Vettey
Try free

Factor, quant and alternatives

For experienced investors: the evidence on factors, rules-based strategies, alternatives and private markets, hedging and expected returns.

Rated with our published methodupdated 4 November 2026no paid placement, everHow we rate

6 steps · 3 videos · 4 books · 25 studies · 20 websites · ✓ 45 success reports

6 steps, in order

Each step shows the best option of each kind first; “See more” has the rest.

1Understand the factor evidence2 videos1 book11 studies6 websites

Expect factor premiums to be smaller than first reported: returns fell after publication and many patterns failed stricter tests. Value and momentum appeared across many markets, but experts still dispute how many factors survive.

Best video

The Problem With Small Cap Stocks
11:45

The Problem With Small Cap Stocks

Ben Felix
67
Well rated
🎓 CFP✓ Community Validated
“Grateful for Avantis- AVUV, AVDV and AVEM. Proper Small and Value exposure.”
✓ 8 success reports· 1 failure
Tap for details ↓

Why this one: The top-scored video for this step, ranked by what viewers reported after watching: why the raw small-company premium is weak, how screening out unprofitable small companies changes the picture, and why many small-cap funds miss it.

Note: Names specific fund managers as examples; we don't recommend any fund.

▸ See 1 more videoMembers

Book

Understand the factor evidence

Your Complete Guide to Factor-Based Investing

Andrew L. Berkin and Larry E. Swedroe, 2016

81Top rated

★ 4.05 on Goodreads (396) · about 9 hours

3 of 4 readers who said either way said it helped

From 26 sampled Goodreads reviews: 3 helped, 1 didn't, 2 already knew most of it; the rest didn't say.

Claim: Fund researchers (Bridgeway; ex-Buckingham)Synthesis of published research

Helps an investor understand which factors (beta, size, value, momentum, profitability, quality, term, carry) survive scrutiny and how to tilt a portfolio towards them.

Heavier read: 11 of 26 sampled readers found it hard going (technical; assumes finance and statistics background).

The idea to hold onto: A factor earns a place only if its premium has lasted decades, shows up across markets and definitions, and has a sound explanation; most candidates fail.

What to read for this goal: The book has nine chapters, most testing one factor against the same criteria, then ten appendices. The chapters are the core for this stage; the appendices are optional.

Key terms, and if it's too heavy · 1 min
  • Factor and premium: A factor is a trait shared by many securities, such as cheapness or small size; its premium is the extra average return it has earned.
  • Market beta: The extra return from owning the stock market rather than safe Treasury bills; the first factor the book tests.
  • The five tests: A factor must be persistent over time, pervasive across markets, robust to different definitions, intuitive in explanation, and investable after costs.
  • Factor zoo: John Cochrane's phrase for the hundreds of factors in academic papers, many likely to be statistical flukes from data mining.
  • Tracking error regret: The discomfort of a factor-tilted portfolio lagging the market index for years, which leads many investors to abandon it at the wrong time.

Too heavy? No lighter rated book for this step yet: our research summary at /blog/factor-investing-what-the-research-says covers the main findings in about 13 minutes.

Our summary, not the author's words; checked 18 Oct 2026 against Bookey summary (chapter and appendix list), Advisor Perspectives review, Banker on Wheels review.

“Hard to follow the logic, but they now understand what factors are.”

▸ Why it's rated 81

Scorecard

Reader outcomes 40%

80

Content quality 20%

81

Author credibility 20%

90

Goal relevance 10%

100

Rating and format 10%

44

What readers said helped (paraphrased)

  • Hard to follow the logic, but they now understand what factors are.
  • Prompted them to add a multifactor ETF to their portfolio.
  • The book introduced them to factor investing.
Why it didn't help some
  • Considered it a fairly useless read.

Already knew most of it

  • Found it common sense; nothing surprised them.
  • Unsure it added much value for them given familiarity with the concepts.

Critics say: Written by advocates of factor funds; value's long slump after publication tested the book's optimism.

Rated for

Judge how much of the factor evidence survives scrutiny 81Know the main factors: value, size, momentum, profitability/quality, low volatility and investment 81Understand what a factor is and how factor premiums are measured 78

Key takeaways

  • Only a handful of the hundreds of published factors meet strict evidence tests
  • Factors can underperform for many years
  • Diversify across factors and keep costs low

From the first 26 Goodreads reviews, read 16 October 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 396 ratings, about 80% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. No audiobook found.

Find on AudibleGoodreads page

Best study

Gross profitability predicts returns about as well as value

Novy-Marx 2013 (Journal of Financial Economics) ↗

80StrongStudy quality

What it found: In mainly US stocks from 1963, gross profits relative to assets predicted returns about as well as cheapness (book-to-market). Profitable firms earned more despite looking expensive, and adding profitability markedly improved value strategies, especially in large, easily traded stocks.

What it means for you: Cheapness alone tells only part of the story; profitability also mattered, though later 'quality' measures are defined differently.

The figures and the limit

Gross profits divided by assets predicted the cross-section of average returns about as well as book-to-market. Profitable firms earned higher average returns despite higher valuation ratios, and controlling for profitability markedly improved value strategies, especially among large, liquid stocks.

The limit: Mainly US stocks from 1963; later 'quality' and profitability factors use different definitions, so results do not transfer one-for-one.

▸ See 10 more studiesMembers

Website: start here

Our research summary

Factor investing: what the research says →

Vettey Team

Best for: Our summary of the core papers, each linked: size, value, momentum, profitability and low beta, then the case against: returns 26% lower out-of-sample and 58% lower after publication across 97 predictors, the 452-anomaly replication study, and the paper that argues most factors do replicate.

▸ See 5 more websitesMembers

+ Add a note

2Put factors to work1 video3 studies6 websites

Judge a factor fund by its actual exposures and costs, not its recent record, which can be flattered by inflows and rising valuations. Timing factors added little after costs, so keep any tilt steady.

Video

Canada's New Evidence-Based ETFs
20:53

Canada's New Evidence-Based ETFs

Ben Felix
76
Highly rated
🎓 CFP✓ Community Validated
“I'm from the UK, but I bought the Avantis small cap/value fund a year ago due to your advice and it's up 40%....”
✓ 12 success reports· 0 failures
Tap for details ↓

Why this one: The top-scored video for this step, ranked by what viewers reported after watching: how rules-based factor funds tilt towards value, size and profitability compared with plain index funds, and the trade-offs of holding them.

Note: About funds newly listed in Canada; we don't recommend any fund, and what's available differs by country.

Best study

Fund 'hot hands' were mostly momentum and costs

Carhart 1997 (The Journal of Finance) ↗

82StrongStudy quality

What it found: In US share funds from 1962 to 1993, including funds that later closed, winning streaks were almost fully explained by common factors such as momentum, plus expenses. The only lasting pattern was the worst funds staying bad; the results didn't support manager skill.

What it means for you: Check a fund's factor exposure and fees before crediting its manager's skill for a strong record.

The figures and the limit

In a sample free of survivor bias, common factors (including one-year momentum) and expenses almost fully explained persistence in equity mutual fund returns. The only unexplained persistence was among the worst funds continuing to underperform, and the results did not support skilled managers.

The limit: US equity mutual funds, 1962 to 1993; the paper introduced the four-factor model commonly used to judge factor funds.

▸ See 2 more studiesMembers

Website: start here

Our research summary

Factor investing: what the research says →

Vettey Team

Best for: Sets out what research found on judging a fund by its factor exposures (the Carhart four-factor model), costs and crowding, the 'smart beta crash' warning and timing factors by their value spreads, alongside the evidence that published predictors weakened after publication.

▸ See 5 more websitesMembers

+ Add a note

3Quantitative and rules-based strategies1 book3 studies6 websites

Read any backtest sceptically: ask how many versions were tried, and expect live results to be weaker. Momentum and trend rules have long backtested records, but momentum has suffered rare, lasting crashes, mostly in rebounds.

Book

Quant and rules-based strategies

The Quants

Scott Patterson, 2010

68Well rated

★ 3.89 on Goodreads (9,532) · about 14 hours

3 of 5 readers who said either way said it helped

From 30 sampled Goodreads reviews: 3 helped, 2 didn't, 2 already knew most of it; the rest didn't say.

Claim: Wall Street Journal reporterJournalism and reported research

Understand how crowded quant strategies and leverage contributed to the 2007 quant quake and wider crisis.

“First quant book they read; shaped their career path and still cites it in interviews.”

▸ Why it's rated 68

Scorecard

Reader outcomes 40%

82

Content quality 20%

39

Author credibility 20%

60

Goal relevance 10%

100

Rating and format 10%

55

What readers said helped (paraphrased)

  • First quant book they read; shaped their career path and still cites it in interviews.
  • Learned of a specific figure's role in inspiring hedge funds, which they had not known.
  • Starting an algorithmic fund; realised quant traders created many derivative products.
Why it didn't help some
  • Former practitioner wanted new insights; says the few insights were lost amid dramatics.
  • Says the book did not work for them because they got easily confused.

Already knew most of it

  • Mostly material already available in profiles they had read; only a couple of new vignettes.
  • Knows many of the people involved; says those familiar with events learn very little.

Critics say: Dramatised and personality-driven; light on technical substance; arguably overstates quants' role in the crisis.

Rated for

Understand how quant funds work and their limits 68

Key takeaways

  • Many quant funds held similar crowded positions.
  • Leverage and crowding amplified the August 2007 unwind.
  • Models can underestimate extreme events.

From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 16 October 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 9,532 ratings, about 82% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. 1 reader says the effect has lasted. Audiobook, 14.2 h.

Find on AudibleGoodreads page

Best study

What it found: In US stocks from 1927 and other markets, momentum strategies earned strong average returns but suffered rare, lasting streaks of big losses, mostly as markets rebounded from falls amid high volatility. Scaling bets to forecasts roughly doubled return per unit of risk in backtests.

What it means for you: Momentum can crash, usually when markets rebound after falls; the improved version is only a backtest.

The figures and the limit

Momentum strategies had strong average returns but suffered infrequent, persistent strings of large losses. These crashes were partly forecastable: they occurred in panic states after market declines, when volatility was high and the market rebounded. A dynamic version that scaled exposure using forecasts of momentum's mean and variance roughly doubled the static strategy's Sharpe ratio in the authors' tests.

The limit: US stocks from 1927 plus international equities and other asset classes; the dynamic strategy is a backtest.

▸ See 2 more studiesMembers

Website: start here

Our research summary

Factor investing: what the research says →

Vettey Team

Best for: What research found on momentum crashes, time-series momentum and a century of trend following (a simulation, not fund returns), and backtest overfitting, including the deflated Sharpe ratio.

▸ See 5 more websitesMembers

+ Add a note

4Alternatives and private markets1 book4 studies5 websites

Judge private equity and hedge funds after all fees, which are higher than headline rates suggest. Private equity has roughly matched public shares in several studies, but results swing with the data and benchmark.

Book

Alternatives and private markets

Pioneering Portfolio Management

David F. Swensen, 2000

77Highly rated

★ 4.16 on Goodreads (1,368) · about 18 hours

6 of 9 readers who said either way said it helped

From 30 sampled Goodreads reviews: 6 helped, 3 didn't; the rest didn't say.

Claim: Yale endowment CIOMethod from professional practiceWritten for professionals

Helps an advanced investor understand how a long-horizon institution sets goals, diversifies into alternatives, manages illiquidity and selects external managers.

Heavier read: 11 of 30 sampled readers found it hard going (dense and textbook-like).

The idea to hold onto: Swensen's case for alternatives rests on an institution's advantages: a very long horizon, tolerance for illiquidity, and access to top external managers. Without them, the case weakens.

What to read for this goal: For this stage: 'Asset Allocation', 'Alternative Asset Classes' and 'Asset Class Management' (manager selection). 'Endowment Purposes' and 'Investment and Spending Goals' are institution-specific; 'Investment Process' and the appendix, 'Impure Fixed Income', are optional. (Chapter titles from the 2009 revised edition.)

Key terms, and if it's too heavy · 1 min
  • Intergenerational equity: Balancing spending for today's beneficiaries against preserving the fund's purchasing power for future ones.
  • Spending rule: Yale's smoothing formula, blending last year's spending with a long-term target rate so payouts stay stable when markets swing.
  • Absolute return: Yale's label for hedge-fund strategies that aim to earn returns largely independent of stock and bond market moves.
  • Illiquidity: Holdings such as private equity and real estate that cannot be sold quickly. A long-horizon fund can accept this, in exchange for potentially higher returns.
  • Agency issues: Conflicts between the interests of those managing money, internally or externally, and the interests of the fund they manage.

Too heavy? No lighter rated book for this step yet. Our research summary's private equity and hedge-fund-fee sections are the closest match, but it doesn't cover the endowment model itself.

Our summary, not the author's words; checked 18 Oct 2026 against EDHEC library record (2009 edition contents), Simon & Schuster (2009 edition), Emily Li review.

“Most ideas were reminders, but asset-liability matching for endowments was new and gave a fresh lens.”

▸ Why it's rated 77

Scorecard

Reader outcomes 40%

75

Content quality 20%

62

Author credibility 20%

90

Goal relevance 10%

100

Rating and format 10%

68

What readers said helped (paraphrased)

  • Most ideas were reminders, but asset-liability matching for endowments was new and gave a fresh lens.
  • Skimmed it; learned that colleges operate largely as big investment portfolios.
  • Key lesson learned: importance of asset allocation alongside good investment ideas.
  • Took away the insight that many institutions are poor at active management.
  • Learned active management can work for a big endowment and why; clarified portfolio principles.
  • Expanded understanding of a new field, notably manager relationships and due diligence.
Why it didn't help some
  • Content too much and not applicable for everyday investors like the reviewer; suggests articles instead.
  • Found it basic, with nothing novel or genuinely insightful for them.
  • Remembers little from the book.

Critics say: Built for large institutions with manager access; endowments copying the model have often trailed simple passive mixes since 2008.

Rated for

Understand the endowment model and why it's hard to copy 77Understand private equity and venture returns and how they're measured 75

Key takeaways

  • Equity bias and broad diversification drive long-run results
  • Illiquid alternatives only pay with genuinely top-tier managers
  • Disciplined rebalancing and governance matter as much as asset choice

From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 16 October 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 1,368 ratings, about 75% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. Audiobook, 17.8 h.

Find on AudibleGoodreads page

Best study

What it found: Over 22 years of hedge fund data, investors effectively paid about 50% of gains in incentive fees, not the headline 20%, as about 60% of gains that earned fees were later lost. An earlier version found investors kept 36 cents per dollar earned above cash.

What it means for you: Headline hedge fund fees understate what investors pay; check how incentive fees apply when gains are later lost.

The figures and the limit

Over a 22-year sample of hedge funds, the effective incentive fee rate was about 50% rather than the headline 20%, because about 60% of the gains on which incentive fees were paid were later offset by losses. The working-paper version estimated investors kept 36 cents of every dollar earned above a risk-free hurdle, before risk adjustment.

The limit: Funds in commercial hedge fund databases (5,917 funds in the working paper); before risk adjustment. One author, Ben-David, discloses that he co-founded and is a partner in an investment adviser that manages a small number of friends-and-family accounts for an incentive fee; until 2016 the adviser was a general partner in a hedge fund.

▸ See 3 more studiesMembers

Website: start here

Our research summary

Factor investing: what the research says →

Vettey Team

Best for: What research found on private equity against public markets (results swing with the data source and benchmark), private equity fees and reported valuations, what hedge fund investors kept after incentive fees (an effective rate of about 50%, not 20%), and commodity futures.

▸ See 4 more websitesMembers

+ Add a note

5Hedging and tail risk1 book2 studies6 websites

To limit falls from a peak, holding less in shares has done better than typical rolling put-buying programs. Covered calls mainly give share exposure plus a volatility premium, with some unrewarded risk. Mostly US data.

Book

Hedging and tail risk

Safe Haven

Mark Spitznagel, 2021

77Highly rated

★ 4.01 on Goodreads (904) · about 7 hours

7 of 11 readers who said either way said it helped

From 30 sampled Goodreads reviews: 7 helped, 4 didn't, 2 already knew most of it; the rest didn't say.

Claim: Founder, tail-hedging fund UniversaMethod from professional practice

Helps an advanced investor understand how drawdowns erode compound returns and judge whether a hedge actually improves portfolio growth after its cost.

Heavier read: 13 of 30 sampled readers found it hard going (mathematical; assumes options and statistics background).

The idea to hold onto: A hedge is worth having only if the whole portfolio compounds faster with it than without it, after paying its cost in good years.

What to read for this goal: For this stage: Part One, 'What Comes First' ('At War with Luck', 'Nature's Admonition', 'The Eternal Return'), builds the compounding argument through worked games; Part Two, 'What Comes After' ('A Taxonomy', 'Holism', 'Bold Conjectures'), applies it to real hedges. The Afterword is optional.

Key terms, and if it's too heavy · 1 min
  • Arithmetic versus geometric average: The simple average of yearly returns versus the compound rate actually earned. Losses pull the compound rate below the simple average.
  • One path, not the average: An investor lives through one sequence of returns, so a strategy that looks good averaged across many outcomes can still ruin that path.
  • Kelly criterion: A formula for sizing bets to maximise long-run compound growth; betting too much raises the average outcome but makes ruin likely.
  • Store of value, alpha, insurance: The book's three types of safe haven: assets that hold steady, strategies that tend to profit in crises, and explicit crash insurance.
  • Cost-effective hedge: A hedge judged by its net effect on the whole portfolio's compound growth after its ongoing cost, not by how much it cuts volatility.

Too heavy? No lighter rated book for this step yet. The 'Hedging and tail risk' section of our research summary covers studies of put-protection programmes; it doesn't cover the book's compounding argument.

Our summary, not the author's words; checked 18 Oct 2026 against Wiley-VCH (contents), Hedge Fund Alpha review, The Surf Report review.

“Now understands why people buy tail-risk puts and will buy them; changed their portfolio beliefs.”

▸ Why it's rated 77

Scorecard

Reader outcomes 40%

77

Content quality 20%

52

Author credibility 20%

90

Goal relevance 10%

100

Rating and format 10%

75

What readers said helped (paraphrased)

  • Now understands why people buy tail-risk puts and will buy them; changed their portfolio beliefs.
  • Got a better handle on geometric vs arithmetic averages and the Kelly criterion.
  • Paradigm shift in understanding risk; better grasps costs and risks of hedging or not.
  • Developed their thinking; now sees two distinct approaches to equity portfolio construction.
  • Central insight on hedged compounding was new; already applying the framework to own investments.
  • Gave them a basis to question their own passive-investing assumptions.
  • Provided simulations and backtesting ideas for their own research and investing.
Why it didn't help some
  • Wanted to learn more from the author but found it a disappointment.
  • Could not continue past the first chapter.
  • Too complex even for an experienced investor; did not get the book.
  • Without advanced expertise, could not glean useful information from it.

Already knew most of it

  • Says a blog post on two concepts covers most of the book.
  • Learned nothing new; had already read widely on the subject.

Critics say: Does not show how an individual could build the payoff he describes; Universa's results are not independently published.

Rated for

Evaluate tail-risk hedging and safe-haven assets 77

Key takeaways

  • Compound (geometric) returns, not average returns, are what matter
  • Most popular safe havens cost more than they add
  • A hedge is only worth holding if it raises portfolio growth

From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 16 October 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 904 ratings, about 77% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. Audiobook, 6.7 h.

Find on AudibleGoodreads page

Best study

Protective puts often protect less than expected

Israelov 2018 (The Journal of Alternative Investments) ↗

50LimitedStudy quality

What it found: In simulations and an S&P 500 put-protection index, typical rolling put-buying programs did a poor job of reducing falls from a peak, compared with simply holding fewer shares. Unless purchases and expiries lined up with falls, puts could make falls and volatility worse.

What it means for you: To cut losses in a fall, holding less in shares has worked better than typical put-buying programs.

The figures and the limit

In simulations and a study of the CBOE S&P 500 5% Put Protection Index, typical protective put programs were quite ineffective at reducing drawdowns compared with simply holding less equity. Unless purchases and expiries happened to line up with drawdowns, puts could increase drawdowns and volatility per unit of expected return.

The limit: US S&P 500 options; covers typical rolling put programs, not every tail-hedge design (some practitioners argue rules for selling puts early change results).

▸ See 1 more studyMembers

Website: start here

Our research summary

Factor investing: what the research says →

Vettey Team

Best for: What research found on where covered-call returns come from (an uncompensated exposure made up about a quarter of risk) and how typical protective put programs compared with simply holding less equity.

▸ See 5 more websitesMembers

+ Add a note

6Expected returns2 studies6 websites

Build expected returns from several sources, leaning on current yields and valuations more than past averages. Valuation signals have mostly failed to time the market, so keep tactical tilts small.

Best study

85StrongStudy quality

What it found: Re-testing dividend yields, earnings yields, book-to-market, interest rates and other signals on US data to 2005, Welch and Goyal found they had failed to forecast the market over the prior 30 years. A reply found forecasts with simple common-sense limits beat the historical average slightly.

What it means for you: Don't expect valuation or interest-rate signals to time the market well; any forecasting edge has been small.

The figures and the limit

Reexamining dividend yields, earnings yields, book-to-market, interest rates and other predictors, Welch and Goyal found the forecasting models had failed both in-sample and out-of-sample over the prior 30 years and would not have helped an investor time the market. Campbell and Thompson responded that forecasts with simple sign restrictions beat the historical average, though by a small margin.

The limit: US equity premium, data to 2005; the debate is over small out-of-sample gains.

▸ See 1 more studyMembers

Website: start here

Our research summary

Factor investing: what the research says →

Vettey Team

Best for: What research found on forecasting the equity premium (most models failed out-of-sample; a reply found small gains) and on building estimates from historical averages, theory, forward-looking indicators and views.

▸ See 5 more websitesMembers

+ Add a note

How everything here is rated

Videos and books are ranked by what viewers and readers report actually happened. Rated studies are scored on how well they were done; the rest are our plain summaries, each with its main limit. Websites, channels and tools are listed for what they're good for, not yet rated. Results vary by individual circumstances.

  • Books carry Book Rating v1.2: the first 30 Goodreads reviews of each book coded as helped, didn't help or already knew it, with the same weights as the video score. A pick has to beat the typical book on reader outcomes.
  • Videos carry the Vettey score: what viewers reported in the comments after trying it (40%), content quality (20%), creator credibility (20%), goal relevance (10%) and metadata (10%). Only videos scoring 60 or more are listed.
  • Research findings are our summaries of published studies, each with its main limit and a link to the source. They aren't given a Study Rating.
  • Websites, channels and tools are listed for what they're good for, with any cautions. They aren't rated.

Updated 4 November 2026. How we rate research ·

A guide to videos, books, studies and websites. It isn't financial advice: it doesn't know your circumstances, and past returns don't guarantee future ones.