults about 65): no association after full adjustment. No absolute figure. Poulia 2025: inverse with high cholesterol in most prospective studies. Jiang 2024 (50 studies): serum parameters 'inconsistent'. Aljahdali 2022: HDL higher only before adjustment. No trial has measured LDL. Diabetes OR 1.58 (1.32–1.90), top vs bottom third, mainly organochlorines; type 2 diabetes OR 1.19, pyrethroids 1.17; metabolic syndrome +30% (+19% fully adjusted). Organochlorines are banned in Australia, the US and the EU but persist in fatty foods; DDE was in 91–100% of organic and conventional milk alike. The organic-obesity link is observational; no study shows pesticides explain it. Case-control and cross-sectional designs can't show which came first. No absolute figure.Who makes this claim: NutriNet-Santé researchers; Poulia 2025; Organic advocates; Environmental advocates
Organic food lowers obesity and metabolic risk in childrenProbably doesn't helpEarly evidenceDirect · 40 daysNo worthwhile effect. In a 40-day trial of 149 children aged 11–12, BMI fell only slightly, and they ate fewer calories.The studies (3)
The detailsMakris 2019: BMI z-score −0.131, below the 0.2 worthwhile size; a post hoc outcome, and children ate fewer calories in the organic period. Gosling 2021 (French survey): slightly lower BMI and obesity, small effects. French Society of Paediatrics: epidemiology suggests less childhood obesity.Who makes this claim: French Society of Paediatrics (suggests a link); organic advocates
Brain and nerves · 1 claim · ?1
Organic food lowers Parkinson's, dementia, ALS or autoimmune disease, and keeps thinking sharperNot yet knownMore data neededLink only · farm-level exposureParkinson's, dementia, ALS and lupus are linked with farm-level pesticides, never studied through food; one study links organic eating with better thinking.The studies (30)
Work, home, near-field: more Parkinson's, ALS, lupus · food: never studied · 1 study: better thinking
The detailsda Silva 2026 (124 studies): work exposure OR 1.46 (1.27–1.68), home use 1.21 (1.06–1.39), which lost significance without one group's 18 studies; no study of food. Largest prospective farm cohort (Shrestha 2020): some pesticides raised risk, others lowered it. APVMA 2026 and US EPA find no clear link from approved paraquat uses. Rotenone, a natural insecticide linked with Parkinson's in applicators (OR 2.5), was allowed in US organic farming until 2019. No absolute figure. ALS: work exposure OR 1.6 (1.1–2.2), 2.7 at high exposure (Labrèche 2026); good-quality studies RR 1.35. Alzheimer's: OR 1.34 (1.08–1.67), 7 studies. INSERM: strong presumption for cognitive disorders, moderate for Alzheimer's (work). Blood organochlorines: ALS mostly inverse, dementia no consistent link. No absolute figures. Insecticides and rheumatoid arthritis OR 1.20 (1.12–1.28), mostly applicators; weedkillers 0.98, fungicides 1.04. Personal insecticide use 6+ times a year: HR 2.04 for RA or lupus. In farm applicators, metribuzin linked with more lupus or Sjögren's, carbaryl with less. No absolute figures. Li 2024: organic food positively associated with cognition; incident mild cognitive impairment HR 0.80 (0.65–0.98) in women only, not tested as a pre-planned difference (exploratory). No score difference or absolute figure in the abstract; full text not read. None of the organic-food reviews covers cognition. Lancet Commission 2024 doesn't list diet or pesticides among 14 dementia risk factors.Who makes this claim: Environmental and organic advocates; Environmental advocates; Organic advocates; Li 2024 authors
Pregnancy, babies and children · 5 claims · ✓1○1±1?2
Organic food in pregnancy protects babies' and children's developmentMixed resultsEarly evidenceLink only · pregnancy to age 19Norway linked organic food in pregnancy with less hypospadias and pre-eclampsia, not fewer autism or ADHD traits; pesticide-trace studies of IQ are split.The studies (49)
Norway: less hypospadias, pre-eclampsia · autism, ADHD: no link · IQ, preterm, birth weight: split
The detailsNo high-quality evidence. Norwegian cohort links organic with less hypospadias (OR 0.42; 0.2% overall) and organic vegetables with less pre-eclampsia (OR 0.79; 5.3% overall); child ADHD/autism symptoms not lower. General population, mostly food exposure: no consistent link in Rotterdam (708) or Denmark (812); lower scores in boys in Canada (verbal IQ −6.28 per ten-fold) and Wuhan (−3.16). Farmworker community (CHAMACOS, 329): 7 IQ points lower, top vs bottom fifth; authors judge most exposure came from food, at levels above the US average (median 128 vs 72 nmol/L), plus drift. Near-field spraying: 2.2 points per SD; home spraying: IQ 1.4% lower per SD. EFSA 2019: no safe level for chlorpyrifos. Urine traces partly reflect harmless breakdown products already on food; boys-only results exploratory. Instanes 2024 (40,707 pairs): a weak link with slightly more symptoms vanished in sibling analyses. Cavalier 2026 (3,339 pairs, mainly dietary exposure): per doubling of TCPy −0.13 (−0.57 to 0.31) SRS points; the whole range sits below a worthwhile size. Biomarker meta-analysis OR 1.13 (0.83–1.54). Near-field, not food: glyphosate within 2 km OR 1.16 (1.06–1.27), chlorpyrifos 1.13; proximity or self-report pooled 1.88. Conflict facts: Chang 2023 sponsored by glyphosate registrants via Bayer; a von Ehrenstein 2019 author is an expert witness for plaintiffs in glyphosate litigation (BMJ correction, 2019). No absolute figures. Lin 2023: preterm OR 1.28 (0.93–1.78) per ten-fold higher level (OHAT moderate); gestation −0.10 weeks (−0.21 to 0.01), below the 0.3-week worthwhile size (very low confidence). Mostly organochlorines and organophosphates. Organic-diet trials in pregnancy cut pyrethroid traces and glyphosate only modestly; none measured birth outcomes. Lin 2023 lists a Danone Institute China grant to one author. No absolute figure. Costa Rica (386 newborns, farming region): −130 g (−256 to −3.5) per ten-fold chlorpyrifos metabolite in late pregnancy, past the 100 g worthwhile size but imprecise; 2,4-D −125 g. Rotterdam: fetal weight 6% lower at 20 weeks per ten-fold, null at delivery. Indiana: birth-weight percentile slope −0.032 per ng/mL glyphosate. No organic-diet study.Who makes this claim: Organic advocates; Vigar 2019 (authors at an organic-food research centre); Norwegian Mother and Child cohort researchers; Environmental and organic advocates; Project TENDR scientists; Organic and environmental advocates; Gonzalez 2025 authors; Environmental advocates
Organic baby food is lower in heavy metals (lead, arsenic, cadmium)Probably doesn't helpEarly evidenceMarker only · product testsIn US tests of 564 baby foods, organic had no less lead or cadmium; rice drives arsenic, organic or not.The studies (14)
5 US tests: no less in organic · Spain, Turkey: more lead · rice foods: high arsenic
The detailsBuying organic doesn't lower metals; food choice does (non-rice cereals, varied vegetables, fewer rice snacks). Opposing: organic crops in general carry less cadmium (Barański 2014), but no baby-food survey shows lower metals for organic. Conflict fact: Gardener 2019 was funded by the Clean Label Project, which employs a co-author. Regulators: US FDA lead action levels (2025) and rice-cereal arsenic limit (2020); EU limits for arsenic, lead and cadmium in baby food (EU); Australia limits total arsenic in grains to 1 mg/kg, no other baby-food metal limits (Australia). Organic toddler formula sweetened with brown rice syrup: total arsenic up to 6 times the US drinking-water limit. US infant rice cereals averaged 101 µg/kg inorganic arsenic, mixed-grain lowest (63). Brown rice carries more than white. Country facts: Australia and New Zealand limit total arsenic in grains, rice included, to 1 mg/kg, with no infant-specific limit (Australia); the EU limits inorganic arsenic in rice for infant food to 0.10 mg/kg (EU); the US FDA sets 100 ppb for infant rice cereal (US).Who makes this claim: Organic baby-food marketing; advocacy testers dispute it; Food-safety researchers; consumer testers
Organic food in pregnancy lowers gestational diabetesLeans toward helping; not yet knownMore data neededLink only · pregnancyIn 2,803 pregnancies, gestational diabetes affected 0.9% of mostly-organic and 1.5% of non-organic eaters; the range includes no effect.The studies (7)
The detailsSimões-Wüst 2021: over 50% organic, 2 of 224 (0.9%) vs conventional 25 of 1,728 (1.5%), aOR 0.53 (0.12–2.30); under 50% organic, aOR 0.71 (0.32–1.54). Diet asked at 34 weeks, after diabetes screening; 1 in 6 recruited through organic and anthroposophic channels. Guesdon 2025 estimated residue intake, not organic eating: glyphosate aOR 0.6, cypermethrin 1.2. Near-field pyrethroids: 17% or more higher risk (Arizona). No absolute figure for the near-field studies.Who makes this claim: Organic advocates; KOALA cohort researchers
Hormones and fertility · 3 claims · ✕1±1?1
High-residue produce is linked with lower success of fertility treatmentProbably harmfulEarly evidenceLink only · treatment cycles, 2007–2021At one US fertility clinic, women eating the most high-residue produce had about 26% lower chance of a live birth per cycle; men's intake was linked with lower fertilisation.The studies (2)
1 US clinic cohort, women and men: fewer live births, lower fertilisation
The detailsUS fertility clinic, 325 women: highest vs lowest high-residue intake linked with 26% lower chance of live birth; low-residue produce not linked.Who makes this claim: EARTH study researchers (Chiu 2018, Kazemi 2025)
Organic food protects sperm, fertility and hormonesMixed resultsEarly evidenceLink only · one visit to 12 months; treatment cyclesAt a US fertility clinic, high-residue produce was linked with lower sperm counts; elsewhere, sperm, conceiving and hormones showed no clear link.The studies (17)
Fertility clinic: lower sperm counts with high-residue produce · others: no clear link · work: poorer sperm
The detailsChiu 2015: top vs bottom quarter of high-residue produce, 49% (31–63%) lower total sperm count, 155 clinic men. No link in 189 young men or 256 Danish farmers (same farmers in two papers). Jensen 1996: 43% higher concentration in organic eaters vs airline workers. Work exposure: SMD −0.43 for concentration; outside work −0.03 (−0.31 to 0.25). No guideline or graded review of dietary studies. Wesselink 2020 (5,234 women): high- and low-residue produce 'not appreciably related' to fecundability. Weissert 2023 (2,069 Danish women): organic food 'not meaningfully associated'; one subgroup FR 1.17 (0.99–1.38). Diet studies (189 men, 633 women): no overall hormone link. Urine levels: none in 715 pregnancies; higher TSH in 1,089 US adults (one survey). Work: 19-study review, most found thyroid changes; INSERM moderate presumption. The EU didn't renew mancozeb (2021), partly as a human endocrine disruptor; it remains registered in Australia (32 products) and the US. US fertility clinic, 325 women: highest vs lowest high-residue intake linked with 26% lower chance of live birth; low-residue produce not linked.Who makes this claim: Organic advocates; Jensen 1996 (Danish organic-food study); Organic and environmental advocates; EARTH study researchers (Chiu 2018, Kazemi 2025)
Organic milk and meat avoid added hormones and so prevent early puberty or acneNot yet knownUntestedLink only · childhood to age 30No study compared organic and hormone-treated foods; milk wasn't linked with earlier puberty in 13,106 children, but dairy is linked with acne.The studies (11)
No organic studies · 2 cohorts: milk not linked with earlier puberty · dairy linked with acne
The detailsChicken and pork carry no added hormones in the US (FDA), so 'hormone-free' labels on them add nothing there (US). Organic milk still contains the cow's natural oestrogens from pregnancy; one US survey found slightly more than in conventional. Menarche HR 0.93 (0.83–1.04) for over 3 glasses a day vs 1–4 a week. No absolute figure. Juhl 2018: any dairy OR 1.25 (1.15–1.36); skim/low-fat milk 1.32; whole milk 1.22; adjusted results attenuated; publication bias found. The link is as strong for skim as whole milk, which points to milk's own components rather than added hormones (our inference). One Juhl 2018 author has a Danish Dairy Research Foundation grant. No absolute figure.Who makes this claim: Organic advocates
Food safety · 2 claims · ✓1○1
Organic animal foods lower exposure to antibiotic-resistant bacteriaProbably helpsEarly evidenceMarker only · food samples, 2012–2023Multidrug-resistant bacteria were less common on organic chicken and pork in a review and US monitoring; a UK study found similar resistance genes.The studies (4)
2 found fewer resistant bacteria on organic · 1 no clear difference · Australian data: resistance low
The detailsReview: bacteria resistant to 3+ antibiotics on 33 more per 100 conventional chicken and pork samples. UK, organic or free-range vs intensive: resistance genes similar.Who makes this claim: Organic advocates; Smith-Spangler 2012
Organic grains have more or fewer mould toxinsProbably doesn't help or harmEarly evidenceMarker only · food testsA review of cereal studies found mould toxins similar in organic and conventional grain; one, DON, was about 50% higher in conventional.The studies (2)
1 review: similar mould toxins, DON higher in conventional · no health studies
The detailsReview of cereal studies: mould-toxin levels similar in organic and conventional grain for eating; one toxin (DON) about 50% higher in conventional.Who makes this claim: Both sides
Nutrients · 1 claim · ±1
Organic food has more nutrients, antioxidants and omega-3 fatsMixed resultsEarly evidenceMarker only · food samplesOrganic crops had more of some antioxidants and less cadmium, with similar vitamins; organic milk and meat had more omega-3, but small amounts.The studies (7)
1 crop review: more antioxidants · 2 reviews: little difference · 2 reviews: more omega-3, small
The detailsCrops, 343 studies: polyphenols 19–69% higher, less cadmium and protein, vitamins mostly similar. An earlier review of 162 studies found no difference in 8 of 11 nutrient categories. Milk: omega-3 56% higher; 500 mL full-fat gives 16% vs 11% of recommended long-chain omega-3. Meat: 47% higher (no absolute figure). Grass feeding explains it.Who makes this claim: Organic sector; Barański 2014 (part-funded by an organic-farming charity); critics: Dangour 2009, Cancer Council Australia; Średnicka-Tober 2016 (part-funded by an organic-farming charity)
Pesticides in your body · 3 claims · ✓2○1
Eating organic food lowers the pesticide residues you eat and carryShown to helpModerate evidenceMarker only · 5 days to 24 weeksIn trials, urine pesticides fell 89–91% in adults and 40% or more in children; switching high-residue, unpeeled produce matters most.The studies (16)
6 trials cut urine pesticides · 1 found little glyphosate change · residues concentrate on unpeeled produce
The detailsAdult trials (13 and 27 people): urinary pesticides 89% and 91% lower in 1–2 weeks (180 vs 17 µg a day); children, 40–49% lower. Advocacy-group analysis of US data: residues on 96% of conventional samples of these foods. Organic crops carry residues 4 times less often (crop review). US data: nearly 60% of conventional samples of low-residue produce had no detectable residues; peeling cuts residues further. High-residue produce eaten with the skin (berries, leafy greens, apples, grapes, stone fruit) carries most residues; peeled or thick-skinned produce (bananas, avocado, mango, onions, sweetcorn, pineapple) carries few: nearly 60% of US conventional samples had none detectable, so organic adds little there.Who makes this claim: Environmental Working Group (advocacy group), Consumer Reports (non-profit consumer tester), Cancer Council Australia; American Academy of Pediatrics agrees on exposure
Residues on conventional food are at unsafe levelsShown not to harmModerate evidenceMarker only · 1 year or survey each; consumer tester 8 yearsJudged by safety limits: over 99% of US and 96.7% of EU samples met them; Australian intakes did, bar one chemical.The studies (4)
3 government reports: within safe limits · 1 consumer tester: 6 foods a serious problem
The detailsOver 99% of US samples (2023) under limits; EU 96.7% (2024); Australian diet exposures (2013–14) below safe intakes for all but one chemical.Who makes this claim: Environmental Working Group (advocacy group), Consumer Reports (non-profit tester; six foods a 'serious problem' by its own score); regulators disagree
Conventional food can carry pesticides banned in the EU, which organic avoidsProbably helpsEarly evidenceMarker only · 2019 snapshotParaquat, atrazine and mancozeb aren't allowed in the EU but are used in Australia and the US; harm from eaten residues is unknown.The studies (10)
1 list comparison: 72 EU-banned pesticides used in the US · regulators confirm paraquat, mancozeb, atrazine
The details72 pesticides used outdoors in the US were banned or being phased out in the EU (2019). Residue health effects at dietary levels unproven. Country facts: paraquat not approved in the EU; kept in Australia with tight new limits (June 2026); US certified applicators only. Mancozeb not renewed in the EU (2021); 32 products registered in Australia; registered in the US. Atrazine withdrawn in the EU (2004); approved in Australia and the US. Organic rules ban synthetic pesticides, but US organic farming could use rotenone until 2019.Who makes this claim: Environmental and organic advocates; Donley 2019 (author employed by an environmental advocacy group)
Other · 1 claim · ?1
Switching to organic food improves health and helps you live longerNot yet knownMore data neededLink only · 2 weeks to 20 yearsNo trial has measured illness, and no study has compared deaths by organic eating; short trials only lowered pesticide and DNA-damage markers.The studies (14)
No trials of illness · no studies of deaths · residue-produce cohorts: mixed · 1 trial: markers lower
The detailsNo trial has measured a disease outcome. The longest controlled trial lasted 40 days (149 children). Cohorts compare habitual organic eaters with others, not people who switched. No guideline. Makris 2019: 8-OHdG GMR 0.888 (0.808–0.976). Abimbola 2024: urinary CRP fell under one creatinine adjustment (q = 0.045), not the other. One trial, no replication; no graded review. PubMed searches (57 and 15 hits) found no human mortality study of organic eating. Nearest: Andersen 2025, cardiovascular disease HR 0.94 per 6-point organic score (not deaths). A fruit-fly study (not rated) is the only lifespan evidence. US: 4+ vs under 1 serve a day of low-residue produce, 36% (32–41%) lower mortality; high-residue HR 0.93 (0.81–1.07); 27,026 deaths. Sweden, 68,844 adults: highest vs lowest fifth of dietary pesticide hazard index, cardiovascular death 0.82, cancer death 0.82. Neither compared organic with conventional food; eating more produce was linked with lower death overall. Bao 2020: highest vs lowest third, all-cause HR 1.56 (1.08–2.26), cardiovascular 3.00 (1.02–8.80); 8.5%, 10.2% and 11.9% died across rising thirds (raw counts, not adjusted). One urine sample; not replicated. Indoor insecticide use about doubles the odds of very high levels, so food isn't the only source. Organic-allowed natural pyrethrins are a separate class. Two multi-chemical NHANES mortality studies not checked for pyrethroids.Who makes this claim: Organic advocates; ORGANIKO trial researchers; organic advocates; Sandoval-Insausti 2022 authors; Environmental advocates
Not reviewed yet · 19 claims · ?19
Organic is better for the environment, soil and farm workersUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet: this card covers eaters' health. Farm workers' pesticide links appear under the related disease claims.The detailsWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet: this card covers eaters' health. Farm workers' pesticide links appear under the related disease claims.
Organic food tastes betterUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet: taste isn't a health outcome.The detailsWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet: taste isn't a health outcome.
Organic labels make processed foods seem healthier or lower in caloriesUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet: label experiments measure impressions, not what people eat.The detailsWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet: label experiments measure impressions, not what people eat.
Why there's no score yetNo score yet: the links with less heart disease, obesity and cancer come from studies that follow people, which can't separate organic food from buyers' income and lifestyle. Here's what we know so far, part by part.What you get 27/40: Three drivers of healthy years each score Small: heart disease about 6% lower per step up an organic-eating score, obesity about 11% lower, and cancer leaning 7% lower (the range includes no effect). Lower urine pesticides add little: no health effect has been shown.How sure 7/25: Early evidence at best: all three links come from studies that follow people, and the cancer result could go either way.Tradeoffs 14.25/20: Raw milk, organic or not, causes far more infections than pasteurised milk. Free-range and organic pork carries Toxoplasma more often, and eggs can carry more dioxins. Each can be avoided: pasteurised milk, well-cooked meat.Versus the alternative 5/15: Against conventional food eaten in the same amounts, washed or peeled: no difference in deaths or disease has been shown.Verdict Score out of 100, for someone who uses it as tested: what you get 40, how sure 25, tradeoffs 20, versus the alternative 15. Cost is shown, not scored. 75+ worth it · 60–74 worth it for some · 45–59 optional · under 45 skip it. With too little research on the main question, or only early research, there's no score or label, because a number would suggest we know.
Fact-checked 5 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
+ Add a note
16Turmeric and curcumin1 product⌄
Probably helps, a little, with knee arthritis pain: trials lasting 1–4 months found slightly less pain than placebo, on low-certainty evidence. It probably lowers a blood marker of inflammation; whether that brings health benefits hasn't been tested.
Product
Turmeric and curcumin supplements
What it is: Capsules or tablets of turmeric root or its main compound, curcumin, often with black pepper extract (piperine) or other forms made to absorb better.
–Early research onlyWorth doing?
Does turmeric ease inflammation and joint pain?
Probably helpsEarly evidence
A little, with knee arthritis pain: trials lasting 1–4 months found slightly less pain than placebo, on low-certainty evidence. It probably lowers a blood marker of inflammation; whether that brings health benefits hasn't been tested.
Bottom line: For knee arthritis pain, it may help a little short term, as an add-on to the exercise and weight care your doctor advises. Skip supplements if you've had liver problems, and stop if your skin or eyes turn yellow.
33 possible effects searched · 27 sources rated · independently checked · 9 Nov 2026
EffectStrength
Knee arthritis pain✓ Probably helps
Direct: about 3 points less on a 20-point scale; 1–4 months
Inflammation in the blood✓ Probably helps
Marker only: CRP about 0.6 mg/L lower; health not tested
Liver injury✕ Probably harmful
Link only: rare case reports, including deaths; label warnings required
✓ helps · ✕ harms · ○ no clear difference · ? not known · dots: strength of evidence
How to do it: Trials gave 80–1,500 mg of turmeric extract or curcumin a day for 1–4 months to adults with knee arthritis and measured pain and function, not the joint's long-term course.
Turmeric in cooking is fine; Australia's regulator says the liver risk doesn't appear to apply to food amounts.
Give it 1–4 months: that's how long the arthritis trials ran.
Read the label's liver warning and know the signs: yellow skin or eyes, dark urine, unusual tiredness.
You don't need a high-absorption form; they haven't eased pain more and may carry more liver risk.
Tell your doctor or pharmacist you take it, especially before surgery or with blood thinners.
Keep up the exercise and weight care your doctor recommends; turmeric is at most an add-on.
Buy spice from regulated stores; some imported loose turmeric has had lead added.
Sticking with it: No data on how many people keep taking it after a year.
Cost: About US$100–180 a year taken daily (US$16.42 for 60 days and US$14.99 for 30 days, 2 leading US products, Nov 2026; our estimate).
Check with your doctor first or skip it: Liver disease now or in the past, gallstones, pregnancy, children, or taking blood thinners or other regular medicines: avoid it or check with your doctor or pharmacist first (your doctor's call).
Risks and who should be careful (20)
taking turmeric leads people to put off proven arthritis careUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
turmeric or curcumin supplements cause liver injuryProbably harmfulEarly evidenceLink only · case reports, 2011–2025Rare, sometimes fatal liver injury has been reported, usually 1–4 months after starting; Australia and Canada now require label warnings.The studies (6)
2 regulators, 1 government reference, 1 case series: rare liver injury
The detailsTGA (to June 2023): 18 reports, 9 possibly linked, 1 death; mandatory label warning since March 2024. US network: 10 cases, 1 death, 7 of 10 with HLA-B*35:01. LiverTox 2025: several dozen cases. Health Canada 2025: 12 Canadian and over 60 international cases, 3 deaths (2 attributed); label warning. Risk may be higher with enhanced-absorption forms (TGA).Who makes this claim: Regulators: Australia's TGA, Health Canada, US NIH; liver specialists
turmeric supplements cause stomach upset or other side effects, in adultsProbably doesn't harmEarly evidenceDirect · up to 4 monthsIn trials of up to 4 months, stomach upset and other side effects were no more common than on placebo.The studies (3)
Reviews and trials: no more side effects than placebo
The detailsZhang 2025 (39 trials, 4,599 adults): no supplement increased adverse events vs placebo. Wang 2020: adverse events 39% vs 53% on placebo. Xu 2025: mild GI effects, headache, rash; no serious events. NCCIH lists nausea, reflux, diarrhoea.Who makes this claim: NCCIH; trial reports
turmeric raises the risk of kidney stonesUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
curcumin lowers iron levelsUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
turmeric raises bleeding risk with blood thinners and changes how some medicines work, in people taking medicinesLeans toward harm; not yet knownAnecdotalLink only · case reports and lab studiesCase reports link it with bleeding in people on blood thinners; lab studies show it can change medicine levels.The studies (3)
1 review of case reports · 1 lab review
The detailsHatfield 2022: turmeric among supplements linked with bleeding in people on anticoagulants, not otherwise. Bahramsoltani 2017: curcumin alters CYP and P-glycoprotein handling of several drug classes in lab and animal studies; 1 human trial. NCCIH: check with a provider if you take medicines.Who makes this claim: Pharmacists and interaction reviews; NCCIH; Health Canada
turmeric worsens gallstones or a blocked bile duct, in people with these conditionsLeans toward harm; not yet knownAnecdotalLink only · expert committee, 2018Europe's herbal-medicines committee, on expert judgement, advises against it with gallstones, bile-duct problems or liver disease.The studies (1)
1 regulator committee: avoid with gallstones
The detailsEMA HMPC 2018 monograph: 'not recommended in case of obstruction of the bile duct, cholangitis, liver disease, gallstones'.Who makes this claim: European Medicines Agency herbal committee
turmeric causes low blood sugar with diabetes medicinesUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
turmeric spice or products can carry lead, for regular users and childrenProbably harmfulEarly evidenceDirect · product testing, 2011–2021Testing found lead added to some turmeric sold in South Asian markets; store-bought spices in the US were low in lead.The studies (2)
2 testing surveys: lead in some imported turmeric
The detailsForsyth 2024: 14% of 356 South Asian market samples above 2 ug/g lead; some over 1,000 ug/g (lead chromate). Angelon-Gaetz 2022: US store-bought spices median 0.07 mg/kg; maximum 6,504 mg/kg in turmeric bought in India.Who makes this claim: Public-health researchers; US state lead investigators
Liver injuryRarely, turmeric supplements injure the liver, sometimes seriously. Stop and see a doctor if your skin or eyes turn yellow, or you have dark urine, unusual tiredness, nausea or stomach pain.The detailsTGA: 18 reports to June 2023, 9 possibly linked, 2 severe, 1 fatal; mandatory label warning from March 2024 at any dose. US DILIN: 10 cases, 5 hospitalised, 1 death, onset 1–4 months, 7 of 10 HLA-B*35:01. LiverTox 2025: several dozen cases.Therapeutic Goods Administration 2023 · 75 Good (official data)Therapeutic Goods Administration 2023 · 75 Good (official data)NIH LiverTox · 75 Good (official data)Halegoua-DeMarzio et al. 2023 · 39 Weak
Blood thinners and other medicinesIf you take a blood thinner or other regular medicines, ask your doctor or pharmacist before starting (your doctor's call).The detailsHatfield 2022: bleeding reports with anticoagulants; Bahramsoltani 2017: CYP and P-glycoprotein effects mostly in lab studies; NCCIH: check with a provider if you take medicines.Hatfield et al. 2022 · 39 WeakBahramsoltani et al. 2017 · 39 WeakUS National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health · 64 Limited
Stronger formsForms made to absorb better, such as those with black pepper extract, may carry more liver risk, and haven't been shown to ease pain more.The detailsTGA: risk may be higher with enhanced-absorption products or higher doses; 4 of 5 newer case reports involved piperine-enhanced products. NCCIH: highly bioavailable products may harm the liver.Therapeutic Goods Administration 2023 · 75 Good (official data)Therapeutic Goods Administration 2023 · 75 Good (official data)US National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health · 64 Limited
Lead in turmeric spiceSome loose turmeric sold in South Asian markets has had lead added for colour; buy spice from regulated stores.The detailsLead chromate found in some turmeric from South Asian markets (Forsyth 2024); US store-bought spices low in lead (Angelon-Gaetz 2022).Forsyth et al. 2024 · 54 LimitedAngelon-Gaetz et al. 2022 · 54 Limited
Arthritis care comes firstExercise and, if you're overweight, weight loss are the strongly recommended first steps for knee arthritis; turmeric isn't a substitute for them.The detailsRACGP 2018 strongly recommends land-based exercise for all people with knee OA and weight management (5–7.5% weight loss if overweight); it makes no recommendation for or against curcuma.RACGP 2018 · 71 GoodRACGP 2018 · 71 Good
CostAbout US$100–180 a year in the US and A$150–690 in Australia, taken as directed (leading products, Nov 2026; our estimate).The detailsUS: US$16.42 for 60 daily capsules and US$14.99 for a 30-day supply (2 leading products, Nov 2026). Australia: A$24.99 for 60 tablets at 1 a day and A$37.79 for 60 tablets at 3 a day (2 leading products with matching pack sizes, Nov 2026).
PrivacyNo privacy issues.The detailsNo data collected by taking a supplement.
The evidence, claim by claim (25)MembersJoint pain · 3 claims · ✓1?2
Turmeric or curcumin supplements ease knee arthritis pain, in adults with osteoarthritisProbably helpsEarly evidenceDirect · 4–16 weeksTrials of 1–4 months found a little less knee pain than placebo, about as much as standard pain relievers; certainty is low.The studies (7)
Low-quality reviews of the same trials: less pain · 1 newer trial: no difference
The detailsWai 2025 (17 trials, GRADE low): WOMAC pain about 2.5–3.2 points lower on a 0–20 scale than placebo, similar to NSAIDs. Zhang 2025: 12 mm less on a 100 mm scale; WOMAC pain not significant. Newest trial (combination, 2026): no difference. Chen 2026 (7 SRs): 37 of 48 outcomes extremely low quality. RACGP 2018: no recommendation either way.Who makes this claim: Supplement marketing ('joint support'); NCCIH ('positive initial evidence'); reviews by trial authors
Turmeric forms made to absorb better (with black pepper extract or special coatings) ease joint pain more than standard extractsNot yet knownEarly evidenceDirect · 4–16 weeksNo clear difference between forms in the one analysis comparing them, but it rested mostly on indirect comparisons.The studies (1)
1 network review: no clear difference between forms
The detailsWai 2025 network analysis: no significant difference between bioavailability-enhanced and conventional preparations; estimates low or very low certainty; few head-to-head trials.Who makes this claim: Makers of high-absorption products
Turmeric or curcumin keeps easing arthritis pain beyond 4 months, in adults with osteoarthritisNot yet knownMore data neededDirect · trials up to 4 monthsTrials have lasted 4 months at most, so whether the small benefit lasts hasn't been tested.The studies (2)
No trial longer than about 4 months
The detailsLiu 2018 (69 trials, GRADE): no supplement had clinically important long-term pain effects; turmeric trials ran 4–16 weeks (Xu 2025 table).Who makes this claim: Supplement marketing (long-term joint health)
Inflammation and blood markers · 3 claims · ✓3
Turmeric or curcumin lowers inflammation (CRP and other blood markers), in adultsProbably helpsEarly evidenceMarker only · 4–24 weeksTrials of 1–6 months lowered CRP, a blood marker of inflammation, by about 0.6 mg/L; whether that improves health hasn't been tested.The studies (3)
3 overlapping reviews: lower inflammation markers
The detailsDehzad 2023 (66 trials, 3,953 adults): CRP -0.58 mg/L; TNF-alpha and IL-6 also lower. Jafari 2024 rates CRP evidence high; Bahari 2025 rates it low, with publication bias. We follow the lower grade: trials disagree widely (I² about 99%).Who makes this claim: Supplement marketing ('anti-inflammatory'); trial authors
Curcumin lowers blood sugar, in adults with type 2 diabetesProbably helpsEarly evidenceMarker only · trials of weeks to monthsIn type 2 diabetes, trials lowered HbA1c by about half a point; across adults generally, the blood-sugar drop was too small to matter.The studies (2)
2 overlapping reviews: lower blood sugar
The detailsMokgalaboni 2024 (18 trials, 1,382 adults with T2D): HbA1c -0.54 points, fasting glucose about -0.64 mmol/L (our conversion). Across all adults (Dehzad 2023, 59 trials): fasting glucose about -0.26 mmol/L, below our worthwhile 0.3.Who makes this claim: Trial authors; supplement marketing ('blood sugar support')
Curcumin prevents type 2 diabetes, in adults with prediabetesProbably helpsEarly evidenceDirect · 9 monthsIn one unrepeated trial of 240 adults with prediabetes, none developed diabetes on curcumin, against about 1 in 6 on placebo.The studies (1)
1 trial: fewer new diabetes cases
The detailsChuengsamarn 2012 (240 Thai adults, 9 months): 16.4% on placebo developed T2DM vs 0% on curcumin. Single centre, not repeated; an effect this large needs confirming.Who makes this claim: Trial authors; supplement marketing
Medicines and who should avoid it · 2 claims · ?2
Turmeric or curcumin supplements are safe in pregnancy and breastfeedingNot yet knownUntestedLink only · no studiesSafety in pregnancy and breastfeeding hasn't been studied; regulators advise against supplements in pregnancy.The studies (2)
2 regulator statements: safety not established
The detailsEMA 2018: safety in pregnancy and lactation not established. NCCIH 2025: supplements in pregnancy may be unsafe; little known above food amounts in breastfeeding.Who makes this claim: EMA; NCCIH
Turmeric or curcumin supplements are safe for childrenNot yet knownUntestedLink only · no studiesUse in children hasn't been studied; Australia limits children's doses and bans it under 2.The studies (2)
2 regulators: not established; dose limits in Australia
The detailsEMA 2018: use under 18 not established. TGA (Australia, from March 2024): maximum 36 mg (2–3 years), 48 mg (4–11), 123 mg (12–17) of curcumin a day; not under 2.Who makes this claim: EMA; TGA
Not reviewed yet · 17 claims · ?17
Turmeric or curcumin lowers LDL cholesterolUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
Turmeric or curcumin lowers blood pressureUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
Turmeric or curcumin helps weight lossUntestedWe haven't reviewed the evidence for this yet.The details
Why there's no score yetNo score yet: the knee-pain benefit rests on early research, mostly small, short trials.What you get 17.8/40: Moderate: knee pain about 3 points lower on a 20-point scale in 1–4 month trials; the blood-marker changes add little.How sure 10/25: Early: the knee-pain benefit rests on low-certainty reviews of small, short trials.Tradeoffs 13/20: Rare but serious liver injury, with deaths reported, takes off 6; lead in some imported spice takes off 1 more. Blood thinners, gallstones, pregnancy and children go under who should skip it.Versus the alternative 5/15: About the same as standard pain relievers for knee arthritis pain, on low-certainty trials.Verdict Score out of 100, for someone who uses it as tested: what you get 40, how sure 25, tradeoffs 20, versus the alternative 15. Cost is shown, not scored. 75+ worth it · 60–74 worth it for some · 45–59 optional · under 45 skip it. With too little research on the main question, or only early research, there's no score or label, because a number would suggest we know.
Fact-checked 9 Nov 2026. Benefits are for people who use it as tested. No paid placement and no affiliate links.
+ Add a note
How everything here is rated
Books are ranked by what viewers and readers report actually happened. Rated studies are scored on how well they were done; the rest are our plain summaries, each with its main limit. Products and protocols are judged by what those studies show. Websites show a reliability rating where we've rated them; the rest are listed for what they're good for. Results vary by individual circumstances.
Studies and guidelines carry the Study Rating (design, risk of bias, size, independence, fit with the wider evidence, publication), on our health and social science scale built on GRADE. Each step's advice comes from our Eat evidence table (60 principles, 336 rated sources, independently fact-checked).
Websites are official and guideline bodies' pages; where we rated the guideline behind a page, its label is in the caution.
Books carry Book Rating v1.2: the first 30 Goodreads reviews of each book coded as helped, didn't help or already knew it, with the same weights as the video score. Two independent teams mapped 296 books to Eat's steps; a pick has to beat the typical book on reader outcomes. Videos (Vettey score) are being rated next.
No paid placement and no affiliate links: payment never affects a rating.
A guide to books, protocols, products, studies and websites. It isn't medical advice: check with your doctor before big changes, especially if you have a health condition.