Vettey
Try free

Allocate capital

For people running their own portfolio: expected returns, how much risk to take, position sizing, leverage, valuing a business and spending rules.

Rated with our published methodupdated 4 November 2026no paid placement, everHow we rate

7 steps · 13 books · 28 studies · 21 websites · ✓ 53 success reports

7 steps, in order

Each step shows the best option of each kind first; “See more” has the rest.

1Estimate expected returns5 studies6 websites

Expect less than past averages: part of past share returns came from rising valuations, which need not repeat. Starting valuations hint at the next decade but have made a poor timing tool. Mostly US data.

Best study

Most published return predictors failed out of sample, in an update to 2021

Goyal, Welch & Zafirov 2024 (Review of Financial Studies) ↗

74GoodStudy quality

What it found: Re-tested with US data to 2021, over a third of 29 newer market-forecasting signals failed even when fitted to the whole period, and half the rest did poorly on new data. A few still worked.

What it means for you: Treat published market-forecasting signals sceptically: most haven't held up on later data.

The figures and the limit

Goyal, Welch and Zafirov re-tested 29 variables from 26 papers published after Goyal and Welch (2008), plus the original 17, with data to the end of 2021. More than one-third of the new variables were no longer significant even in sample. Of those that were, half performed poorly out of sample. A small number still performed reasonably well both in and out of sample.

The limit: US equity premium data. Valuation ratios are among the variables tested. Updates the 2008 study cited at Levels 2 and 4 rather than repeating it. Statistical performance alone doesn't show that a timing rule would have paid after costs.

▸ See 4 more studiesMembers

Website: start here

Our research summary

Allocating capital: what the research says →

Vettey Team

Best for: Our cited summary, starting with five findings for this step: starting valuation explained about a quarter of next-10-year US returns (R-squared 0.24, 1900–2015), yet a valuation-timing strategy had a Sharpe ratio of 0.37 against 0.38 for buy-and-hold; most published return predictors failed out of sample in an update to 2021; the world equity premium since 1900 with lower forward estimates; and the contested question of whether the US record is the exception.

▸ See 5 more websitesMembers

+ Add a note

2Decide how much risk to take2 books3 studies5 websites

Decide your share in risky assets with the typical outcome in mind, not the average, and take little enough risk that a bad run can't ruin you. The formulas are very sensitive to their inputs.

Best book

Decide how much risk to take

The Missing Billionaires

Victor Haghani and James White, 2023

84Top rated

★ 3.81 on Goodreads (703) · about 11 hours

6 of 8 readers who said either way said it helped

From 30 sampled Goodreads reviews: 6 helped, 2 didn't; the rest didn't say.

Claim: Elm Wealth's founder (Haghani, LTCM co-founder) and CEO (White)Synthesis of published research

Helps investors size risky positions with the Merton share, set a spending rule tied to wealth and risk, and avoid ruinous over-betting. It also covers annuities: the authors show fairly priced ones can add a lot for retirees, and say expense, complexity and opacity are why few people buy them.

Heavier read: 15 of 30 sampled readers found it hard going (maths and statistics; reads like an economics textbook).

The idea to hold onto: The authors, who run Elm Wealth, treat spending and investing as one lifetime decision, sizing risk by expected excess return, risk and risk aversion, and warn against over-betting.

What to read for this goal: For this sub-goal, read Section II, Lifetime Spending and Investing, and "Human Capital" in Section III. "A Taste of the Merton Share" sets up the core rule. The shaded technical sidebars and Section IV, Puzzles, are optional.

Key terms, and if it's too heavy · 1 min
  • Merton share: The fraction of wealth to hold in a risky asset: its expected excess return divided by risk aversion times the asset's variance.
  • Expected utility: Judging a choice by the average satisfaction, rather than money, it brings across outcomes; since each extra dollar adds less, large losses outweigh equal gains.
  • Relative risk aversion: A number for how strongly someone dislikes risk; the authors put typical investors around 2 to 3, and higher numbers mean smaller risky positions.
  • Certainty-equivalent return: The certain return someone would accept in place of a risky one; it lets risky choices be compared on a like-for-like basis.
  • Human capital: The value today of a person's expected future earnings, which lifetime models count alongside financial wealth.

Too heavy? Try Lifecycle Investing (Book Rating 93 on this page) first: a short book built on one easy-to-grasp idea, spreading stock exposure across a lifetime.

Our summary, not the author's words; checked 18 Oct 2026 against The Missing Billionaires: contents (Wiley-VCH), Sex, Lies, and Optimizing Utility: review by William Bernstein (Advisor Perspectives, Dec 2023), A New Book Takes a Deep Dive at Solving the Portfolio Problem by James Picerno (The Capital Spectator, Nov 2023).

“Shifted their thinking on saving; utility maximisation now seemed practically usable for them.”

▸ Why it's rated 84

Scorecard

Reader outcomes 40%

84

Content quality 20%

81

Author credibility 20%

90

Goal relevance 10%

100

Rating and format 10%

66

What readers said helped (paraphrased)

  • Shifted their thinking on saving; utility maximisation now seemed practically usable for them.
  • Now sees maximising expected utility, not wealth; finally grasped volatility drag via coin game.
  • Sizing concepts new to them; realised common knowledge on investment sizing is weak.
  • Learned their instinctive 50% bet size was far too high; optimal is 10-20%.
  • Opening case prompted them to question how they manage their own money.
  • Some puzzles helped them see their own cognitive biases; most of book a slog.
Why it didn't help some
  • Wanted concrete position-sizing advice for own portfolio; found none usable, waste of time.
  • Could not connect with the core idea; still unsure how to apply utility approach.

Critics say: Formula-heavy and US-centric; sells the authors' firm's dynamic-allocation philosophy.

Rated for

Account for human capital, horizon and other wealth over your lifetime 84Set your risky-asset share from expected excess return, volatility and risk aversion (the Merton share) 84Understand the Kelly criterion and why practitioners bet a fraction of it 84Understand expected utility, risk aversion and why the average return isn't what you maximise 82Choose a spending rule (fixed real amount, percentage of portfolio, guardrails or amortisation-based) 82Break an asset's expected return into income, growth and change in valuation 82

Key takeaways

  • Size risk with expected return, variance and risk aversion (Merton share)
  • Spend a fraction linked to wealth and expected returns
  • Excess risk and spending explain why fortunes vanish

From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 18 October 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 703 ratings, about 84% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. Audiobook, 11.2 h.

Find on AudibleGoodreads page

▸ See 1 more bookMembers

Best study

The average return overstates what a typical investor ends up with

Hughson, Stutzer & Yung 2006 (Financial Analysts Journal) ↗

52LimitedStudy quality

What it found: Long-run share returns are lopsided: a few big outcomes pull the average up, so the typical result is lower. In the authors' simulations of a large-company share index, only about 30% of runs reached the expected 30-year return.

What it means for you: Plan around the typical outcome, which is lower than the average return compounded over decades.

The figures and the limit

Long-horizon cumulative returns are skewed, so the median outcome sits below the mathematical expectation. The chance of reaching the expected cumulative return falls toward zero as the horizon lengthens. In the authors' simulated index (lognormal, about 15% yearly volatility), there was only about a 30% probability of meeting or exceeding the expected 30-year cumulative return. To forecast the median outcome, they compound the average log (geometric) return instead. Even with 54 years of data, typical stock volatility of 15% leaves historical averages uncertain by about ±400 basis points.

The limit: A statistical argument with simulations, not a study of investors. The 30% figure depends on the assumed volatility and horizon.

▸ See 2 more studiesMembers

Website: start here

Our research summary

Allocating capital: what the research says →

Vettey Team

Best for: What research found on why the median outcome sits below the average (about a 30% chance of meeting the expected 30-year cumulative return in one simulation), the Merton share and the assumptions behind it, and the coin-flip experiment in which 28% of quantitatively trained players went bust despite a 60/40 edge.

▸ See 4 more websitesMembers

+ Add a note

3Size and concentrate positions3 books4 studies3 websites

The evidence favours staking less than the growth-maximising (Kelly) amount, as edges are uncertain, and holding more stocks: concentration cost most investors studied. Selling deserves the same care as buying. Mostly US data.

Best book

Size and concentrate positions

The Warren Buffett Portfolio

Robert G. Hagstrom, 1999

85Top rated

★ 4.23 on Goodreads (1,978) · about 6 hours

5 of 6 readers who said either way said it helped

From 30 sampled Goodreads reviews: 5 helped, 1 didn't, 2 already knew most of it; the rest didn't say.

Claim: Portfolio manager; formerly CIO, Legg Mason Focus CapitalMethod from professional practice

Helps an investor understand the trade-offs of concentrated portfolios, position sizing and tolerating volatility relative to an index.

“Learned focus investing beyond CFA classes; realised investing is hard work.”

▸ Why it's rated 85

Scorecard

Reader outcomes 40%

89

Content quality 20%

62

Author credibility 20%

90

Goal relevance 10%

100

Rating and format 10%

93

What readers said helped (paraphrased)

  • Learned focus investing beyond CFA classes; realised investing is hard work.
  • Knew of concentrated bets but only grasped their vital importance after reading.
  • Gained better understanding of their own investing style and how they analyse businesses.
  • Reflected on their position sizing and formulated pointed questions for their newsletter provider.
  • Learned about focused portfolios and picking companies by business economics, not stock price.
Why it didn't help some
  • Waste of time; did not deliver the Buffett-focused content they expected.

Already knew most of it

  • Not much new for anyone who has read a bit about investing.
  • Learned nothing; already familiar with Berkshire meetings and mental models.

Critics say: Concentration raises the dispersion of outcomes; the book leans on Buffett's exceptional record and some Kelly-style sizing is loosely applied.

Rated for

Decide how concentrated to be 85Size positions by edge, downside and correlation, and set rules to add, trim or sell 83

Key takeaways

  • Concentrate in a few businesses you understand well
  • Size positions by conviction and probability
  • Expect to lag the index at times when concentrated

From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 18 October 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 1,978 ratings, about 89% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. Audiobook, 5.8 h.

Find on AudibleGoodreads page

▸ See 2 more booksMembers

Best study

What it found: In US broker accounts, 1991–1996, households holding few stocks picked better trades than diversified ones, but took more risk and earned less for it. Concentration usually cost investors; focused funds did worse after fees.

What it means for you: Concentration cost most investors in these studies; only a small group seemed to have the information to justify it.

The figures and the limit

Using US discount-broker accounts from 1991 to 1996, Ivković, Sialm and Weisbenner found that stock trades by households with concentrated portfolios outperformed those of diversified households, especially in larger accounts and in local or non-S&P 500 stocks. But the concentrated portfolios carried more total risk and had lower Sharpe ratios. Goetzmann and Kumar found most US individual investors under-diversified, in patterns linked to overconfidence, trend-following and local bias, and that under-diversification was costly for most of them; only a small subset appeared to concentrate because of superior information. Among mutual funds, Sapp and Yan found that focused funds (few holdings) did no better than diversified funds before expenses, significantly worse after them, and closed more often.

The limit: Contested. The concentrated-household result shows better stock selection on average, not better risk-adjusted portfolios; the other two studies find concentration costly on average. All are US observational studies in which investors and funds chose their own level of concentration.

▸ See 3 more studiesMembers

Website: start here

Our research summary

Allocating capital: what the research says →

Vettey Team

Best for: What research found on Kelly betting (in one example of 700 bets, full Kelly reached $100,000 or more 16.6% of the time but could leave $18), shortfall risk still falling beyond 100 stocks, the contested evidence on concentration, and professional managers whose sales did worse than selling at random.

▸ See 2 more websitesMembers

+ Add a note

4Use (or avoid) leverage1 book2 studies9 websites

Not borrowing is a valid choice. If you borrow, know how far markets can fall before a margin call forces a sale, and don't expect daily-reset leveraged funds to track a steady multiple over time.

Book

Use (or avoid) leverage

Lifecycle Investing

Ian Ayres and Barry J. Nalebuff, 2010

93Top rated

★ 4.12 on Goodreads (417) · about 7 hours

6 of 7 readers who said either way said it helped

From 30 sampled Goodreads reviews: 6 helped, 1 didn't; the rest didn't say.

Claim: Yale professors of law and economicsAuthor's own research

Helps investors understand time diversification across a lifetime and consider modest early leverage to spread equity exposure more evenly.

“Years ago it first introduced them to lifecycle investing theory, though they now dislike the strategy.”

▸ Why it's rated 93

Scorecard

Reader outcomes 40%

93

Content quality 20%

90

Author credibility 20%

100

Goal relevance 10%

100

Rating and format 10%

81

What readers said helped (paraphrased)

  • Years ago it first introduced them to lifecycle investing theory, though they now dislike the strategy.
  • Time diversification via early leverage became central to their investing life.
  • Book shaped their retirement investing strategy more than any other; listed their adopted takeaways.
  • Became convinced leverage when young is rational; gave them hope for alternative strategies.
  • Most influential book on their own retirement strategy.
  • Persuaded that leverage, with guardrails, belongs in an investment strategy.
Why it didn't help some
  • Strategies too advanced and not what they wanted; borrowing to invest felt too risky.

Critics say: Leverage advice is contested and depends on cheap borrowing and investor discipline; US-centric.

Rated for

Account for human capital, horizon and other wealth over your lifetime 93Decide whether to use leverage, and set a limit 93Understand how leverage changes returns, volatility drag and the risk of ruin 91

Key takeaways

  • Diversify across time, not only across assets
  • Modest leverage when young can lower lifetime risk
  • Target a lifetime equity exposure, then deleverage

From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 18 October 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 417 ratings, about 93% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. 2 readers say the effect has lasted. Audiobook, 6.6 h.

Find on AudibleGoodreads page

Best study

What it found: In US data back to 1871, borrowing up to 2:1 for shares while young, then holding less in shares later, matched the average retirement wealth of a steady 75% in shares, with about 21% less spread. At 2:1, one portfolio lost 53% in October 1929.

What it means for you: Early borrowing helped in this contested test, but deep falls and margin calls can force sales at low prices.

The figures and the limit

Using US stock data back to 1871, Ayres and Nalebuff find that holding stocks at up to 2:1 leverage early in working life, then reducing equity exposure later, produced the same average retirement wealth as a constant 75% stock allocation with a 21% smaller standard deviation. For an investor with relative risk aversion of 4, they estimate a 37% gain in certainty-equivalent wealth. The worst month was October 1929, when a fully leveraged young investor's portfolio fell 53% in that month. About one cohort in eight (11 of 96) lost more than 40% in at least one month. At 2:1 leverage with a 25% maintenance margin, forced selling starts after a market fall of about one-third; in their monthly-rebalanced data there were no margin calls under a 25% maintenance requirement, and six months with calls under 35%.

The limit: Contested and dependent on assumptions: cheap borrowing, monthly rebalancing and continuing to invest through crashes. Figures are from the authors' 2010 working paper; the 2013 Journal of Portfolio Management version may differ. Regulators (the SEC, FINRA and ASIC's Moneysmart) warn that margin calls can force sales at low prices; see Websites.

▸ See 1 more studyMembers

Website: start here

Our research summary

Allocating capital: what the research says →

Vettey Team

Best for: What research found on leverage when young (the same average retirement wealth with a 21% smaller standard deviation in US data back to 1871, but a 53% fall in the worst month (October 1929), and forced selling after a market fall of about one-third at 2:1), and on why daily-reset leveraged funds drift from their stated multiple.

▸ See 8 more websitesMembers

+ Add a note

5Value a business3 books5 studies7 websites

Value a business on modest growth assumptions: high earnings growth rarely lasts and high profitability tends to fade. Check how management has used cash on buybacks and acquisitions; neither is automatically good. Mostly US data.

Best book

Value a business

Expectations Investing

Alfred Rappaport and Michael J. Mauboussin, 2001

90Top rated

★ 3.95 on Goodreads (341) · about 7 hours

3 of 4 readers who said either way said it helped

From 19 sampled Goodreads reviews: 3 helped, 1 didn't, 2 already knew most of it; the rest didn't say.

Claim: Kellogg professor emeritus; researcher at Counterpoint Global (Morgan Stanley Investment Management, a fund manager)Method from professional practiceWritten for professionals

Helps an investor work out what a share price already implies about future cash flows, and judge whether those expectations are realistic.

Heavier read: 4 of 19 sampled readers found it hard going (technical terms and coined jargon; the M&A chapter).

The idea to hold onto: A share price already embeds a forecast. The method reads that forecast first, then asks whether the company is more likely to exceed it or fall short.

What to read for this goal: For this stage, read Part I, Gathering the Tools, then "How to Estimate Price-Implied Expectations". "Beyond Discounted Cash Flow" (real options) and the later corporate-signals chapters, including "Mergers and Acquisitions", which some readers found needlessly complicated, are optional here.

Key terms, and if it's too heavy · 1 min
  • Reverse DCF: Running a discounted cash flow model backwards: taking the share price as given and solving for the forecasts it implies, instead of estimating value.
  • Price-implied expectations: The future sales growth, margins and investment a company must deliver to justify its current share price.
  • Market-implied forecast period: The number of years of forecast cash flows needed to justify today's share price.
  • Expectations infrastructure: The authors' map linking value triggers (sales, costs, investments) through value factors, such as price/mix and economies of scale, to value drivers.
  • Value drivers: The forecast inputs, such as sales growth, operating margins and investment needs, that set free cash flow and therefore value.

Too heavy? Try Warren Buffett Accounting Book (Book Rating 80 on this page) first: sampled readers found its line-by-line walk through financial statements easy for beginners.

Our summary, not the author's words; checked 18 Oct 2026 against Expectations Investing: chapter summaries (authors' book site, revised edition), Expectations Investing, 2003 paperback: contents (Librairie Eyrolles), Book Review: Expectations Investing by Mark K. Bhasin (CFA Institute Enterprising Investor, Jan 2022).

“Applied the case-study template to a company and tilted their process toward price-implied expectations.”

▸ Why it's rated 90

Scorecard

Reader outcomes 40%

88

Content quality 20%

82

Author credibility 20%

100

Goal relevance 10%

100

Rating and format 10%

79

What readers said helped (paraphrased)

  • Applied the case-study template to a company and tilted their process toward price-implied expectations.
  • Reverse-engineering framework not new, but learned about options, deferred taxes, M&A and buybacks.
  • Used some of the concepts in recent investment decisions.
Why it didn't help some
  • Got irritated, stopped halfway, and regrets the time spent.

Already knew most of it

  • Says the author's books compile existing material; nothing new for them, though precise.
  • Nothing new in the book for them.

Critics say: Requires comfort with DCF; 2001 examples are dated (revised 2021 edition updates them).

Rated for

Build a discounted cash flow valuation and read what a price implies (reverse DCF) 90

Key takeaways

  • Start from the price, not your own forecast
  • Find the value driver that matters most
  • Judge the odds that expectations will be revised

From the first 19 Goodreads reviews, read 18 October 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 341 ratings, about 88% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. Audiobook, 7.0 h.

Find on AudibleGoodreads page

▸ See 2 more booksMembers

Best study

What it found: Across US firms in 1951–1997, only about 3% of survivors beat the median earnings growth rate five years running, close to the 3.1% chance would give. About 10% grew faster than 18% a year over ten years, and analysts' long-term forecasts were too optimistic.

What it means for you: Be wary of any price that assumes years of high earnings growth; few firms have delivered it.

The figures and the limit

Across US firms from 1951 to 1997, the median growth rate of operating performance roughly matched GDP growth, and only about 10% of firms grew faster than 18% a year over ten years. For income before extraordinary items, about 3% of surviving firms beat the median growth rate five years in a row, close to the 3.1% expected by chance. Analysts' long-term (IBES) growth forecasts were too optimistic and added little predictive power. The authors conclude that valuations assuming persistently high growth 'rest on shaky foundations'.

The limit: US firms. Lakonishok is a founding partner of LSV Asset Management, a value-investing fund manager, which the paper doesn't mention. Figures are from the 2001 NBER working paper; the study was published in 2003. Sales growth showed some persistence; earnings growth showed essentially none. Relevant to reading what a price implies: high long-run growth has been rare.

▸ See 4 more studiesMembers

Website: start here

Our research summary

Allocating capital: what the research says →

Vettey Team

Best for: What research found on how rarely earnings growth persisted (about 3% of surviving firms beat the median five years running, close to the 3.1% expected by chance), profitability reverting at about 38% a year, company hurdle rates averaging twice their cost of capital, buyback returns that faded by 2003–2012, and acquirers' shareholders losing $240 billion in 1998–2001.

▸ See 6 more websitesMembers

+ Add a note

6Read capital and market cycles3 books4 studies3 websites

Watch where capital is flooding in: heavy investment and frothy credit have come before low returns and weaker growth. Treat these as warnings about the next few years, not precise timing signals. Mostly US data.

Best book

Read capital and market cycles

Irrational Exuberance

Robert J. Shiller, 2000

84Top rated

★ 3.98 on Goodreads (8,624) · about 14 hours

3 of 4 readers who said either way said it helped

From 30 sampled Goodreads reviews: 3 helped, 1 didn't, 3 already knew most of it; the rest didn't say.

Claim: Yale economist; 2013 Nobel laureateAuthor's own research

Helps an investor understand the psychological and structural drivers of bubbles and why high valuations warn of lower long-run returns.

Heavier read: 6 of 30 sampled readers found it hard going (academic exposition; some arguments need rereading).

The idea to hold onto: Market prices can drift far from fundamentals because rising prices feed the enthusiasm that lifts them further. High valuations have been followed, on average, by weaker long-run returns.

What to read for this goal: In the 2015 third edition, read "The Stock Market in Historical Perspective", "Amplification Mechanisms: Naturally Occurring Ponzi Processes" and "Efficient Markets, Random Walks, and Bubbles". The bond and real estate chapters are optional here; the appendix Nobel lecture is the most mathematical part.

Key terms, and if it's too heavy · 1 min
  • Cyclically adjusted price-earnings ratio (CAPE): Share price divided by average inflation-adjusted earnings over the previous ten years, which smooths out swings in profits over the business cycle.
  • Speculative bubble: A period when rising prices themselves draw in buyers, through enthusiasm spread by word of mouth and the media, lifting prices beyond what fundamentals support.
  • Amplification mechanisms: Feedback loops in which price rises lift confidence and expectations, prompting more buying and further rises; Shiller likens this to a fraudster-free Ponzi scheme.
  • Precipitating factors: Events and trends, such as the arrival of the internet, that help set off a boom, separate from the feedback that then amplifies it.
  • Efficient markets hypothesis: The idea that prices already reflect all public information, so they are the best estimate of value; Shiller argues it fails for whole markets.

Too heavy? No rated book on this step is known to be a lighter read; the studies in this step summarise the evidence first.

Our summary, not the author's words; checked 18 Oct 2026 against Irrational Exuberance, revised and expanded third edition: contents (UAM Iztapalapa library catalogue), Irrational Exuberance: Revised and Expanded Third Edition (Princeton University Press), Irrational Exuberance (book): editions and reception (Wikipedia).

“Read it twice over many years; draws on its psychology chapters in own books and training.”

▸ Why it's rated 84

Scorecard

Reader outcomes 40%

85

Content quality 20%

70

Author credibility 20%

100

Goal relevance 10%

100

Rating and format 10%

61

What readers said helped (paraphrased)

  • Read it twice over many years; draws on its psychology chapters in own books and training.
  • Re-evaluated own view of bubble dynamics and the assumed long-run superiority of stocks.
  • Prompted them to rethink how heavily their own money relies on the stock market and review investments.
Why it didn't help some
  • Wanted more actionable investing advice than the book gave them.

Already knew most of it

  • Says everyone knows bubbles exist; felt the author added little to what they already understood.
  • Skimmed it; felt they learned nothing new about markets beyond minor historical details.
  • Found little here not already covered in other behavioural and markets books they had read.

Critics say: Valuation signals can stay stretched for years, so it's no timing tool; US-centric.

Rated for

Recognise market and credit cycles, and what they do and don't imply for positioning 84Use valuation measures (CAPE, earnings yield, bond yields, credit spreads) to set return expectations, and know how often they've misled 82

Key takeaways

  • High valuations predict poor long-run returns
  • Stories and feedback loops amplify prices
  • Housing can be in a bubble too

From the first 30 Goodreads reviews, read 18 October 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 8,624 ratings, about 85% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. 1 reader says the effect has lasted. Audiobook, 13.8 h.

Find on AudibleGoodreads page

▸ See 2 more booksMembers

Best study

Credit growth has been a strong predictor of financial crises

Schularick & Taylor 2012 (American Economic Review) ↗

84StrongStudy quality

What it found: Across 14 developed countries from 1870 to 2008, fast credit growth was a powerful predictor of financial crises. Central banks responded to crises more aggressively over time, but crises still cost a lot of lost output.

What it means for you: Rapid credit growth signals rising crisis risk, but it predicts crises, not market returns, and crises are rare.

The figures and the limit

Across 14 countries from 1870 to 2008, total credit rose strongly relative to output and money in the second half of the 20th century. Credit growth was a powerful predictor of financial crises. Monetary policy responses to crises became more aggressive over time, but the output costs of crises stayed large.

The limit: Country-level data for developed economies. Predicts crises, not market returns, and crises are rare, so the estimates rest on relatively few events.

▸ See 3 more studiesMembers

Website: start here

Our research summary

Allocating capital: what the research says →

Vettey Team

Best for: What research found on the capital cycle in dry bulk shipping (orders for new ships rose from under 10% of the fleet in 2001 to over 75% in 2008, before a −76% year), fast asset growth predicting lower stock returns, frothy credit preceding wider spreads and weaker growth, and credit growth as a predictor of financial crises: average relationships, not timing signals.

▸ See 2 more websitesMembers

+ Add a note

7Set a spending rule1 book5 studies8 websites

Treat 4% as a US-history rule of thumb, not a guarantee; broader data point lower. Flexible rules that trim spending after bad years let you start higher, and annuities can guard against outliving savings.

Book

Set a spending rule

Living Off Your Money

Michael H. McClung, 2016

78Highly rated

★ 4.41 on Goodreads (56) · about 9 hours

3 of 3 readers who said either way said it helped

From 7 sampled Goodreads reviews: 3 helped, 0 didn't; the rest didn't say.

Claim: Private investor; credentials not verifiedAuthor's own research

Helps a retiree set a variable withdrawal rule and a harvesting method for stocks and bonds, tested against historical data.

Heavier read: 4 of 7 sampled readers found it hard going (technical, mathematical and textbook-like).

The idea to hold onto: Retirement income has two separate levers: how much to withdraw each year, and which assets to sell to fund it. Letting spending flex with markets trades steady income for durability.

What to read for this goal: Start with the introduction; the book's structure isn't summarised here.

Key terms, and if it's too heavy · 1 min
  • Sequence-of-returns risk: The danger that poor returns early in retirement, while withdrawals continue, drain a portfolio even if long-run average returns turn out fine.
  • Harvesting strategy: The rule for deciding which assets, stocks or bonds, to sell each year to fund spending, which also shifts the portfolio's mix over time.
  • Prime Harvesting: McClung's harvesting rule: fund spending from bonds first, and sell stocks mainly after they rise about 20% above their inflation-adjusted starting value.
  • Variable withdrawal strategy: A spending rule in which each year's withdrawal rises or falls with portfolio results, instead of staying constant in real terms.
  • Failure rate: The share of historical test periods in which a strategy would have run out of money before the retirement ended.

Too heavy? Try Die with Zero (Book Rating 77 on this page; it covers spending rules only in part) first: none of its 30 sampled readers found it hard going.

Our summary, not the author's words; checked 18 Oct 2026 against Book Review: Living Off Your Money by Michael McClung, by The Accumulator (Monevator, Oct 2017), The Ultimate Guide to Safe Withdrawal Rates, Part 13: Prime Harvesting (Early Retirement Now, Apr 2017).

“Harvesting-strategy section gave them useful ideas and a better sense of key considerations for own plan.”

▸ Why it's rated 78

Scorecard

Reader outcomes 40%

88

Content quality 20%

100

Author credibility 20%

40

Goal relevance 10%

100

Rating and format 10%

50

What readers said helped (paraphrased)

  • Harvesting-strategy section gave them useful ideas and a better sense of key considerations for own plan.
  • Learned retirement needs a different approach; realised some tools, like inflation-adjusted annuities, are unworkable for them.
  • Guaranteed-income section made the frameworks finally come together for their understanding.
Why it didn't help some

Critics say: Self-published and demanding; requires tolerance of volatile income.

Rated for

Choose a spending rule (fixed real amount, percentage of portfolio, guardrails or amortisation-based) 78Understand safe withdrawal rates and sequence-of-returns risk 76

Key takeaways

  • Variable withdrawals beat a fixed-dollar rule
  • Harvest gains from stocks in good years (Prime Harvesting)
  • Expect income and allocation to move

From the first 7 Goodreads reviews, read 18 October 2026, each coded as helped, didn't help, already knew it or no verdict. Weighted to all 56 ratings, about 88% of readers who said whether it helped said it did. No audiobook found.

Find on AudibleGoodreads page

Best study

A 38-country sample points to a much lower sustainable withdrawal rate

Anarkulova, Cederburg, O'Doherty & Sias 2025 (Journal of Pension Economics and Finance) ↗

73GoodStudy quality

What it found: Using returns from 38 developed countries, the authors estimate that a 65-year-old couple accepting a 5% chance of running out of money could withdraw just 2.31% a year, which they call 'materially lower' than the 4% rule.

What it means for you: Beyond US history, sustainable withdrawal rates may be well below 4%; this estimate is contested and defines failure differently.

The figures and the limit

Using asset-class returns from 38 developed countries, the authors estimate that a 65-year-old couple willing to accept a 5% chance of financial ruin could withdraw just 2.31% a year. They call this 'materially lower' than conventional advice such as the 4% rule.

The limit: Contested: far below US-history results such as Bengen's 4%. The sample includes countries with poor real returns, and the paper's keywords point to survivor bias and 'easy data' bias in narrower samples. As with the 4% rule, withdrawals are a fixed inflation-adjusted amount set as a percentage of the balance at retirement, and 'ruin' means running out of money (confirmed from the working-paper version; the published text is paywalled). The comparison with Bengen still differs in how failure is defined (a 5% lifetime chance of ruin for a couple, versus no failure over 30+ years), the portfolio and the data. Level 2 cites a related paper by three of the same authors on 30-year stock returns.

▸ See 4 more studiesMembers

Website: start here

Our research summary

Allocating capital: what the research says →

Vettey Team

Best for: Shows the withdrawal-rate evidence both ways: Bengen's 4% (raised with inflation, it never ran out in under 33 years of US history from 1926), 2.31% across 38 developed countries for a 5% chance of ruin, and guardrail rules (with two further rules and at least 65% in equities) that supported 5.2–5.6% starting rates by cutting spending after poor markets. Also annuity theory, pricing and take-up.

▸ See 7 more websitesMembers

+ Add a note

How everything here is rated

Books are ranked by what viewers and readers report actually happened. Rated studies are scored on how well they were done; the rest are our plain summaries, each with its main limit. Websites, channels and tools are listed for what they're good for, not yet rated. Results vary by individual circumstances.

  • Books carry Book Rating v1.2: the first 30 Goodreads reviews of each book coded as helped, didn't help or already knew it, with the same weights as the video score. A pick has to beat the typical book on reader outcomes.
  • Videos carry the Vettey score: what viewers reported in the comments after trying it (40%), content quality (20%), creator credibility (20%), goal relevance (10%) and metadata (10%). Only videos scoring 60 or more are listed.
  • Research findings are our summaries of published studies, each with its main limit and a link to the source. They aren't given a Study Rating.
  • Websites, channels and tools are listed for what they're good for, with any cautions. They aren't rated.

Updated 4 November 2026. How we rate research ·

A guide to books, studies and websites. It isn't financial advice: it doesn't know your circumstances, and past returns don't guarantee future ones.