Tears, and removing them, are both linked with later knee osteoarthritis, mostly a link, not proof. We found no trial showing exercise prevents it, though exercise and a healthy weight are core care if it develops. For injury tears, experts favour keeping the meniscus: your doctor's call.
What the research found: We found no trial showing that exercise, weight loss or education prevents knee osteoarthritis after a tear. In two trials, osteoarthritis progressed about as much after exercise as after removal surgery. For people going back to sport, training programmes of strength, balance and agility exercises cut ACL injuries in athletes by about half or more: in young women athletes, from 1 in 54 to 1 in 111. Only one study counted meniscus injuries, and it found no clear difference.
The figures and the limit
In one trial, 23% had X-ray osteoarthritis 10 years after surgery and 20% after exercise; in another, progression was comparable at 5 years. A 2025 review of 82 studies found training programmes cut ACL injuries by about 60% (0.39, 95% CI 0.25 to 0.60; high certainty), with no clear effect on all leg injuries (0.81, 0.61 to 1.08; low certainty). The review's summary gives no absolute figures; the 1 in 54 to 1 in 111 figure comes from an earlier pooled analysis of 18 studies in young women athletes. A US physiotherapy guideline gives these programmes its top grade for athletes: several sessions a week of more than 20 minutes. The one study that counted meniscus injuries, in elite men footballers, found no significant difference. For osteoarthritis itself, the guideline for England offers exercise to everyone and says that, for people who are overweight, losing 10% of body weight is likely to be better than 5%.
The limit: The osteoarthritis links come from studies that follow people, which can't show cause. The training studies were in athletes, more than half of them girls and women. They were prevention studies, not studies of people who already had a meniscus tear, and the one trial of preventing a second ACL injury (39 women) found no clear difference.
Exercises for strength and balance
Caution: The videos on these pages aren't specific to meniscus tears, and some show deep knee bends. After a repair, experts advise no deep squats, jumping or twisting for at least 4 months. Ask your physio which suit your tear and stage.